Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
ACC's BigEast back-fill
Author Message
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #101
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-18-2026 11:01 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  They just spent over $60 million renovating Finneran (which it needed)...I think they are good for awhile with that

https://www.ewingcole.com/project/finneran-pavilion/

The issue is football. While the product has been very good, the facility is lacking. Its really not even MAC level. At some point, a teardown/replacement would be in order, in my opinion.

It would be interesting if Temple and Nova had a shared site that fit their needs (maybe 30K)...and worked with the City to build it in a good central location. The MLS would have been an opportunity to build a really good facility that could house all 3 (via rental). Maybe Philly would step up and make that a community Economic Development project at some point. Bring MLS in from Chester, give Temple a better sized facility and bring in Nova from the suburbs. It would need to be on the SEPTA line.

Maybe, just maybe, Villanova doesn't need FBS to be successful as an institution, notwithstanding that if it can't average more than 4,000 being a top 10 FCS program, the investment to bring it up to G6 is prohibitive. The same applies for Georgetown and games at Audi Field and/or the new Commanders stadium.
(This post was last modified: 06-18-2026 08:47 PM by DFW HOYA.)
06-18-2026 08:46 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HP-TBDPITL Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,527
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #102
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-18-2026 08:46 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 11:01 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  They just spent over $60 million renovating Finneran (which it needed)...I think they are good for awhile with that

https://www.ewingcole.com/project/finneran-pavilion/

The issue is football. While the product has been very good, the facility is lacking. Its really not even MAC level. At some point, a teardown/replacement would be in order, in my opinion.

It would be interesting if Temple and Nova had a shared site that fit their needs (maybe 30K)...and worked with the City to build it in a good central location. The MLS would have been an opportunity to build a really good facility that could house all 3 (via rental). Maybe Philly would step up and make that a community Economic Development project at some point. Bring MLS in from Chester, give Temple a better sized facility and bring in Nova from the suburbs. It would need to be on the SEPTA line.

Maybe, just maybe, Villanova doesn't need FBS to be successful as an institution, notwithstanding that if it can't average more than 4,000 being a top 10 FCS program, the investment to bring it up to G6 is prohibitive. The same applies for Georgetown and games at Audi Field and/or the new Commanders stadium.

Oh I agree completely. Nova doesnt need FBS football....but its a misnomer to say they didnt go after it because of local logistics for a stadium. Philly had an opportunity with the MLS to do something that could have helped out Temple....and potentially leave the door open for Villanova. But that didnt happen and the Union have a 30 year lease that will go to 2040 now.
06-19-2026 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,832
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #103
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-18-2026 10:11 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 05:27 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-15-2026 01:41 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-15-2026 12:49 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  I've been there. My daughter got recruited to play soccer there. There is space, at least as much space as Tulane had. Tulane's stadium backs up to an old residential district and there was consternation about building it. So no, Nova isnt special in that regard.

It's less about the space as much as it is about the local government, particularly as they work with these communities while acquiring the two other schools. Radnor is not signing off on that kind of construction.

Other schools in that conference have less space and even more litigious neighbors.

Be it Villanova's original grounds, or Cabrini's old space, or Rosemont's across the tracks by Villanova, Radnor Township houses it all, and won't be playing. This feels like a battle Villanova is more willing to take with the Township, and with some of the new facilities built over the years (past two decades, really), it feels like a draw. Especially when looking at Villanova to the south/west side of Lancaster Avenue with what used to be fields and a gravel parking lot. Athletics, otoh...

Part of me wonders if Villanova would ever want to build a facility like Xfinity/Wells Fargo Center (along I-95) on its campus, but just can't because of the Township. They have the space to do it now. Yet, location, while it's decent enough by Villanova's main campus, it's still not necessarily ideal. People talk up SEPTA access. Sure, there's two lines (high-speed and regional). I don't know if you could ever get Amtrak into that equation (since the regional line is on Amtrak tracks). I-476 can become a parking lot, and Lancaster and Montgomery Avenues pivot to traffic light-h*ll. I-95 feels like bliss by comparison to some if you aren't on campus.

