![]() |
|
5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes (/thread-1029918.html) Pages: 1 2 |
5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Attackcoog - 06-24-2026 12:31 PM Eager to lessen the chaos of the transfer portal era, the NCAA approved a new eligibility model for Division I athletes on Tuesday that will allow five seasons of competition over a five-year period that begins with their full-time enrollment or the academic year following their 19th birthday, whichever occurs first. https://www.nbcsports.com/college-football/news/ncaa-panel-approves-new-eligibility-rules-giving-division-i-athletes-5-years-to-play-5-seasons RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - The Beaver - 06-24-2026 01:25 PM This was in Trump's EO and both house's bills, wasn’t it? Not exactly a huge fan of it myself but it is what it is. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Attackcoog - 06-24-2026 01:52 PM Not sure it makes any difference at this point. The NCAA has lost virtually any ability to enforce rules---so does changing the rule really matter when virtually any rule they create would likely lose in court if challenged? To answer my own question---I guess it still matters....until it doesnt. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - PicksUp - 06-24-2026 01:57 PM From X/Twitter: [Rothstein] Attorney Ryan Downton --- the same attorney that represented Diego Pavia against the NCAA --- tells me that a group of more than 50 college basketball players from the HS Class of 2022 will be filing lawsuits in at least five states seeking inclusion in the NCAA's rule change. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - AssKickingChicken - 06-24-2026 04:43 PM (06-24-2026 01:25 PM)The Beaver Wrote: This was in Trump's EO and both house's bills, wasn’t it? Not exactly a huge fan of it myself but it is what it is. I don’t want to get political or into anything related to his EO, but why do you oppose the five year limit? That’s pretty much the system we have had for years until fairly recently. You got four years plus a redshirt. The redshirt rules have been loosened considerably. Not really a fan of that but I can live with it. I don’t like the players getting eight or nine years, it’s college, not a career. Let them play every game in all five years. Normal college students aren’t always graduating in four years anyway. If you get hurt, too damn bad. After five years you’re done. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - AztecEmpire - 06-24-2026 04:48 PM Always disliked calculating if someone spent their RS year or not, 5 for 5, keep it simple. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - billybobby777 - 06-24-2026 05:55 PM If you want more than 5 years of eligibility you can go on a 2 year LDS mission. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Attackcoog - 06-24-2026 06:00 PM (06-24-2026 05:55 PM)billybobby777 Wrote: If you want more than 5 years of eligibility you can go on a 2 year LDS mission. Or the military. I think military service and religious commitments are the only 2 exceptions found in the 5 to play 5 rule. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - The Beaver - 06-24-2026 06:07 PM (06-24-2026 04:43 PM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:(06-24-2026 01:25 PM)The Beaver Wrote: This was in Trump's EO and both house's bills, wasn’t it? Not exactly a huge fan of it myself but it is what it is. I don't like the sequential part or the age limits. If someone is a student who hasn't played professionally they should be allowed to participate for four years plus, seemingly, a red shirt year. I don't see why eligibility should expire without the player actually playing. Though of course I am not a huge fan of modern day red-shirting either. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - bryanw1995 - 06-24-2026 06:08 PM (06-24-2026 04:48 PM)AztecEmpire Wrote: Always disliked calculating if someone spent their RS year or not, 5 for 5, keep it simple. This is my thought, too. 5 years from when you graduate hs or when you turn 19, whichever comes first. Simple and easy. You tear up your knee and miss a year, you still got 4 more years. Get hurt 4 times and you don't end up spending 8 years in college like Cam Rising did after all of his medical redshirts. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Attackcoog - 06-24-2026 07:19 PM (06-24-2026 06:08 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:(06-24-2026 04:48 PM)AztecEmpire Wrote: Always disliked calculating if someone spent their RS year or not, 5 for 5, keep it simple. Employers are not allowed to discriminate on the basis of age---though the players are not considered employees (at least they arent yet) and the law exists primarily to protect folks over 40 from age descrimination. Of course, some smarty pants very athletic 40 year old freshman might be able to make a case on that basis. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Aztec Since 88 - 06-24-2026 07:55 PM (06-24-2026 06:00 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:(06-24-2026 05:55 PM)billybobby777 Wrote: If you want more than 5 years of eligibility you can go on a 2 year LDS mission. The only other exception i can think of is pregnancy for women sports . RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - USF_Bullsharks - 06-25-2026 08:05 AM Simple is better. I would have been ok with 6 years too, but 5 is fine. I'm also still a proponent of sitting a year for transferring and conference restrictions on intra-conference transfers. Times have changed and don't think those are ever coming back. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - ken d - 06-25-2026 09:04 AM (06-24-2026 01:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote: From X/Twitter: With the NCAA's history of losing in court, you can be sure there will always be attorneys (and clients) who will challenge any NCAA ruling on a contingency fee basis. Personally, I believe they would lose this one, and if they start having wins in court the lawsuits will slow down. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - ken d - 06-25-2026 09:47 AM (06-24-2026 01:57 PM)PicksUp Wrote: From X/Twitter: Those players can't be suing in order to be subject to the new rules. The rule change does not apply to athletes already enrolled. They will be able to compete based on the rules in effect before this change. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Garden_KC - 06-25-2026 02:27 PM (06-25-2026 08:05 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote: Simple is better. I would have been ok with 6 years too, but 5 is fine. I'm also still a proponent of sitting a year for transferring and conference restrictions on intra-conference transfers. Times have changed and don't think those are ever coming back. Six years is more accommodating for a graduate transfer. It also allows for the stockpiling of more experience on the roster. It makes freshman classes smaller combined with the 105 player rule there are less players to replace. Five years makes transferring more risky since it limits the amount of time you'll have to compete in most cases. If less players are transferring that also can limit roster spots for freshman to a degree becuse they are also competing with players in the portal for those spots. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Stugray2 - 06-25-2026 03:21 PM I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court. I mean coaches can jump five schools in five years, but players are limited to one. How is that OK? IRL one can work for a new company every year without penalty. Students can change schools without penalty. But athletes are restricted to one transfer? This is written by a coach, for coaches. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - nodak651 - 06-25-2026 04:54 PM (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court. I'm all for that if players paid a buyout like coaches do. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Frank the Tank - 06-25-2026 07:10 PM (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court. I have a very hard time seeing how this will be defended in court if/when there is a lawsuit. It’s not about the age itself, but rather like every other attempted NCAA rule on player compensation and movement, the colleges are imposing these rules from above without any actual agreement with the players themselves. That has been the crux of virtually every antitrust case (and eventual loss) against the NCAA. The fact that they’re still allowing exceptions for religious mission and military service time also shows that it’s not some type of safety concern about older players. If it was strictly a clear restriction on those who had played a certain professional level of their sport, it would have a better chance of passing legal muster. RE: 5 Years to Play 5 Likely Coming for College Athletes - Gitanole - 06-25-2026 07:15 PM (06-25-2026 03:21 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: I wonder how the NCAA thinks this will hold up in court. Many proposed limits on athletes are noticeably quiet about any corresponding limits on coaches, yes. |