jimrtex
All American

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
|
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 12:35 PM)bullet Wrote: (02-03-2026 12:08 PM)ken d Wrote: (02-03-2026 11:41 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote: (01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote: "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."
The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.
Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.
But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.
Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.
The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.
I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.
I think that a breakaway in which the elite schools declared their athletes employees would have to take place before the courts preemptively declare all college athletes to be employees. Then, the only recourse for the lesser schools would be for congressional legislation saying they are an exception to the current standards for classification as employees.
The irony here is that if the NCAA had declared just football players and men's basketball players to be employees a long time ago, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation now.
Well it was a swimmer who sued. But, of course, the money that attracted the lawyers was in football and basketball. In reality, there's not any difference. Yes, football and basketball generate more money, but that's irrelevant (legally anyway) in whether a person is an employee or not. It may be relevant in public perception, but how much revenue you generate is not a factor.
Grant House, a swimmer, was suing for damages for NIL money that he might have earned but for NCAA rules against it. Olivia Dunne, the LSU gymnast was the top awardee. But even for these damages, most went to football and basketball players, particularly at P5 schools.
There were also alleged damages for "broadcast NIL". The NCAA denied that there is such a thing, and continues to deny it, and it is specifically against new NCAA rules. But the NCAA agreed to $$$ to settle the lawsuit, and those $$$ are being distributed to mostly football and basketball players as if there was such a thing. The plaintiffs lawyers get a healthy cut. The NCAA also agreed to permit schools to pay players up to the cap. Most of that payment is in the form of NIL to promote the school or its athletic program. Fernando Mendoza is not being paid for throwing the football, he is being paid for promoting the University of Indiana and its football program through the use of his fame or notoreity (for throwing the football). He is likely also received 3rd Party NIL.
If there is a ruling that student athletes are employees, the injunction part of the settlement is voided, since the employees will be able to negotiate a CBA.
In the Johnson case which is an attempt to have athletes declared employees, the 2nd Court of Appeals has ruled that some athletes may be employees. On remand, the district court is supposed to set the boundaries (one of the plaintiffs is a cross-country worker/runner for Cornell).
|
|