(12-07-2025 10:13 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Switch from five champions to five representatives, problem solved. Or hold selection day before CCGs are played. Or do nothing and assume that conferences will fix their CCG selection criteria to prevent this from happening again on their own. Not only the ACC but the SEC too nearly let stuff get out of hand by not taking their best two teams to go to the CCG. Thats not the CFB playoff selectors' fault, thats the conferences'.
I like having selection day or bid-allocation day prior to CCGs.
The ACC and ND would have each been allocated 1 bid after 12 games and the ACC would be 100% on the hook for whether they allowed Miami to vie for that spot.
If/when we get to multiple AQs and WCGs, handing out bids to conferences in this manner would LESSEN the committees ability to screw teams over. If the ACC was given 2 bids, they (not the committee) would have to decide whether their 2nd bid goes to their highest ranked non-champ or CCG loser.
Tried posting bullet points from Dellenger, but post did not send and was erased.
Everything except B1G supports 16, but signs they may allow 16 as potential stepping stone for 20+ team CFP
16 probably reevaluated after a couple seasons
If 16 teams, it looks like it could be a standard bracket (no byes), probably 5+11
If standard 16, would be discussion and momentum to have 1st AND 2nd round on campus
Tried posting bullet points from Dellenger, but post did not send and was erased.
Everything except B1G supports 16, but signs they may allow 16 as potential stepping stone for 20+ team CFP
16 probably reevaluated after a couple seasons
If 16 teams, it looks like it could be a standard bracket (no byes), probably 5+11
If standard 16, would be discussion and momentum to have 1st AND 2nd round on campus
No byes that is interesting.
They want revenue from those home games apparently.
I can see where they could be more comfortable with 16 until the early 2030's where more major changes to the sport come into play.
Tried posting bullet points from Dellenger, but post did not send and was erased.
Everything except B1G supports 16, but signs they may allow 16 as potential stepping stone for 20+ team CFP
16 probably reevaluated after a couple seasons
If 16 teams, it looks like it could be a standard bracket (no byes), probably 5+11
If standard 16, would be discussion and momentum to have 1st AND 2nd round on campus
No byes that is interesting.
They want revenue from those home games apparently.
I can see where they could be more comfortable with 16 until the early 2030's where more major changes to the sport come into play.
I'm surprised this is being considered and that this isn't getting talked about. Nothing this set in stone, but the potential for a 16 team CFP with no byes and 2 rounds on campus is wild to me. I'm not gonna complain, but I figured the P4 would want standalone games for TV and money. Also if it's 5+11, there likely goes the potential for WCGs while CCGs probably take a hit.
(12-12-2025 12:55 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: I'm surprised this is being considered and that this isn't getting talked about. Nothing this set in stone, but the potential for a 16 team CFP with no byes and 2 rounds on campus is wild to me. I'm not gonna complain, but I figured the P4 would want standalone games for TV and money. Also if it's 5+11, there likely goes the potential for WCGs while CCGs probably take a hit.
If they play everything over three weekends and move Army Navy, CCGs will be converted into play-in games. If you have a 4/4/2/2, 3v6 and 4v5 and so on. 1/2 probably get a bye into the first round for P2s.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 01:09 PM by RUScarlets.)
(12-12-2025 12:55 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: I'm surprised this is being considered and that this isn't getting talked about. Nothing this set in stone, but the potential for a 16 team CFP with no byes and 2 rounds on campus is wild to me. I'm not gonna complain, but I figured the P4 would want standalone games for TV and money. Also if it's 5+11, there likely goes the potential for WCGs while CCGs probably take a hit.
If they play everything over three weekends and move Army Navy, CCGs will be converted into play-in games. If you have a 4/4/2/2, 3v6 and 4v5 and so on. 1/2 probably get a bye into the first round for P2s.
You do get that it's a straight top 16 and not the conference bull****.
(12-12-2025 01:21 PM)stever20 Wrote: You do get that it's a straight top 16 and not the conference bull****.
There are still three weekends in play here, so yeah, there will be some form of play-in games the first weekend. Dellenger has been pretty consistent that the 1st weekend games will be converted to prevent #3 teams in the standings from resting up. So we can agree to disagree.
(12-12-2025 01:21 PM)stever20 Wrote: You do get that it's a straight top 16 and not the conference bull****.
There are still three weekends in play here, so yeah, there will be some form of play-in games the first weekend. Dellenger has been pretty consistent that the 1st weekend games will be converted to prevent #3 teams in the standings from resting up. So we can agree to disagree.
