Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 07:15 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 06:54 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I’m not backpedaling at all. He has a poor record playing against winning teams, much like our last coach. Facts. Is it true or not?
I’ve acknowledged some of his accomplishments too.
Overall, an uninspired hire. Our AD mentioned a “splash hire”. This isn’t one.
Again, decent hire, but not great by any means. I expect Silverfield type success. We’ll see if he does better.
None of them have winning records against teams with winning records. This includes Silverfield, Huff, Golesh, and Sumrall. Might as well knock them down a peg because they all breathe oxygen too. Sheesh.
You know who else has never even beaten a single team with a winning record? Hartline. But that's a "wow" hire according to a couple here.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 10:22 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 03:09 PM)k2tigers Wrote: here is today's from Sr. CFB writer for the Athletic - in chronolical order of hire:
(this site is premium so I didn't link article - six of the Top 20 received grades A- and above)
Grading college football's coaching carousel:
- by Chris Vannini
Tulane - Will Hall: B-
Memphis - Charles Huff: A-
"Huff checks off a lot of boxes for Memphis. He's won a conference championship at Marshall in 2024. He's very good at accumulating talent on a roster, as one of the best recruiters in the country at Penn St. and Alabama as an assistant. Memphis has one of the largest roster budgets in the Group of 5, so it should be able to get players, and fans had become frustrated with former coach Ryan Silverfield's inability to take the Tigers to a conference championship game. Huff went from Sun Belt championship Marshall to 1-11 Southern Miss last offseason due to clashes with the Marshall administration. But he brought a lot of those good Marshall players with him and improved Southern Miss to 7-5 and played for a division title on the last week of the season. The upside here is clear, and Memphis wanted upside."
UConn - Jason Candle: B
Penn State - Matt Campbell: A-
Kansas State - Collin Klein: A-
Cal - Tosh Lupoi: B+
James Madison - Billy Napier: B
South Florida - Brian Hartline: B+
North Texas - Neal Brown: B
Kentucky - Will Stein: B+
UCLA - Bob Chesney: B+
Michigan State - Pat Fitzgerald: B-
LSU - Lane Kiffin: A
Ole Miss - Pete Golding: B
Florida - Jon Sumrall: A-
Auburn - Alex Golesh: B+
Arkansas - Ryan Silverfield: B
Colorado State - Jim Mora: B
Oklahoma /state - Eric Morris: B+
Virginia Tech - James Franklin: A-
I guess Vannini doesn't know what he's talking about either. Ignore the curved grades and let's categorize them:
Group 1 (A): Kiffin
Group 2 (A-): Huff, Campbell, Klein, Sumrall, Franklin
Group 3 (B+): Lupoi, Hartline, Stein, Chesney, Golesh, Morris
Group 4 (B): Campbell, Napier, Brown, Golding, Silverfield, Mora
Group 5 (B-): Hall, Fitzgerald
|
|
| 12-09-2025 10:35 PM |
|
dcg141
1st String

Posts: 2,355
Joined: Mar 2009
Reputation: 100
I Root For: Leaving the AAC
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
Anyone have a list of coaches records against teams with winning records? Would be curious to see that.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 10:37 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 10:37 PM)dcg141 Wrote: Anyone have a list of coaches records against teams with winning records? Would be curious to see that.
I've always felt like conference standings is a better metric. Many times - at least at G5's - the "winning record games" are P4's played on the road. However, if you consistently end up at the top of your conference, you're beating many of your "winning record" peers both H/A.
But, no, I don't have a list. I've compiled a few before but it's hard work. Maybe someone can get AI to accurately do it.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 10:42 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 10:37 PM)dcg141 Wrote: Anyone have a list of coaches records against teams with winning records? Would be curious to see that.
Seems people here had a huge problem with Silverfield’s 12-20 record against teams with winning records. They should be insanely happy about Huff’s 7-18 record. But I digress.
Anyway, I think he’s an OK hire. Definitely not a splash hire.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 11:17 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
SI coaching grades
Here's another writer's grades of coaching hires. Summary of relevant coaches and names mentioned by our board experts:
A: Huff, Hartline, Sumrall
A-: Napier, Klein, Golesh
B+: Neal Brown, Stein
B-: Candle, Silverfield
C: Hall
|
|
| 12-11-2025 10:04 AM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-11-2025 10:04 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: SI coaching grades
Here's another writer's grades of coaching hires. Summary of relevant coaches and names mentioned by our board experts:
A: Huff, Hartline, Sumrall
A-: Napier, Klein, Golesh
B+: Neal Brown, Stein
B-: Candle, Silverfield
C: Hall
I'm more in agreement with this list than some others but I'd move the RS hire to the C level. After all, AR is an SEC program & doesn't have the long mediocre history of UK or Vandy FB. And if these programs can win, AR can also. So with their ability to financially support their FB program, they should have been able to support a better hire (at least on paper). Nonetheless, I like RS & hope he kills it at AR, which at this point is a winning record.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 10:15 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
Names not hired and not heard to be interviewing anywhere:
Freeze - Surprised some small school hasn't taken him. No thanks for us.
Shanahan - Definite potential. Makes me think he's not on the market and waiting on Cignetti to retire.
Mack - Surprised an AAC didn't get him. Certain potential. I like Huff better for us.
Mullen - Heard he told Arky no (in addition to us) which is surprising. Must be content in Vegas for now.
Orgeron - Joker. But publicly said he wanted back in.
Briles - Haven't kept up with him, but haven't heard his name. Should be getting some looks.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 11:42 AM |
|
Atlanta
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,620
Joined: Nov 2009
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: Metro Atlanta
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
Mullen might get a shot for a second round at Miss St in another year or two if he's interested.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 07:50 PM |
|
Lord2FLI
Peanut Vendor

