CSNbbs
Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn (/thread-1021818.html)

Pages: 1 2


Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Garrettabc - 12-10-2025 06:45 PM

https://www.reddit.com/r/ACC/comments/1pj3ebp/comment/ntbctlj/


Full disclosure, I authored it, so of course I approve. I'll address the most common complaints and the finer nuances that was ignored or went unnoticed:

1) Tulane - the complaints are that they will go back to sucking in football, their other sports suck, they don't have many fans. So let me address these things, these are all legit concerns which the caveat in joining as noted with a "*" was that they would need to make significant investments to their athletic program. If they are willing to do that, I think they would be a worthwhile long term project. Not to mention it's a good sports city and have a fertile recruiting ground.

2) UConn - UConn fans have added their comments and I appreciate the feedback. The most common negative feedback is that they are not leaving the Big East unless they get full football membership. The fact of the matter is that they tried to get into the B12 with a non-football membership, but did not get the votes. The ACC is a much better fit and would likely make more money as a non-football member.

3) Would it make money? - It should as long as ESPN honors the last owed pro-rata. The ACCN could also be monetized in the most populated part of Louisiana and probably get the entire state of Connecticut. The CW will also likely renew with the ACC (2027) and would be looking for more content.

4) Will people watch? - it does not matter as much as it used to, if they have low ratings, the "brand fund" pays accordingly. People will of course watch UConn basketball and they will have a multiplier effect when they play SU, UL, Duke and UNC.

5) Notre Dame - ND wants to play an average of 5 ACC games every year, fine. Give UConn an annual game as a fellow Indy and non-football ACC member and we'll call it good.

6) Football divisions - helps to keep rivalries from being broken up, gives us more games fans want and less of the games we don't, cuts down on overall travel and gives 3 teams (in this model) a chance for playoff glory.

7) Basketball divisions - again, for many of the same reasons as football divisions.

8) 2 Basketball tournaments - improves game quality with more evenly matched teams and does not cram as many games in 1 venue.

9) FSU, UNC, Clemson - would these proposed changes keep them around longer? If more money is coming in, then that helps. If we have more games that the fans want to see, then that helps. Tulane is a school FSU fans kind of likes and they definitely like New Orleans.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - bryanw1995 - 12-10-2025 06:50 PM

I don't like idea of the ACC adding any g5 programs today, but I went through that reddit thread and upvoted all your posts at least! You can never have enough upvotes on a reddit post, never know when you'll get swamped with a bunch of downvotes due to a perceived slight from an unrelated thread 3 years ago.

COGS


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - The Beaver - 12-10-2025 06:55 PM

Tulane is not additive. You're paying them a 1/18th football share to do what, exactly? At that point you might as well take UConn all sports and only have one extra mouth to feed. Husky football has more fans than Tulane anyway.

But no, even that isn't really advisable at this time since UConn isn't additive either and can be added as replacement whenever neccessary.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Garrettabc - 12-10-2025 07:09 PM

(12-10-2025 06:55 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Tulane is not additive. You're paying them a 1/18th football share to do what, exactly? At that point you might as well take UConn all sports and only have one extra mouth to feed. Husky football has more fans than Tulane anyway.

But no, even that isn't really advisable at this time since UConn isn't additive either and can be added as replacement whenever neccessary.

The ACC is about to have an odd scheduling situation where 16 teams will play 9 conference games and 1 team will play 8 conference games, an 18th team fixes that. The ACC is owed a pro-rata, so any team would technically work, then it's a matter of figuring out the best scheduling model. This whole idea is set up on 18 football and 20 basketball.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Gitanole - 12-10-2025 07:30 PM

(12-10-2025 07:09 PM)Garrettabc Wrote:  
(12-10-2025 06:55 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Tulane is not additive. You're paying them a 1/18th football share to do what, exactly? At that point you might as well take UConn all sports and only have one extra mouth to feed. Husky football has more fans than Tulane anyway.

But no, even that isn't really advisable at this time since UConn isn't additive either and can be added as replacement whenever necessary.

The ACC is about to have an odd scheduling situation where 16 teams will play 9 conference games and 1 team will play 8 conference games, an 18th team fixes that. The ACC is owed a pro-rata, so any team would technically work, then it's a matter of figuring out the best scheduling model. This whole idea is set up on 18 football and 20 basketball.

Burning your last pro rata on a G# is not the play in the ACC’s current situation. The conference hardly needs to dilute its football SoS metrics. And there is no rush to do so when B12 schools could become available around 2031 anyway.

No conference needs to expand just to effect a schedule workaround from having an odd number of teams. That oddity has already been patched in the ACC to the satisfaction of current members.

