Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
Author Message
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #21
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(01-29-2026 11:06 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 09:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 09:44 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

They’re Congress! They pass laws! If the desire is to give student-athletes an avenue to engage in collective bargaining, but there’s opposition to deeming them employees, just change the collective bargaining law to include a carve-out for student-athletes empowering them to organize and bargain like unionized employees do but without being considered employees.

Washington D.C.… where common sense goes to die.

The 2 parties have gone back to sniping at each other constantly for the past 20 years, just like in the bad old days before WW2. There used to be unifying principles like loyalty to the Country, but nowadays it seems that they can't even agree on issues where they already have much common ground. It's better in your highly gerrymandered district to stick it to (the other party) than it is to actually get something done most of the time.

Yep. I worked in D.C. in the ‘80s, in a job that gave me access to observe the back-and-forth politicking among the heavyweights. Even then partisanship was a strong driving factor in most decisions — Reagan was a polarizing figure — but there was still a fair amount of common ground between the parties and some areas of debate in which party affiliation didn’t matter at all.

Folks felt they were there to do the country’s business. Nuts and bolts stuff. Authorize a project to save the Everglades. Reform the welfare program for Native Americans. Get a bridge built in West Virginia. Coalitions could be built around shared personal interests or regional connections as much as party ties. Getting a bill through to address a college athletics issue wouldn’t have been thought of as a partisan matter.

The people in power then have mostly passed on but if they could see Washington today they would be in utter disbelief.

Many of them, probably, but some would remember a time before WW2 when it was much more polarized. The weird thing is not that the 2 parties seem determined to kill each other and perhaps the country, too, but rather that we've had such a long period in which the good of the country was considered by most to be more important than the good of the individual or party. We had a spirit of bipartisanship for so long that most forgot that it was an historical anomaly.
01-30-2026 03:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,546
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #22
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(01-30-2026 03:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 11:06 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 09:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 09:44 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

They’re Congress! They pass laws! If the desire is to give student-athletes an avenue to engage in collective bargaining, but there’s opposition to deeming them employees, just change the collective bargaining law to include a carve-out for student-athletes empowering them to organize and bargain like unionized employees do but without being considered employees.

Washington D.C.… where common sense goes to die.

The 2 parties have gone back to sniping at each other constantly for the past 20 years, just like in the bad old days before WW2. There used to be unifying principles like loyalty to the Country, but nowadays it seems that they can't even agree on issues where they already have much common ground. It's better in your highly gerrymandered district to stick it to (the other party) than it is to actually get something done most of the time.

Yep. I worked in D.C. in the ‘80s, in a job that gave me access to observe the back-and-forth politicking among the heavyweights. Even then partisanship was a strong driving factor in most decisions — Reagan was a polarizing figure — but there was still a fair amount of common ground between the parties and some areas of debate in which party affiliation didn’t matter at all.

Folks felt they were there to do the country’s business. Nuts and bolts stuff. Authorize a project to save the Everglades. Reform the welfare program for Native Americans. Get a bridge built in West Virginia. Coalitions could be built around shared personal interests or regional connections as much as party ties. Getting a bill through to address a college athletics issue wouldn’t have been thought of as a partisan matter.

The people in power then have mostly passed on but if they could see Washington today they would be in utter disbelief.

Many of them, probably, but some would remember a time before WW2 when it was much more polarized. The weird thing is not that the 2 parties seem determined to kill each other and perhaps the country, too, but rather that we've had such a long period in which the good of the country was considered by most to be more important than the good of the individual or party. We had a spirit of bipartisanship for so long that most forgot that it was an historical anomaly.

In 1856 Representative Preston Brooks of South Carolina attacked Senator Charles Sumner of Massachusetts with his cane and nearly beat him to death.
01-30-2026 04:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #23
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote:  "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."

The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.

Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.

But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.

Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.

The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.

I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.
02-03-2026 11:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,302
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #24
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 11:41 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote:  "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."

The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.

Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.

But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.

Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.

The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.

I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.

I think that a breakaway in which the elite schools declared their athletes employees would have to take place before the courts preemptively declare all college athletes to be employees. Then, the only recourse for the lesser schools would be for congressional legislation saying they are an exception to the current standards for classification as employees.

The irony here is that if the NCAA had declared just football players and men's basketball players to be employees a long time ago, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation now.
02-03-2026 12:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Sicembear11 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 991
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation: 242
I Root For: Baylor
Location:
Post: #25
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 12:08 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 11:41 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote:  "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."

The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.

Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.

But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.

Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.

The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.

I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.

