RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-11-2026 09:50 PM)axdtigers Wrote:
Well please don't let Goodman help hire a new coach with those 3 names. Two coaches who are no better than what we have and a guy who doesn't even have a full season as head coach? We are way better than that.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 09:37 AM)Titans3775 Wrote:
(01-11-2026 09:50 PM)axdtigers Wrote:
Well please don't let Goodman help hire a new coach with those 3 names. Two coaches who are no better than what we have and a guy who doesn't even have a full season as head coach? We are way better than that.
Not going to give John Martin and Jeff Goodman another click...So what 3 names did those geniuses come up with?
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 09:42 AM)Tiger87 Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:37 AM)Titans3775 Wrote:
(01-11-2026 09:50 PM)axdtigers Wrote:
Well please don't let Goodman help hire a new coach with those 3 names. Two coaches who are no better than what we have and a guy who doesn't even have a full season as head coach? We are way better than that.
Not going to give John Martin and Jeff Goodman another click...So what 3 names did those geniuses come up with?
Three guys who would almost certainly be the 4th failure in a row.
Ryan Miller - A guy who doesn't even have a single season of head coaching experience.
Shaheen Holloway - Who went 7-25 last year and has double digit losses every season of his career.
Tony Skinn - Who has never even sniffed the tournament and has never had a team ranked higher than #73.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 08:53 AM)presskh Wrote:
(01-12-2026 07:56 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Penny has been a head coach now for 8 years… he’s 54 years old.
Either he has the capacity or he doesn’t.
Penny is a good front face for the program and helps with recruiting and fund raising. However, he needs help with developing players and getting them to play as a team.
He doesn’t think he needs help, thus the revolving door of coaches.
The one constant, besides 8 years of underachievement, has been the turmoil on the staff and Penny’s inability to develop a culture. He’s simply not head coach material & it shouldn't have taken this long to figure it out.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 09:51 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:53 AM)presskh Wrote:
(01-12-2026 07:56 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Penny has been a head coach now for 8 years… he’s 54 years old.
Either he has the capacity or he doesn’t.
Penny is a good front face for the program and helps with recruiting and fund raising. However, he needs help with developing players and getting them to play as a team.
He doesn’t think he needs help, thus the revolving door of coaches.
The one constant, besides 8 years of underachievement, has been the turmoil on the staff and Penny’s inability to develop a culture. He’s simply not head coach material & it shouldn't have taken this long to figure it out.
Idk how it can even be argued he is a good front face. We have had negative headline after negative headline his entire tenture.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 08:49 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:28 AM)Atlanta Wrote:
(01-12-2026 07:56 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Penny has been a head coach now for 8 years… he’s 54 years old.
Either he has the capacity or he doesn’t.
Penny's life & lifestyle don't depend on being a successful college MB. coach, so he's simply a caretaker of a program for which he has affection & he will never do the work necessary to be a successful HC, even if he had the capacity to be successful.
Its a rich man’s hobby, but not a career. His interest in the job ebbs and flows depending on other’s skepticism of his ability. In the interim, the men’s basketball program flounders.
Unfortunately, beyond his one-time financial gift, Penny doesn't have a history of being supportive of the program's coaches unless he's running it, which is too bad. He could be a great public ambassador for the program & it's coaches if he'd step aside and let a competent coaching staff take over.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 09:35 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Bill Laurie is a big Penny guy.
Good point. This is a reason why should the university decide to part ways with Penny, it needs to be done in a high-level, professional manner.
Bill was big mad the way Larry was let go...if we were to part ways with Penny in an ugly fashion, we'd likely lose his financial support at the worst possible time.
It's tough for the 64-year-old me to watch our program struggle in this day and age of the NIL / Transfer Portal. I just hope we can find some solutions before things get worse.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 05:17 AM)Keeper Wrote:
(01-11-2026 10:52 PM)Alcalde2 Wrote:
(01-11-2026 08:26 PM)Willie Becton Wrote: I think we will come back stronger than ever in the next game.
I know some folks hate Penny but he could thrive if exposed to an Xs and Os guy.
I sent the athletic department a letter asking them to consider bringing in COACH Josh Pastner as an adjunct to Penny. I think if theyd do that we would see results.
Have faith everyone.
The cavalry is coming.
Penny has had Larry Brown, Frank Haith, Rick Stansbury, Mike Davis among others, and he never listened to any of them. What makes you think he's suddenly going to listen to Josh??
If Penny wants to be a college head coach he should learn it to earn it. Go be an assistant with a great coach and maybe learn how to identify his best players and keep them on the floor together for significant periods of time. If he doesn't want to be a college head coach he should stop wasting our time and destroying the program. He has been indulged long enough. It is truly a shame that he can't even accept his flaws, and has disappointed his fans year after year. He has tarnished his legacy.
As most of you know, Penny led a coup to get his Orlando Magic coach fired. He knew more than Brian Hill who had taken them to the Finals just 2 years before. Penny is not very bright, but he thinks he is a basketball genius.That explains why his staff members abandon ship every year.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Can we do better than losing to FAU by nine in year 8 with 10X the NIL? Yes. The answer is yes.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
This. Living in this conference is absolutely debilitating.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
Tony Skinn is, imo, a pretty decent candidate. I saw George Mason play this weekend on TV, like what I saw. He is a GMU guy and ex-player so he might not be in a big rush to leave. I'm sure Memphis could give him a raise.
I would also look at the coach at St. Louis too.
(This post was last modified: 01-12-2026 10:55 AM by tigerlands.)
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:12 AM)Atlanta Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:49 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote:
(01-12-2026 08:28 AM)Atlanta Wrote:
(01-12-2026 07:56 AM)Marc Mensa Wrote: Penny has been a head coach now for 8 years… he’s 54 years old.