Posts: 4,779
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 561
I Root For: The End
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-11-2025 11:42 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: Names not hired and not heard to be interviewing anywhere:
Freeze - Surprised some small school hasn't taken him. No thanks for us.
Shanahan - Definite potential. Makes me think he's not on the market and waiting on Cignetti to retire.
Mack - Surprised an AAC didn't get him. Certain potential. I like Huff better for us.
Mullen - Heard he told Arky no (in addition to us) which is surprising. Must be content in Vegas for now.
Orgeron - Joker. But publicly said he wanted back in.
Briles - Haven't kept up with him, but haven't heard his name. Should be getting some looks.
I feel confident that Shanahan is not available to anyone. There's just no way schools weren't kicking the doors down to talk to him, but I didn't see his name brought up (by the media) anywhere.
|
|
| 12-11-2025 08:44 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 04:28 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,748
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2239
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 04:28 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 04:49 PM |
|
Tiger46
Legend

Posts: 25,038
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 343
I Root For: Tigers
Location: Colleyville, TX
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-11-2025 07:50 PM)Atlanta Wrote: Mullen might get a shot for a second round at Miss St in another year or two if he's interested.
Our two sons graduated from MS State in early 2000's. I hear them talking at Thanksgiving about next year being the year they go out and get someone but I wasn't familiar with the name. They really got behind when Leach died so tragically.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 04:55 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 04:49 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:28 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
Maybe so but from their perspective, which is a mostly skeptical fanbase against him, they are very surprise so far. To hold in-state talent that’s going elsewhere is significant
|
|
| 12-12-2025 04:57 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,748
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2239
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 04:57 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:49 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:28 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
Maybe so but from their perspective, which is a mostly skeptical fanbase against him, they are very surprise so far. To hold in-state talent that’s going elsewhere is significant
I disagree. These kids weren't five stars -- three stars and a couple of very low four stars at best -- and it still netted the bottom of the SEC for recruiting. I guess being a little bet better, but still at the bottom is something to be happy about when there's nothing to really be happy about? At least they didn't pull a Tulane?
|
|
| 12-12-2025 05:06 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 05:06 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:57 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:49 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:28 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
Maybe so but from their perspective, which is a mostly skeptical fanbase against him, they are very surprise so far. To hold in-state talent that’s going elsewhere is significant
I disagree. These kids weren't five stars -- three stars and a couple of very low four stars at best -- and it still netted the bottom of the SEC for recruiting. I guess being a little bet better, but still at the bottom is something to be happy about when there's nothing to really be happy about? At least they didn't pull a Tulane?
Once again, I’m not talking about SEC conference comparisons. Just from their fan base perspective I’m reading right now, which started out negative to skepticism about the guy, they are surprised so far at what they see.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 05:23 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,748
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2239
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 05:23 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 05:06 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:57 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:49 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:28 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: Just reading the recent Hogs message boards and the boards are warming up a little to Sliverfield. Recruiting-wise, people are surprised and kinda impressed he flipped like four or five big in-state kids right outta the gate—including a couple four-stars that were headed elsewhere. That got some “okay, maybe he can recruit Arkansas hard “buzz and quieted a few haters.