I think that a breakaway in which the elite schools declared their athletes employees would have to take place before the courts preemptively declare all college athletes to be employees. Then, the only recourse for the lesser schools would be for congressional legislation saying they are an exception to the current standards for classification as employees.

The irony here is that if the NCAA had declared just football players and men's basketball players to be employees a long time ago, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation now.

Why would they when they had the "Student-athlete" ruling to rely on until it got shredded decades later?

Why would football players and men's basketball players be "employees" but women's basketball and baseball and all other athletics programs are not?

Blaming the NCAA is and has been the wrong course. They are a group of colleges that ran athletics programs and gave out scholarships and room-and-board and that product found itself much more popular than many would've anticipated.
02-03-2026 12:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,884
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #26
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 12:08 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 11:41 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote:  "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."

The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.

Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.

But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.

Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.

The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.

I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.

I think that a breakaway in which the elite schools declared their athletes employees would have to take place before the courts preemptively declare all college athletes to be employees. Then, the only recourse for the lesser schools would be for congressional legislation saying they are an exception to the current standards for classification as employees.

The irony here is that if the NCAA had declared just football players and men's basketball players to be employees a long time ago, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation now.

Well it was a swimmer who sued. But, of course, the money that attracted the lawyers was in football and basketball. In reality, there's not any difference. Yes, football and basketball generate more money, but that's irrelevant (legally anyway) in whether a person is an employee or not. It may be relevant in public perception, but how much revenue you generate is not a factor.
02-03-2026 12:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,243
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #27
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

Why would collective bargaining require the players to be employees? Yes--I know---thats obviously true under current law. However, seems like I remember from civics classes that Congress literally writes the laws. If Congress writes an exception into the law---then the players dont have to be employees. Its literally that simple. From what Ive observed---Congress loves writing exceptions----Im afraid I dont see this as a big hurdle.
(This post was last modified: 02-03-2026 03:07 PM by Attackcoog.)
02-03-2026 03:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
nodak651 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,313
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 136
I Root For: North Dakota
Location:
Post: #28
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
I don't see how it's possible to follow title ix rules that are currently in place if athletes were to be classified as employees. I don't know the details well enough to point out any specifics, but intuitively, it just doesn't seem right.
02-03-2026 04:23 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #29
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 12:35 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 12:08 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 11:41 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 02:07 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 11:09 AM)ken d Wrote:  "The employment system is dramatically different than what a student-athlete is," Cruz told ESPN. "A student-athlete is meant to be a student, to get a degree. And the entire world of employment regulation is designed for a totally different system."

The NCAA (and its member schools) cynically coined that phrase as a way to justify an amateur system of sports that shamelessly exploited athletes for the purpose of enabling them to extract money from their alumni and friends. The athletes, at least in the revenue sports, are not meant to be students, they are/were meant to be athletes. They were just required to be students, in order to justify favorable tax treatment for the wealthy boosters of their schools.

Participating on the field as a football player does nothing to advance his pursuit of a degree, with the possible exception of one studying for a career in physical education. No doubt one learns valuable life lessons through sports, but one doesn't have to be enrolled as a student to benefit from that.

But we also have to understand that American society, at least a clear majority of it, values athletic prowess above virtually all academic performance and that athletes, especially the most talented of them, deserve to be treated differently. In the end, like everything else, the golden rule will apply. The ones who have the gold get to make the rules.

Actually they were students. Its just that they have become more athlete than student as the money has increased in the last 20-40 years. There were some ringers in the teens and twenties, but most were actual students who played the games.

The most difficult part is that it's only for the very best of the best that this is actually the case. A football player at Texas or Georgia? Mostly athlete, and many of them probably care little about classes or getting a degree. Ditto for TCU or UH. But what about Tulsa, Temple, Nevada, or New Mexico? Not many of those kids are under any illusions about NFL glory, and not many of them at all are getting big NIL checks. Drop down to FCS, D2, and D3 and it's basically the old "no NIL" system, or at least extremely limited NIL with a few guys getting 5 figures a year in bags or whatever. This is why we see guys like JR who have been watching this play out over many decades predicting a true breakaway I thin. There's no reason to completely reconstitute Athletics governance at Marshall, Idaho, Sac St, Mary Hardin Baylor, etc etc etc b/c Ohio St's QB makes $5m a year, and there's also no reason for the same entity to be mostly non-profit on the one hand but be dominated by the 5% of schools that have $100m++ Athletic budgets.

I'm still strongly against forcing schools to say that their kids are "employees" instead of "student-athletes", but I also think that a breakaway that roughly follows the contours of the current P4 would likely decide that they wanted to do that on their own without govt coercion. But that way, Stephen F Austin wouldn't be forced down an unsustainable path just b/c that path was better for my Aggies and your Longhorns.

