Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Thread Closed 
Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Author Message
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #61
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 11:24 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  Side note on the ACC, Todge alluded to this but when Cal, Stanford, and SMU joined up the ACC was able to exercise their pro rata clause to increase their total media deal by 17/14ths. That $$ of course does not distribute directly to the new schools who of course are on partial (or less) deals. It helps fund the performance payouts that kept fsu Clemson & co. appeased for now with the cash flow sitiation.

The ESPN deal still allows the ACC one more pro rata addition. So the ACC doesn’t even need to lose anyone to consider adding one more attractive up-and-comer from THE AMERICAN or the Big12 or any of the other g8 that look interesting. Bring USF (or Memphis, or Marshall) in on an smu deal, and espn will contractually up the ante in the fsu performance fund.

Won’t hold my breath on this scenario as I’m sure a bit of eyebrow raising already happened on the last +3 especially the ponies, so I really don’t think ACC adds an 18th (unless one of us make say back to back CFP runs including winning at least one playoff game)

And that one of us happened to also be AAU, and have a nice new stajium or major upgrades in works.

USF, Tulane, Rice, Buffalo is your short list.
Kansas would politely take the phone calls, but of course they’re not headed over.

I don’t see ACC adding anyone unless they lose teams. The 17 teams now is important because if the BigTen poaches 2, they are still over the 14 number which is key with ESPN deal. If that happens then I’m sure they’ll add to keep themselves safe if SEC takes anyone.

But we will get an idea on how this goes probably by 2028
06-03-2026 11:28 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #62
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

No, they won't. They didn't "choose" a private bank loan. They were essentially forced into it. The stadium revenue streams they're relying on are taxable, which makes the project ineligible for tax-exempt public bonding. That's why they went with a 7% private loan -- this isn't a matter of waiting for a better rate. Taxable municipal bonds exist, but their rates are highly comparable to private loans and carry so much overhead and oversight that it defeats the purpose.

Quote:USF management has determined that it is in the best interest of the University and DSO to issue the debt on a taxable basis[b] since most of the Project's [b]revenues will be 'private use' and/or used by private/for-profit tenants.

https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ummary.pdf

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

How is it being implied? It's not implied. It's happening right now. USF is incurring internal debt to pay external debt. Do you understand what that means? It's the institutional equivalent of paying off your credit cards with new credit cards, except the university is on the hook to underwrite the risk. So when they have to issue an internal loan, it leaves the reserves, it reduces liquidity, it can't be reinvested, and now the university is fully exposed to all of the risk. This specifically ties the endowment and institutional health directly to the athletic department's ability to service the debt.

This also means they're not actually paying for anything. They're kicking the can down the road and never chipping away at the principal. This is not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

The language is unambiguous. Financial communications use highly specific terminology to eliminate subjective interpretation and guesswork. What the memo clearly states is that the level of operating risk created by USF's financing structure dramatically increases the probability that both the endowment and charitable giving will be negatively impacted if athletics can't cover the debt service. That is the only correct reading of the sentence.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

No. There will be no bonding. It's a 20-year loan, and they're already borrowing internally just to make the payments.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

This analogy is absolute nonsense. USF is not a wealthy individual choosing to finance a house. They're an athletic department that can't pay its bills and is already having to borrow internally just to service a 7% loan. You don't "just invest the difference" when you don't have the capital. This isn't optional. It's called structural insolvency.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

Do you realize that you're over-complicating this? When the memo clearly states the debt may require subsidies from "unrestricted funds from the endowment," that means exactly what it says. Institutional money that would normally stay invested may have to be diverted to cover the athletic shortfalls. I don't know how that can be made any more clear. What difference does it make if it's principal or "PRECEDES" (investment yields) that you're misspelling? It's still endowment-sourced money that's being used to prop up athletics because they can't even cover their own financing. Anything not remaining with the endowment is actively taking from the endowment. Again, not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

No kidding. Of course every athletic department receives university support. When has that not been the case? Will you tell me next that water is wet? The point is that the institutional subsidies are mutually exclusive of the internal lending to cover debt service. They are not the same line items. A structural bailout isn't standard budgeting. Straw man much?
06-04-2026 12:28 AM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #63
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 11:01 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  Correct. Nothing is being taken from the endowment.

USF was not getting much revenue from playing at RJS
No money from concessions nor parking
No money from suites at RJS
No money from advertising at the stadium
They were being charged a fee for tickets sold

All the above will now be available as extra revenue in new stadium and we are not even accounting naming rights for the stadium.

In addition to this, you will also bring in later the Fletcher District which will also bring extra revenue and more events to the stadium.

Already the University is close to finalizing deal with the Tampa Bay Authority to help bring events and run events there.

I know for some of the haters on this board, trying to bash others when they are moving forward it’s a way to hide their insecurities.

USF will continue moving forward and hopefully some of posters on this board will get a chance to go to a game at our new stadium.

First, nobody is claiming that USF is violating Federal law by raiding donor-restricted endowments. What USF is doing and what the state warned about, is a massive drain on the university's cash reserves. This is coming directly from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment per the Division of Bond Finance. I have already documented this extensively and you're playing word games.

You're fundamentally confusing gross revenue with net profit margin. Sure, USF now captures the concessions and parking they didn't have at RJS. They also just signed an agreement giving the Tampa Sports Authority up to 20% of non-USF event revenues just to operate the building. Let's look at the actual math of your "extra revenue" narrative:
  • Moving to the stadium gives USF parking and concession revenue, but it also comes with 100% of the operating cost. Net incremental revenue is only projected at roughly $9M-10M annually.
  • Truist Bank expects $20M annually and gets paid first.
You're sunshine pumping over a $10M revenue bump while completely blinding yourself to a $20M fixed liability. The math doesn't work, which is exactly why the Board of Trustees had to step in with a $22.5M internal loan from its unrestricted pools just to keep the athletic department above water.

Money is fungible. When you freeze $22.5M of the university's core working capital in an athletic bailout loan, that's money that stops earning market interest, stops funding academic programs and intiatives, and stops paying for operational expenses and capital improvements on campus. You can play all of the word games that you want with the definition of "endowment," but the bottom line is you can't word game your way out of a balance sheet in the red. USF is actively bailing out your athletic department with institutional savings. It's creative accounting -- a shell game. Period.

USF's $350 million answer to a 30-year problem is going vertical

Quote:Build Core estimates the incremental revenue at $9 to $10 million annually - which would nearly double USF football - revenue base from its reported $9.4 million in fiscal year 2022-23.
06-04-2026 02:30 AM
Find all posts by this user
ghostofclt! Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 13,828
Joined: Oct 2018
Reputation: 8226
I Root For: Charlotte
Location: n/a
Post: #64
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 11:24 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  Side note on the ACC, Todge alluded to this but when Cal, Stanford, and SMU joined up the ACC was able to exercise their pro rata clause to increase their total media deal by 17/14ths. That $$ of course does not distribute directly to the new schools who of course are on partial (or less) deals. It helps fund the performance payouts that kept fsu Clemson & co. appeased for now with the cash flow sitiation.

The ESPN deal still allows the ACC one more pro rata addition. So the ACC doesn’t even need to lose anyone to consider adding one more attractive up-and-comer from THE AMERICAN or the Big12 or any of the other g8 that look interesting. Bring USF (or Memphis, or Marshall) in on an smu deal, and espn will contractually up the ante in the fsu performance fund.

Won’t hold my breath on this scenario as I’m sure a bit of eyebrow raising already happened on the last +3 especially the ponies, so I really don’t think ACC adds an 18th (unless one of us make say back to back CFP runs including winning at least one playoff game)

And that one of us happened to also be AAU, and have a nice new stajium or major upgrades in works.

USF, Tulane, Rice, Buffalo is your short list.
Kansas would politely take the phone calls, but of course they’re not headed over.

clt says academics don't matter at the acc. UNC CHeat is example one
06-04-2026 05:05 AM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #65
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 12:28 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

No, they won't. They didn't "choose" a private bank loan. They were essentially forced into it. The stadium revenue streams they're relying on are taxable, which makes the project ineligible for tax-exempt public bonding. That's why they went with a 7% private loan -- this isn't a matter of waiting for a better rate. Taxable municipal bonds exist, but their rates are highly comparable to private loans and carry so much overhead and oversight that it defeats the purpose.

Quote:USF management has determined that it is in the best interest of the University and DSO to issue the debt on a taxable basis[b] since most of the Project's [b]revenues will be 'private use' and/or used by private/for-profit tenants.

https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ummary.pdf

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

How is it being implied? It's not implied. It's happening right now. USF is incurring internal debt to pay external debt. Do you understand what that means? It's the institutional equivalent of paying off your credit cards with new credit cards, except the university is on the hook to underwrite the risk. So when they have to issue an internal loan, it leaves the reserves, it reduces liquidity, it can't be reinvested, and now the university is fully exposed to all of the risk. This specifically ties the endowment and institutional health directly to the athletic department's ability to service the debt.