GM hire—Gaizka Crowley from Arizona—just dropped yesterday and the boards are loving it. Hogville’s calling it a straight-up splash, like this is the wow hire we were promised vibes. Fans are pumped ‘cause he helped flip Arizona from four-and-eight to nine-and-three with killer portal and recruiting work. Insiders are saying he’s a rising star, and it’s got people way more excited than the on-field staff stuff so far.
They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
Maybe so but from their perspective, which is a mostly skeptical fanbase against him, they are very surprise so far. To hold in-state talent that’s going elsewhere is significant
I disagree. These kids weren't five stars -- three stars and a couple of very low four stars at best -- and it still netted the bottom of the SEC for recruiting. I guess being a little bet better, but still at the bottom is something to be happy about when there's nothing to really be happy about? At least they didn't pull a Tulane?
Once again, I’m not talking about SEC conference comparisons. Just from their fan base perspective I’m reading right now, which started out negative to skepticism about the guy, they are surprised so far at what they see.
I never disputed that. I simply disagree with the rationale behind the newfound enthusiasm among their fans. From what I've seen, Arkansas initiated a broad and systematic effort to swing the momentum with a comprehensive media campaign to push the narrative that they wanted through their network of media contacts and fan podcasts. Clearly it worked, but that won't change the reality.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 05:39 PM |
|
k2tigers
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,343
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 993
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 05:39 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 05:23 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 05:06 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:57 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-12-2025 04:49 PM)msu35 Wrote: They're excited about being virtually last place in SEC recruiting even though Silverfield was recruiting for Arkansas weeks before they announced the hire? A GM might help, but the GM isn't making in-game decisions and doing the game planning. How did Silverfield perform with top resources, top recruiting credibility, and a very supportive administration relative to his peers in the American? Was he beating the teams he needed to or did he average 6th place in the conference over his career?
They're competing with sharks in the SEC -- this ain't the G6 anymore.
Maybe so but from their perspective, which is a mostly skeptical fanbase against him, they are very surprise so far. To hold in-state talent that’s going elsewhere is significant
I disagree. These kids weren't five stars -- three stars and a couple of very low four stars at best -- and it still netted the bottom of the SEC for recruiting. I guess being a little bet better, but still at the bottom is something to be happy about when there's nothing to really be happy about? At least they didn't pull a Tulane?
Once again, I’m not talking about SEC conference comparisons. Just from their fan base perspective I’m reading right now, which started out negative to skepticism about the guy, they are surprised so far at what they see.
I never disputed that. I simply disagree with the rationale behind the newfound enthusiasm among their fans. From what I've seen, Arkansas initiated a broad and systematic effort to swing the momentum with a comprehensive media campaign to push the narrative that they wanted through their network of media contacts and fan podcasts. Clearly it worked, but that won't change the reality.
That's exactly what happened. And Silverfield wasn't the reason those players from Bryant flipped.
|
|
| 12-12-2025 05:54 PM |
|
Keeper
Heisman

Posts: 5,237
Joined: Aug 2017
Reputation: 277
I Root For: Memphis
Location: memphis
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
I believe CRS will do well at Arkansas given their limitations and the level of competition. He will win some big ones and lose some head scratchers, but overall he will have some successful bowl seasons and may even compete for a division title occasionally. Not many SEC teams do that. At least I wish him that success.
Our Head Coach is Charles Huff, I wish him great success and championship seasons. Go Tigers Go
(This post was last modified: 12-15-2025 01:05 PM by Keeper.)
|
|
| 12-12-2025 08:01 PM |
|
EarthBoundMisfit
Tongue tied and twisted

Posts: 18,713
Joined: May 2005
Reputation: 1548
I Root For: CardiacAblation
Location: Madisonville,KY
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-12-2025 08:01 PM)Keeper Wrote: I believe CRS will do well at Arkansas given their limitations and the level of competition. He will win some big ones and lose some head scratchers, but overall he will has some successful bowl seasons and may even compete for a division title occasionally. Not many SEC teams do that. At least I wish him that success.
Our Head Coach is Charles Huff, I wish him great success and championship seasons. Go Tigers Go
respectfully...
I'll take Things that will never happen ever for $800 Alex.
|
|
| 12-14-2025 10:33 AM |
|