Two knits…

Rosemont College’s grounds are in a different township and county. Although the two campuses are adjacent, Villanova is in Radnor/Delaware County while Rosemont is in Lower Merion/Montgomery County. VU’s merger with Rosemont College seems very synergistic…likely a similar logistical situation as University of Notre Dame & bordering St Mary’s College.

If Villanova University ever needs to enlarge or replace the Finneran Pavilion, IMO they should still be able to compromise with local residents. The University has done an outstanding job with all the new construction over the past several decades. Today’s Philly Inquirer had a front page article reporting that Villanova starter homes now exceed $1M…the highest home values in the region. Villanova University actually transitioned from a commuter to residential institution while dramatically improving the aesthetics of the community. Moving a proposed new arena closer to the Blue Route makes intuitive sense for managing traffic and minimizing residents’ concerns.

Actually, they both straddle the county line, but, yeah, the "heart" of Rosemont's campus is in MontCo/Lower Merion (both have some/few properties/infrastructure in the other respective county/township). A challenge with the Rosemont campus is that the current primary access is via the smaller Montgomery Avenue road, and not as close as 476 and Lancaster Avenue. I don't know if doing business athletically is more feasible in Lower Merion (it's certainly more friendly with commercial zoning), but, I don't know how Radnor isn't also disrupted, even a little.

The bit about a bigger arena on the main campus is more about that challenging relationship the school has with its athletics and Radnor Township. That projects have to be more innovative, restorative/refurbishing than new and bigger. Refurb projects, like the Finneran one from those years back, cost a lot. The football stadium enhancement projects...not cheap given what it fully hopes to achieve. If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.
06-19-2026 11:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #104
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.
06-19-2026 07:05 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Cutter of Bish Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,832
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
Post: #105
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.
06-19-2026 07:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #106
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 10:11 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 05:27 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-15-2026 01:41 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-15-2026 12:49 PM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  I've been there. My daughter got recruited to play soccer there. There is space, at least as much space as Tulane had. Tulane's stadium backs up to an old residential district and there was consternation about building it. So no, Nova isnt special in that regard.

It's less about the space as much as it is about the local government, particularly as they work with these communities while acquiring the two other schools. Radnor is not signing off on that kind of construction.

Other schools in that conference have less space and even more litigious neighbors.

Be it Villanova's original grounds, or Cabrini's old space, or Rosemont's across the tracks by Villanova, Radnor Township houses it all, and won't be playing. This feels like a battle Villanova is more willing to take with the Township, and with some of the new facilities built over the years (past two decades, really), it feels like a draw. Especially when looking at Villanova to the south/west side of Lancaster Avenue with what used to be fields and a gravel parking lot. Athletics, otoh...

Part of me wonders if Villanova would ever want to build a facility like Xfinity/Wells Fargo Center (along I-95) on its campus, but just can't because of the Township. They have the space to do it now. Yet, location, while it's decent enough by Villanova's main campus, it's still not necessarily ideal. People talk up SEPTA access. Sure, there's two lines (high-speed and regional). I don't know if you could ever get Amtrak into that equation (since the regional line is on Amtrak tracks). I-476 can become a parking lot, and Lancaster and Montgomery Avenues pivot to traffic light-h*ll. I-95 feels like bliss by comparison to some if you aren't on campus.

Two knits…

Rosemont College’s grounds are in a different township and county. Although the two campuses are adjacent, Villanova is in Radnor/Delaware County while Rosemont is in Lower Merion/Montgomery County. VU’s merger with Rosemont College seems very synergistic…likely a similar logistical situation as University of Notre Dame & bordering St Mary’s College.

