your arguments are become so desperate it is laughable
1. the screen capture I showed from The Florida Universities BOR states clearly they believe that a portion (and a large portion) of the project could be bonded out with tax free bonds......your OPINION on that carries no weight relative to their opinion on that especially to anyone with a brain
here are clear examples
Examples of Bond-Funded Stadiums
Soldier Field: Renovated in 2003 for the Chicago Bears using approximately $399 million in tax-exempt bonds.
Yankee Stadium: One of the largest recipients of this type of subsidy.
I am sure you will try and be dumb enough to try and claim that somehow a university stajium is different than a pro sports stajium or that a city or state is different than a public university......but again it is as clear as day that tax free bonds have been used to build stajiums in the past and the opinion of those in charge of Florida universities is that could have been done for most of the USF project
so I provided proof that people that fel with these types of things on a frequent basis believe it is possible and I provided proof that it has been done for pro sports
you used "dunning kruger" two times while being shown proof that others of way higher intellect and knowledge disagree with you
2. once again your desperation and ignorance is showing....I made clear about the restricted-nonextendible money and the other money
I am the one that has repeatedly stated that a university cannot spend the corpus of the endowment while you are the one that repeatedly states "the endowment is under threat" which is you attempting to imply that the university will in fact spend into the corpus
the fact that you do not understand that universities and other non-profits can and do raise and lower the distributions from their endowments just shows you are daft
https://blog.carnegieinvest.com/nonprofi...erent-rule
so under UPMIFA there is no cap on what an endowment can pay out as a % there are only guidelines.....and in fact this article talks about 7%
as long as the university is not going below the Historic Dollar Value calculation for their endowment they are able to distribute money
when a donation is made the university is going to tell the donor what the expected payout from their donation is if it is earmarked for a specific program.....the donors get "units" in the endowment and they get a payout based on those units.....excess money over and above that stated per unit payout is available for other things
it can be reinvested into the corpus, it can be placed into university reserves, or it can be added back as a part of that unit.....or the distribution can be increased (legally as the above document states) and actually without limit as the above document states as long as Historic Dollar Value is maintained
so if a university has 200 units several years back taking up 50% of their endowment and the other 50% is not spoken for with specific projects or programs and the per unit payout is 4% and they have been getting a 9% return......well over time that university will have a lot more money in the endowment that is not spoken for......but of course if they are returning it to the endowment and it becomes part of the corpus then it still counts in the HDV
now if the university is still doing well and getting 12% returns for several years in a row they can LEGALLY (as stated in the document above) have their BOR vote to increase the value of the distribution......and while I mentioned 4.5% to 5% that document talks about 7% (which it clearly states is not a legal limit)
thus a university would have 200 units in their endowment getting their standard 4% payout, they would have a large increase over time in money that is not spoken for with any specific project or program which they can use 100% of the payout, and they have the payout above the 4% (or whatever was set when the "unit" was created) available to them
or they can simply start paying out 5%, they can pay the standard "unit" % and place other money in a "rainy day fund" as is legally permissible
the fact that you were clearly unaware that universities and other non-profits can and do vote to increase their distributions shows you are well out of your realm of knowledge on this subject which is why it is so hard for you to grasp you have been proven wrong time and again
as I CLEARLY stated universities do not spend into the corpus of endowments.....so you attempting to try and make that a point to me is laughable when I make that yo you several post back.....the fact that you think that even with money that is in an endowment and is "spoken for" that every dollar return made on that money is either distributed to that program or project or the amount over and above is always placed into the "spoken for" part of the endowment again shows your lack of knowledge......if someone donated $1 million for a project and the university has a 15% return for 5 years running and they pay out 4% that does not mean that the other 11% is placed in the endowment as "spoken for" with that same project from when the donation was made.....now yes a smart university will try and keep adding to that for inflation, but they will also look at the programs overall.....is that program now built out on lab space, is it bringing in large grants that fund professors and grad students and new equipment and overall it is doing well.....if so then they might take all of that 11% and place it in the endowment as "not spoken for"