I think that a breakaway in which the elite schools declared their athletes employees would have to take place before the courts preemptively declare all college athletes to be employees. Then, the only recourse for the lesser schools would be for congressional legislation saying they are an exception to the current standards for classification as employees.

The irony here is that if the NCAA had declared just football players and men's basketball players to be employees a long time ago, we probably wouldn't be having this conversation now.

Well it was a swimmer who sued. But, of course, the money that attracted the lawyers was in football and basketball. In reality, there's not any difference. Yes, football and basketball generate more money, but that's irrelevant (legally anyway) in whether a person is an employee or not. It may be relevant in public perception, but how much revenue you generate is not a factor.
Grant House, a swimmer, was suing for damages for NIL money that he might have earned but for NCAA rules against it. Olivia Dunne, the LSU gymnast was the top awardee. But even for these damages, most went to football and basketball players, particularly at P5 schools.

There were also alleged damages for "broadcast NIL". The NCAA denied that there is such a thing, and continues to deny it, and it is specifically against new NCAA rules. But the NCAA agreed to $$$ to settle the lawsuit, and those $$$ are being distributed to mostly football and basketball players as if there was such a thing. The plaintiffs lawyers get a healthy cut. The NCAA also agreed to permit schools to pay players up to the cap. Most of that payment is in the form of NIL to promote the school or its athletic program. Fernando Mendoza is not being paid for throwing the football, he is being paid for promoting the University of Indiana and its football program through the use of his fame or notoreity (for throwing the football). He is likely also received 3rd Party NIL.

If there is a ruling that student athletes are employees, the injunction part of the settlement is voided, since the employees will be able to negotiate a CBA.

In the Johnson case which is an attempt to have athletes declared employees, the 2nd Court of Appeals has ruled that some athletes may be employees. On remand, the district court is supposed to set the boundaries (one of the plaintiffs is a cross-country worker/runner for Cornell).
02-05-2026 03:54 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #30
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 04:23 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  I don't see how it's possible to follow title ix rules that are currently in place if athletes were to be classified as employees. I don't know the details well enough to point out any specifics, but intuitively, it just doesn't seem right.

As long as access to athletics qualifies as education opportunity, the Constitution’s equal protection principle applies. That’s the basis for Title IX. An official ‘employee’ designation is unlikely to affect that one way or the other.

What the designation would affect is the body of law applied to the relationship of athletes to schools. A new carved-out designation would start its own clock running at the time of passage. Otherwise, the employer-employee model is likely to be adopted—and at least a century of statute and case law already exists to regulate that.

___
(This post was last modified: 02-06-2026 03:47 AM by Gitanole.)
02-06-2026 03:44 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #31
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-03-2026 03:04 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

Why would collective bargaining require the players to be employees? Yes--I know---thats obviously true under current law. However, seems like I remember from civics classes that Congress literally writes the laws. If Congress writes an exception into the law---then the players dont have to be employees. Its literally that simple. From what Ive observed---Congress loves writing exceptions----Im afraid I dont see this as a big hurdle.

It's about legislation that can pass. For whatever reason, most colleges don't want collective bargaining so too many Congressmen don't, either. It's just one more example of the ever-widening gulf between the P4 and everybody else. Take out the P4, let them collectively bargain however they want, employees, not employees, whatever, and give everyone else exactly what the NCAA used to be (but still with NIL ofc). We are still stuck trying to pretend that South Alabama is the same as ALABAMA, when it's clearly not.
(This post was last modified: 02-06-2026 11:12 AM by bryanw1995.)
02-06-2026 11:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Native Georgian Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 31,619
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1428
I Root For: TULANE+GA.STATE
Location: Decatur GA
Post: #32
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(01-30-2026 03:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  The weird thing is not that the 2 parties seem determined to kill each other and perhaps the country, too, but rather that we've had such a long period in which the good of the country was considered by most to be more important than the good of the individual or party. We had a spirit of bipartisanship for so long that most forgot that it was an historical anomaly.
What period of time are you describing?
02-06-2026 12:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Online
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #33
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-06-2026 12:19 PM)Native Georgian Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 03:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  The weird thing is not that the 2 parties seem determined to kill each other and perhaps the country, too, but rather that we've had such a long period in which the good of the country was considered by most to be more important than the good of the individual or party. We had a spirit of bipartisanship for so long that most forgot that it was an historical anomaly.
What period of time are you describing?

