Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)


Post Reply 
Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
Author Message
hburg Online
Moderator
*

Posts: 13,473
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 522
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Make An Impact...
Post: #101
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

ODU made thier choice when they thought they had to. I think any CAA fan back in the day would be upset with Richmond, VCU, and GMU more than ODU. JMU's hand was also forced by the same reasons, but more in football. It seems like ODU is on the rise again, hopefully our basketball programs can do the same. Our rivalry has a ton of potential that I hope will blossom.
07-29-2026 09:41 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
hburg Online
Moderator
*

Posts: 13,473
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 522
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Make An Impact...
Post: #102
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 09:28 AM)Purplehazed Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:18 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:03 AM)Purplehazed Wrote:  Memphis just sucks, the whole city and anything in it sucks.
Jesus, imagine if fedex did not need a place to land, even worse

Totally agree. Have been to Memphis 4x and do not plan on ever returning. Got robbed once, car stolen on another trip, and had a murder next door to friends I was staying with. However, the P4 is all about money. "What can Brown do for you"? It can look very appealing to some of those leagues if they do, in fact, expand. I know they tried to buy their way in before but given a choice of teams...that Brown money may look very green and appealing.

I think you mean blue and orange...the airport must have a fence 16 feet tall or the planes would get jacked on the runways. The place is that ghetto

I wonder how much has changed, if any, since the TNNG deployment there.
07-29-2026 09:44 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
mturn017 Offline
ODU Homer
*

Posts: 18,901
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 1828
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Roanoke, VA
Post: #103
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.
07-29-2026 10:17 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
everyone Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,257
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 117
I Root For: USM
Location:
Post: #104
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 09:18 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:03 AM)Purplehazed Wrote:  Memphis just sucks, the whole city and anything in it sucks.
Jesus, imagine if fedex did not need a place to land, even worse

Totally agree. Have been to Memphis 4x and do not plan on ever returning. Got robbed once, car stolen on another trip, and had a murder next door to friends I was staying with. However, the P4 is all about money. "What can Brown do for you"? It can look very appealing to some of those leagues if they do, in fact, expand. I know they tried to buy their way in before but given a choice of teams...that Brown money may look very green and appealing.

Interstate 269 is a game changer. I live in TN and have family in MS so being able to drive around Memphis is heaven.
07-29-2026 10:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,961
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #105
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-28-2026 11:47 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(07-28-2026 11:11 AM)GreenBison Wrote:  App and JMU don’t fit the AAC “MO”. Just compare yourselves to the CUSA 6 they took on the last go round. Big city schools with mediocre to terrible football and basketball. The AAC Presidents want high academics and a large population with wealthy and diverse students that they can recruit to build up their student populations.

Rice and Tulsa will not be happy if they lose Tulane and USF because of academics. Academics will be a larger metric than football success.

JMU is a Top 150 academic school (pushing Top 100) and pushing to grow to 30,000 students in the next decade or so while adding R1 status. JMU has ACC academic aspirations, so don't think the AAC would really ignore us for that.

Markets maybe, but I am sure JMU could argue the DC and Richmond markets since no P4 teams exist in either.

Toledo, Buffalo, Delaware probably higher on their list.
(This post was last modified: 07-29-2026 11:11 AM by GreenBison.)
07-29-2026 11:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GreenBison Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,961
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
Post: #106
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-28-2026 02:55 PM)TrueBlueDrew Wrote:  
(07-28-2026 11:47 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(07-28-2026 11:11 AM)GreenBison Wrote:  App and JMU don’t fit the AAC “MO”. Just compare yourselves to the CUSA 6 they took on the last go round. Big city schools with mediocre to terrible football and basketball. The AAC Presidents want high academics and a large population with wealthy and diverse students that they can recruit to build up their student populations.

Rice and Tulsa will not be happy if they lose Tulane and USF because of academics. Academics will be a larger metric than football success.

JMU is a Top 150 academic school (pushing Top 100) and pushing to grow to 30,000 students in the next decade or so while adding R1 status. JMU has ACC academic aspirations, so don't think the AAC would really ignore us for that.

Markets maybe, but I am sure JMU could argue the DC and Richmond markets since no P4 teams exist in either.