This also means they're not actually paying for anything. They're kicking the can down the road and never chipping away at the principal. This is not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

The language is unambiguous. Financial communications use highly specific terminology to eliminate subjective interpretation and guesswork. What the memo clearly states is that the level of operating risk created by USF's financing structure dramatically increases the probability that both the endowment and charitable giving will be negatively impacted if athletics can't cover the debt service. That is the only correct reading of the sentence.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

No. There will be no bonding. It's a 20-year loan, and they're already borrowing internally just to make the payments.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

This analogy is absolute nonsense. USF is not a wealthy individual choosing to finance a house. They're an athletic department that can't pay its bills and is already having to borrow internally just to service a 7% loan. You don't "just invest the difference" when you don't have the capital. This isn't optional. It's called structural insolvency.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

Do you realize that you're over-complicating this? When the memo clearly states the debt may require subsidies from "unrestricted funds from the endowment," that means exactly what it says. Institutional money that would normally stay invested may have to be diverted to cover the athletic shortfalls. I don't know how that can be made any more clear. What difference does it make if it's principal or "PRECEDES" (investment yields) that you're misspelling? It's still endowment-sourced money that's being used to prop up athletics because they can't even cover their own financing. Anything not remaining with the endowment is actively taking from the endowment. Again, not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

No kidding. Of course every athletic department receives university support. When has that not been the case? Will you tell me next that water is wet? The point is that the institutional subsidies are mutually exclusive of the internal lending to cover debt service. They are not the same line items. A structural bailout isn't standard budgeting. Straw man much?

1. there are all kinds of things that can be done to gain the ability to bond part of the project out....I am not an in depth follower of this project so the part you showed about the financing does state it is not eligible for tax free bonds......but there is nothing that says in the future once the project is complete the parts of it that serve the athletics of the university cannot be split off and bonded out

2. and again there is ZERO that shows that money is being taken straight from the corpus of the endowment and used for this project.....that is simply your interpretation of what is happening

3. there is nothing that says the entire project could not be farmed out for up front money to an organization that will run the events, give a cut to the university, and give the university needed dates of use and at the end of the deal the use and ownership returns to the university......this is what was done with UT Austin and The Moody Center and Oak View Group

the only difference being that UT formed the deal prior to construction, but there is nothing that prevents a deal from happening after construction is done
06-04-2026 08:13 AM
Find all posts by this user
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #66
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

While you are correct on most of these points, I'll have to call out that "no different than every G5 program" should be restated as "nearly every program in the country", as there are maybe a handful of programs who can pay $400MM in cash in a single year, and even those who can wouldn't as they'd finance it anyways. The OP makes a ton of assumptions, uses a bunch of rhetoric and baseless claims to try and make themselves feel better. As long as they feel better about themselves, then this thread is a positive. 02-13-banana
06-04-2026 09:19 AM
Find all posts by this user
Sellular1 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 2,382
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 217
I Root For: USF
Location: The ATL
Post: #67
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Love this idiot giving USF crap. Next he’s going to talk about how Memphis has better beaches than Tampa and that Memphis isn’t actually the worst city in the country to live in.
06-04-2026 12:11 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #68
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 08:13 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 12:28 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

No, they won't. They didn't "choose" a private bank loan. They were essentially forced into it. The stadium revenue streams they're relying on are taxable, which makes the project ineligible for tax-exempt public bonding. That's why they went with a 7% private loan -- this isn't a matter of waiting for a better rate. Taxable municipal bonds exist, but their rates are highly comparable to private loans and carry so much overhead and oversight that it defeats the purpose.

Quote:USF management has determined that it is in the best interest of the University and DSO to issue the debt on a taxable basis[b] since most of the Project's [b]revenues will be 'private use' and/or used by private/for-profit tenants.

https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ummary.pdf

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

How is it being implied? It's not implied. It's happening right now. USF is incurring internal debt to pay external debt. Do you understand what that means? It's the institutional equivalent of paying off your credit cards with new credit cards, except the university is on the hook to underwrite the risk. So when they have to issue an internal loan, it leaves the reserves, it reduces liquidity, it can't be reinvested, and now the university is fully exposed to all of the risk. This specifically ties the endowment and institutional health directly to the athletic department's ability to service the debt.

This also means they're not actually paying for anything. They're kicking the can down the road and never chipping away at the principal. This is not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

The language is unambiguous. Financial communications use highly specific terminology to eliminate subjective interpretation and guesswork. What the memo clearly states is that the level of operating risk created by USF's financing structure dramatically increases the probability that both the endowment and charitable giving will be negatively impacted if athletics can't cover the debt service. That is the only correct reading of the sentence.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

No. There will be no bonding. It's a 20-year loan, and they're already borrowing internally just to make the payments.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

This analogy is absolute nonsense. USF is not a wealthy individual choosing to finance a house. They're an athletic department that can't pay its bills and is already having to borrow internally just to service a 7% loan. You don't "just invest the difference" when you don't have the capital. This isn't optional. It's called structural insolvency.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

Do you realize that you're over-complicating this? When the memo clearly states the debt may require subsidies from "unrestricted funds from the endowment," that means exactly what it says. Institutional money that would normally stay invested may have to be diverted to cover the athletic shortfalls. I don't know how that can be made any more clear. What difference does it make if it's principal or "PRECEDES" (investment yields) that you're misspelling? It's still endowment-sourced money that's being used to prop up athletics because they can't even cover their own financing. Anything not remaining with the endowment is actively taking from the endowment. Again, not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

No kidding. Of course every athletic department receives university support. When has that not been the case? Will you tell me next that water is wet? The point is that the institutional subsidies are mutually exclusive of the internal lending to cover debt service. They are not the same line items. A structural bailout isn't standard budgeting. Straw man much?

1. there are all kinds of things that can be done to gain the ability to bond part of the project out....I am not an in depth follower of this project so the part you showed about the financing does state it is not eligible for tax free bonds......but there is nothing that says in the future once the project is complete the parts of it that serve the athletics of the university cannot be split off and bonded out

2. and again there is ZERO that shows that money is being taken straight from the corpus of the endowment and used for this project.....that is simply your interpretation of what is happening

3. there is nothing that says the entire project could not be farmed out for up front money to an organization that will run the events, give a cut to the university, and give the university needed dates of use and at the end of the deal the use and ownership returns to the university......this is what was done with UT Austin and The Moody Center and Oak View Group

the only difference being that UT formed the deal prior to construction, but there is nothing that prevents a deal from happening after construction is done

I see the poster child of Dunning-Kruger has returned. You certainly picked a strange hill to die on, playing USF's white knight; but I digress. Your tactics are transparent. When you run out of facts, you move the goalposts or weaponize ignorance.

1) No. I told you the facts, and you're ignoring the law. You can't retroactively convert a private placement loan into a tax-exempt municipal bond when the underlying revenue streams violate IRS private-use limits. Your suggestion is complete nonsense. This is Federal law. Educate yourself for once: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/141

2) Stop playing word games. They don't strengthen your position. Go back and read the memorandum again if you're confused. It explicitly identifies the risk to the endowment's unrestricted funds and is written in plain English: "subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment." Whether it touches core principal or investment returns, it's still capital that's being drained from the endowment pool to cover unbudgeted athletic deficits. This isn't opinion. It comes directly from the State of Florida Division of Bond Finance. No amount of wishful thinking or creative fan-fiction changes objective reality.

3) This is a false equivalence. Texas didn't build an arena, realize they couldn't afford the debt, and then ask Oak View Group (OVG) to bail them out. OVG funded the entire $375 million construction cost of the Moody Center upfront in exchange for operating rights. UT assumed zero debt. Do you not understand that USF has already taken on the debt and ownership risk themselves? A third-party operator is not going to swoop in post-construction to absorb a toxic, 7% debt profile unless USF surrenders virtually all revenue upside, which completely defeats the entire purpose of building the stadium to generate athletic revenue in the first place.
06-04-2026 01:54 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #69
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 09:19 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  The OP makes a ton of assumptions, uses a bunch of rhetoric and baseless claims to try and make themselves feel better. As long as they feel better about themselves, then this thread is a positive. 02-13-banana

No, I bring you the hard facts that your fragile little ego clearly can't handle. I also bring the literal receipts from the State of Florida Division of Bond Finance and the Board of Governors. You can pretend objective documentation is "rhetoric" all you want, but it doesn't change reality.

Whatever you have to do to feel good about the stadium, even if it means believing fairy tales, right?
06-04-2026 02:02 PM
Find all posts by this user
Bear Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 599
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 20
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #70
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
I read some of these posts, and it's basically just a rhetoric of assumptions BASED ONLY on the "WORST CASE SCENARIO" for USF.

Sure, if USF is stuck in the American for the next 30 years. Then yes, this would be a disaster.

However:

1.) The stadium is literally a strategic asset, NOT a luxury expense. We aren't building a "lazy river" but, model to reshape the entire university. Owning the stadium means that USF keeps tickets, concessions, parking, SPONSORHSIP, and event revenue. Remember, this is TAMPA BAY (not Memphis), and concerts, high school championships, can be done year round... even more so in the Winter/Spring season. We already saw how the experience helped Cincy, UCF, and Houston.

