Dukes_Royals
All American

Posts: 2,999
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 84
I Root For: James Madison University
Location: Harrisonburg, VA
|
RE: Potential AAC raid of Sun Belt
(07-28-2026 12:39 PM)Herd6993 Wrote: (07-27-2026 03:48 PM)Dukes_Royals Wrote: (07-27-2026 03:22 PM)Herd6993 Wrote: (07-27-2026 02:58 PM)High Country Student Wrote: The main appeal is more money and a conference with better brand access to the CFP. Whether we like it or not, AAC teams seem to have a much easier time getting ranked in those polls and gaining access to the NY6 or CFP. For App, we would also get two in state conference opponents.
The teams benefiting from that perception are the very ones rumored to be leaving—Memphis, Tulane, USF, and possibly even Navy and Army. If that happens, the AAC's television value, national perception, and CFP credibility are all going to take a hit.
At that point, you're no longer comparing today's AAC to the Sun Belt. If those departures occur, the AAC would not be much different than "C-USA 3.0".
However, if it is that important to be with ECU and UNCC, knock yourself out.
Every conference is like that. Take Troy, JMU, Louisiana, and App out of the SBC, and you only have two division champions left since the 2016-2017 season (Marshall and Coastal). Are the AAC's leftovers better than the SBC's leftovers? Some would say yes, others would say no.
I'm not sure why you're including Troy and Louisiana in the equation. Neither has been seriously mentioned as a candidate to leave the Sun Belt.
As for the AAC, it's worth noting that almost every team that has played in its conference championship over the past several years is either already gone or rumored to be leaving. Cincinnati, Houston, UCF, and SMU have already departed. Now Memphis, Tulane, and USF are widely discussed as potential targets, with even Army and Navy possibly hitting the door, if that occurs.
That would leave North Texas and Tulsa as the only recent conference championship participants likely remaining. So the real question is this: if those departures happen, what exactly are you joining?
Does a conference built around North Texas, Rice, Tulsa, UAB, FAU, Charlotte, Temple, and the remaining members really excite you?
Just as important, if the AAC loses those brands, its television revenue will decline, and so is its CFP clout. The conference's current perception was built largely by programs that are already gone or may soon be gone. Yes, there will be exit fees, but history has shown that the schools remaining in the conference typically retain most of that money rather than distributing it to future members. A new member is much more likely to inherit a conference with lower media value and less national influence than the one being discussed today
I took the top two Eastern football programs and the top two Western football programs. There has been no smoke on any SBC schools to the AAC (just JMU wants to be in a P4 said by our President) so its all hypothetical. So my hypothetical the AAC loses 4 schools and adds 4 SBC schools.
And in that scenario, you still 100% leave the SBC. Yes the best programs are out of the AAC, but the leftovers are better than the leftovers in the SBC. Since the SBC would also be taking a hit losing its top programs.
|
|