Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,554
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Embarrassing attendance at USC
(09-06-2026 11:43 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-06-2026 10:50 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-06-2026 10:14 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-06-2026 09:31 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-05-2026 04:17 PM)schmolik Wrote: USC has the issue of being in an urban market/area (LA) with a lot of other options other than going to a college football game but another issue unique to USC is they're a private school. Among the top college football schools, how many others are private? Notre Dame is the #1 that comes to mind but South Bend is a lot more isolated and weather isn't as great as LA so it's easier to sell football. Miami is probably the closest comparable school and I would think just like USC if Miami isn't winning they'll probably have a hard time competing with other activities in South Florida as well. I spent two years in State College and four years in Champaign, Illinois. Of course it's easy to sell Penn State football. But I had reasonable interest in Illinois football, it's not like there's a lot to do there outside of the university. Only one SEC school is private and most of them are in "college towns". Only two Big Ten schools are private and most of them are in college towns as well. It's not really fair to compare USC to Penn State or even Notre Dame (both private).
USC might be private, but it’s not like Northwestern or Vandy in terms of undergrad size. They have over 20,000 undergrad students, which believe it or not is more than Nebraska and Oregon along with being right in the range of Iowa. When you look at total enrollment including grad students, it’s over 47,000, which right in the middle of the Big Ten for overall figures (close to Indiana, Wisconsin, and even more than crosstown UCLA).
So, USC is more like a flagship type student body than it is like Northwestern, Vandy, Duke, etc.
I think people are also still vastly not getting that not all large markets are the same just like not all college markets are the same. Even with your own experience, the level of football fandom in State College is not the same as football fandom in Champaign despite begin very demographically similar isolated Big Ten college towns. Similarly, LA isn’t like NYC or even Chicago - this isn’t Rutgers-level interest in the NYC market. The U in the Miami market is a more apt comparison (and without in-state football brand at the level of Florida and Florida State). I think people are conflating a higher level of fairweatherness for attendance (which sure, USC and Miami may have more of compared to an SEC college town) with a binary determination that this must mean that the market “does not care about college football”, which is just wrong.
I mean, I’m as hardcore of an Illini as anyone, but it would be laughable to think that we have anything on USC in terms of football fandom and we truly do have few things to do in town other than to attend a football game. It’s not just a college town vs. large market dichotomy.
There's fair weather fans, and then there's 30k butts in the seats for the first game of the season. That's not fair weather at a football factory, that's "For Whom the Bell Tolls" apocalyptic for a football factory. Toss in USC's long term ratings slump, a slump that is falling against the rising tide of so many others, and if I'm a Fox or B1G exec, I'm concerned. Not as concerned as I would be if UCLA, Washington and Oregon didn't all look to be turning out as better than expected, but still, USC was the whole reason this party got started. And even as an A&M fan, I'm a bit concerned b/c SoCal is, as you love pointing out, just a huge place. We already get short shrift in NYC, and now that lack of football enthusiasm seems to have taken root in SoCal. I don't know if we'll ever recover there tbh. I'd like to think that we will, but we all know that football wasn't always the most popular sport in America, and there will likely come a time in the future when it's not the most popular one. Hopefully, USC fires Riley, brings in a real coach and starts winning big, and their fans come back in droves.
But this gets back to another key difference (and I think Gitanole’s point of the “flyover” analysis of the LA market is an appropriate one): Southern California is still the largest source of football recruits in the country outside of Texas and the heart of the Florida/Georgia corridor. This isn’t the Northeast where, yes, there is a rapidly declining high school football culture and that arguably compounds issues with college football interest there. (That being said, the NFL is extremely strong in Northeast markets, so I don’t think football participation levels really have as much of an impact on football *spectators* as some people make it out to be).
I just don’t think it’s binary. I will completely concede that the LA market is not like Birmingham or Columbus or even Atlanta in terms of concentrated college football interest. I do not disagree with that at all.
However, I do think a lot of people in SEC country seem to have this binary view that if it place doesn’t love college football in the same way that they do, then it must mean that they “don’t care” about college football at all. In reality, there’s a wide spectrum. I mean, I’m stating something against my own self-interest as a Big Ten fan: Rutgers will never “own NYC” and I will never pretend that’s why they were added to the Big Ten or think that will ever happen. Putting LA into that category is just not the same: USC and even UCLA are still much more important on the pecking order of the whole LA sports scene by comparison and there actually *is* a strong high school football culture in Southern California in a way that belies an overall argument that “Southern California is losing interest in football”.