If Villanova University ever needs to enlarge or replace the Finneran Pavilion, IMO they should still be able to compromise with local residents. The University has done an outstanding job with all the new construction over the past several decades. Today’s Philly Inquirer had a front page article reporting that Villanova starter homes now exceed $1M…the highest home values in the region. Villanova University actually transitioned from a commuter to residential institution while dramatically improving the aesthetics of the community. Moving a proposed new arena closer to the Blue Route makes intuitive sense for managing traffic and minimizing residents’ concerns.

Actually, they both straddle the county line, but, yeah, the "heart" of Rosemont's campus is in MontCo/Lower Merion (both have some/few properties/infrastructure in the other respective county/township). A challenge with the Rosemont campus is that the current primary access is via the smaller Montgomery Avenue road, and not as close as 476 and Lancaster Avenue. I don't know if doing business athletically is more feasible in Lower Merion (it's certainly more friendly with commercial zoning), but, I don't know how Radnor isn't also disrupted, even a little.

The bit about a bigger arena on the main campus is more about that challenging relationship the school has with its athletics and Radnor Township. That projects have to be more innovative, restorative/refurbishing than new and bigger. Refurb projects, like the Finneran one from those years back, cost a lot. The football stadium enhancement projects...not cheap given what it fully hopes to achieve. If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

My point is that a large part of the “challenging relationship” between the university and the township was previously deserved, but now may have shifted.

IMHO, old Villanova University was an aesthetic eye-sore for too long. A semi-commuter school that prized utilitarianism…parking lots and chain link fences providing the first impressions for too many decades. The school’s aesthetics wasn’t in synch with the ending component of its Augustinian ethos…the primacy of love of God and neighbors. Its neighbors have always been very wealthy, upper middle-class. By contrast, Georgetown University has always been architecturally and aesthetically aligned with its neighbors. The DC comparable to Villanova University was George Washington University from the 1970s and 1980s…it just didn’t adequately invest in enhancing its campus and neighborhood.

Today’s Villanova University is completely different. The recent developments on Lancaster Avenue have dramatically improved the aesthetics of the entire community. It was contentious and somewhat petty, but the positioning of crosses on the new foot bridge (parallel versus perpendicular to the flow of street traffic) was instructive. No doubt that neighbors demands for quality and style can be tedious and expensive, but the end result are win-win solutions that build trust. As a sidelight, IMHO Northwestern’s renovated Ryan Stadium is looking gorgeous from the outside…a comparably wealthy neighborhood in Evanston, IL that hosts FBS crowds.
06-20-2026 09:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #107
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 10:26 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-20-2026 10:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #108
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 09:32 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 10:11 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(06-18-2026 05:27 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-15-2026 01:41 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  It's less about the space as much as it is about the local government, particularly as they work with these communities while acquiring the two other schools. Radnor is not signing off on that kind of construction.

Other schools in that conference have less space and even more litigious neighbors.

Be it Villanova's original grounds, or Cabrini's old space, or Rosemont's across the tracks by Villanova, Radnor Township houses it all, and won't be playing. This feels like a battle Villanova is more willing to take with the Township, and with some of the new facilities built over the years (past two decades, really), it feels like a draw. Especially when looking at Villanova to the south/west side of Lancaster Avenue with what used to be fields and a gravel parking lot. Athletics, otoh...

Part of me wonders if Villanova would ever want to build a facility like Xfinity/Wells Fargo Center (along I-95) on its campus, but just can't because of the Township. They have the space to do it now. Yet, location, while it's decent enough by Villanova's main campus, it's still not necessarily ideal. People talk up SEPTA access. Sure, there's two lines (high-speed and regional). I don't know if you could ever get Amtrak into that equation (since the regional line is on Amtrak tracks). I-476 can become a parking lot, and Lancaster and Montgomery Avenues pivot to traffic light-h*ll. I-95 feels like bliss by comparison to some if you aren't on campus.