2.) Debt Financing does NOT equal financial irresponsibility! USF's debt is spread out over decades and aligns with future revenue growth. Which is GOING to happen. In your write-up, you totally ignored inflation-adjusted growth in media rights (and especially if USF leaves the AAC). NIL ecosystems (winning helps a lot), and other even revenue. You provided ZERO modeling on upside scenarios and relied heavily on doomsday outcomes.

3.) Also, your claim about raiding funds is very overstated. Universities often reallocated internal capital for MAJOR projects (which USF has done several times over the past 30 years). Also, foundations advancing funds against future donations is a very common fundraising practices. Also, auxiliary funds (housing, parking, etc...) are also used for large capital financing pools. What is more important is sustainability (which USF is much better on than Memphis). Remember, unlike Memphis, we are considered a VERY STRONG academic university. Even by the state's governor (despite stripping out our Sarasota/Manatee campus)... which will heavily reduce our current liabilities... I think to the tune of $200 million.

4.) This whole purpose is to get USF in the Power conferences. USF has market size, facilities, and all around institutional commitment. We have spent years NOT investing in our biggest asset in athletics (which is football); and we have seen what happens when we DO NOT invest. USF wants to avoid getting locked out again. Yes, winning matters... but winning with strong infrastructure is a MUST.

5.) Your criticisms of our head coach... is ONLY speculation. We will come back to this in December. Or, God forbid, we lost to FIU lol. Also, you can't compare USF's past hiring practices -- as we have an entirely different administration running USF. From the President, to the CEO, to the Board... It ain't the same ole' South Florida.

6.) Some comparable facts:

USF: #11-13 Media market, 50k+ student (400,00 living alumni), rapidly expanding growth IN ALL factors (academic and athletic), Strategy: USF scales upward.
Memphis: Smaller metro (not even top 20), around 22k enrollment, plateaued growth trajectory (enrollment, research, etc...), Strategy: "optimize current state".

I hope we both go P4, as I always enjoyed being in a conference with Memphis. Great fans!

7.) There are risks, I agree. Worst case scenario is literally our history. If there are weak ticket sles, harder NIL pressure, and a decline in revenue. There are going to be major problems. Maybe USF could be forced to cut non-revenue producing sports. But, football will now be a priority.

But your entire analysis ignores the upsides: Potential increase attendance from having an OCS (team culture, scheduling tough opponents, premium seating), Sponsorship, the potential for a conference upgrade (which would bring Big East level competition). Easier to fill a stadium playing in the ACC or B12. There was always going to be risk, with any high reward. We want to avoid stagnation, irrelevance, and missing another round of alignment. I can't take anymore heartbreak (and not due to spending, but the opposite).

So anyways, your original critique assumes that the statuesque is safe and investment is reckless. That's EXACTLY what our OLD ADMIN believed back in the 2010s... And look what that got us. It's all or NOTHING. In today's college athletics, failing to invest in infrastructure and brand positioning is the riskiest move of all. And USF is NOT chasing relevance, they are building the foundation required to compete for it long-term. The stadium is NOT a vanity project in the way you believe; it's a necessary asset in a landscape where facilities, market presence, and institutional commitment determines who advances and who gets left behind.

Didn't the B12 already tell Memphis "NO" already? And you are guys are investing very heavily now. NIL for MBB and major stadium upgrades (that's not really your stadium?).
(This post was last modified: 06-04-2026 03:12 PM by Bear.)
06-04-2026 02:59 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #71
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 02:59 PM)Bear Wrote:  What is more important is sustainability (which USF is much better on than Memphis). Remember, unlike Memphis, we are considered a VERY STRONG academic university. Even by the state's governor (despite stripping out our Sarasota/Manatee campus)... which will heavily reduce our current liabilities... I think to the tune of $200 million.

This is perhaps the most hilarious self-own I have ever witnessed on this board. You are literally celebrating the state government forcibly seizing your campus footprint as a financial windfall. Do you realize that?

Let's correct the record with objective reality, since you clearly skimmed a headline and think you understand:

First, your math is wrong. USF isn't shedding "$200 million in liabilities". That $200M figure you're touting was New College President Richard Corcoran celebrating how much physical infrastructure and value they are literally taking away from USF. The actual debt being shifted off USF's books to New College is a fraction of that.

USF Sarasota-Manatee Will Be Transferred to New College

Quote:New College is a pet project of Gov. Ron DeSantis, and New College of Florida president Richard Corcoran is a powerful, well-connected player in Florida politics. He has stated that the takeover of USF "means we get $200 million worth of facilities move-in ready," Dr. Laurey Stryker, former president of USF Sarasota-Manatee, told us earlier this month.

Consider that you're losing a major asset footprint; a 32 acre regional campus and its entire future enrollment pipelines. While USF fought like hell to retain the $22.47M in recurring operating funds to pay for the "teach-out" of existing students, you're fundamentally losing physical capital. In what universe is this a "good" thing? Richard Corcoran is certainly applauding New College's windfall. Trying to spin a hostile political carving-up of your university's academic footprint as a "strategic asset reduction" to help justify an athletic department's precipitous debt spiral is pure, unadulterated delusional thinking, and only serves to validate everything that I'm stating.

You claim that I provided zero modeling on the "upside." The Florida Division of Bond Finance explicitly stated that your "upside" model is a complete fairy tale. Again, J. Ben Watkins III noted on the record that USF arbitrarily jacked up stadium revenue projections by 300% ($15.2M) overnight -- from $5.3M to $20.5M -- just to make the debt coverage ratios pass inspection. The state explicitly warned that your upside is "highly speculative and volatile." Facts, not feels.

You say raiding housing, parking, and student auxiliary funds is "common." It's common when an institution is desperate for cash liquidity. When you siphon money intended for student services to pay off a 7% taxable private bank loan, you aren't "scaling upward." You're compromising the baseline student experience and undermining liquidity to pay for a luxury asset you objectively can't afford.

You aren't "building a foundation." You're willfully dismantling your academic infrastructure, borrowing tens of millions from your endowment, just to fund a football program that is burning cash for social media likes and an aspirational delusion where a "power" conference hands you the golden ticket while ignoring that your athletic department is completely insolvent. This is the literal definition of "hood rich."
06-04-2026 03:37 PM
Find all posts by this user
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #72
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 02:59 PM)Bear Wrote:  I read some of these posts, and it's basically just a rhetoric of assumptions BASED ONLY on the "WORST CASE SCENARIO" for USF.

Sure, if USF is stuck in the American for the next 30 years. Then yes, this would be a disaster.

However:

1.) The stadium is literally a strategic asset, NOT a luxury expense. We aren't building a "lazy river" but, model to reshape the entire university. Owning the stadium means that USF keeps tickets, concessions, parking, SPONSORHSIP, and event revenue. Remember, this is TAMPA BAY (not Memphis), and concerts, high school championships, can be done year round... even more so in the Winter/Spring season. We already saw how the experience helped Cincy, UCF, and Houston.

2.) Debt Financing does NOT equal financial irresponsibility! USF's debt is spread out over decades and aligns with future revenue growth. Which is GOING to happen. In your write-up, you totally ignored inflation-adjusted growth in media rights (and especially if USF leaves the AAC). NIL ecosystems (winning helps a lot), and other even revenue. You provided ZERO modeling on upside scenarios and relied heavily on doomsday outcomes.

3.) Also, your claim about raiding funds is very overstated. Universities often reallocated internal capital for MAJOR projects (which USF has done several times over the past 30 years). Also, foundations advancing funds against future donations is a very common fundraising practices. Also, auxiliary funds (housing, parking, etc...) are also used for large capital financing pools. What is more important is sustainability (which USF is much better on than Memphis). Remember, unlike Memphis, we are considered a VERY STRONG academic university. Even by the state's governor (despite stripping out our Sarasota/Manatee campus)... which will heavily reduce our current liabilities... I think to the tune of $200 million.

4.) This whole purpose is to get USF in the Power conferences. USF has market size, facilities, and all around institutional commitment. We have spent years NOT investing in our biggest asset in athletics (which is football); and we have seen what happens when we DO NOT invest. USF wants to avoid getting locked out again. Yes, winning matters... but winning with strong infrastructure is a MUST.

5.) Your criticisms of our head coach... is ONLY speculation. We will come back to this in December. Or, God forbid, we lost to FIU lol. Also, you can't compare USF's past hiring practices -- as we have an entirely different administration running USF. From the President, to the CEO, to the Board... It ain't the same ole' South Florida.

6.) Some comparable facts:

USF: #11-13 Media market, 50k+ student (400,00 living alumni), rapidly expanding growth IN ALL factors (academic and athletic), Strategy: USF scales upward.
Memphis: Smaller metro (not even top 20), around 22k enrollment, plateaued growth trajectory (enrollment, research, etc...), Strategy: "optimize current state".

I hope we both go P4, as I always enjoyed being in a conference with Memphis. Great fans!

7.) There are risks, I agree. Worst case scenario is literally our history. If there are weak ticket sles, harder NIL pressure, and a decline in revenue. There are going to be major problems. Maybe USF could be forced to cut non-revenue producing sports. But, football will now be a priority.

