Attackcoog
Moderator

Posts: 49,255
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
Saw an interesting question----would this end the popular practice of early spring enrollment by incoming high school football players seeking to get a head start by participating in spring practices?
(This post was last modified: 06-25-2026 07:36 PM by Attackcoog.)
|
|
| 06-25-2026 07:35 PM |
|
JxGx78
1st String

Posts: 1,264
Joined: Sep 2006
Reputation: 41
I Root For: UAB
Location: Birmingham, AL
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-25-2026 07:35 PM)Attackcoog Wrote: Saw an interesting question----would this end the popular practice of early spring enrollment by incoming high school football players seeking to get a head start by participating in spring practices?
With the purposed changes to the calendar around spring/summer practices I think we will see more of an NFL style OTA summer schedule vs the traditional spring practices.
|
|
| 06-25-2026 07:50 PM |
|
46566
1st String

Posts: 1,624
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation: 25
I Root For: Gonzaga
Location: California
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
I'd prefer a 6th year option of a medical redshirt exemption. If a player gets injured they should be given a extra year. Regular red shirts are built in. If anything maybe cap the medical red shirts a player can have at one or two. A player basically gets 1 regular redshirt and potentially 1 medical redshirt plus 4 playing years.
|
|
| 06-25-2026 08:02 PM |
|
Gitanole
Barista

Posts: 13,937
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2821
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-24-2026 01:52 PM)Attackcoog Wrote: Not sure it makes any difference at this point. The NCAA has lost virtually any ability to enforce rules---so does changing the rule really matter when virtually any rule they create would likely lose in court if challenged? To answer my own question---I guess it still matters....until it doesnt.
That was my feeling when I saw your OP. Where has it been established that the NCAA can constitutionally make policy like this?
Establish that first, then this looks like a rule. Until then this looks like lawsuit bait.
|
|
| 06-25-2026 10:06 PM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-25-2026 10:06 PM)Gitanole Wrote: (06-24-2026 01:52 PM)Attackcoog Wrote: Not sure it makes any difference at this point. The NCAA has lost virtually any ability to enforce rules---so does changing the rule really matter when virtually any rule they create would likely lose in court if challenged? To answer my own question---I guess it still matters....until it doesnt.
That was my feeling when I saw your OP. Where has it been established that the NCAA can constitutionally make policy like this?
Establish that first, then this looks like a rule. Until then this looks like lawsuit bait.
In the absence of a lawsuit, you can't establish that it's constitutional. On the other hand, some NCAA policies have been judged to pass muster, and if any policy is likely to be OK, I imagine this one is. Will it be challenged? Without question.
|
|
| 06-26-2026 09:42 AM |
|
jimrtex
All American

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-25-2026 07:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court.
I mean coaches can jump five schools in five years, but players are limited to one. How is that OK?
IRL one can work for a new company every year without penalty. Students can change schools without penalty. But athletes are restricted to one transfer?
This is written by a coach, for coaches.
I have a very hard time seeing how this will be defended in court if/when there is a lawsuit.
It’s not about the age itself, but rather like every other attempted NCAA rule on player compensation and movement, the colleges are imposing these rules from above without any actual agreement with the players themselves. That has been the crux of virtually every antitrust case (and eventual loss) against the NCAA.
The fact that they’re still allowing exceptions for religious mission and military service time also shows that it’s not some type of safety concern about older players.
If it was strictly a clear restriction on those who had played a certain professional level of their sport, it would have a better chance of passing legal muster.
Rule of reason. The rules have a pro-competitive basis.
Playing rules are a result of an agreement between schools. If a school is restricted to having 11 players on the field and 12 games in a season that is a constraint on labor opportunities for football workers. Rules requiring football workers to be students making progress towards a degree is a constraint on labor opportunities for football workers who are not inclined to going to college, or not very good at academic work, or are lazy.
But all of these have a pro-competitive effect. While courts have ruled that college athletes are not amateurs, they have never ruled that they don't have to be students. Since student athletes have to achieved 40% of credits after two years, 60% after three years, and 80% after four years, it is not unreasonable to restrict student athletes to five years of competition when they are expected to complete their degree in five years or less.
The exceptions for religious missions and military service recognize these as legitimate reasons for interrupting college. I wouldn't be surprised if there were not waivers for students whose injury was so severe that they could attend class or otherwise make academic progress.
|
|
| 06-29-2026 09:05 AM |
|
ken d
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,309
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-25-2026 07:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court.
I mean coaches can jump five schools in five years, but players are limited to one. How is that OK?
IRL one can work for a new company every year without penalty. Students can change schools without penalty. But athletes are restricted to one transfer?
This is written by a coach, for coaches.
I have a very hard time seeing how this will be defended in court if/when there is a lawsuit.
It’s not about the age itself, but rather like every other attempted NCAA rule on player compensation and movement, the colleges are imposing these rules from above without any actual agreement with the players themselves. That has been the crux of virtually every antitrust case (and eventual loss) against the NCAA.
The fact that they’re still allowing exceptions for religious mission and military service time also shows that it’s not some type of safety concern about older players.
If it was strictly a clear restriction on those who had played a certain professional level of their sport, it would have a better chance of passing legal muster.
If they can't enforce a reasonable rule like this without a CBA, how can they enforce any rule at all? For example, does this mean that that the rules requiring an athlete to be a full time student are unenforceable? Or requiring reasonable progress toward a degree?
|
|
| 06-29-2026 10:53 AM |
|
Attackcoog
Moderator