Two knits…

Rosemont College’s grounds are in a different township and county. Although the two campuses are adjacent, Villanova is in Radnor/Delaware County while Rosemont is in Lower Merion/Montgomery County. VU’s merger with Rosemont College seems very synergistic…likely a similar logistical situation as University of Notre Dame & bordering St Mary’s College.

If Villanova University ever needs to enlarge or replace the Finneran Pavilion, IMO they should still be able to compromise with local residents. The University has done an outstanding job with all the new construction over the past several decades. Today’s Philly Inquirer had a front page article reporting that Villanova starter homes now exceed $1M…the highest home values in the region. Villanova University actually transitioned from a commuter to residential institution while dramatically improving the aesthetics of the community. Moving a proposed new arena closer to the Blue Route makes intuitive sense for managing traffic and minimizing residents’ concerns.

Actually, they both straddle the county line, but, yeah, the "heart" of Rosemont's campus is in MontCo/Lower Merion (both have some/few properties/infrastructure in the other respective county/township). A challenge with the Rosemont campus is that the current primary access is via the smaller Montgomery Avenue road, and not as close as 476 and Lancaster Avenue. I don't know if doing business athletically is more feasible in Lower Merion (it's certainly more friendly with commercial zoning), but, I don't know how Radnor isn't also disrupted, even a little.

The bit about a bigger arena on the main campus is more about that challenging relationship the school has with its athletics and Radnor Township. That projects have to be more innovative, restorative/refurbishing than new and bigger. Refurb projects, like the Finneran one from those years back, cost a lot. The football stadium enhancement projects...not cheap given what it fully hopes to achieve. If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

My point is that a large part of the “challenging relationship” between the university and the township was previously deserved, but now may have shifted.

IMHO, old Villanova University was an aesthetic eye-sore for too long. A semi-commuter school that prized utilitarianism…parking lots and chain link fences providing the first impressions for too many decades. The school’s aesthetics wasn’t in synch with the ending component of its Augustinian ethos…the primacy of love of God and neighbors. Its neighbors have always been very wealthy, upper middle-class. By contrast, Georgetown University has always been architecturally and aesthetically aligned with its neighbors. The DC comparable to Villanova University was George Washington University from the 1970s and 1980s…it just didn’t adequately invest in enhancing its campus and neighborhood.

Today’s Villanova University is completely different. The recent developments on Lancaster Avenue have dramatically improved the aesthetics of the entire community. It was contentious and somewhat petty, but the positioning of crosses on the new foot bridge (parallel versus perpendicular to the flow of street traffic) was instructive. No doubt that neighbors demands for quality and style can be tedious and expensive, but the end result are win-win solutions that build trust. As a sidelight, IMHO Northwestern’s renovated Ryan Stadium is looking gorgeous from the outside…a comparably wealthy neighborhood in Evanston, IL that hosts FBS crowds.

This makes me wonder if Temple could have granted more concessions to the surrounding neighborhood.
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 10:28 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
06-20-2026 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #109
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 10:24 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.

Didn't PSU try to form an Eastern conference in the 80s before eventually turning to the B1G? iirc, it was BE stalwarts like Providence that killed that deal, not media-deal driven realignment. With PSU as a tentpole, Miami probably never leaves and the "Eastern" or "Big East", whatever they called it, would be stronger than the ACC today most likely, or at least comparable to it.
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 11:39 AM by bryanw1995.)
06-20-2026 11:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Acres Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,156
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 96
I Root For: Houston, Texas Southern
Location:
Post: #110
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-14-2026 08:47 PM)46566 Wrote:  I think Big 12 is to big to expand purely in the East. Teams are already going from Ohio to Florida and also to Arizona. Big 12 has to determine what it wants to be known for. Go easy and potentially anger the western 5 or stay in central and western US and simply hope West Virginia, UCF and Cincinnati leave to the ACC. Big 12 could try to build itself as the dominant conference from California to Texas for recruiting. Pick up San Diego State and Fresno State for a temporary half share each. Maybe look into Oregon State and Washington State. Subtly ask Cal and Stanford if they still want a eastern based conference as their main conference.

