Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Playoff change still possible
Author Message
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #121
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 05:36 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 04:58 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 04:41 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 02:38 PM)JRsec Wrote:  I'm hardly stuck in the past. I've seen the future as clearly or better than most on this forum. But I also know what is true in the conference. Ultimately the fans will determine what is successful, after all they are the customer base whether they are in the stadia across the conference on Saturdays or watching the set at home. Either way they are the consumers. Donors and fans will eventually make their feelings known by either supporting the changes or fading away from them.

At 20 schools everyone can play everyone else every 3 years with 9 conference games still as the benchmark. That's plenty of mix for 4 divisions designed to handle regional rivals that you would play every year. It preserves both. This no divisional play crap is a construct of the networks and it has permitted within the Big 10 Indiana to advance without having to play Michigan or Ohio State until the finals.

The division-less format doesn't help the SEC have more marketable games, it handicaps its long-played rivalries. Texas I'm sure would like to have a set number of key regional games on every year's schedule while playing everyone else every 3 years. The home and home would change on the turn every three years.

Expanding the playoffs with at large berths and going division-less profits the networks more than the conferences or schools and doesn't appeal to fans raised on regional rivalries.

Time will prove me right about this. The core value of college football fandom is regional. It's okay to branch out on difficulty of schedule, but nobody benefits from leaving the roots that grew them.
I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.

With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.

That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.

The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.

What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.

Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.

The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.

I'm not trying to agitate you. You are just getting agitated! I just don't think you are right on some of these things and so am disagreeing. Its a message board. You are convinced 100% you are right and take any debate as a personal attack.

Even if its someone like you or Frank who I both respect, if I think you are making incongruent arguments, I will point it out.

I didn't think the pay for play would go this far and I don't like it, but I have accepted it. The presidents still haven't accepted that athletes being employees is inevitable without Congressional action, but its obvious its coming. And divisions aren't coming back.

Your last statement is true. The sooner we move to an employee relationship the sooner we can clean up the portal. The schools should be compensated when someone takes one of their players in the portal. IOW, the raiding party needs to pay a buyout. With a contract you can do that.

I do think I'm right, and I expect some disagreements and/or argumentation, just not accusation. Disagree with my argument and it is discussion. Attack my motives and it becomes personal. I prefer things as they were with the BCS. I could live with the 4 school CFP. The arguments now are needless. Take the top 4 schools and play it off. Usually, one of those didn't belong and most years there were only 3 with a real shot at winning it all, sometimes just 2. Now all the hogwash is over the 11th and 12th team in. Take it to 16 and they'll be fussing over #17. Wasted breath and wasted time is all that is.

If the ACC and Big 12 survive the next consolidation and rebuild, I'd be in great favor of each holding their own playoff for champion and those 4 schools would advance and be seeded and play it off. To hell with a committee! Let each conference make what it can from its own championship format and let the Networks manage the final 4. Then the SEC and Big Ten could do what is best for each of them as the formats that benefit the one do not suit the other.

Some writer made the argument the other day that the portal has meant more teams have a chance to win so the playoff should get bigger. It is true that Ohio St., Alabama and Georgia can't stockpile players and depth and that a lot of their 2nd stringers are starting elsewhere.

Ohio St. hasn't really been tested except by Texas. If Ohio St. isn't as good as we think, there are a lot of teams who could win this year. If Ohio St. is that good, well then maybe IU, Georgia and Texas Tech are the only ones who are good enough to knock off Ohio St.
12-02-2025 08:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #122
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 08:03 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:36 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 04:58 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 04:41 PM)bullet Wrote:  I just find it odd that you say the networks decide everything, but on this one topic, the networks are powerless and the fans (who have been ignored by ADs for most of the last 25 years) are suddenly all powerful.

With 16 teams you get 3 rivalries every year. That's plenty. With 24, you can still get two every year while playing everyone else every 3 years.

That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.

The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.

What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.

Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.

The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.

I'm not trying to agitate you. You are just getting agitated! I just don't think you are right on some of these things and so am disagreeing. Its a message board. You are convinced 100% you are right and take any debate as a personal attack.

Even if its someone like you or Frank who I both respect, if I think you are making incongruent arguments, I will point it out.

I didn't think the pay for play would go this far and I don't like it, but I have accepted it. The presidents still haven't accepted that athletes being employees is inevitable without Congressional action, but its obvious its coming. And divisions aren't coming back.

Your last statement is true. The sooner we move to an employee relationship the sooner we can clean up the portal. The schools should be compensated when someone takes one of their players in the portal. IOW, the raiding party needs to pay a buyout. With a contract you can do that.

I do think I'm right, and I expect some disagreements and/or argumentation, just not accusation. Disagree with my argument and it is discussion. Attack my motives and it becomes personal. I prefer things as they were with the BCS. I could live with the 4 school CFP. The arguments now are needless. Take the top 4 schools and play it off. Usually, one of those didn't belong and most years there were only 3 with a real shot at winning it all, sometimes just 2. Now all the hogwash is over the 11th and 12th team in. Take it to 16 and they'll be fussing over #17. Wasted breath and wasted time is all that is.

If the ACC and Big 12 survive the next consolidation and rebuild, I'd be in great favor of each holding their own playoff for champion and those 4 schools would advance and be seeded and play it off. To hell with a committee! Let each conference make what it can from its own championship format and let the Networks manage the final 4. Then the SEC and Big Ten could do what is best for each of them as the formats that benefit the one do not suit the other.

Some writer made the argument the other day that the portal has meant more teams have a chance to win so the playoff should get bigger. It is true that Ohio St., Alabama and Georgia can't stockpile players and depth and that a lot of their 2nd stringers are starting elsewhere.