You didn't read what they said. They said a straight 5+11 meaning 5 AQ and 11 at larges. With no byes. That is what's gathering momentum. Not the craptasitc big 10 proposal where Big Ten could get 4 teams in even if they don't deserve it.
Splitting round 1 into two weeks would give Disney a solid 4 game schedule for three weeks in a row. There is money there. And if we down to three bowls I hope they boot the Peach, Cotton and Fiesta and go down to just Rose, Orange and Sugar.
(12-12-2025 02:10 PM)stever20 Wrote: You didn't read what they said. They said a straight 5+11 meaning 5 AQ and 11 at larges. With no byes. That is what's gathering momentum. Not the craptasitc big 10 proposal where Big Ten could get 4 teams in even if they don't deserve it.
I will watch the video later or fast forward to the time stamp, but that format will simply not be passed. The #3 teams in the conference are not going to get a bye CCG weekend, followed by a home campus game (see Ole Miss and UO this year). If you believe that will happen, I have the proverbial bridge to sell you.
They may be giving more clout to seeding by having two campus rounds, but that doesn't jive with anything we've heard prior to this point. So, I don't put much stock into this particular report. I do think Dellenger's sources are setting the table for something else that will look like the pre-24 team, at least for '25-'26. Those will be play-in games for G6 and/or At-Large.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 02:28 PM by RUScarlets.)
(12-12-2025 02:10 PM)stever20 Wrote: You didn't read what they said. They said a straight 5+11 meaning 5 AQ and 11 at larges. With no byes. That is what's gathering momentum. Not the craptasitc big 10 proposal where Big Ten could get 4 teams in even if they don't deserve it.
I will watch the video later or fast forward to the time stamp, but that format will simply not be passed. The #3 teams in the conference are not going to get a bye CCG weekend, followed by a home campus game (see Ole Miss and UO this year). If you believe that will happen, I have the proverbial bridge to sell you.
They may be giving more clout to seeding by having two campus rounds, but that doesn't jive with anything we've heard prior to this point. So, I don't put much stock into this particular report. I do think Dellenger's sources are setting the table for something else that will look like the pre-24 team, at least for '25-'26. Those will be play-in games for G6 and/or At-Large.
That's literally what they're talking about. I know you hate that but whatever. Literally, no one other than Fox and the Big Ten wants what you're wanting.
(12-12-2025 02:22 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Splitting round 1 into two weeks would give Disney a solid 4 game schedule for three weeks in a row. There is money there. And if we down to three bowls I hope they boot the Peach, Cotton and Fiesta and go down to just Rose, Orange and Sugar.
(12-12-2025 02:31 PM)stever20 Wrote: That's literally what they're talking about. I know you hate that but whatever. Literally, no one other than Fox and the Big Ten wants what you're wanting.
Pretty significant I'd say! But yeah, I think you are completely missing the point and you already called me an idiot in past discussions, so yeah, we will just have to wait and see.
(12-12-2025 02:31 PM)stever20 Wrote: That's literally what they're talking about. I know you hate that but whatever. Literally, no one other than Fox and the Big Ten wants what you're wanting.
Pretty significant I'd say! But yeah, I think you are completely missing the point and you already called me an idiot in past discussions, so yeah, we will just have to wait and see.
I get it. You hate the CCG more than anything else.
You just hate that they're talking about a straight 5+11 and you refuse to acknowledge that at all. Instead putting in your feelings about the CCG. I get it. You don't think it's fair. Oh well. Life ain't fair.
(12-12-2025 02:41 PM)stever20 Wrote: I get it. You hate the CCG more than anything else.
You just hate that they're talking about a straight 5+11 and you refuse to acknowledge that at all. Instead putting in your feelings about the CCG. I get it. You don't think it's fair. Oh well. Life ain't fair.
Yes… from a competitive standpoint, it is obsolete. But there are still contracts in place and that takes time to iron out.
Aside from that, why is Dellenger still talking about two campus rounds? Wasn’t that put to bed with the mid January SFs? Maybe I’ll end up being right about that one too, as Bowl season goes into the dumpsters.
(12-12-2025 02:41 PM)stever20 Wrote: I get it. You hate the CCG more than anything else.
You just hate that they're talking about a straight 5+11 and you refuse to acknowledge that at all. Instead putting in your feelings about the CCG. I get it. You don't think it's fair. Oh well. Life ain't fair.
Yes… from a competitive standpoint, it is obsolete. But there are still contracts in place and that takes time to iron out.
