The Cutter of Bish
Heisman

Posts: 8,832
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
|
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 10:28 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (06-20-2026 09:32 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote: (06-18-2026 10:11 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: (06-18-2026 05:27 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote: Be it Villanova's original grounds, or Cabrini's old space, or Rosemont's across the tracks by Villanova, Radnor Township houses it all, and won't be playing. This feels like a battle Villanova is more willing to take with the Township, and with some of the new facilities built over the years (past two decades, really), it feels like a draw. Especially when looking at Villanova to the south/west side of Lancaster Avenue with what used to be fields and a gravel parking lot. Athletics, otoh...
Part of me wonders if Villanova would ever want to build a facility like Xfinity/Wells Fargo Center (along I-95) on its campus, but just can't because of the Township. They have the space to do it now. Yet, location, while it's decent enough by Villanova's main campus, it's still not necessarily ideal. People talk up SEPTA access. Sure, there's two lines (high-speed and regional). I don't know if you could ever get Amtrak into that equation (since the regional line is on Amtrak tracks). I-476 can become a parking lot, and Lancaster and Montgomery Avenues pivot to traffic light-h*ll. I-95 feels like bliss by comparison to some if you aren't on campus.
Two knits…
Rosemont College’s grounds are in a different township and county. Although the two campuses are adjacent, Villanova is in Radnor/Delaware County while Rosemont is in Lower Merion/Montgomery County. VU’s merger with Rosemont College seems very synergistic…likely a similar logistical situation as University of Notre Dame & bordering St Mary’s College.
If Villanova University ever needs to enlarge or replace the Finneran Pavilion, IMO they should still be able to compromise with local residents. The University has done an outstanding job with all the new construction over the past several decades. Today’s Philly Inquirer had a front page article reporting that Villanova starter homes now exceed $1M…the highest home values in the region. Villanova University actually transitioned from a commuter to residential institution while dramatically improving the aesthetics of the community. Moving a proposed new arena closer to the Blue Route makes intuitive sense for managing traffic and minimizing residents’ concerns.
Actually, they both straddle the county line, but, yeah, the "heart" of Rosemont's campus is in MontCo/Lower Merion (both have some/few properties/infrastructure in the other respective county/township). A challenge with the Rosemont campus is that the current primary access is via the smaller Montgomery Avenue road, and not as close as 476 and Lancaster Avenue. I don't know if doing business athletically is more feasible in Lower Merion (it's certainly more friendly with commercial zoning), but, I don't know how Radnor isn't also disrupted, even a little.
The bit about a bigger arena on the main campus is more about that challenging relationship the school has with its athletics and Radnor Township. That projects have to be more innovative, restorative/refurbishing than new and bigger. Refurb projects, like the Finneran one from those years back, cost a lot. The football stadium enhancement projects...not cheap given what it fully hopes to achieve. If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.
My point is that a large part of the “challenging relationship” between the university and the township was previously deserved, but now may have shifted.
IMHO, old Villanova University was an aesthetic eye-sore for too long. A semi-commuter school that prized utilitarianism…parking lots and chain link fences providing the first impressions for too many decades. The school’s aesthetics wasn’t in synch with the ending component of its Augustinian ethos…the primacy of love of God and neighbors. Its neighbors have always been very wealthy, upper middle-class. By contrast, Georgetown University has always been architecturally and aesthetically aligned with its neighbors. The DC comparable to Villanova University was George Washington University from the 1970s and 1980s…it just didn’t adequately invest in enhancing its campus and neighborhood.
Today’s Villanova University is completely different. The recent developments on Lancaster Avenue have dramatically improved the aesthetics of the entire community. It was contentious and somewhat petty, but the positioning of crosses on the new foot bridge (parallel versus perpendicular to the flow of street traffic) was instructive. No doubt that neighbors demands for quality and style can be tedious and expensive, but the end result are win-win solutions that build trust. As a sidelight, IMHO Northwestern’s renovated Ryan Stadium is looking gorgeous from the outside…a comparably wealthy neighborhood in Evanston, IL that hosts FBS crowds.
This makes me wonder if Temple could have granted more concessions to the surrounding neighborhood.
Temple is more like Tulane and Georgetown where the local relationship is a specific neighborhood within city limits. Temple might face resistance from locals at the impact site for an OCS, but, given what Temple has done over the years with property acquisition in the area, it's more favorable with simply less locals than 15-20+ years back. Resistance is more likely city hall itself because of impacted nearby infrastructure, like area roads and mass transit.
Villanova's like Boston College, where the campus spans two or so different towns. Villanova being in two different counties, to boot. BC football's stadium is Boston's issue, but Newton is impacted. I don't know if doing business in one is preferred over the other. The differences between Montco and Lower Merion and that part of Delco and Radnor are noticeable. A lot more moving parts.
I don't know if Radnor cares enough about Villanova's intentions, though. If Villanova could be a suburban version of Penn, and it does feel like they're trying, that relationship/feud could be like Captain America, with Radnor totally pulling the "I can do this all day" bit with respect to resistance and litigation. I don't know if I'd color things "win-win," either, considering those costs just pile onto incoming students, and program growth due to zoning and building restrictions has to be more incremental (I'm thinking of their newish School of Engineering building; good space, but Penn State it is not). I'm also mindful of that basketball game a few years back where there was a delay due to a loose/open panel that acted like a magnifying glass at the arena, blinding players and officials with the sun that had to be waited out until the panel could be adjusted or the sun just passed on by. $80 million...for that?
It's one of the things I hope for Villanova and the Rosemont acquisition, and that Villanova can find some of its operations in MontCo to be more feasible with Radnor just having to sit and cry over it. If Lower Merion is more aligned toward Villanova's ambitious growth and vision, I'm for that. DelCo can just stay weird.
|
|