WW2 immediately followed by Cold War closely followed by 9/11. Nothing brings a feuding family/group/country together like an external threat. The past decade + we have seen an accelerating return to the politics of old, which I classify as the "default state" of politics.
02-06-2026 12:24 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Native Georgian Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 31,619
Joined: May 2008
Reputation: 1428
I Root For: TULANE+GA.STATE
Location: Decatur GA
Post: #34
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-06-2026 12:24 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-06-2026 12:19 PM)Native Georgian Wrote:  
(01-30-2026 03:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  The weird thing is not that the 2 parties seem determined to kill each other and perhaps the country, too, but rather that we've had such a long period in which the good of the country was considered by most to be more important than the good of the individual or party. We had a spirit of bipartisanship for so long that most forgot that it was an historical anomaly.
What period of time are you describing?
WW2 immediately followed by Cold War closely followed by 9/11.
Hmmmmm.

The bipartisan spirit fostered by the national trauma of 9/11 lasted about 12 months, at the max. In some ways, less than that. By 2003/04 — and ever since — the main thrust of Dem/GOP politics has resembled a war of attrition between rival gangs that genuinely hate each other, much more so than whatever “external threats” exist that should be bringing us together. Just my 2 cents.

I know this isn’t the politics board so I promise to leave it there.
02-06-2026 12:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,342
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 975
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #35
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
The small fry conferences definitely don't want athletes as employees. (Strange to see the WAC/UAC sign, but not the ASUN.)

(This post was last modified: 02-07-2026 02:41 AM by Stugray2.)
02-06-2026 05:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #36
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-06-2026 11:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 03:04 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

Why would collective bargaining require the players to be employees? Yes--I know---thats obviously true under current law. However, seems like I remember from civics classes that Congress literally writes the laws. If Congress writes an exception into the law---then the players dont have to be employees. Its literally that simple. From what Ive observed---Congress loves writing exceptions----Im afraid I dont see this as a big hurdle.

It's about legislation that can pass. For whatever reason, most colleges don't want collective bargaining so too many Congressmen don't, either. It's just one more example of the ever-widening gulf between the P4 and everybody else. Take out the P4, let them collectively bargain however they want, employees, not employees, whatever, and give everyone else exactly what the NCAA used to be (but still with NIL ofc). We are still stuck trying to pretend that South Alabama is the same as ALABAMA, when it's clearly not.

The right to collectively bargain is exactly that: a right.

It is based on US Constitution guarantees: the right to freedom of assembly and the right to express and seek redress of grievances.

Whether you call the people being paid ‘employees’ or carve out a new category for them that calls them something else, those people retain their rights. They can collectively bargain. They can do so through a ‘union’ according to present labour law, or through whatever new mechanism gets carved out.

My impression is that some in university administration were slow to get the memo as to how recent court rulings have changed things. They moved to persuade legislators to turn back the clock rather than craft a bill that would actually withstand court scrutiny and set up functional structures for the future.

As it happens, legislators don’t like spending time hammering out bills if they think any resulting law will be struck down as unconstitutional. It’s far easier just to spike the discussion and let courts decide things anyway.

Ironically, as a result of being unrealistic, the odds of conference commissioners and university administrators getting their nightmare scenario now go up. They are more likely now to get employees as their athletes and unions as the collective bargaining mechanism.
02-06-2026 07:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,884
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #37
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-06-2026 07:57 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(02-06-2026 11:06 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(02-03-2026 03:04 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(01-29-2026 04:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  https://www.espn.com/college-sports/stor...s-congress

The Republican from Texas, who holds a key position in advancing NCAA legislation as chair of the Senate Commerce Committee, told ESPN in an interview Wednesday that Congress might run out of time to act if it can't find a bipartisan solution in the coming months. During a yearslong effort to restore order to the college sports industry, Republicans and Democrats have remained largely divided on whether college athletes should have a future avenue for collective bargaining, which would require them to be employees.

Article seems to focus on making college athletes employees, it circles back to the question 4 or 5 times. The author seems to have an agenda. Cruz is just trying to get legislation that can pass. Too bad Cody Campbell killed the legislation last year, I'm not confident they'll be able to get it across the finish line this year.

Why would collective bargaining require the players to be employees? Yes--I know---thats obviously true under current law. However, seems like I remember from civics classes that Congress literally writes the laws. If Congress writes an exception into the law---then the players dont have to be employees. Its literally that simple. From what Ive observed---Congress loves writing exceptions----Im afraid I dont see this as a big hurdle.