One thing to consider: Southern California overindexes on producing top athletes in virtually *every* sport other than maybe pure indoor winter sports like hockey. They still produce a ton of football players. They also produce a ton of baseball, softball, soccer, and volleyball players along with swimmers and track and field athletes and cyclists and even outdoor winter athletes like skiers and snowboarders. The strength of Southern California in producing high level athletes in virtually *everything* almost masks how great they are in still producing top football talent. People shouldn’t mistake with how a lot of communities might care about *only* producing football players with the LA market not caring about football even at the youth levels. LA is simply great at producing top athletes in virtually *everything*. Their geography and weather are basically perfect for producing the widest range of athletes for anything that is played or competed outside and that can’t be replicated anywhere else. It’s not “football culture” in the Southern sense, but rather “we’re great athletes in *everything*” culture and football is a segment of it as opposed to the sole focus.
This is just so different than the NYC to Boston corridor that is straight up terrible at producing football talent and the football culture. Southern California might not be Texas Friday Night Lights level, but it is still a totally different universe than Northeast football culture or lack thereof outside of watching the NFL. (Note that New Jersey and Maryland are actually pretty good at producing football talent compared to the rest of the Northeast region, so there are some intra-regional differences, too. This was definitely part of the overall calculus for the Big Ten wanting Rutgers and Maryland - those states were the largest producers of football talent that were contiguous to the then-Big Ten footprint by a very large margin.)
They're sure not overindexing on "football enthusiasm". Not only did they lose the Rams and Raiders for decades, they're now losing interest in even mighty USC, allegedly at least in part b/c they have a couple of pro teams in town. I think an appropriate metric for Greater LA is to use a 1/3 to 1/2 multiplier when comparing it to anywhere else, and northern california perhaps 1/4 or 1/5. IE, the ~ 18m in Greater LA are like 6-9m elsewhere, so like Houston or Atlanta, and the ~ 10m in the Bay area more like San Antonio or Jacksonville. Still valuable, still able to produce a lot of top tier talent, but not overwhelmingly important. I'd much rather have Chicago and DFW, I'll put it that way, and I think that you would, too.
Look - if the LA market isn’t watching USC if/when they’re a legit national title contender, then we can talk.
We can go around in circles about this forever, but we have direct metrics from the 2000s that USC was the *single* biggest ratings draw in all of college football. Not Ohio State. Not Alabama. Not Miami. Not Texas. It was USC. *That* is the peak when they are competing for national titles. They were not competing for national titles in the 2010s up until now, so of course their ratings haven’t had that peak.
Let’s put aside the Lakers, which are really in their own category in the LA market as really having impenetrable interest there whether they win or lose. They have the closest thing to total inelastic demand of any sports team in the LA market.
The Dodgers are more instructive and much more like what I’m stating about USC. The whole “LA just cares about the Lakers and Dodgers” argument is a much more, “What have you done for me lately?” item with respect to the Dodgers. However, when it comes to viewership, the Dodgers really didn’t get to the top of being national ratings draws and selling out every game until the last couple of years with their World Series runs with Shohei Ohtani. Even with the excellent Dodgers teams in the 2010s with Clayton Kershaw and the like that made a lot of deep playoff runs, they were a solid draw, but the very biggest ratings draws in MLB with much more inelastic demand (win or lose) have been the Yankees, Cubs, and Red Sox (which are really the MLB equivalents of Ohio State, Alabama, and Notre Dame in terms of just being evergreen top brands even in down years).
When you look at Dodgers viewership, they really had hockey stick type viewership growth over the past few years nationally. There was a base level of viewership that the Dodgers drew when they were good or even very good teams, but it was exponential logarithmic growth when they turned into a truly dominant team. There was a tipping point in the LA market where the Dodger viewers grew in such a fashion plus the national interest on top of it. Anyone thinking that this is how LA watches the Dodgers all of the time hasn’t been looking at the data over the past 15 years.
That was almost the exact same pattern for USC in the 2000s. They may fall way below Ohio State and Alabama in viewership when they aren’t at a competitive peak, but when they *are* at a competitive peak, there’s no team with a higher viewership ceiling (just like the Dodgers for baseball). If you’re a league that doesn’t already have Ohio State and Michigan where you need to almost totally depend on USC year-over-year (like arguably the Pac-12), then feel free to argue the risk there, but if a league is essentially holding a call option in USC where if it hits, it has shown to be the very biggest draw in all of college football, that’s far more compelling than a team with upper middle even keel interest without that upside. You take that every time as league - I don’t think anyone can seriously sit here and say any conference (including the SEC) would turn down USC if they approached them to join.
Put another way, outside of the Lakers, getting top level sports interest in the LA market is a very high bar. It’s a higher bar than what the teams in places like Chicago or Philly need to clear. However, when a team is able to clear that bar, then the ceiling is pretty insane where it blows everything else away nationally (even compared to New York teams in a lot of cases as their sports loyalties are way more split).
|
|