The 4Cs want to be in California. G5 schools though, at this point are a no go for the big12. I’d suspect they’d prefer Cal, Stanford if they are willing and if the network allow.
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 03:26 PM by Acres.)
06-20-2026 02:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bill Marsh Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
Post: #111
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 11:38 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:24 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.

Didn't PSU try to form an Eastern conference in the 80s before eventually turning to the B1G? iirc, it was BE stalwarts like Providence that killed that deal, not media-deal driven realignment. With PSU as a tentpole, Miami probably never leaves and the "Eastern" or "Big East", whatever they called it, would be stronger than the ACC today most likely, or at least comparable to it.

It wasn’t “BE stalwarts like Providence”who killed a proposed Eastern conference built around football. And Miami wasn’t part of any discussions at that time. PC and the BE didn’t have the ability to block the formation of a football centered conference for any schools who wanted to move in that direction. At the time football independence was a viable position while there were forces pushing schools toward forming basketball associations. It was that dynamic that was at work and the preferences of individual schools pursuing what they considered to be their own best interests.
06-20-2026 09:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bill Marsh Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
Post: #112
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 10:24 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.

Today Holy Cross has an enrollment a little over 3000. Back in 1986 its enrollment was 2500. They are highly competitive academically with a student body comprised entirely of high achievers. The idea that they could have continued to compete at IA or today’s FBS is a bridge too far. Colleges are academic institutions first and foremost. Decisions by their leadership should np be made based on what serves their academic mission - and at a school like Holy Cross, they are.
06-20-2026 09:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TUowl06 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,640
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
Post: #113
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
There was a good discussion about the hierarchy of Catholic higher education institutions in the United States. Generally it seemed like the following was the viewpoint...

Notre Dame and Georgetown are the "Holy Grails of Catholic Higher Education", which institution is better is debatable given context
Boston College, Villanova, Holy Cross and Fordham comprise the group of elites. Villanova is the most recent addition to this group thanks to a change in direction that was articulated perfectly by WahooWa84.

After the above six there's a clear drop off imo. St. Louis, Catholic U., U of Scranton, Marquette, Santa Clara, Loyola-Maryland, and Duquesne perhaps make up the next tier.
Then comes DePaul, St. John's, Seton Hall, Gonzaga, Dayton, St. Joe's, Xavier, Loyola-Chicago, Loyola-Marymount, and so on....
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 10:54 PM by TUowl06.)
06-20-2026 10:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Bill Marsh Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,634
Joined: Apr 2010
Reputation: 125
I Root For: UConn & Providence
Location: Connecticut
Post: #114
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 10:38 PM)TUowl06 Wrote:  There was a good discussion about the hierarchy of Catholic higher education institutions in the United States. Generally it seemed like the following was the viewpoint...

Notre Dame and Georgetown are the "Holy Grails of Catholic Higher Education", which institution is better is debatable given context
Boston College, Villanova, Holy Cross and Fordham comprise the group of elites. Villanova is the most recent addition to this group thanks to a change in direction that was articulated perfectly by WahooWa84.

After the above six there's a clear drop off imo. St. Louis, Catholic U., U of Scranton, Marquette, Santa Clara, Loyola-Maryland, and Duquesne perhaps make up the next tier.
Then comes DePaul, St. John's, Seton Hall, Gonzaga, Dayton, St. Joe's, Xavier, Loyola-Chicago, Loyola-Marymount, and so on....

I’m not so sure that Villanova is a recent addition. Way back in the 1962, there was a NY Times article written about the “Catholic Ivies”. It included:

Notre Dame
Georgetown
Holy Cross
Boston College
Fordham
Villanova
(This post was last modified: 06-20-2026 11:04 PM by Bill Marsh.)
06-20-2026 10:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TUowl06 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,640
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Temple/DePaul/K-State
Location: NEPA & Manhattan, KS
Post: #115
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 10:59 PM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:38 PM)TUowl06 Wrote:  There was a good discussion about the hierarchy of Catholic higher education institutions in the United States. Generally it seemed like the following was the viewpoint...