But your entire analysis ignores the upsides: Potential increase attendance from having an OCS (team culture, scheduling tough opponents, premium seating), Sponsorship, the potential for a conference upgrade (which would bring Big East level competition). Easier to fill a stadium playing in the ACC or B12. There was always going to be risk, with any high reward. We want to avoid stagnation, irrelevance, and missing another round of alignment. I can't take anymore heartbreak (and not due to spending, but the opposite).

So anyways, your original critique assumes that the statuesque is safe and investment is reckless. That's EXACTLY what our OLD ADMIN believed back in the 2010s... And look what that got us. It's all or NOTHING. In today's college athletics, failing to invest in infrastructure and brand positioning is the riskiest move of all. And USF is NOT chasing relevance, they are building the foundation required to compete for it long-term. The stadium is NOT a vanity project in the way you believe; it's a necessary asset in a landscape where facilities, market presence, and institutional commitment determines who advances and who gets left behind.

Didn't the B12 already tell Memphis "NO" already? And you are guys are investing very heavily now. NIL for MBB and major stadium upgrades (that's not really your stadium?).

USF is going the right direction, Memphis is not. There is a long list of schools that have blown by us. Its sad. Thr fact a loon Memphis fan would expend the energy to even make this thread reeks with the stench of fear. Its embarrassing.

I hope we beat you 72-0 but dont think all Memphis alums are loons. Our sidewalkera are mental cases.
(This post was last modified: 06-04-2026 05:24 PM by shere khan.)
06-04-2026 05:18 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #73
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 05:18 PM)shere khan Wrote:  USF is going the right direction, Memphis is not. There is a long list of schools that have blown by us. Its sad. Thr fact a loon Memphis fan would expend the energy to even make this thread reeks with the stench of fear. Its embarrassing.

I hope we beat you 72-0 but dont think all Memphis alums are loons. Our sidewalkera are mental cases.

The fact that you had to run away and hide on the AAC board to farm "likes" from the USF fan base shows where the fear genuinely originates from. You have no argument, only histrionic cries of existential dread and cuckolding to rival institutions. I can now see why the tenure track was never extended, and why you're encumbered by the crushing weight of your pathologies.

When you're ready to engage in a genuine debate involving facts and not conjecture, I'm not hiding anywhere. You know where to find me.
06-04-2026 05:28 PM
Find all posts by this user
Bear Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 599
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 20
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #74
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 03:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 02:59 PM)Bear Wrote:  What is more important is sustainability (which USF is much better on than Memphis). Remember, unlike Memphis, we are considered a VERY STRONG academic university. Even by the state's governor (despite stripping out our Sarasota/Manatee campus)... which will heavily reduce our current liabilities... I think to the tune of $200 million.

This is perhaps the most hilarious self-own I have ever witnessed on this board. You are literally celebrating the state government forcibly seizing your campus footprint as a financial windfall. Do you realize that?

Let's correct the record with objective reality, since you clearly skimmed a headline and think you understand:

First, your math is wrong. USF isn't shedding "$200 million in liabilities". That $200M figure you're touting was New College President Richard Corcoran celebrating how much physical infrastructure and value they are literally taking away from USF. The actual debt being shifted off USF's books to New College is a fraction of that.

USF Sarasota-Manatee Will Be Transferred to New College

Quote:New College is a pet project of Gov. Ron DeSantis, and New College of Florida president Richard Corcoran is a powerful, well-connected player in Florida politics. He has stated that the takeover of USF "means we get $200 million worth of facilities move-in ready," Dr. Laurey Stryker, former president of USF Sarasota-Manatee, told us earlier this month.

Consider that you're losing a major asset footprint; a 32 acre regional campus and its entire future enrollment pipelines. While USF fought like hell to retain the $22.47M in recurring operating funds to pay for the "teach-out" of existing students, you're fundamentally losing physical capital. In what universe is this a "good" thing? Richard Corcoran is certainly applauding New College's windfall. Trying to spin a hostile political carving-up of your university's academic footprint as a "strategic asset reduction" to help justify an athletic department's precipitous debt spiral is pure, unadulterated delusional thinking, and only serves to validate everything that I'm stating.

You claim that I provided zero modeling on the "upside." The Florida Division of Bond Finance explicitly stated that your "upside" model is a complete fairy tale. Again, J. Ben Watkins III noted on the record that USF arbitrarily jacked up stadium revenue projections by 300% ($15.2M) overnight -- from $5.3M to $20.5M -- just to make the debt coverage ratios pass inspection. The state explicitly warned that your upside is "highly speculative and volatile." Facts, not feels.

You say raiding housing, parking, and student auxiliary funds is "common." It's common when an institution is desperate for cash liquidity. When you siphon money intended for student services to pay off a 7% taxable private bank loan, you aren't "scaling upward." You're compromising the baseline student experience and undermining liquidity to pay for a luxury asset you objectively can't afford.

You aren't "building a foundation." You're willfully dismantling your academic infrastructure, borrowing tens of millions from your endowment, just to fund a football program that is burning cash for social media likes and an aspirational delusion where a "power" conference hands you the golden ticket while ignoring that your athletic department is completely insolvent. This is the literal definition of "hood rich."

Listen, we know that it’s a political move driven by DeSantis and New College allies—not USF voluntarily "shedding liabilities" as a brilliant financial strategy. I will concede that you’re right that USF is losing physical assets and future enrollment pipelines there (a 32-acre campus). No one's celebrating the loss of footprint. However, I noticed this is merely the one item that you actually gave a rebuttal to… and not the many other points that I provided.

That said, reviewing the campus deal…. New College will take on $53 million in debt (mostly for the Atala Hall dorms) and makes monthly payments back to USF (just under $200k/mo). USF retains operating funds for the teach-out of current students (~$22M recurring). And you are right that "$200M" figure is New College's president hyping the value of the move-in-ready facilities they're acquiring. Because, that is still a real value, whether you like it or not.

It's a net mixed bag imposed externally—not some self-inflicted wound proving athletic mismanagement. USF's main Tampa campus and growth trajectory remain intact. Don’t forget, that USF is an AAU university with access to greater research funds. Pretending that this is as if USF was "dismantling academic infrastructure" to fund football is an absolute REACH!

This isn't "hood rich" or torching cash for vibes. USF is moving from renting RJS (where we have zero control of key revenue streams like parking, concessions, sponsorships, and naming rights) to owning an on-campus asset. What do you guys know about this?
Like I said before, that’s standard for teams that moved up—Cincinnati, UCF, Houston gained from similar investments. Also, SDSU and Colorado St made similar investments.

Again, the Tampa Bay's market (ranked 11/13th), population growth (Tampa is exploding, unlike Memphis), alumni base (400k+), and year-round event potential (concerts, etc.) are real advantages Memphis doesn't match. We are NOT in the same boat!

In regard to the stadium debt (~$200M private financing via Truist, part of ~$340M total project); you have to remember that this isn’t just a stadium. This ALSO includes an entire FOOTBALL OPERATIONS CENTER (which we already received $25 million donation from TGH). This is literally a P4 level facility and will be one of the nicest in the state of Florida. The annual debt service is significant (~$20M range), BUT spread over decades. And hopefully, in a P4 league… we can afford that easily. The projections from consultants that you keep citing estimated first-year stadium revenues around $20.5M (tickets ~$7.6M, premium seating/donations ~$8.3M, etc.), with non-stadium athletics revenues providing a base, and conservative models used lower figures for coverage ratios.
Sure, Ben Watkins and the Division of Bond Finance flagged risks… That's their job: conservative oversight. USF adjusted projections which raised eyebrows.
But again! Like I said before, universities often use internal reallocations, foundations, auxiliary funds, and asset sales for major capital projects like this. It's not unprecedented "desperation"… it's how big infrastructure gets built when state support is limited. FSU does, ucf does it, heck, I bet Memphis is going to be doing it too.

The bet is that better facilities plus on-campus experience drive attendance, NIL appeal, sponsorships, and conference positioning to make it sustainable. Risks exist - sure, but stagnation was the bigger long-term threat given past underinvestment.
USF has operated with deficits in some years, like many G5 programs. You know the P4 sees Tampa’s metro and USF’s enrollment, plus the academic profile (which the B12 desperately needs) gives USF a higher upside potential than Memphis for P4 interest.

No one at USF claimed zero risk or perfect execution. The old "do nothing" approach left us irrelevant and locked out before. This is a high-stakes push for infrastructure and relevance in a winner-take-most sport. If revenues hit, it pays off big. If not, tough choices follow—but that's the reality of competing today.

Memphis has done well lately and built smartly in spots. Respect to that. But downplaying the USF market/assets while ignoring your own limitations (and the external politics here) is shortsighted. Like I said before, not sure why you HATE USF so much, but I hope both programs rise (which is also better for the AAC short-term).

I am curious who gets out of the AAC first…
(This post was last modified: 06-04-2026 06:03 PM by Bear.)
06-04-2026 05:58 PM
Find all posts by this user
Bear Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 599
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 20
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #75
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 05:18 PM)shere khan Wrote:  USF is going the right direction, Memphis is not. There is a long list of schools that have blown by us. Its sad. Thr fact a loon Memphis fan would expend the energy to even make this thread reeks with the stench of fear. Its embarrassing.

I hope we beat you 72-0 but dont think all Memphis alums are loons. Our sidewalkera are mental cases.