It's about legislation that can pass. For whatever reason, most colleges don't want collective bargaining so too many Congressmen don't, either. It's just one more example of the ever-widening gulf between the P4 and everybody else. Take out the P4, let them collectively bargain however they want, employees, not employees, whatever, and give everyone else exactly what the NCAA used to be (but still with NIL ofc). We are still stuck trying to pretend that South Alabama is the same as ALABAMA, when it's clearly not.

The right to collectively bargain is exactly that: a right.

It is based on US Constitution guarantees: the right to freedom of assembly and the right to express and seek redress of grievances.

Whether you call the people being paid ‘employees’ or carve out a new category for them that calls them something else, those people retain their rights. They can collectively bargain. They can do so through a ‘union’ according to present labour law, or through whatever new mechanism gets carved out.

My impression is that some in university administration were slow to get the memo as to how recent court rulings have changed things. They moved to persuade legislators to turn back the clock rather than craft a bill that would actually withstand court scrutiny and set up functional structures for the future.

As it happens, legislators don’t like spending time hammering out bills if they think any resulting law will be struck down as unconstitutional. It’s far easier just to spike the discussion and let courts decide things anyway.

Ironically, as a result of being unrealistic, the odds of conference commissioners and university administrators getting their nightmare scenario now go up. They are more likely now to get employees as their athletes and unions as the collective bargaining mechanism.

You're imagining things the way you want. They can define what constitutes an employee with a great deal of discretion. Being unconsititional is not a concern of Congress. Having something more than 1/3 can agree on is!
02-06-2026 10:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #38
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-06-2026 10:58 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(02-06-2026 07:57 PM)Gitanole Wrote:  The right to collectively bargain is exactly that: a right.

It is based on US Constitution guarantees: the right to freedom of assembly and the right to express and seek redress of grievances.

Whether you call the people being paid ‘employees’ or carve out a new category for them that calls them something else, those people retain their rights. They can collectively bargain. They can do so through a ‘union’ according to present labour law, or through whatever new mechanism gets carved out.

My impression is that some in university administration were slow to get the memo as to how recent court rulings have changed things. They moved to persuade legislators to turn back the clock rather than craft a bill that would actually withstand court scrutiny and set up functional structures for the future.

As it happens, legislators don’t like spending time hammering out bills if they think any resulting law will be struck down as unconstitutional. It’s far easier just to spike the discussion and let courts decide things anyway.

Ironically, as a result of being unrealistic, the odds of conference commissioners and university administrators getting their nightmare scenario now go up. They are more likely now to get employees as their athletes and unions as the collective bargaining mechanism.

You're imagining things the way you want. They can define what constitutes an employee with a great deal of discretion. Being unconsititional is not a concern of Congress. Having something more than 1/3 can agree on is!

Your second sentence is almost correct.

The designation ‘employee’ is arrived at by tests under labour law. Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment), statutes (lawmakers enact), and case law (courts rule and create precedent).

The term ‘employee’ is the legal default once certain conditions are met. Once those are met, the entire body of existing law regulating employer-employee relationships applies.

A suggestion raised by the House decision is the desirability of a new designation, something other than ‘employee,’ that would apply to compensated student athletes. If carved out, existing statutory law regarding employees as such need not apply (such as laws regulating taxes, non-competes, etc). Athletes and athletic departments would get the chance to set a lot of their own precedents.

In order to get that, they do need a bill that authorises this new designation, they need it to pass through Congress and become law, and they need the new law to stick without being overturned as unconstitutional by courts.

Fail at any of those steps, and everyone is back to labour law as it now exists on the books. Likely outcome? Hello, employees. Hello, unions.
____
(This post was last modified: 02-07-2026 02:07 AM by Gitanole.)
02-07-2026 01:51 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ouflak Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 317
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation: 69
I Root For: University of Oklahoma
Location:
Post: #39
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-07-2026 01:51 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment)

This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.
02-07-2026 07:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,080
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2771
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #40
RE: Sen. Ted Cruz against idea of college athletes as employees
(02-07-2026 07:08 AM)ouflak Wrote:  
(02-07-2026 01:51 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  Labour law consists of Constitutional principles (can only be changed by amendment)

This is purely and historically correct. And I'm truly amazed at all of the, as far I can tell otherwise, seemingly intelligent people who suggest that you can just 'cap' NIL or force people to stay at one place and one place only, without either amending the 13th and 14th amendments of the Constituion to somehow exclude student athletes, or repealing those amendments altogether for everybody - and we just all live with consequences.

You can’t cap NIL, but I don’t think anyone is saying that. We’ve had this discussion and you’re still conflating NIL with revenue sharing. You were also upset about procedures qualifying NIL. Contracts don’t force people to stay in one place but they do introduce recourse if the person leaves.
02-07-2026 08:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.