RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:51 AM)memphis mania Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
This. Living in this conference is absolutely debilitating.
It wouldn’t be as debilitating if we were dominating it. Penny is incapable of getting us to the ability to accomplish that.
His contract goes until 2027, correct? Ashton will have played his 4 years of eligibility after the 2027 season, correct? At that point, Penny will have done all he can to help his sons and EHS kids get through college and into the pros at some level. Think about this - he did (arguably) his best coaching job last year, without a family connection to any of the players on the team. Just sayin’….
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 01:02 PM)former guest Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:51 AM)memphis mania Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
This. Living in this conference is absolutely debilitating.
It wouldn’t be as debilitating if we were dominating it. Penny is incapable of getting us to the ability to accomplish that.
His contract goes until 2027, correct? Ashton will have played his 4 years of eligibility after the 2027 season, correct? At that point, Penny will have done all he can to help his sons and EHS kids get through college and into the pros at some level. Think about this - he did (arguably) his best coaching job last year, without a family connection to any of the players on the team. Just sayin’….
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 09:48 AM)Titans3775 Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:42 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:37 AM)Titans3775 Wrote:
(01-11-2026 09:50 PM)axdtigers Wrote:
Well please don't let Goodman help hire a new coach with those 3 names. Two coaches who are no better than what we have and a guy who doesn't even have a full season as head coach? We are way better than that.
Not going to give John Martin and Jeff Goodman another click...So what 3 names did those geniuses come up with?
Three guys who would almost certainly be the 4th failure in a row.
Ryan Miller - A guy who doesn't even have a single season of head coaching experience.
Shaheen Holloway - Who went 7-25 last year and has double digit losses every season of his career.
Tony Skinn - Who has never even sniffed the tournament and has never had a team ranked higher than #73.
Ryan Miller is all John Martin. He's got his head way far up brother Mike's rectum.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:26 AM)GermantownTiger Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:35 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Bill Laurie is a big Penny guy.
Good point. This is a reason why should the university decide to part ways with Penny, it needs to be done in a high-level, professional manner.
Bill was big mad the way Larry was let go...if we were to part ways with Penny in an ugly fashion, we'd likely lose his financial support at the worst possible time.
It's tough for the 64-year-old me to watch our program struggle in this day and age of the NIL / Transfer Portal. I just hope we can find some solutions before things get worse.
*Was a big Penny guy. I've heard that his support of Penny has waned over the past year or so.
Also, as Goodman noted, Penny does not have the full backing of FedEx.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
If Penny were let go the first two coaches that should be called before anyone else does are
Brian Wardle(Bradley) or Takayo Siddle ( UNC Wilmington ). All these guys do is win.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 02:28 PM)MtownTigers916 Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:26 AM)GermantownTiger Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:35 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Bill Laurie is a big Penny guy.
Good point. This is a reason why should the university decide to part ways with Penny, it needs to be done in a high-level, professional manner.
Bill was big mad the way Larry was let go...if we were to part ways with Penny in an ugly fashion, we'd likely lose his financial support at the worst possible time.
It's tough for the 64-year-old me to watch our program struggle in this day and age of the NIL / Transfer Portal. I just hope we can find some solutions before things get worse.
*Was a big Penny guy. I've heard that his support of Penny has waned over the past year or so.
Also, as Goodman noted, Penny does not have the full backing of FedEx.
If both of these points are true, it makes me very concerned.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 12:42 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: It would be such a Memphis thing - have a former player worth $5b and piss him off to the point he no longer gives money. On the flip side, I don’t think our big $ folks have the “whatever it takes” desire to see Tiger basketball win big in the same manner that Fertita does at Houston or the former player turned oil tycoon paying millions for Texas Tech football. Saw somewhere that Mark Cuban is now giving a small fortune to Hoosier football. Just no way that Memphis can compete with that.
Word is Bill is not very happy with the head of the athletic department.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 12:42 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: It would be such a Memphis thing - have a former player worth $5b and piss him off to the point he no longer gives money. On the flip side, I don’t think our big $ folks have the “whatever it takes” desire to see Tiger basketball win big in the same manner that Fertita does at Houston or the former player turned oil tycoon paying millions for Texas Tech football. Saw somewhere that Mark Cuban is now giving a small fortune to Hoosier football. Just no way that Memphis can compete with that.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 01:16 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Absolutely
Penny lost a good bit of his Ambassadors providing NIL 3 or so years ago. One of them was a whale. He still has some but the money will be there once he is gone No one was going to provide NIL funds for a failing business, that was simply waiting for a "gone out of business" sign.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 04:48 PM)2tigers Wrote:
(01-12-2026 12:42 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: It would be such a Memphis thing - have a former player worth $5b and piss him off to the point he no longer gives money. On the flip side, I don’t think our big $ folks have the “whatever it takes” desire to see Tiger basketball win big in the same manner that Fertita does at Houston or the former player turned oil tycoon paying millions for Texas Tech football. Saw somewhere that Mark Cuban is now giving a small fortune to Hoosier football. Just no way that Memphis can compete with that.
Cuban graduated from Indiana.
I know. Someone said today they saw where he said he never attended an IU football game while a student. Not sure if true or not.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
It is not out of the realm of reality that a coach can have a "swing and a miss" when it comes to recruiting. One year is an abnormality. However, two or three is a trend.
The world has changed with transfer portal and NIL. The ceremony of granting contract extensions is no longer relevant. intending to show potential players that the administration has confidence in a particular coach in order to keep those players from eliminating a school from consideration because the coach might not be there after a year or so. So, that being said, don't put any significance to CPH contract only running through 2027.