Posts: 49,255
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-29-2026 10:53 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-25-2026 07:10 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court.
I mean coaches can jump five schools in five years, but players are limited to one. How is that OK?
IRL one can work for a new company every year without penalty. Students can change schools without penalty. But athletes are restricted to one transfer?
This is written by a coach, for coaches.
I have a very hard time seeing how this will be defended in court if/when there is a lawsuit.
It’s not about the age itself, but rather like every other attempted NCAA rule on player compensation and movement, the colleges are imposing these rules from above without any actual agreement with the players themselves. That has been the crux of virtually every antitrust case (and eventual loss) against the NCAA.
The fact that they’re still allowing exceptions for religious mission and military service time also shows that it’s not some type of safety concern about older players.
If it was strictly a clear restriction on those who had played a certain professional level of their sport, it would have a better chance of passing legal muster.
If they can't enforce a reasonable rule like this without a CBA, how can they enforce any rule at all? For example, does this mean that that the rules requiring an athlete to be a full time student are unenforceable? Or requiring reasonable progress toward a degree?
I think the Sorsby fiasco showed us just how weak the conferences are with respect to rule enforcement in this current litigious environment. That mess is the main reason Ive come around to the idea the conferences probably need some sort of Congressional grant of a limited anti-trust exemption---and they need it sooner rather than later. As long as there is no players union to negotiate a CBA with---I simply dont see any alternative for a functional league.
|
|
| 06-29-2026 11:21 AM |
|
TrojanCampaign
Heisman

Posts: 6,093
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 335
I Root For: USC, AAMU,
Location: Huntsville
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
I'm not a fan of the obvious age discrimination here. College sports are something that college students do. And we don't prevent people older than 24 from going to college. So why should they be prevented from playing sports? For example, let's say I'm a woman. I get pregnant at 18 and decide to focus on school. But the I choose to resume pursuing sports at 22. If I'm still good enough to make a roster why is it right to discriminate against me?
|
|
| 06-29-2026 12:10 PM |
|
Attackcoog
Moderator

Posts: 49,255
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
|
RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes
(06-29-2026 12:10 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote: I'm not a fan of the obvious age discrimination here. College sports are something that college students do. And we don't prevent people older than 24 from going to college. So why should they be prevented from playing sports? For example, let's say I'm a woman. I get pregnant at 18 and decide to focus on school. But the I choose to resume pursuing sports at 22. If I'm still good enough to make a roster why is it right to discriminate against me?
The article does mention the rule provides for a maternity exception. I dont know if that means just the typical time given to women in the workforce for maternity leave---or if it is an exception allowing the athlete to compete their 5 years well after what would normally be considered too old by rule to compete. There isnt a lot of detail presented.
(This post was last modified: 06-29-2026 12:59 PM by Attackcoog.)
|
|
| 06-29-2026 12:58 PM |
|