Notre Dame and Georgetown are the "Holy Grails of Catholic Higher Education", which institution is better is debatable given context
Boston College, Villanova, Holy Cross and Fordham comprise the group of elites. Villanova is the most recent addition to this group thanks to a change in direction that was articulated perfectly by WahooWa84.

After the above six there's a clear drop off imo. St. Louis, Catholic U., U of Scranton, Marquette, Santa Clara, Loyola-Maryland, and Duquesne perhaps make up the next tier.
Then comes DePaul, St. John's, Seton Hall, Gonzaga, Dayton, St. Joe's, Xavier, Loyola-Chicago, Loyola-Marymount, and so on....

I’m not so sure that Villanova is a recent addition. Way back in the 1962, there was a NY Times article written about the “Catholic Ivies”. It included:

Notre Dame
Georgetown
Holy Cross
Boston College
Fordham
Villanova

As someone who is interested in Catholic Higher Education I am surprised, but not shocked to see Villanova listed among that group considering the importance of geographic dispersion. This said, Villanova was widely viewed as a solid, regional Catholic institution until roughly the turn of the 21st century. Beyond Villanova's obvious ideological selling point, the institution's broad appeal was its demure Main Line location that provided easy access to the hustle and bustle of Philly. And circling back to 'Nova's ideology, the Jesuits generally hold themselves in the highest of regards when it comes to Catholic Education so an institution founded by the Augustinians had fight and claw for respect. To this point, it took Notre Dame significant time (into the 1970s, perhaps even the 1980s) to establish itself as the standard for Catholic Higher Ed.
06-21-2026 12:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #116
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 09:30 PM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:24 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.

Today Holy Cross has an enrollment a little over 3000. Back in 1986 its enrollment was 2500. They are highly competitive academically with a student body comprised entirely of high achievers. The idea that they could have continued to compete at IA or today’s FBS is a bridge too far. Colleges are academic institutions first and foremost. Decisions by their leadership should np be made based on what serves their academic mission - and at a school like Holy Cross, they are.

Sorry, I disagree. They dropped scholarships. That has nothing to do with enrollment. Their football stadium is over 23k and has been prior to 1986.
06-21-2026 07:34 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #117
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-21-2026 12:23 AM)TUowl06 Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:59 PM)Bill Marsh Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:38 PM)TUowl06 Wrote:  There was a good discussion about the hierarchy of Catholic higher education institutions in the United States. Generally it seemed like the following was the viewpoint...

Notre Dame and Georgetown are the "Holy Grails of Catholic Higher Education", which institution is better is debatable given context
Boston College, Villanova, Holy Cross and Fordham comprise the group of elites. Villanova is the most recent addition to this group thanks to a change in direction that was articulated perfectly by WahooWa84.

After the above six there's a clear drop off imo. St. Louis, Catholic U., U of Scranton, Marquette, Santa Clara, Loyola-Maryland, and Duquesne perhaps make up the next tier.
Then comes DePaul, St. John's, Seton Hall, Gonzaga, Dayton, St. Joe's, Xavier, Loyola-Chicago, Loyola-Marymount, and so on....

I’m not so sure that Villanova is a recent addition. Way back in the 1962, there was a NY Times article written about the “Catholic Ivies”. It included:

Notre Dame
Georgetown
Holy Cross
Boston College
Fordham
Villanova

As someone who is interested in Catholic Higher Education I am surprised, but not shocked to see Villanova listed among that group considering the importance of geographic dispersion. This said, Villanova was widely viewed as a solid, regional Catholic institution until roughly the turn of the 21st century. Beyond Villanova's obvious ideological selling point, the institution's broad appeal was its demure Main Line location that provided easy access to the hustle and bustle of Philly. And circling back to 'Nova's ideology, the Jesuits generally hold themselves in the highest of regards when it comes to Catholic Education so an institution founded by the Augustinians had fight and claw for respect. To this point, it took Notre Dame significant time (into the 1970s, perhaps even the 1980s) to establish itself as the standard for Catholic Higher Ed.