Tip of the hat!
06-04-2026 06:05 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #76
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 05:58 PM)Bear Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 03:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 02:59 PM)Bear Wrote:  What is more important is sustainability (which USF is much better on than Memphis). Remember, unlike Memphis, we are considered a VERY STRONG academic university. Even by the state's governor (despite stripping out our Sarasota/Manatee campus)... which will heavily reduce our current liabilities... I think to the tune of $200 million.

This is perhaps the most hilarious self-own I have ever witnessed on this board. You are literally celebrating the state government forcibly seizing your campus footprint as a financial windfall. Do you realize that?

Let's correct the record with objective reality, since you clearly skimmed a headline and think you understand:

First, your math is wrong. USF isn't shedding "$200 million in liabilities". That $200M figure you're touting was New College President Richard Corcoran celebrating how much physical infrastructure and value they are literally taking away from USF. The actual debt being shifted off USF's books to New College is a fraction of that.

USF Sarasota-Manatee Will Be Transferred to New College

Quote:New College is a pet project of Gov. Ron DeSantis, and New College of Florida president Richard Corcoran is a powerful, well-connected player in Florida politics. He has stated that the takeover of USF "means we get $200 million worth of facilities move-in ready," Dr. Laurey Stryker, former president of USF Sarasota-Manatee, told us earlier this month.

Consider that you're losing a major asset footprint; a 32 acre regional campus and its entire future enrollment pipelines. While USF fought like hell to retain the $22.47M in recurring operating funds to pay for the "teach-out" of existing students, you're fundamentally losing physical capital. In what universe is this a "good" thing? Richard Corcoran is certainly applauding New College's windfall. Trying to spin a hostile political carving-up of your university's academic footprint as a "strategic asset reduction" to help justify an athletic department's precipitous debt spiral is pure, unadulterated delusional thinking, and only serves to validate everything that I'm stating.

You claim that I provided zero modeling on the "upside." The Florida Division of Bond Finance explicitly stated that your "upside" model is a complete fairy tale. Again, J. Ben Watkins III noted on the record that USF arbitrarily jacked up stadium revenue projections by 300% ($15.2M) overnight -- from $5.3M to $20.5M -- just to make the debt coverage ratios pass inspection. The state explicitly warned that your upside is "highly speculative and volatile." Facts, not feels.

You say raiding housing, parking, and student auxiliary funds is "common." It's common when an institution is desperate for cash liquidity. When you siphon money intended for student services to pay off a 7% taxable private bank loan, you aren't "scaling upward." You're compromising the baseline student experience and undermining liquidity to pay for a luxury asset you objectively can't afford.

You aren't "building a foundation." You're willfully dismantling your academic infrastructure, borrowing tens of millions from your endowment, just to fund a football program that is burning cash for social media likes and an aspirational delusion where a "power" conference hands you the golden ticket while ignoring that your athletic department is completely insolvent. This is the literal definition of "hood rich."

Listen, we know that it’s a political move driven by DeSantis and New College allies—not USF voluntarily "shedding liabilities" as a brilliant financial strategy. I will concede that you’re right that USF is losing physical assets and future enrollment pipelines there (a 32-acre campus). No one's celebrating the loss of footprint. However, I noticed this is merely the one item that you actually gave a rebuttal to… and not the many other points that I provided.

That said, reviewing the campus deal…. New College will take on $53 million in debt (mostly for the Atala Hall dorms) and makes monthly payments back to USF (just under $200k/mo). USF retains operating funds for the teach-out of current students (~$22M recurring). And you are right that "$200M" figure is New College's president hyping the value of the move-in-ready facilities they're acquiring. Because, that is still a real value, whether you like it or not.

It's a net mixed bag imposed externally—not some self-inflicted wound proving athletic mismanagement. USF's main Tampa campus and growth trajectory remain intact. Don’t forget, that USF is an AAU university with access to greater research funds. Pretending that this is as if USF was "dismantling academic infrastructure" to fund football is an absolute REACH!

This isn't "hood rich" or torching cash for vibes. USF is moving from renting RJS (where we have zero control of key revenue streams like parking, concessions, sponsorships, and naming rights) to owning an on-campus asset. What do you guys know about this?
Like I said before, that’s standard for teams that moved up—Cincinnati, UCF, Houston gained from similar investments. Also, SDSU and Colorado St made similar investments.

Again, the Tampa Bay's market (ranked 11/13th), population growth (Tampa is exploding, unlike Memphis), alumni base (400k+), and year-round event potential (concerts, etc.) are real advantages Memphis doesn't match. We are NOT in the same boat!

In regard to the stadium debt (~$200M private financing via Truist, part of ~$340M total project); you have to remember that this isn’t just a stadium. This ALSO includes an entire FOOTBALL OPERATIONS CENTER (which we already received $25 million donation from TGH). This is literally a P4 level facility and will be one of the nicest in the state of Florida. The annual debt service is significant (~$20M range), BUT spread over decades. And hopefully, in a P4 league… we can afford that easily. The projections from consultants that you keep citing estimated first-year stadium revenues around $20.5M (tickets ~$7.6M, premium seating/donations ~$8.3M, etc.), with non-stadium athletics revenues providing a base, and conservative models used lower figures for coverage ratios.
Sure, Ben Watkins and the Division of Bond Finance flagged risks… That's their job: conservative oversight. USF adjusted projections which raised eyebrows.
But again! Like I said before, universities often use internal reallocations, foundations, auxiliary funds, and asset sales for major capital projects like this. It's not unprecedented "desperation"… it's how big infrastructure gets built when state support is limited. FSU does, ucf does it, heck, I bet Memphis is going to be doing it too.

The bet is that better facilities plus on-campus experience drive attendance, NIL appeal, sponsorships, and conference positioning to make it sustainable. Risks exist - sure, but stagnation was the bigger long-term threat given past underinvestment.
USF has operated with deficits in some years, like many G5 programs. You know the P4 sees Tampa’s metro and USF’s enrollment, plus the academic profile (which the B12 desperately needs) gives USF a higher upside potential than Memphis for P4 interest.

No one at USF claimed zero risk or perfect execution. The old "do nothing" approach left us irrelevant and locked out before. This is a high-stakes push for infrastructure and relevance in a winner-take-most sport. If revenues hit, it pays off big. If not, tough choices follow—but that's the reality of competing today.

Memphis has done well lately and built smartly in spots. Respect to that. But downplaying the USF market/assets while ignoring your own limitations (and the external politics here) is shortsighted. Like I said before, not sure why you HATE USF so much, but I hope both programs rise (which is also better for the AAC short-term).

I am curious who gets out of the AAC first…

The point of all of this is to approach it both objectively and honestly. Conceding that you miscalculated the New College transaction by roughly $147M, and admitting that USF is actively losing its regional asset footprint, etc., is a good start towards an honest conversation.

Unfortunately, the goalpost moving pivot to the standard G6 coping mechanism (e.g. Cincinnati, UCF, Houston, and SD State) ignores the critical, fatal flaw in your comparison. Not one of those institutions built their stadiums by completely wiping out their financial liquidity. The athletic department is so insolvent they have to actively raid the endowment coffers for unbudgeted debt bailouts. This is not a matter of opinion.

Let's look at the actual structural differences you are trying to simply handwave away:
  • Cincinnati and Houston moved to the P4 before the current House settlment and revenue-sharing era. They didn't hae to finance a project at a spiking 7% interest rate while simultaneously taking out an emergency, $22.5M internal loan just to cover basic athletic operating exependitures and player revenue shares. This is simply fact and illustrates why USF's actions are so incredibly irresponsible and dangerous.
  • The Director of Bond Finance unamibiguously wrote that USF submitted revised projects that were "materially different than originally provided" because the loan interest rate jumped 1.5%. To cover that up, USF literally jacked up projected stadium revenue by 300% overnight.
  • The Director of Bond Finance also explicitly warned that "whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultant estimates." This isn't normal infrastructure building. It is a literally a high-wire act with no safety net and zero margin for error. Let that sink in.
  • You talk about the "Tampa's market" and your "400K" alumni base, yet your own financial disclosures unambiguously show that contributions decreased by 18.11%. The market isn't hitting the targets, and the State told you exactly what will happen when you miss those goals: "the debt being incurred is secured by gross revenue from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment." This is not ambiguous.
You can hide behind the "AAU" designation and tout the Tampa census report all you want. Let's not pretend that USF athletics is at the top of the pyramid for sports dollars in Tampa, especially with your big brother UCF next door, not to mention the professional sports in Orlando as well. To characterize the Florida sports market as overly saturated would be a gross understatement -- this isn't about "hating" USF. This is an objective assay of the financial health of the University and its stadium efforts, corroborated by your own financials and the State government.

As for who gets out of the AAC first? Who knows? What I can say is that Memphis is building its infrastructure sustainably with private capital and smart management. USF is betting the farm on a lottery ticket borrowed from it's own students while using inflated projections that the Bond Director officially flagged as a house of cards. If there's one thing I'm certain of, no "power" conference is inviting an insolvent and mismanaged athletic department, irrespective of the three-letter acronym associated with it. I bet it would make for one hell of a "30 for 30" though -- wait and see indeed.