If I'm making the call, I will just consider this years team as a coaches failure in judgment on these players abilities, write the $$ loss in NIL money as a sh!t just happens, and get ready to start again next year from scratch. Now, do it again next year and we have to put CPH on a PIP and let the chips fall where they may.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 06:17 PM)mapdude Wrote: It is not out of the realm of reality that a coach can have a "swing and a miss" when it comes to recruiting. One year is an abnormality. However, two or three is a trend.
The world has changed with transfer portal and NIL. The ceremony of granting contract extensions is no longer relevant. intending to show potential players that the administration has confidence in a particular coach in order to keep those players from eliminating a school from consideration because the coach might not be there after a year or so. So, that being said, don't put any significance to CPH contract only running through 2027.
If I'm making the call, I will just consider this years team as a coaches failure in judgment on these players abilities, write the $$ loss in NIL money as a sh!t just happens, and get ready to start again next year from scratch. Now, do it again next year and we have to put CPH on a PIP and let the chips fall where they may.
Discuss...
Penny is incapable of getting it done at Memphis. If this program is going to again be a viable national program, then it will be with someone else leading it. He cannot do it.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 04:51 PM)griffin Wrote:
(01-12-2026 01:16 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Absolutely
Penny lost a good bit of his Ambassadors providing NIL 3 or so years ago. One of them was a whale. He still has some but the money will be there once he is gone No one was going to provide NIL funds for a failing business, that was simply waiting for a "gone out of business" sign.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Temple, Wichita State and UAB need to get their past mojo back, if possible. FL Atlantic had that one "magical season", it probably didn't get them much cred. A little, but not much. Of course, there are worse places to go play college BB for money.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 06:41 PM)Herff Tiger Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Temple, Wichita State and UAB need to get their past mojo back, if possible. FL Atlantic had that one "magical season", it probably didn't get them much cred. A little, but not much. Of course, there are worse places to go play college BB for money.
Small schools being able to build a roster over multiple years and make a run with a senior and junior laden team is over. Those guys will all just get snapped up before then now.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-11-2026 03:31 PM)ShilohTiger Wrote: So Warren Nolan predicted we'd lose by 2 points, and we lost by 11 points.
This was always going to be a tough away game.
FAU is predicted to win the conference regular season now with a 13-5 conference record.
The problem is that we are way worse than the preseason predictions.
Our rebounding is atrocious.
FAU has good players and a good coach going in a better direction than our program.
I don't think this team can go 12-6 in conference.
Penny won't get his 20 wins this season and the big question is will we finish this season above .500?
I'm on record as stating we won't. Penny should do the right thing and step down at the end of the season, regardless of how it turns out. Short of winning a NC there's nothing he can do to regain my support.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 06:32 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote:
(01-12-2026 04:51 PM)griffin Wrote:
(01-12-2026 01:16 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Absolutely
Penny lost a good bit of his Ambassadors providing NIL 3 or so years ago. One of them was a whale. He still has some but the money will be there once he is gone No one was going to provide NIL funds for a failing business, that was simply waiting for a "gone out of business" sign.
The Bates ordeal pissed some of them off.
I sure hope you guys are right about the money returning with a new coach in place.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:59 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:12 AM)Atlanta Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:49 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:28 AM)Atlanta Wrote:
(01-12-2026 07:56 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Penny has been a head coach now for 8 years… he’s 54 years old.
Either he has the capacity or he doesn’t.
Penny's life & lifestyle don't depend on being a successful college MB. coach, so he's simply a caretaker of a program for which he has affection & he will never do the work necessary to be a successful HC, even if he had the capacity to be successful.
Its a rich man’s hobby, but not a career. His interest in the job ebbs and flows depending on other’s skepticism of his ability. In the interim, the men’s basketball program flounders.
Unfortunately, beyond his one-time financial gift, Penny doesn't have a history of being supportive of the program's coaches unless he's running it, which is too bad. He could be a great public ambassador for the program & it's coaches if he'd step aside and let a competent coaching staff take over.
I could be wrong, but I believe it was Penny who sabotaged Tubby. I think Tubby was led to believe the East kids would come to Memphis and he’d have a shot at a last national title run. Instead, he had the overblown fiasco with the Lawson clan and Penny’s routing of ALo to Wichita State. I don’t think Tubby ever wanted to get his hands dirty and risk his future HoF induction on NCAA infractions, so he settled into mediocre players he could recruit on the up & up; but I think promises were initially made to Tubby that ultimately did not materialize. Had Tubby coached the Precious Achuiwa squad, they undoubtedly make the NCAA’s & possibly make a deep run.
(01-12-2026 06:32 PM)2021 Tiger Football!! Wrote:
(01-12-2026 04:51 PM)griffin Wrote:
(01-12-2026 01:16 PM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Absolutely
Penny lost a good bit of his Ambassadors providing NIL 3 or so years ago. One of them was a whale. He still has some but the money will be there once he is gone No one was going to provide NIL funds for a failing business, that was simply waiting for a "gone out of business" sign.
The Bates ordeal pissed some of them off.
Bates was the end for my season tickets. Not only Bates, but Lomax, Jayden & Dandridge getting so much PT caused a lot of transfers. And Penny letting Bates back on the team after he spent the 2nd half of the season in Michigan was IT. That overrated clown playing in the NCAA tournament game was a betrayal to everybody on that team. The End
(This post was last modified: 01-12-2026 09:30 PM by P3PPC.)