I know this is going to come as a shock to JMU fans but every university has “aspirations” to have better academics 03-lmfao

So that’s why we have exit fees? 03-lmfao
07-29-2026 11:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OsageJ Online
Sun Belt Nationalist
*

Posts: 11,055
Joined: May 2002
Reputation: 683
I Root For: stAte
Location:
Post: #107
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 09:18 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:03 AM)Purplehazed Wrote:  Memphis just sucks, the whole city and anything in it sucks.
Jesus, imagine if fedex did not need a place to land, even worse

Totally agree. Have been to Memphis 4x and do not plan on ever returning. Got robbed once, car stolen on another trip, and had a murder next door to friends I was staying with. However, the P4 is all about money. "What can Brown do for you"? It can look very appealing to some of those leagues if they do, in fact, expand. I know they tried to buy their way in before but given a choice of teams...that Brown money may look very green and appealing.

I have been to Memphis countless times for many different reasons. I wonder where you were. I have been downtown when it was pretty rough and never had a problem.
07-29-2026 11:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
seaking4steel Online
1st String
*

Posts: 1,561
Joined: May 2018
Reputation: 181
I Root For: Penn St, App St
Location:
Post: #108
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-28-2026 01:20 PM)OsageJ Wrote:  Very true but the teams and fans slobbering all over themselves never pay attention. I hope the teams in the AAC that are never happy get to leave soon. Hopefully the teams( App and JMU have been lightly complaining since they got here. App would have had an east league by now.). Hope y'all get to leave too. It seems its always the same schools that have one foot out the door. Usually its certain fans but I imagine they heard it from some guy guy in a tie. It is so tiring.

Aside from complaining about being an outlier for 8 years, most of the "complaining" from App has only come recently. It's largely in response to this conference's awful media deal. Our AD has outright said that App needs to be where the school can get the most revenue. Unless we can finally renegotiate and get more money from ESPN, then expect App and JMU to send feelers elsewhere.

The Sun Belt is a better conference than it was 5 years ago. I hope ESPN is able to realize that and compensate all of us accordingly.
07-29-2026 12:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
islandTROYtrojan Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 369
Joined: May 2026
Reputation: 69
I Root For: Troy and the SBC
Location: Key West/Montgomery
Post: #109
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 11:49 AM)OsageJ Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:18 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 09:03 AM)Purplehazed Wrote:  Memphis just sucks, the whole city and anything in it sucks.
Jesus, imagine if fedex did not need a place to land, even worse

Totally agree. Have been to Memphis 4x and do not plan on ever returning. Got robbed once, car stolen on another trip, and had a murder next door to friends I was staying with. However, the P4 is all about money. "What can Brown do for you"? It can look very appealing to some of those leagues if they do, in fact, expand. I know they tried to buy their way in before but given a choice of teams...that Brown money may look very green and appealing.

I have been to Memphis countless times for many different reasons. I wonder where you were. I have been downtown when it was pretty rough and never had a problem.

Downtown twice and a neighborhood of million-dollar homes.
07-29-2026 12:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MonGNARch Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,161
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 87
I Root For: The Ol' Dirty
Location: DC
Post: #110
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 10:17 AM)mturn017 Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.

Right. The American isn't the American of years past. It's half old CUSA foes and half what was left behind after the P4 came in and poached. Unless the SBC East all bolted for the American I see no reason to jump. SBC is currently the perfect fit for us
07-29-2026 01:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukester Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,149
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #111
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 01:28 PM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 10:17 AM)mturn017 Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.

Right. The American isn't the American of years past. It's half old CUSA foes and half what was left behind after the P4 came in and poached. Unless the SBC East all bolted for the American I see no reason to jump. SBC is currently the perfect fit for us

I can imagine ODU and JMU will stick together for the forseeable future. JMU's calling card is success and facilities. ODU's calling card it their market.
07-29-2026 03:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
oasispirate Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,428
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 38
I Root For: East Carolina
Location: Raleigh, NC
Post: #112
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
My guess is ECU will either end up in a watered down ACC or the Sun Belt at the end of the day. I suppose it's possible in this crazy world we could reorganize a regional American. I do wonder if the Miami's, UNCs, CLemsons, FSUs, etc still have the option of "moving up".