Stating that, I want every school to succeed. A strong AAC is the best-case scenario for all member institutions. I don't want to see you fail. I want you to knock it out of the park and for both Memphis and USF to rise up. Don't confuse my condemnation of a malfeasant administration with hate for your school. That is the furthest from the truth even if my message isn't pretty.
06-04-2026 06:40 PM
Find all posts by this user
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,623
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #77
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-03-2026 11:24 PM)owl at the moon Wrote:  Side note on the ACC, Todge alluded to this but when Cal, Stanford, and SMU joined up the ACC was able to exercise their pro rata clause to increase their total media deal by 17/14ths. That $$ of course does not distribute directly to the new schools who of course are on partial (or less) deals. It helps fund the performance payouts that kept fsu Clemson & co. appeased for now with the cash flow sitiation.

The ESPN deal still allows the ACC one more pro rata addition. So the ACC doesn’t even need to lose anyone to consider adding one more attractive up-and-comer from THE AMERICAN or the Big12 or any of the other g8 that look interesting. Bring USF (or Memphis, or Marshall) in on an smu deal, and espn will contractually up the ante in the fsu performance fund.

Won’t hold my breath on this scenario as I’m sure a bit of eyebrow raising already happened on the last +3 especially the ponies, so I really don’t think ACC adds an 18th (unless one of us make say back to back CFP runs including winning at least one playoff game)

And that one of us happened to also be AAU, and have a nice new stajium or major upgrades in works.

USF, Tulane, Rice, Buffalo is your short list.
Kansas would politely take the phone calls, but of course they’re not headed over.

Well Rice would qualify if “they have stadium upgrades in the works” but ill believe it when I see I see the stajum upgrades.
06-04-2026 07:46 PM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #78
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 01:54 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 08:13 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  
(06-04-2026 12:28 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. I would imagine they will be able to bond out the facility at some point and time unless there are laws in Florida that prevent bonds from being issued for athletics projects and that would lower the interest rate

No, they won't. They didn't "choose" a private bank loan. They were essentially forced into it. The stadium revenue streams they're relying on are taxable, which makes the project ineligible for tax-exempt public bonding. That's why they went with a 7% private loan -- this isn't a matter of waiting for a better rate. Taxable municipal bonds exist, but their rates are highly comparable to private loans and carry so much overhead and oversight that it defeats the purpose.

Quote:USF management has determined that it is in the best interest of the University and DSO to issue the debt on a taxable basis[b] since most of the Project's [b]revenues will be 'private use' and/or used by private/for-profit tenants.

https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...ummary.pdf

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. the document does not say they are using funds from the endowment in the way that is being implied

How is it being implied? It's not implied. It's happening right now. USF is incurring internal debt to pay external debt. Do you understand what that means? It's the institutional equivalent of paying off your credit cards with new credit cards, except the university is on the hook to underwrite the risk. So when they have to issue an internal loan, it leaves the reserves, it reduces liquidity, it can't be reinvested, and now the university is fully exposed to all of the risk. This specifically ties the endowment and institutional health directly to the athletic department's ability to service the debt.

This also means they're not actually paying for anything. They're kicking the can down the road and never chipping away at the principal. This is not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  what is says is this "material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts"......that can just as easily be read to mean that in the future USF will be encouraging donors to give to the athletics project to reduce the debt or to support athletics operations so that money can be used to pay the debt......thus that would reduce money flowing into the endowment long term

The language is unambiguous. Financial communications use highly specific terminology to eliminate subjective interpretation and guesswork. What the memo clearly states is that the level of operating risk created by USF's financing structure dramatically increases the probability that both the endowment and charitable giving will be negatively impacted if athletics can't cover the debt service. That is the only correct reading of the sentence.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  of course there is also the alternative that with lower interest rates or bonding with lower borrowing cost and with better in the field performance from improved facilities USF will be able to increase donations and invest that money in the endowment and as long as that investment performs better than the borrowing/bond interest rate then USF is money ahead.........while I would be the first to say I am skeptical that will result in massive new donations even $8 or $10 million over a couple of years would matter.....and once the facilities are paid for well the money in the endowment and any money earned over and above the cost of borrowing is still there

No. There will be no bonding. It's a 20-year loan, and they're already borrowing internally just to make the payments.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  it is no different than someone with the ability to pay for a new house and a new car with cash deciding to finance anyway......if they are paying $500,000 for a house and $100,000 for a car and the loan on the house will cost them 5.75% and the car has a manufacturer incentive of 5% they are looking at borrowed money of $600,000 and interest of about 5.5% or so for the combines money......if they can but some stocks with stable dividends in the 6% to 8% range, put some in CDs earning 4.75%, and then some mutual funds with a history of 10% gains and "gamble" a bit on a few stocks that can increase dramatically and end up with a pretty safe portfolio that earns them 8% or 9% on average per year (not remotely unachievable and really not a major return) they are a lot of money ahead over 5 to 15 years on the car and house note and they still have all their money plus the money they earned over and above the interest

This analogy is absolute nonsense. USF is not a wealthy individual choosing to finance a house. They're an athletic department that can't pay its bills and is already having to borrow internally just to service a 7% loan. You don't "just invest the difference" when you don't have the capital. This isn't optional. It's called structural insolvency.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. lastly the statement is made "debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

again this does not imply that money will be taken straight out of the endowment.......and in fact the "unrestricted part" would imply to most that the discussion is about PRECEDES from the endowment that are not restricted for any particular use......because generally the very fact that money is in an endowment and not in a shorter term account means the money is RESTRICTED to being in the endowment......and it is the proceeds that would possible be unrestricted if the money was donated with no particular use in mind

Do you realize that you're over-complicating this? When the memo clearly states the debt may require subsidies from "unrestricted funds from the endowment," that means exactly what it says. Institutional money that would normally stay invested may have to be diverted to cover the athletic shortfalls. I don't know how that can be made any more clear. What difference does it make if it's principal or "PRECEDES" (investment yields) that you're misspelling? It's still endowment-sourced money that's being used to prop up athletics because they can't even cover their own financing. Anything not remaining with the endowment is actively taking from the endowment. Again, not a complicated concept.

(06-03-2026 10:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  and this is no different than every G5 program out there that is subsidizing their athletics with academic side money.....aside from any actual student approved fees one can pretend the rest of the subsidies comes from wherever they want to.....be it student tuition or unrestricted precedes from the endowment

Memphis has $21.62 million in support from the academic side that is outside of the $7.19 million in student approved fees

north Texas state has $22.66 plus the $15.61 in student fees

USF will be higher if things do not work out with the level of expected income, but again there is nothing in any of that which suggest that money will be directly removed from the endowment

No kidding. Of course every athletic department receives university support. When has that not been the case? Will you tell me next that water is wet? The point is that the institutional subsidies are mutually exclusive of the internal lending to cover debt service. They are not the same line items. A structural bailout isn't standard budgeting. Straw man much?

1. there are all kinds of things that can be done to gain the ability to bond part of the project out....I am not an in depth follower of this project so the part you showed about the financing does state it is not eligible for tax free bonds......but there is nothing that says in the future once the project is complete the parts of it that serve the athletics of the university cannot be split off and bonded out

2. and again there is ZERO that shows that money is being taken straight from the corpus of the endowment and used for this project.....that is simply your interpretation of what is happening

3. there is nothing that says the entire project could not be farmed out for up front money to an organization that will run the events, give a cut to the university, and give the university needed dates of use and at the end of the deal the use and ownership returns to the university......this is what was done with UT Austin and The Moody Center and Oak View Group

the only difference being that UT formed the deal prior to construction, but there is nothing that prevents a deal from happening after construction is done

I see the poster child of Dunning-Kruger has returned. You certainly picked a strange hill to die on, playing USF's white knight; but I digress. Your tactics are transparent. When you run out of facts, you move the goalposts or weaponize ignorance.

1) No. I told you the facts, and you're ignoring the law. You can't retroactively convert a private placement loan into a tax-exempt municipal bond when the underlying revenue streams violate IRS private-use limits. Your suggestion is complete nonsense. This is Federal law. Educate yourself for once: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/141

2) Stop playing word games. They don't strengthen your position. Go back and read the memorandum again if you're confused. It explicitly identifies the risk to the endowment's unrestricted funds and is written in plain English: "subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment." Whether it touches core principal or investment returns, it's still capital that's being drained from the endowment pool to cover unbudgeted athletic deficits. This isn't opinion. It comes directly from the State of Florida Division of Bond Finance. No amount of wishful thinking or creative fan-fiction changes objective reality.

3) This is a false equivalence. Texas didn't build an arena, realize they couldn't afford the debt, and then ask Oak View Group (OVG) to bail them out. OVG funded the entire $375 million construction cost of the Moody Center upfront in exchange for operating rights. UT assumed zero debt. Do you not understand that USF has already taken on the debt and ownership risk themselves? A third-party operator is not going to swoop in post-construction to absorb a toxic, 7% debt profile unless USF surrenders virtually all revenue upside, which completely defeats the entire purpose of building the stadium to generate athletic revenue in the first place.

