(07-27-2026 09:41 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote: No B12 school is going to even remotely consider the ACC even in its current form let alone a watered down version if UVA/FSU/UNC/Miami leave. The inverse is the likely option. As always G6 realignment won't happen because of the G6's desires, but rather what starts at the SEC/B10.
As for unfamiliar opponents, JMU has plenty of those in the SBC. 4 years in they are starting to become familiar but they are not there yet. After removing App and Ga Southern, JMU hasn't played any SBC opponent more than 6 times. And Troy is the only West school JMU has played more than once.
I think you're overlooking a couple of important factors.
First, the ACC's current television contract—despite being negotiated years before the Big 12's most recent deal—is still worth significantly more overall than the Big 12's(roughly 90 million per year). That suggests the ACC brand, inventory, and media value have remained stronger even under what many consider an undervalued contract. If they can maintain at least 75% of their current contract value it will still be worth considering by the east coast Big 12 schools.
Second, the timing matters. The most likely window for another major round of realignment is 2030–31, when the Big 12's Grant of Rights expires and ACC's is reduced. At that point, schools would be free to evaluate all of their options rather than being locked into the conference.
I am not saying it going to happen, but it most certainly will be entertained by all. In particular WVU and UC whose fans are going through what Marshall fans just recently did. They want more games against schools they are familiar with and can TRAVEL too.
As to your second point, When JMU joined the Sun Belt, they weren't starting from scratch. Fans already knew who App State, Marshall, Old Dominion, Coastal Carolina, and Georgia Southern were. Those were schools they had competed against or followed for years, and they fit naturally into JMU's geographic footprint. And the conference allowed them to consistently play them through a regional based schedule.
The American is a different story. If schools like Memphis, Tulane, and USF were to leave then don't be shocked if Army/Navy think about it too. You're largely left with ECU, Charlotte, and maybe App State as familiar regional opponents. The rest of the schedule becomes more games against schools like FAU, North Texas, Rice, Tulsa, and UTSA.
For a lot of schools and fan bases, that's not a compelling selling point. Many of them have already been in that conference footprint before. It's essentially "been there, done that." One of the reasons schools like Marshall were so eager to leave Conference USA wasn't because those programs were bad—it was because the regional rivalries and fan interest had eroded. Moving back toward that same collection of opponents isn't necessarily an upgrade. However, if the American only loses 1 school, then go for it (assuming SBC TV money is still bad).
As to the flavor of the month comment. it wasn't meant as disrespect, just means they are the team everybody talks about right now. No different than what Marshall or App have been through.