I like the American, but honestly if Memphis and USF are gone it loses a lot of luster. UTSA is a good program though with a lot of potential. No offense to some of the Sun Belt schools but if ECU were not going to make the cut I would go all in on regionality. It would also be interesting to see what Navy and Army do during this split. This is also assuming USF, Memphis, and Tulane move up while ECU doesn't make the cut.
07-29-2026 06:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MonGNARch Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,161
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 87
I Root For: The Ol' Dirty
Location: DC
Post: #113
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 03:11 PM)Dukester Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 01:28 PM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 10:17 AM)mturn017 Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.

Right. The American isn't the American of years past. It's half old CUSA foes and half what was left behind after the P4 came in and poached. Unless the SBC East all bolted for the American I see no reason to jump. SBC is currently the perfect fit for us

I can imagine ODU and JMU will stick together for the forseeable future. JMU's calling card is success and facilities. ODU's calling card it their market.

I sure hope so. After losing VCU and treading the wilderness in CUSA without any "real" rivalries in-conference was abysmal, which was why I was so glad we moved to SBC together. Thinking about it, it was Charlotte I guess? they never got my ire like VCU or JMU and even in-conference I had more ill-will towards schools like LT, MTSU, and WKU but they were so far flung and new to students that it never caught on. Like the Joker said to Batman at the end of Dark Knight: "I think you and I are destined to do this forever", but we will see
07-30-2026 07:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MonGNARch Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,161
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 87
I Root For: The Ol' Dirty
Location: DC
Post: #114
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 06:44 PM)oasispirate Wrote:  My guess is ECU will either end up in a watered down ACC or the Sun Belt at the end of the day. I suppose it's possible in this crazy world we could reorganize a regional American. I do wonder if the Miami's, UNCs, CLemsons, FSUs, etc still have the option of "moving up".

I like the American, but honestly if Memphis and USF are gone it loses a lot of luster. UTSA is a good program though with a lot of potential. No offense to some of the Sun Belt schools but if ECU were not going to make the cut I would go all in on regionality. It would also be interesting to see what Navy and Army do during this split. This is also assuming USF, Memphis, and Tulane move up while ECU doesn't make the cut.

I think the unfortunate (maybe fortunate?) thing about all of this mega-conference nonsense is that the G6 will be left behind BUT it will allow us to focus more on regionality. the MAC and SBC are really the last of that mindset and I think it's why they are so stable. But I don't know, I thought the mega-conferences were going to be unsustainable and they would blow up (and that may still happen) and it would force things back to some sense or normality but who knows what the outcome of this will be
07-30-2026 07:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Herd6993 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 635
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 94
I Root For: Marshall
Location:
Post: #115
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-30-2026 07:53 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 03:11 PM)Dukester Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 01:28 PM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 10:17 AM)mturn017 Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 08:18 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  ODU hoops were a power and football was on the rise. VCU and GMU leaving the CAA for the A10 while we were seeing a diluted CAA forced our hand, as well as ECU calling us over then bolting for the American after we joined. But in retrospect, JMU did the right things staying FCS and won a national championship before making the jump.

However, the jumping of conferences also coincided with the collapse of our basketball programs. Our head coach getting fired mid-season after battling alcoholism (thankfully he was able to conquer his demons and is in a much better palce and works in the athletic department again) and going 5-25, leading to a restart with a new coach in a new conference where we had no history with the majority of the schools. Then Wood Selig firing Wendy Larry and replacing her with Karen Barefoot...

Our identity had been stripped, our football program stuggled because Bobby Wilder was in over his head and all the good will of dominating in the CAA was lost, and we went on a journey of mediocrity for a decade. Hindsight is 2020, but the jumping of the conference alone was not the only deciding factor. Don't forget the Cox bill that was designed to screw over ODU and is now getting rolled back with JMU moving up to FBS. It was the right choice at the time but then we didn't have the leadership in place to navigate these waters (and I still think we don't moving forward), and the SBC is an incredibly lucky landing spot after all the mismanagement that went on when we were in CUSA

I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.