1.

https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...randum.pdf

[Image: ddd.png]

The State Board of Administration for Florida Universities states right there in one of the first paragraphs that they believe that bonds would be the better and lower cost form of financing. They specifically mention private use, but they also clearly state the same thing that I stated that you can break down various portions of a project into private use and non private use and thus use a combination of tax free and taxable financing

They also state that USF did not share with them their reasoning for making the CHOICE they made, but they clearly state they think it would be possible to break the project down into parts and use different forms of financing for each part......and I can assure you those people making that statement are much much smarter than you even dream that you are

2. when you use the google with these terms "can the U South Florida spend the corpus of it's endowment"

https://giving.usf.edu/download_file/force/4258/1266

Net position provides three classifications including net investment in capital assets, restricted, and unrestricted net position. Net investment in capital assets consists of capital assets, net of accumulated depreciation and reduced by outstanding balances of mortgages or other borrowings associated with those assets. Restricted net position consists of expendable resources made up of external, donor restricted funds and appreciation from the endowment while restricted-nonexpendable resources represent permanent endowments to be held in perpetuity

you are the one playing word games.....you are the one that is repeatedly talking about a "threat to the endowment" while that threat does not exist

lets go over the basics.....many of the dollars in the endowment are pledged for specific programs and thus the earnings from that go to those programs period the end and that is not going to change

The dividend payout rate on endowment invested amounts for years ended June 30, 2025 and 2024, was
4%. Annually, the Foundation’s Board evaluates historical performance, projected returns, and the needs
of the University to determine the appropriate dividend payout rate.

currently USF pays out 4% that is well below what a number of universities are paying out with some paying 5% with the average being 4.5%

so currently USF is paying out below the average.....plus endowments generally calculate on a multi year rolling average

just because money is in the endowment does not mean that is is part of the permanent endowment

for 2025 the total was 722,838,408$ with 283,909,249 being "restricted expendable" thus that money is for a specific purpose and will be used to pay for that and spent fully as required by the donor and 438,929,159 nonexpendable

if USF decides to go to a 100% payout of a multi-year rolling average of their endowment earnings if that is even legal in Florida well that would be foolish, but the results of that would be that once the endowment went negative they would be restricted from spending from it until it is built back up.....but I am not sure that would be legally possible

they are looking at about $18 million in debt service so with their endowment as shown if they moved from a 4% payout to a 5% payout it would generate an additional $7 million per year and they would still be right in line with many other universities

plus looking at the 2025 NACUBO comparison of endowments USF went from $ 708,333,000 in 2024 to $ 768,035,000 in 2025 or 8.43% so even paying out 5% if they can keep up those returns they are growing their endowment by 3.43% a year with no additional contributions from any source.....going back to 2022 their endowment was $604,517,000 so they are growing their endowment just fine

3. Texas could have easily afforded to build their arena, but being that it is the only major event space in Austin they did not feel like their athletics department wanted to be involved in managing all of that. They had $108 million in naming rights alone so cash was not an issue it was a lack of desire to manage all of the possible events and the feeling that a company that is geared up to manage events was better able to get the largest number of events into the venue on an annual basis which would bring the most revenue to UT with the least effort


so lets go over things.......the Florida BAO for universities stated the exact same thing that I did.......bond out part of the over all area and use loans for the rest.....they state they believe that is possible to do, but they allowed USF to make the decision on what to do......and we know they smarter than you ever will be

so you were wrong there on your opinion


next USF cannot spend into the endowment and there is no "danger" to the endowment......the only "danger" would be slowed growth from taking a larger payout than the current 4% which is below the average in the USA of 4.5% and below what a number of universities pay out which is 5%

and if they did go to 5% that would result in an additional $7+ million per year which is almost half of the stated $18 million debt service.....so your repeated attempts to place the "USF endowment in danger" are wrong especially when a payout of 5% in line with many other US universities would generate meaningful amounts of money towards service of the debt and would still have growth for the endowment off of investment income alone......we all know what you are ATTEMPTING to imply even if you try and crawdad back from that when called out

3. UT would have had no issue paying for their facility and instead decided to turn over management and construction because they feel that will generate the most income for them especially as the only major events center in the region


and really you should run over and try and figure out how to increase the academic stature, the endowment, the graduation rate, and the research profile of penny's can't coach playground for ballas with issues because USF is doing very well academically, research wise, and doing much better with their endowment.....I think Memphis is the last place they need to seek advice from
06-04-2026 09:27 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #79
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. https://www.flbog.edu/wp-content/uploads...randum.pdf

[Image: ddd.png]

The State Board of Administration for Florida Universities states right there in one of the first paragraphs that they believe that bonds would be the better and lower cost form of financing. They specifically mention private use, but they also clearly state the same thing that I stated that you can break down various portions of a project into private use and non private use and thus use a combination of tax free and taxable financing

They also state that USF did not share with them their reasoning for making the CHOICE they made, but they clearly state they think it would be possible to break the project down into parts and use different forms of financing for each part......and I can assure you those people making that statement are much much smarter than you even dream that you are

I don't have to dream anything about my intellect, but thanks for your projection. The great irony is that you believe you found the "smoking gun" but all it does is fully support exactly what I have told you far too many times at this point. They had no choice. What you're suggesting, but refusing to comprehend, is that the university administration would have been even more incompetent and irresponsible than the facts currently support. If this was their better option, why would they have chosen commercial lending? Hint: Federal law.

Since you didn't read or failed to comprehend the link I supplied earlier in the thread, for your review: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/141

(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. when you use the google with these terms "can the U South Florida spend the corpus of it's endowment"

https://giving.usf.edu/download_file/force/4258/1266

Net position provides three classifications including net investment in capital assets, restricted, and unrestricted net position. Net investment in capital assets consists of capital assets, net of accumulated depreciation and reduced by outstanding balances of mortgages or other borrowings associated with those assets. Restricted net position consists of expendable resources made up of external, donor restricted funds and appreciation from the endowment while restricted-nonexpendable resources represent permanent endowments to be held in perpetuity

<TRUNCATED>

plus looking at the 2025 NACUBO comparison of endowments USF went from $ 708,333,000 in 2024 to $ 768,035,000 in 2025 or 8.43% so even paying out 5% if they can keep up those returns they are growing their endowment by 3.43% a year with no additional contributions from any source.....going back to 2022 their endowment was $604,517,000 so they are growing their endowment just fine

This is by far the most hilarious display of Dunning-Kruger economics yet. You genuinely believe that USF can just arbitrarily bump their endowment payout rate from 4% to 5% to "generate an additional $7 million" to hand over to the athletic department.

Let's educate you on basic fiduciary law and how university foundations actually work:
  • The corpus is protected under Florida's Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act (UPMIFA), an endowment's principal (the corpus) is legally protected. Period.
  • You noted that USF has $283M in "restricted expendable" funds and suggested they can just spend that. No, they can't. "Donor-restricted" means exactly that. If a donor gives $10M to the College of Engineering or a cancer research fund, the university BOT cannot legally redirect those payouts to cover a subprime mortgage on a football stadium. Doing so is literal financial fraud and people would go to prison.
  • When the State Bond Director specifically warned that athletic failure will "require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment," he is warning that the ONLY pools of money the university has total discretion over will be systematically drained to bail out football. Bumping the payout rate to pay for a stadium doesn't mean "free money." It literally means you are actively starving the academic departments, scholarships, and faculty chairs that rely on those unrestricted yields.
Again, you continue to inadvertently prove my point. Bottom line, academics are subsidizing a toxic athletic ledger. No debate on that point.

(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. Texas could have easily afforded to build their arena, but being that it is the only major event space in Austin they did not feel like their athletics department wanted to be involved in managing all of that. They had $108 million in naming rights alone so cash was not an issue it was a lack of desire to manage all of the possible events and the feeling that a company that is geared up to manage events was better able to get the largest number of events into the venue on an annual basis which would bring the most revenue to UT with the least effort

You completely backtracked on your original point. First, you tried to pretend that USF could "farm out" their stadium to Oak View Group (OVG) post-construction just like Texas did. After I had to educate you on the facts that Texas took on zero debt and OVG paid for it upfront, you're pulling your most common move; moving the goalposts to talk about Austin's event market. Touche.

Wake up. Texas did not have a $200M mortgage at 7% interest with Truist Bank when they partnered with OVG. USF does. No private venue management firm on Earth is going to step in post-construction, assume USF's crushing debt service, allow USF to keep the primary football revenues they need to look attractive to a "power" conference, and do it just out of the goodness of their hearts. This is a completely stupid and illiterate business model.

(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  so lets go over things.......the Florida BAO for universities stated the exact same thing that I did.......bond out part of the over all area and use loans for the rest.....they state they believe that is possible to do, but they allowed USF to make the decision on what to do......and we know they smarter than you ever will be

<TRUNCATED>

and if they did go to 5% that would result in an additional $7+ million per year which is almost half of the stated $18 million debt service.....so your repeated attempts to place the "USF endowment in danger" are wrong especially when a payout of 5% in line with many other US universities would generate meaningful amounts of money towards service of the debt and would still have growth for the endowment off of investment income alone......we all know what you are ATTEMPTING to imply even if you try and crawdad back from that when called out

This is complete idiocy and not worthy of a response. Everything has already been over-explained in previous commentary.