Either he has the capacity or he doesn’t.
Penny's life & lifestyle don't depend on being a successful college MB. coach, so he's simply a caretaker of a program for which he has affection & he will never do the work necessary to be a successful HC, even if he had the capacity to be successful.
Its a rich man’s hobby, but not a career. His interest in the job ebbs and flows depending on other’s skepticism of his ability. In the interim, the men’s basketball program flounders.
Unfortunately, beyond his one-time financial gift, Penny doesn't have a history of being supportive of the program's coaches unless he's running it, which is too bad. He could be a great public ambassador for the program & it's coaches if he'd step aside and let a competent coaching staff take over.
I could be wrong, but I believe it was Penny who sabotaged Tubby. I think Tubby was led to believe the East kids would come to Memphis and he’d have a shot at a last national title run. Instead, he had the overblown fiasco with the Lawson clan and Penny’s routing of ALo to Wichita State. I don’t think Tubby ever wanted to get his hands dirty and risk his future HoF induction on NCAA infractions, so he settled into mediocre players he could recruit on the up & up; but I think promises were initially made to Tubby that ultimately did not materialize. Had Tubby coached the Precious Achuiwa squad, they undoubtedly make the NCAA’s & possibly make a deep run.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
The conf affiliation ain’t changing. Our NIL is great for this league but we won’t be able to compete nationally any longer. Certainly not with Hardaway putting together rosters like this one. But if this is all we could afford, then it’s all we could afford. Our ceiling for this season and going forward is win the AAC tournament and get a 10,11,12 seed or not play in the dance at all. On a good year we might luck up and win a 6/11 or 5/12 game. Too many things stacked against us now.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 11:03 AM)MemTigers1998 Wrote: The conf affiliation ain’t changing. Our NIL is great for this league but we won’t be able to compete nationally any longer. Certainly not with Hardaway putting together rosters like this one. But if this is all we could afford, then it’s all we could afford. Our ceiling for this season and going forward is win the AAC tournament and get a 10,11,12 seed or not play in the dance at all. On a good year we might luck up and win a 6/11 or 5/12 game. Too many things stacked against us now.
Penny was a mediocre coach when he had overwhelming talent. The bottom line is the guy has only 3 NCAA appearances and a single NCAA win in 8 years. Boosters have been pouring money into his rosters, only to see the same frustrating returns every season, so “if this is it”, then what difference does it make?. Might as well be a .500 AAC squad and allocate the money somewhere else.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
The truth is that allocating more $$ to football is just throwing it away too. Silverfield wasted 6 years worth of football support. We could win the next 10 AAC championships, and year 11 we’d still be in the American.
(This post was last modified: 01-12-2026 11:24 AM by MemTigers1998.)
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:51 AM)Titans3775 Wrote:
(01-12-2026 10:34 AM)Claw Wrote: Do any of you REALLY think a different coach can do much better in the current NIL environment?
If Penny is ready to leave, then let him go. Expecting a tidal change is overly optimistic. Even with competitive NIL cash, good players aren't going to come play in this conference. There's a ceiling now that we won't crack.
Things change, but right now we are in a really bad position. Any coach would be failing.
Can we do better than losing to FAU by nine in year 8 with 10X the NIL? Yes. The answer is yes.
Agree. I hear a lot of whining about lack of NIL money. I’d bet we’re at the top of the AAC and still have an awful team. It’s hard to compete with the top P4s, but we should dominate the AAC. Penny can’t keep coaches or players. It’s constant turnover, every year. Seriously, 1 NCAA win? It’s way past time to move on.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
(01-12-2026 10:26 AM)GermantownTiger Wrote:
(01-12-2026 09:35 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Bill Laurie is a big Penny guy.
Good point. This is a reason why should the university decide to part ways with Penny, it needs to be done in a high-level, professional manner.
Bill was big mad the way Larry was let go...if we were to part ways with Penny in an ugly fashion, we'd likely lose his financial support at the worst possible time.
It's tough for the 64-year-old me to watch our program struggle in this day and age of the NIL / Transfer Portal. I just hope we can find some solutions before things get worse.
Which is why it needs to be done during Ed Scott's tenure. Can you imagine Tom Bowen handling this?
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
It would be such a Memphis thing - have a former player worth $5b and piss him off to the point he no longer gives money. On the flip side, I don’t think our big $ folks have the “whatever it takes” desire to see Tiger basketball win big in the same manner that Fertita does at Houston or the former player turned oil tycoon paying millions for Texas Tech football. Saw somewhere that Mark Cuban is now giving a small fortune to Hoosier football. Just no way that Memphis can compete with that.
RE: ***The Official Memphis vs Florida Atlantic Basketball Thread***
dumb*** Goodman compared Penny's tenure to Josh Pastner, but although the overall win percentage numbers are similar, the breakdown on those numbers has been very different
I think Penny has proven he CAN coach, given his in season results against top 25 teams. Josh couldnt beat top teams, but he was able to win most of the games he was supposed to win.
The biggest problem I see with Penny is that he has NO idea how to build a winning culture. He is the exact opposite of a coach like Curt Cignetti... and I know thats football, but my point is that you can see how every little detail is controlled through holding players to a standard of excellence even in the repetition of simple fundamental plays.
Im not sure how much truth is behind it, but Ive heard on here several times that Penny often shows up late to practice? True or not, there has been a massive drop in effort between the difficult out of conference schedule and the weaker league schedule. Evidence seems to point to this being because Penny is the opposite kind of coach of Cignetti... that he is a horrible example on all levels because he gets up to coach the big games harder, then goes lax during the conference season or doesnt show to practice on time. He also has zero ability to contain in house drama. It seeps out every single season. Its a shame because I think Penny has what cant be taught, and fails in the arena of discipline, psychology and culture.