Right. The American isn't the American of years past. It's half old CUSA foes and half what was left behind after the P4 came in and poached. Unless the SBC East all bolted for the American I see no reason to jump. SBC is currently the perfect fit for us

I can imagine ODU and JMU will stick together for the forseeable future. JMU's calling card is success and facilities. ODU's calling card it their market.

I sure hope so. After losing VCU and treading the wilderness in CUSA without any "real" rivalries in-conference was abysmal, which was why I was so glad we moved to SBC together. Thinking about it, it was Charlotte I guess? they never got my ire like VCU or JMU and even in-conference I had more ill-will towards schools like LT, MTSU, and WKU but they were so far flung and new to students that it never caught on. Like the Joker said to Batman at the end of Dark Knight: "I think you and I are destined to do this forever", but we will see


I think that's one of the biggest strengths of the Sun Belt. The conference appeals to fans rather than corporate America.

Marshall has been through five different conferences (or versions of conferences) during my lifetime, and by far the worst experience was C-USA 3.0. It wasn't necessarily because of the schools themselves, but because the league was so geographically scattered. As a fan, it was hard to get excited about playing schools in Texas every year when there was little history or opportunity to travel.

The Sun Belt is different. Having so many games within driving distance allows fans to travel, interact with opposing fan bases, and build genuine rivalries. That's what makes college football special- it is about rivalries and those rivalries is what keep people engaged.
07-30-2026 08:57 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
islandTROYtrojan Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 369
Joined: May 2026
Reputation: 69
I Root For: Troy and the SBC
Location: Key West/Montgomery
Post: #116
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
I think the unfortunate (maybe fortunate?) thing about all of this mega-conference nonsense is that the G6 will be left behind BUT it will allow us to focus more on regionality. the MAC and SBC are really the last of that mindset and I think it's why they are so stable. But I don't know, I thought the mega-conferences were going to be unsustainable and they would blow up (and that may still happen) and it would force things back to some sense or normality but who knows what the outcome of this will be
[/quote]

Totally agree with this. MAC and SBC are the most stable due to being conferences where rivalries and proximity matter and fuel the fans. As I have stated numerous times...not every team in college football is focused on being in the P4 or even has a desire to be in that group. There are some that are and that is fine but I do not believe the average fan cares about that at our level. They just want to beat teams that matter to them. Having the P4 out of the way will allow the G6 to engage more fan interest in what will become what college football was always meant to be. P4 becoming NFL lite will diminish the college fan experience eventually and endless needs to fundraise will become tiresome. Who can outspend the other will be the goal with little actual connection to the school.
07-30-2026 09:04 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MonGNARch Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,161
Joined: Jan 2015
Reputation: 87
I Root For: The Ol' Dirty
Location: DC
Post: #117
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-30-2026 08:57 AM)Herd6993 Wrote:  
(07-30-2026 07:53 AM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 03:11 PM)Dukester Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 01:28 PM)MonGNARch Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 10:17 AM)mturn017 Wrote:  I agree that most of our recent woes were self inflicted. Still CUSA wasn't a great home for us and would be very wary of a move to the American.

Right. The American isn't the American of years past. It's half old CUSA foes and half what was left behind after the P4 came in and poached. Unless the SBC East all bolted for the American I see no reason to jump. SBC is currently the perfect fit for us

I can imagine ODU and JMU will stick together for the forseeable future. JMU's calling card is success and facilities. ODU's calling card it their market.

I sure hope so. After losing VCU and treading the wilderness in CUSA without any "real" rivalries in-conference was abysmal, which was why I was so glad we moved to SBC together. Thinking about it, it was Charlotte I guess? they never got my ire like VCU or JMU and even in-conference I had more ill-will towards schools like LT, MTSU, and WKU but they were so far flung and new to students that it never caught on. Like the Joker said to Batman at the end of Dark Knight: "I think you and I are destined to do this forever", but we will see


I think that's one of the biggest strengths of the Sun Belt. The conference appeals to fans rather than corporate America.

Marshall has been through five different conferences (or versions of conferences) during my lifetime, and by far the worst experience was C-USA 3.0. It wasn't necessarily because of the schools themselves, but because the league was so geographically scattered. As a fan, it was hard to get excited about playing schools in Texas every year when there was little history or opportunity to travel.

