https://www.reddit.com/r/ACC/comments/1p...t/ntbctlj/
Full disclosure, I authored it, so of course I approve. I'll address the most common complaints and the finer nuances that was ignored or went unnoticed:
1) Tulane - the complaints are that they will go back to sucking in football, their other sports suck, they don't have many fans. So let me address these things, these are all legit concerns which the caveat in joining as noted with a "*" was that they would need to make significant investments to their athletic program. If they are willing to do that, I think they would be a worthwhile long term project. Not to mention it's a good sports city and have a fertile recruiting ground.
2) UConn - UConn fans have added their comments and I appreciate the feedback. The most common negative feedback is that they are not leaving the Big East unless they get full football membership. The fact of the matter is that they tried to get into the B12 with a non-football membership, but did not get the votes. The ACC is a much better fit and would likely make more money as a non-football member.
3) Would it make money? - It should as long as ESPN honors the last owed pro-rata. The ACCN could also be monetized in the most populated part of Louisiana and probably get the entire state of Connecticut. The CW will also likely renew with the ACC (2027) and would be looking for more content.
4) Will people watch? - it does not matter as much as it used to, if they have low ratings, the "brand fund" pays accordingly. People will of course watch UConn basketball and they will have a multiplier effect when they play SU, UL, Duke and UNC.
5) Notre Dame - ND wants to play an average of 5 ACC games every year, fine. Give UConn an annual game as a fellow Indy and non-football ACC member and we'll call it good.
6) Football divisions - helps to keep rivalries from being broken up, gives us more games fans want and less of the games we don't, cuts down on overall travel and gives 3 teams (in this model) a chance for playoff glory.
7) Basketball divisions - again, for many of the same reasons as football divisions.
8) 2 Basketball tournaments - improves game quality with more evenly matched teams and does not cram as many games in 1 venue.
9) FSU, UNC, Clemson - would these proposed changes keep them around longer? If more money is coming in, then that helps. If we have more games that the fans want to see, then that helps. Tulane is a school FSU fans kind of likes and they definitely like New Orleans.