bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,978
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Embarrassing attendance at USC
(09-06-2026 07:57 PM)LatahCounty Wrote: (09-06-2026 10:50 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: But this gets back to another key difference (and I think Gitanole’s point of the “flyover” analysis of the LA market is an appropriate one): Southern California is still the largest source of football recruits in the country outside of Texas and the heart of the Florida/Georgia corridor. This isn’t the Northeast where, yes, there is a rapidly declining high school football culture and that arguably compounds issues with college football interest there. (That being said, the NFL is extremely strong in Northeast markets, so I don’t think football participation levels really have as much of an impact on football *spectators* as some people make it out to be).
I just don’t think it’s binary. I will completely concede that the LA market is not like Birmingham or Columbus or even Atlanta in terms of concentrated college football interest. I do not disagree with that at all.
However, I do think a lot of people in SEC country seem to have this binary view that if it place doesn’t love college football in the same way that they do, then it must mean that they “don’t care” about college football at all. In reality, there’s a wide spectrum. I mean, I’m stating something against my own self-interest as a Big Ten fan: Rutgers will never “own NYC” and I will never pretend that’s why they were added to the Big Ten or think that will ever happen. Putting LA into that category is just not the same: USC and even UCLA are still much more important on the pecking order of the whole LA sports scene by comparison and there actually *is* a strong high school football culture in Southern California in a way that belies an overall argument that “Southern California is losing interest in football”.
One thing to consider: Southern California overindexes on producing top athletes in virtually *every* sport other than maybe pure indoor winter sports like hockey. They still produce a ton of football players. They also produce a ton of baseball, softball, soccer, and volleyball players along with swimmers and track and field athletes and cyclists and even outdoor winter athletes like skiers and snowboarders. The strength of Southern California in producing high level athletes in virtually *everything* almost masks how great they are in still producing top football talent. People shouldn’t mistake with how a lot of communities might care about *only* producing football players with the LA market not caring about football even at the youth levels. LA is simply great at producing top athletes in virtually *everything*. Their geography and weather are basically perfect for producing the widest range of athletes for anything that is played or competed outside and that can’t be replicated anywhere else. It’s not “football culture” in the Southern sense, but rather “we’re great athletes in *everything*” culture and football is a segment of it as opposed to the sole focus.
This is just so different than the NYC to Boston corridor that is straight up terrible at producing football talent and the football culture. Southern California might not be Texas Friday Night Lights level, but it is still a totally different universe than Northeast football culture or lack thereof outside of watching the NFL. (Note that New Jersey and Maryland are actually pretty good at producing football talent compared to the rest of the Northeast region, so there are some intra-regional differences, too. This was definitely part of the overall calculus for the Big Ten wanting Rutgers and Maryland - those states were the largest producers of football talent that were contiguous to the then-Big Ten footprint by a very large margin.)
This is right. It's an area that supports all sports -- it never overindexed for college football the way the south did. I doubt the area suddenly dislikes football in general, but COLLEGE football has gone out of its way lately to make itself more unlikeable. In relative terms, it's probably worse off everywhere but it has a much greater relative height to fall from in SEC country and the midwest.
I strongly disagree with this statement. COLLEGE football is more popular today, based upon butts in seats, tv ratings, or water cooler chatter, than it's been in years, probably decades. Some conferences or teams get more criticism (like generic SEC hate or Michigan's neverending supply of hail marys), but, overall, CFB is on a roll. I discussed this the other day with some others on this board, but even out West, everywhere except California has strong football support. Washington, Oregon, Arizona, Utah, Colorado if you want to say they're "West"...all of them have static or even rising football enthusiasm these days. We can go towards the midwest, and Nebraska, Iowa (the State), Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois, Indiana ofc, all the former Big 8 schools, OSU, Michigan...football enthusiasm at all of those places is similar to or even greater than it's been in a while. The SE and SW seem to have about the same fanatical level of enthusiasm as ever. ACC schools are getting more butts in seats and more eyeballs on their games. There's only one place in the country where CFB is on a negative trend, and that's in California.
This is no generic "I don't like California b/c it's California" post, either. I love California. My sister and 2 brothers have lived most of their lives there. My daughter looked at Berkley but I told her I wouldn't pay for that when UT Austin was in her own State (don't tell bullet I said that). Their CFB history, especially at USC, is very impressive. But the people of California, even SoCal, just don't seem to care as much about FB in general these days, with the Fresno St fans being notable exceptions ofc. People in this thread have spun 6 ways from Sunday, but, at the end of the day, that's what it boils down to. UCLA can't get 40k butts in seats for many games. USC can't get 50k for their first 2 cupcakes, with ~ 30k for week 1 and 45k actual butts in seats in week 2. THAT isn't a weather problem or a "we have a million cooler things to do problem", that's a "we don't care quite as much about football and oh look there's a soccer game going on down the road lets go to that!" problem. But to say that it's a national rather a local problem is inaccurate.
|
|