What about USF and St. Mary’s?
06-21-2026 07:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TerryD Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 16,979
Joined: Feb 2006
Reputation: 1269
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location: Grayson Highlands
Post: #118
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-20-2026 11:38 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-20-2026 10:24 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:29 PM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 07:05 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(06-19-2026 11:12 AM)The Cutter of Bish Wrote:  If Radnor wasn't the way that it is, or was, it's one of those "what if's" that could make things in the Philly area very different. And, yeah, I think the school is D1A/FBS because of that different relationship. As is...it is what it is.

Yet, you probably wouldn't put Georgetown in that same criteria, despite a nearly identical-sized athletic budget and number of sports sponsored.

No, I wouldn't. Maybe if Georgetown had produced highly regarded and relevant NFL talent and had football success at the FCS level, I might. Maybe if Villanova was as highly esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. If Boston College was as esteemed academically as Georgetown, I might. Schools like BC, Villanova, and others look up to Georgetown. Georgetown, arguably, doesn't have to look up to much amongst its Catholic peers, other than Notre Dame. It's looking more at the Ivy than others. The Ivy doesn't do football scholarships...cool, neither will Georgetown. Villanova isn't even close to being in that kind of class or company. Heck, nobody locally looks at them and Penn and confuses the two.

Exactly, great post. Nail on the head with the scholarship and Ivy rules.

One issue with many posters here is they tend to lump schools in groups like "Metro Catholic" and "Metro Public" for no reasons beyond the simple. It's especially strange when Pitt and UCF are lumped together, or even dare I say Cincinnati and Memphis. UCF isn't even in Orlando and Pitt is closer to a B1G school than a Big XII school, institutionally speaking.

I've often felt Villanova is more akin to Boston College than it is Georgetown, and had Father Fun-Police not tried to kill the program in the 80's, Villanova would have found a way to remain 1-A/FBS or moved up around the turn of the century.

Whether or not they should/shouldn't is subjective. Clearly, they have held high regard for football dating back to the late 1940's. Holy Cross is another Catholic institution that could have maintained 1-A/FBS ball, and actually has an adequate stadium.

This is opening a larger discussion of Eastern Football, and the lack of a conference or conferences to provide stability. Ideally, there would be two compact leagues; one upper tier (Penn State, Pitt, Syracuse etc.) and another mid-major (Villanova, Holy Cross, Delaware), but unfortunately media-deal driven realignment has created an uprooted ecosystem.

Didn't PSU try to form an Eastern conference in the 80s before eventually turning to the B1G? iirc, it was BE stalwarts like Providence that killed that deal, not media-deal driven realignment. With PSU as a tentpole, Miami probably never leaves and the "Eastern" or "Big East", whatever they called it, would be stronger than the ACC today most likely, or at least comparable to it.

Joe wanted unequal revenue sharing in football but equal revenue sharing in basketball.

That idea at that time killed the idea of an Eastern Conference with Penn State as a member.
06-21-2026 08:17 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TexanMark Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,093
Joined: Jul 2003
Reputation: 1539
I Root For: Syracuse
Location: St. Augustine, FL
Post: #119
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
This board has the most interesting discussions...
06-21-2026 09:29 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #120
RE: ACC's BigEast back-fill
(06-21-2026 07:34 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Sorry, I disagree. They dropped scholarships. That has nothing to do with enrollment. Their football stadium is over 23k and has been prior to 1986.

They brought them back more than a decade ago. All but one PL school offers scholarships at the 63-grant FCS limit.
(This post was last modified: 06-21-2026 12:57 PM by DFW HOYA.)
06-21-2026 12:57 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.