Aside from that, why is Dellenger still talking about two campus rounds? Wasn’t that put to bed with the mid January SFs? Maybe I’ll end up being right about that one too, as Bowl season goes into the dumpsters.
they also make the conferences a boatload of money. And get big time TV ratings. See Big Ten last weekend as a prime example.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 02:50 PM by stever20.)
(12-12-2025 02:22 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Splitting round 1 into two weeks would give Disney a solid 4 game schedule for three weeks in a row. There is money there. And if we down to three bowls I hope they boot the Peach, Cotton and Fiesta and go down to just Rose, Orange and Sugar.
That is what makes sense
One thing I could buy is the P2 champs getting a home SF game guaranteed. That jives with two campus rounds and incentivizing a CCG. Three more conf champs AQ.
(This post was last modified: 12-12-2025 03:01 PM by RUScarlets.)
Tried posting bullet points from Dellenger, but post did not send and was erased.
Everything except B1G supports 16, but signs they may allow 16 as potential stepping stone for 20+ team CFP
16 probably reevaluated after a couple seasons
If 16 teams, it looks like it could be a standard bracket (no byes), probably 5+11
If standard 16, would be discussion and momentum to have 1st AND 2nd round on campus
Here is his article (which doesn’t mention about bye)
Should this year’s College Football Playoff selections trigger expansion to the postseason field?
“Absolutely,” the ACC commissioner said Wednesday morning from the Sports Business Journal’s annual college athletics forum at the Aria Casino. “If you're leaving teams out of the playoff that could win a national championship, then you don't have the right number.”
About 24 hours prior to Phillips’ comments, somewhere within a conference room at the nearby Bellagio Casino, three of the power conference commissioners — Phillips, Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark and the SEC’s Greg Sankey — gathered in person, with a fourth joining virtually (Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti), to discuss exactly that: expanding the playoff field.
*******
Phillips now wants a 16 team playoff.
So do Sankey, Yormark, and the ND AD.
It’s really just the Big Ten and Petitti who aren’t on board. I know they want mutli autobids but I also suspect that the B10 is worried the SEC would grab even more at-large bids in an expanded format. The SEC got 5 this year and would’ve had 7 under a 16 team model while the B10 would have only 3.
I personally prefer the 12 team format but we will see…
Tried posting bullet points from Dellenger, but post did not send and was erased.
Everything except B1G supports 16, but signs they may allow 16 as potential stepping stone for 20+ team CFP
16 probably reevaluated after a couple seasons
If 16 teams, it looks like it could be a standard bracket (no byes), probably 5+11
If standard 16, would be discussion and momentum to have 1st AND 2nd round on campus
Here is his article (which doesn’t mention about bye)
Should this year’s College Football Playoff selections trigger expansion to the postseason field?
“Absolutely,” the ACC commissioner said Wednesday morning from the Sports Business Journal’s annual college athletics forum at the Aria Casino. “If you're leaving teams out of the playoff that could win a national championship, then you don't have the right number.”
About 24 hours prior to Phillips’ comments, somewhere within a conference room at the nearby Bellagio Casino, three of the power conference commissioners — Phillips, Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark and the SEC’s Greg Sankey — gathered in person, with a fourth joining virtually (Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti), to discuss exactly that: expanding the playoff field.
*******
Phillips now wants a 16 team playoff.
So do Sankey, Yormark, and the ND AD.
It’s really just the Big Ten and Petitti who aren’t on board. I know they want mutli autobids but I also suspect that the B10 is worried the SEC would grab even more at-large bids in an expanded format. The SEC got 5 this year and would’ve had 7 under a 16 team model while the B10 would have only 3.
I personally prefer the 12 team format but we will see…
If 16 is the number, I really wonder if the compromise could 2/2/2/2/1+7 with 6 WCGs. B1G and SEC host 2 games, ACC and B12 host 1 game. 3rd and 4th place B1G and SEC teams and 3rd place ACC and B12 teams host the next 6 highest ranked at-large teams. Petitti gets his 3 games and the SEC has the opportunity to rack up bids while reaping the same profits the B1G would get hosting 2 WCGs and keeping the CCG. Also worth noting the SEC goes to 9 games next year so 7 teams may not be as obtainable going forward, but we shall see.
For me, I don't think expanding the playoff will help and think adding a 13th regular season game with a requirement for the P4 to play 12 P4 opponents would solve a lot of the issues we're seeing while keeping the CFP at 12 teams or slightly expanding it to 14 teams. The bloated P4 conferences can play 9 or 10 conference games while providing 2 or 3 P4 non-conference games for brands and rivalries, then 1 G6 opponent to maintain the 7th home game. I would also keep CCGs and potentially add WCGs. There would be a 2nd bye as well.