and again universities can look and see they have returned 10% for 5 years plus taken in new (especially unrestricted) donations and decide to raise the distribution while still sending only 4% (or maybe 4.25% or 4.75% or whatever) while taking another 1% to 1.75% for "general use".......or place it into a "rainy day fund" that will not be a part of the endowment in the future and will not count as part of the HDV.....and in doing so they can have a lot of extra money.......while not digging into the corpus of their endowment one bit and in fact still leaving a % or 2 of growth in the endowment
and once again....USF has grown their academic profile dramatically over the last 10 to 15 years and they have grown their research productivity over the last 10 to 15 years dramatically.....I am sure they are more confident in what they are doing than someone from Memphis
3. I did not backtrack on any point....I did not state that USF could farm out their stajium for up front money just like Texas did"
what I stated is that USF could farm out the project for up front money....I am fully aware that Ut Austin did not get up front money from their project.....because the "up front money" was Oak view paying the cost of a facility that is on UT land and that UT owns and will regain control of in the future......you reading that to imply that Ut got upfront money is because you are desperate to be right about something.....anything....when you are clearly so wrong
USF is the one carrying the cost currently for their facility so they are paying the money and thus there is nothing that would suggest an impossibility of getting up front money and then a % of future revenues.....and if you want to try and split hairs in desperation to be right the only real difference is UT got theirs in the form of a facility and infrastructure while USF would get theirs in the terms of cash or if not much cash up front a larger % of revenues because USF paid for the facilities
but again in your desperation to try and be right about a really irrelevant point that I was not actually making you are missing out on the very real reality that USF will have several very large, very nice, very new, and very modern venues in a large metro area that are ripe for someone to come in and manage for up front money and a % of profits or for a larger % of profits.....it is not as if the facilities get built and after the university utilizes them on the days they need them there is just nothing else that can be done with them to generate revenue.....and it is not like there are not several large and growing and very competitive companies that are looking to move into university facilities management for shares of the profits......which is again the overall point not that UT did or did not get straight cash homie instead of the cost of their facilities covered completely while USF is in the opposite situation of having facilities coming online and available to those that could be interested in managing them better than a university can
4. I am not sure why you are saying "what".....UT Austin could have easily built their new facility on their own......but the university is generally not in the concert and events business they are not in the business of dealing with Taylor Swift, Metallica, circus acts or whatever else might want to use their venue.....it is easier, more profitable, and just a smarter business decision to let a company that manages multiple venues,that signs contracts with tour operators for several venues at a time, that deals with other aspects of event management on a much larger basis handle that while UT concentrates on sports......where they have been doing very well recently
I am not sure how hard that is to understand.....there are about 60 to 70 days/nights per year that UT needs that arena at most and that leaves 305 to 295 days/nights per year that someone else can deal with filling the facility and UT can take cash from that instead of their athletics department wasting time and effort trying to do that on their own
5. and what is embarrassing is someone that does not understand that endowment payouts can be adjusted, they do not understand that many athletics venues have been built with tax free bonds even for pro sports and that The State of Florida BOR for public universities believes it is possible to do so.......and that does not understand venue management especially of college sports venues (and even more so shiny new ones) is becoming a very big business and very competitive and there is nothing preventing USF from making a deal after the venues are built for management of it....be it for up front cash or for a % of the revenues and doing so will most likely give them a lot of financial relief
and you are attempting to frame your argument that USF is going to do lasting harm to their endowment while ignoring there are laws in place to prevent that and while ignoring that legally USF can increase the payout from their endowment and doing so even 1% would present them with a lot of cash even if it is not the most preferable thing to do
but when you are talking about a university that has made outstanding decisions in terms of academic achievement and elevation of reputation and in terms of research funding growth I think they deserve to be given the benefit of the doubt about how they manage their university especially relative to universities that need a LOT of work and have needed that for a long time......while spending over $20 million per year in academic side money on athletics and with only $8 million of that student approved......that seems like a crime especially compared to what USF is doing while their academics and research profile keeps climbing
you are the one that started this thread so there is no embarrassment on my part to point out "pssst.....hey mr concerned about the impending DOOOM for USF and their endowment and academics.....have you looked over at what is going on in far west Tennessee?".....have you compared that to what is going on over in slightly off on direction/location Florida