(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. UT would have had no issue paying for their facility and instead decided to turn over management and construction because they feel that will generate the most income for them especially as the only major events center in the region

What?

(06-04-2026 09:27 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  and really you should run over and try and figure out how to increase the academic stature, the endowment, the graduation rate, and the research profile of penny's can't coach playground for ballas with issues because USF is doing very well academically, research wise, and doing much better with their endowment.....I think Memphis is the last place they need to seek advice from

Ah, right on cue, when you embarrass yourself and expose your ignorance, you pivot to personal shots about Memphis and Penny Hardaway. Look, insult Memphis all you want, and keep misunderstanding the financial disclosures you're frantically Googling; but it won't save you. You have to be able to interpret and understand the materials to make a factual and coherent argument. Whether you believe it or not, USF built a financial house of cards -- no amount of mental gymnastics changes this reality.
06-04-2026 10:47 PM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #80
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
your arguments are become so desperate it is laughable

1. the screen capture I showed from The Florida Universities BOR states clearly they believe that a portion (and a large portion) of the project could be bonded out with tax free bonds......your OPINION on that carries no weight relative to their opinion on that especially to anyone with a brain

here are clear examples

Examples of Bond-Funded Stadiums

Soldier Field: Renovated in 2003 for the Chicago Bears using approximately $399 million in tax-exempt bonds.

Yankee Stadium: One of the largest recipients of this type of subsidy.

I am sure you will try and be dumb enough to try and claim that somehow a university stajium is different than a pro sports stajium or that a city or state is different than a public university......but again it is as clear as day that tax free bonds have been used to build stajiums in the past and the opinion of those in charge of Florida universities is that could have been done for most of the USF project

so I provided proof that people that fel with these types of things on a frequent basis believe it is possible and I provided proof that it has been done for pro sports

you used "dunning kruger" two times while being shown proof that others of way higher intellect and knowledge disagree with you

2. once again your desperation and ignorance is showing....I made clear about the restricted-nonextendible money and the other money

I am the one that has repeatedly stated that a university cannot spend the corpus of the endowment while you are the one that repeatedly states "the endowment is under threat" which is you attempting to imply that the university will in fact spend into the corpus

the fact that you do not understand that universities and other non-profits can and do raise and lower the distributions from their endowments just shows you are daft

https://blog.carnegieinvest.com/nonprofi...erent-rule

so under UPMIFA there is no cap on what an endowment can pay out as a % there are only guidelines.....and in fact this article talks about 7%

as long as the university is not going below the Historic Dollar Value calculation for their endowment they are able to distribute money

when a donation is made the university is going to tell the donor what the expected payout from their donation is if it is earmarked for a specific program.....the donors get "units" in the endowment and they get a payout based on those units.....excess money over and above that stated per unit payout is available for other things

it can be reinvested into the corpus, it can be placed into university reserves, or it can be added back as a part of that unit.....or the distribution can be increased (legally as the above document states) and actually without limit as the above document states as long as Historic Dollar Value is maintained

so if a university has 200 units several years back taking up 50% of their endowment and the other 50% is not spoken for with specific projects or programs and the per unit payout is 4% and they have been getting a 9% return......well over time that university will have a lot more money in the endowment that is not spoken for......but of course if they are returning it to the endowment and it becomes part of the corpus then it still counts in the HDV

now if the university is still doing well and getting 12% returns for several years in a row they can LEGALLY (as stated in the document above) have their BOR vote to increase the value of the distribution......and while I mentioned 4.5% to 5% that document talks about 7% (which it clearly states is not a legal limit)

thus a university would have 200 units in their endowment getting their standard 4% payout, they would have a large increase over time in money that is not spoken for with any specific project or program which they can use 100% of the payout, and they have the payout above the 4% (or whatever was set when the "unit" was created) available to them

or they can simply start paying out 5%, they can pay the standard "unit" % and place other money in a "rainy day fund" as is legally permissible

the fact that you were clearly unaware that universities and other non-profits can and do vote to increase their distributions shows you are well out of your realm of knowledge on this subject which is why it is so hard for you to grasp you have been proven wrong time and again

as I CLEARLY stated universities do not spend into the corpus of endowments.....so you attempting to try and make that a point to me is laughable when I make that yo you several post back.....the fact that you think that even with money that is in an endowment and is "spoken for" that every dollar return made on that money is either distributed to that program or project or the amount over and above is always placed into the "spoken for" part of the endowment again shows your lack of knowledge......if someone donated $1 million for a project and the university has a 15% return for 5 years running and they pay out 4% that does not mean that the other 11% is placed in the endowment as "spoken for" with that same project from when the donation was made.....now yes a smart university will try and keep adding to that for inflation, but they will also look at the programs overall.....is that program now built out on lab space, is it bringing in large grants that fund professors and grad students and new equipment and overall it is doing well.....if so then they might take all of that 11% and place it in the endowment as "not spoken for"

and again universities can look and see they have returned 10% for 5 years plus taken in new (especially unrestricted) donations and decide to raise the distribution while still sending only 4% (or maybe 4.25% or 4.75% or whatever) while taking another 1% to 1.75% for "general use".......or place it into a "rainy day fund" that will not be a part of the endowment in the future and will not count as part of the HDV.....and in doing so they can have a lot of extra money.......while not digging into the corpus of their endowment one bit and in fact still leaving a % or 2 of growth in the endowment

and once again....USF has grown their academic profile dramatically over the last 10 to 15 years and they have grown their research productivity over the last 10 to 15 years dramatically.....I am sure they are more confident in what they are doing than someone from Memphis

3. I did not backtrack on any point....I did not state that USF could farm out their stajium for up front money just like Texas did"

what I stated is that USF could farm out the project for up front money....I am fully aware that Ut Austin did not get up front money from their project.....because the "up front money" was Oak view paying the cost of a facility that is on UT land and that UT owns and will regain control of in the future......you reading that to imply that Ut got upfront money is because you are desperate to be right about something.....anything....when you are clearly so wrong

USF is the one carrying the cost currently for their facility so they are paying the money and thus there is nothing that would suggest an impossibility of getting up front money and then a % of future revenues.....and if you want to try and split hairs in desperation to be right the only real difference is UT got theirs in the form of a facility and infrastructure while USF would get theirs in the terms of cash or if not much cash up front a larger % of revenues because USF paid for the facilities

but again in your desperation to try and be right about a really irrelevant point that I was not actually making you are missing out on the very real reality that USF will have several very large, very nice, very new, and very modern venues in a large metro area that are ripe for someone to come in and manage for up front money and a % of profits or for a larger % of profits.....it is not as if the facilities get built and after the university utilizes them on the days they need them there is just nothing else that can be done with them to generate revenue.....and it is not like there are not several large and growing and very competitive companies that are looking to move into university facilities management for shares of the profits......which is again the overall point not that UT did or did not get straight cash homie instead of the cost of their facilities covered completely while USF is in the opposite situation of having facilities coming online and available to those that could be interested in managing them better than a university can

4. I am not sure why you are saying "what".....UT Austin could have easily built their new facility on their own......but the university is generally not in the concert and events business they are not in the business of dealing with Taylor Swift, Metallica, circus acts or whatever else might want to use their venue.....it is easier, more profitable, and just a smarter business decision to let a company that manages multiple venues,that signs contracts with tour operators for several venues at a time, that deals with other aspects of event management on a much larger basis handle that while UT concentrates on sports......where they have been doing very well recently

I am not sure how hard that is to understand.....there are about 60 to 70 days/nights per year that UT needs that arena at most and that leaves 305 to 295 days/nights per year that someone else can deal with filling the facility and UT can take cash from that instead of their athletics department wasting time and effort trying to do that on their own

5. and what is embarrassing is someone that does not understand that endowment payouts can be adjusted, they do not understand that many athletics venues have been built with tax free bonds even for pro sports and that The State of Florida BOR for public universities believes it is possible to do so.......and that does not understand venue management especially of college sports venues (and even more so shiny new ones) is becoming a very big business and very competitive and there is nothing preventing USF from making a deal after the venues are built for management of it....be it for up front cash or for a % of the revenues and doing so will most likely give them a lot of financial relief

and you are attempting to frame your argument that USF is going to do lasting harm to their endowment while ignoring there are laws in place to prevent that and while ignoring that legally USF can increase the payout from their endowment and doing so even 1% would present them with a lot of cash even if it is not the most preferable thing to do

but when you are talking about a university that has made outstanding decisions in terms of academic achievement and elevation of reputation and in terms of research funding growth I think they deserve to be given the benefit of the doubt about how they manage their university especially relative to universities that need a LOT of work and have needed that for a long time......while spending over $20 million per year in academic side money on athletics and with only $8 million of that student approved......that seems like a crime especially compared to what USF is doing while their academics and research profile keeps climbing

you are the one that started this thread so there is no embarrassment on my part to point out "pssst.....hey mr concerned about the impending DOOOM for USF and their endowment and academics.....have you looked over at what is going on in far west Tennessee?".....have you compared that to what is going on over in slightly off on direction/location Florida
06-05-2026 12:57 AM
Find all posts by this user
Thread Closed 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.