If P2 leagues again call up new members from the M2, it makes sense then for M2 leagues to consider backfilling with G# schools. The ACC no doubt keeps these two schools on speed dial, among others, just in case.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - CardFan1 - 12-10-2025 07:51 PM

There are only 3 P5 schools that make sense for ACC 16th team in order for competitive Sports
1 Memphis
2 USF
3 UConn
I can’t see Tulane for any ACC consideration. They haven’t done anything to make their program grow since the old Metro, CUSA days even Southern Miss would be a better option.
The best options likely won’t happen and bringing in the 3 we should have offered when the Big 12 was in trouble WVU, Cincinnati, UCF but that ship already sailed.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Gitanole - 12-10-2025 08:02 PM

(12-10-2025 07:51 PM)CardFan1 Wrote:  There are only 3 P5 schools that make sense for ACC 16th team in order for competitive Sports
1 Memphis
2 USF
3 UConn
I can’t see Tulane for any ACC consideration. They haven’t done anything to make their program grow since the old Metro, CUSA days even Southern Miss would be a better option.
The best options likely won’t happen and bringing in the 3 we should have offered when the Big 12 was in trouble WVU, Cincinnati, UCF but that ship already sailed.

You mean G5, I think.

Who the ACC wants will depend on who moves and what the plan is regarding future conference identity.

What would an nACC be? It depends in large part on who is around to do the asking. The league could build turf out west. It could throw up its hands on gridiron and be a hoops conference. It could re-emphasise football. It could play up academic choosiness or play it more egalitarian. It could see itself as a sports haven for private schools.

There are many ways that path could go, depending on needs and opportunities.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Garrettabc - 12-10-2025 08:13 PM

(12-10-2025 07:51 PM)CardFan1 Wrote:  There are only 3 P5 schools that make sense for ACC 16th team in order for competitive Sports
1 Memphis
2 USF
3 UConn
I can’t see Tulane for any ACC consideration. They haven’t done anything to make their program grow since the old Metro, CUSA days even Southern Miss would be a better option.
The best options likely won’t happen and bringing in the 3 we should have offered when the Big 12 was in trouble WVU, Cincinnati, UCF but that ship already sailed.

My first choice in all of this would be having Tulane or USF as a football only member which will bring the ACC to 18 in football and basketball assuming things blow over with Notre Dame and keep the proposed football division, I just think you'd have to shuffle the divisions around if UConn or Memphis was added and you'd make less people happy for various reasons. Tulane football seems to be the acceptable compromise and does not step on FSU's toes like USF would do.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - TrojanCampaign - 12-10-2025 09:56 PM

(12-10-2025 06:55 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Tulane is not additive. You're paying them a 1/18th football share to do what, exactly? At that point you might as well take UConn all sports and only have one extra mouth to feed. Husky football has more fans than Tulane anyway.

But no, even that isn't really advisable at this time since UConn isn't additive either and can be added as replacement whenever neccessary.

Lol, we rarely agree on much but I think all these people advocating for Tulane are silly. I have said this multiple times.

When Tulane starts losing to Boston College and Wake Forest in football. What do they bring to ACC athletics?

1. New Orleans? Nope, that's LSU.
2. Good basketball? Nope.
3. Large fan base? Nope
4. Good facilities? Nope.

I'm not attacking the ACC but even with Clemson and others. Their status as a power is being propped up by politics. Losing teams then adding bad G5 programs is laughable. This isn't Utah or BYU with a national brand.

Tulane is a good AC program.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - bullet - 12-10-2025 09:59 PM

UConn gives the ACC an even number in football and is a big addition in men's and women's basketball.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - DFW HOYA - 12-10-2025 10:06 PM

(12-10-2025 09:59 PM)bullet Wrote:  UConn gives the ACC an even number in football and is a big addition in men's and women's basketball.

Until....Geno retires.
Until...Dan Hurley goes off to the NBA to relieve the stress.

Then it's the UConn of 2017 and 2018.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Gitanole - 12-10-2025 10:12 PM

(12-10-2025 09:59 PM)bullet Wrote:  UConn gives the ACC an even number in football and is a big addition in men's and women's basketball.

This is why the Huskies are no doubt one of the programs on the ACC’s future backfill list.

For now, all Connecticut adds in football is an even number. Any gridiron team can. And even numbers are not a top priority for a conference that already has its 9-game scheduling worked out.

The ACC has one pro rata spot remaining. The conference membership is unlikely to burn that bid now on a G# program. Still, some ambitious programs are getting a look. It’s a good bet that in time the ACC’s needs will change, and the conference members doing the voting will be different.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - quo vadis - 12-10-2025 10:15 PM

IMO, Tulane and USF would be the best ACC backfills


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - Scoochpooch1 - 12-11-2025 08:53 AM

(12-10-2025 09:56 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  
(12-10-2025 06:55 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  Tulane is not additive. You're paying them a 1/18th football share to do what, exactly? At that point you might as well take UConn all sports and only have one extra mouth to feed. Husky football has more fans than Tulane anyway.

But no, even that isn't really advisable at this time since UConn isn't additive either and can be added as replacement whenever neccessary.