The Sun Belt is different. Having so many games within driving distance allows fans to travel, interact with opposing fan bases, and build genuine rivalries. That's what makes college football special- it is about rivalries and those rivalries is what keep people engaged.

I'm glad you guys moved with us too. and while I love the SBC as a whole, the SBC east is my favorite group of schools we've shared a conference with since the CAA days. VCU, W&M, GMU, JMU, Towson, Richmond... so many close school with friends and family going to all of those so it was personal and organic. CUSA felt like we transferred to a new school and it felt so forced to come up with organic feelings against those schools. Now, JMU, App, Marshall, Coastal, the GA schools, it is so much more organic again as I know people who went to those schools and have history with them
07-30-2026 09:17 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
everyone Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,257
Joined: Dec 2016
Reputation: 117
I Root For: USM
Location:
Post: #118
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-30-2026 09:04 AM)islandTROYtrojan Wrote:  I think the unfortunate (maybe fortunate?) thing about all of this mega-conference nonsense is that the G6 will be left behind BUT it will allow us to focus more on regionality. the MAC and SBC are really the last of that mindset and I think it's why they are so stable. But I don't know, I thought the mega-conferences were going to be unsustainable and they would blow up (and that may still happen) and it would force things back to some sense or normality but who knows what the outcome of this will be

Totally agree with this. MAC and SBC are the most stable due to being conferences where rivalries and proximity matter and fuel the fans. As I have stated numerous times...not every team in college football is focused on being in the P4 or even has a desire to be in that group. There are some that are and that is fine but I do not believe the average fan cares about that at our level. They just want to beat teams that matter to them. Having the P4 out of the way will allow the G6 to engage more fan interest in what will become what college football was always meant to be. P4 becoming NFL lite will diminish the college fan experience eventually and endless needs to fundraise will become tiresome. Who can outspend the other will be the goal with little actual connection to the school.
[/quote]

The MAC is not stable. NIU went out west for a reason. They are desperate for money and added Sac State...how's that for proximity. They will struggle to survive.
07-30-2026 09:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMU2004 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,815
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 185
I Root For: DUKES
Location: the Commonwealth
Post: #119
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
Yea, the MAC is in trouble. Several schools in dangerous enrollment/economic situations.
07-30-2026 09:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMUNation Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #120
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-29-2026 08:16 AM)MUsince96 Wrote:  
(07-29-2026 07:58 AM)JMUNation Wrote:  I wouldn’t be so tough on JMU fans. It is all conversation and mostly because we have a new President who isn’t afraid to publicly dream big. He is planting seeds for the future. By the way, JMU does not receive a full share from the SBC. Our payout likely contributes to the changing conferences talk. The schools that have been here awhile get a full payout. As a new school, we don’t.

What irks our President is that JMUs media value is the highest in the conference yet the conference chooses to base payouts on tenure. Tenure is an old payment model in education that bases pay on longevity instead of performance. Tenure is not well embraced in the business world.

The Big 12 publicly shot down Memphis last year. I don’t think the large state institutions of the Big 12 see Memphis as adding value to their league. They are eyeing bigger fish. I don’t see the AAC getting raided further. S. Florida is the only school that I could see receiving a P4 invite. Memphis, Tulane and ECU are no different than App and Marshall. They located in states where P4 schools dominate the national college sports scene. These colleges have large and established fan/donor bases established over many generations.

Schools like JMU, APP, ECU and Memphis need to focus on staying at the top of their peer group. I honestly believe the P4 talk by their Presidents and ADs is simply done to motivate donors. There is no real basis to it. History has shown that when schools move up in conference status, the better schools leave them. Both VCU, GMu and ODU experienced this here in Virginia. VT did as well when CUSA was originally formed.

ODU has made many conference changes over the years and they always end up back in a conference with JMU. Their fans can tell you the grass is not greener. It’s usually filled with fools gold.

First I've heard about not receiving a full share. I thought the recent tax records showed everyone getting the same. With JMU getting slightly more due to the CFP appearance.

The number shared with me was $500k. I believe App received over $2 mil, which is a full share. Last season we did receive extra money because of the CFP. I think we received extra money the year we went to the NCAA Tournament in basketball too. I am not sure how long it will be until we receive a full share of conference revenue.
07-30-2026 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.