Lol, we rarely agree on much but I think all these people advocating for Tulane are silly. I have said this multiple times.

When Tulane starts losing to Boston College and Wake Forest in football. What do they bring to ACC athletics?

1. New Orleans? Nope, that's LSU.
2. Good basketball? Nope.
3. Large fan base? Nope
4. Good facilities? Nope.

I'm not attacking the ACC but even with Clemson and others. Their status as a power is being propped up by politics. Losing teams then adding bad G5 programs is laughable. This isn't Utah or BYU with a national brand.

Tulane is a good AC program.

Can Tulane purchase LSU via a hostile takeover?


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - NJ2MDTerp - 12-11-2025 10:35 AM

UConn and USF. The former is an ideal replacement for UNC, if the Tarheels choose to leave the ACC. They're both basketball schools with ordinary football. The ACC still remains in the NC market but gains viewers in the northeast that BC can't attract. Also, it appears UConn has a well run athletic department, and the school's administration wants UConn athetics to be successful.

USF should replace FSU. Just by looking at who the school has hired, whether current or in the past, tells me the school wants to win in football. A new stadium is in the works. AAU status. Central FL location.

I'm surprised the ACC doesn't have a 3-4 OOC game arrangement with these two schools to get them ready for anticipated departures.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - ballantyneapp - 12-11-2025 10:41 AM

Tulane might make the cut for a depleted ACC, but they are not a candidate for proactive addition.

As mentioned they aren't anywhere near additive for the TV contract, nor do they ahve the financial backing to forgo conference payouts. They are simply on the sidelines


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - DFW HOYA - 12-11-2025 11:19 AM

To be fair, the "perfect" ACC was the original lineup:

Clemson
Duke
Maryland
North Carolina State
North Carolina
South Carolina
Virginia
Wake Forest


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - CliftonAve - 12-11-2025 11:21 AM

Garrett is the most obvious UConn fan posing as a fan of another school in board history.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - HartfordHusky - 12-11-2025 11:25 AM

(12-11-2025 11:21 AM)CliftonAve Wrote:  Garrett is the most obvious UConn fan posing as a fan of another school in board history.

Nobody suggesting a UConn non-football membership in the ACC is a UConn fan.


RE: Reddit: Perfect ACC with Tulane and UConn - tf8693 - 12-11-2025 11:41 AM

(12-10-2025 06:45 PM)Garrettabc Wrote:  https://www.reddit.com/r/ACC/comments/1pj3ebp/comment/ntbctlj/


Full disclosure, I authored it, so of course I approve. I'll address the most common complaints and the finer nuances that was ignored or went unnoticed:

1) Tulane - the complaints are that they will go back to sucking in football, their other sports suck, they don't have many fans. So let me address these things, these are all legit concerns which the caveat in joining as noted with a "*" was that they would need to make significant investments to their athletic program. If they are willing to do that, I think they would be a worthwhile long term project. Not to mention it's a good sports city and have a fertile recruiting ground.

2) UConn - UConn fans have added their comments and I appreciate the feedback. The most common negative feedback is that they are not leaving the Big East unless they get full football membership. The fact of the matter is that they tried to get into the B12 with a non-football membership, but did not get the votes. The ACC is a much better fit and would likely make more money as a non-football member.

3) Would it make money? - It should as long as ESPN honors the last owed pro-rata. The ACCN could also be monetized in the most populated part of Louisiana and probably get the entire state of Connecticut. The CW will also likely renew with the ACC (2027) and would be looking for more content.

4) Will people watch? - it does not matter as much as it used to, if they have low ratings, the "brand fund" pays accordingly. People will of course watch UConn basketball and they will have a multiplier effect when they play SU, UL, Duke and UNC.

5) Notre Dame - ND wants to play an average of 5 ACC games every year, fine. Give UConn an annual game as a fellow Indy and non-football ACC member and we'll call it good.

6) Football divisions - helps to keep rivalries from being broken up, gives us more games fans want and less of the games we don't, cuts down on overall travel and gives 3 teams (in this model) a chance for playoff glory.

7) Basketball divisions - again, for many of the same reasons as football divisions.

8) 2 Basketball tournaments - improves game quality with more evenly matched teams and does not cram as many games in 1 venue.

9) FSU, UNC, Clemson - would these proposed changes keep them around longer? If more money is coming in, then that helps. If we have more games that the fans want to see, then that helps. Tulane is a school FSU fans kind of likes and they definitely like New Orleans.

A few comments:

1. ND doesn't want six ACC opponents. It doesn't even want five. You guys make noise about wanting ND to stick around, then go completely tone deaf as to what it will take to make that happen (if it even can happen at this point).

2. I'm not sure how your basketball schedule works beyond the double round-robin in each division. I suppose you could do an 18-game schedule with each division skipping one other division every year on a rotating basis. That might be the cleanest way to do it. But in that event, every team has five conference opponents that they don't see every year.