Ohio St. hasn't really been tested except by Texas. If Ohio St. isn't as good as we think, there are a lot of teams who could win this year. If Ohio St. is that good, well then maybe IU, Georgia and Texas Tech are the only ones who are good enough to knock off Ohio St.

Hard to know yet, but I think Indiana could pose some match up issues for the Buckeyes. Their passing game is pretty strong. It will be determined by OSU's pass rush and Indiana's pass blocking. Explosive plays are more of threat to Ohio State than ground and pound which they match up with very well. You will remember that until Arch found his rhythm the ability to keep Texas under 20 was fairly easy to do. When Arch found his rhyhm throwing the ball scoring took off.

As to the portal here's the thing nobody is admitting yet. Yes, players will be freer to move around, but the concentration of wealth has not changed. The top players will be bought by the deepest pockets. So, the concentration of talent at the top levels will only enhance. Depth will be a problem for everyone as everyone's 2nd string will look for playing time. I suspect this will be addressed with the return of platoon play. Think of it as a certain number of minutes of rest for the starters while other top players take the field, sort of like subs in a basketball game. If they don't do something like this, injuries during the season will not see a player of similar strength and ability taking his place.
12-02-2025 08:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #123
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 08:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 08:03 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:36 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 05:11 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 04:58 PM)JRsec Wrote:  That's because that's not what I said. The networks may very well get their way, but in the end if they disrupt what it is that fans respond to, the NET result will be less viewership and less interest.

The same is true about the way of life is some states. People may not have the say so, but they ultimately vote with their feet when they leave it.

What you have been lately is someone who is trying to agitate me. You attacked a post in another forum on an erroneous assumption. You call my views antiquated, but they are just true. When it comes to the playoffs the conferences need to be careful. Right now they own their CCGs and the SEC's pays out more than 70 million a year for the single event. Do we really want to abandon that control and that iconic game to get less overall from the network directed CFP? I don't think so. The games that matter most to the fans drive the popularity of the SEC, not one season's experiment in allowing the networks to set up super games. Did that profit the SEC or the network? They earned more and we got the same pay and 5 million more for that 9th game next year.

Is losing Georgia/Auburn as an annual worth 5 million? No way it is. Donations to get those away tickets brought the university more revenue than that. ESPN is directing things which will profit them. Those things which we control that actually help us help ourselves are the things we need to hold onto regardless of what they offer. Sankey is a commissioner not native to the region but who under Slive got very familiar with it. Still he's a former corporate contract lawyer for sports. Who are the presidents? People hired mostly from elsewhere to run the universities. They are professional academicians. They are not Athletic Directors, or Trustees.

The network is getting its way on most of this, I ackonwledge that. But in the end the people will vote with their feet and pocketbook over changes they do not like. Remember NASCAR. Violate what the people love as local traditions and they will abandon it. Two things can be true at once. The networks are in control. If the SEC doesn't stand up for what is important to an extremely loyal fan base, then these decisions could result in consequences the current leadership are too alien to see.

I'm not trying to agitate you. You are just getting agitated! I just don't think you are right on some of these things and so am disagreeing. Its a message board. You are convinced 100% you are right and take any debate as a personal attack.

Even if its someone like you or Frank who I both respect, if I think you are making incongruent arguments, I will point it out.

I didn't think the pay for play would go this far and I don't like it, but I have accepted it. The presidents still haven't accepted that athletes being employees is inevitable without Congressional action, but its obvious its coming. And divisions aren't coming back.

Your last statement is true. The sooner we move to an employee relationship the sooner we can clean up the portal. The schools should be compensated when someone takes one of their players in the portal. IOW, the raiding party needs to pay a buyout. With a contract you can do that.

I do think I'm right, and I expect some disagreements and/or argumentation, just not accusation. Disagree with my argument and it is discussion. Attack my motives and it becomes personal. I prefer things as they were with the BCS. I could live with the 4 school CFP. The arguments now are needless. Take the top 4 schools and play it off. Usually, one of those didn't belong and most years there were only 3 with a real shot at winning it all, sometimes just 2. Now all the hogwash is over the 11th and 12th team in. Take it to 16 and they'll be fussing over #17. Wasted breath and wasted time is all that is.

If the ACC and Big 12 survive the next consolidation and rebuild, I'd be in great favor of each holding their own playoff for champion and those 4 schools would advance and be seeded and play it off. To hell with a committee! Let each conference make what it can from its own championship format and let the Networks manage the final 4. Then the SEC and Big Ten could do what is best for each of them as the formats that benefit the one do not suit the other.

Some writer made the argument the other day that the portal has meant more teams have a chance to win so the playoff should get bigger. It is true that Ohio St., Alabama and Georgia can't stockpile players and depth and that a lot of their 2nd stringers are starting elsewhere.

Ohio St. hasn't really been tested except by Texas. If Ohio St. isn't as good as we think, there are a lot of teams who could win this year. If Ohio St. is that good, well then maybe IU, Georgia and Texas Tech are the only ones who are good enough to knock off Ohio St.

Hard to know yet, but I think Indiana could pose some match up issues for the Buckeyes. Their passing game is pretty strong. It will be determined by OSU's pass rush and Indiana's pass blocking. Explosive plays are more of threat to Ohio State than ground and pound which they match up with very well. You will remember that until Arch found his rhythm the ability to keep Texas under 20 was fairly easy to do. When Arch found his rhyhm throwing the ball scoring took off.

As to the portal here's the thing nobody is admitting yet. Yes, players will be freer to move around, but the concentration of wealth has not changed. The top players will be bought by the deepest pockets. So, the concentration of talent at the top levels will only enhance. Depth will be a problem for everyone as everyone's 2nd string will look for playing time. I suspect this will be addressed with the return of platoon play. Think of it as a certain number of minutes of rest for the starters while other top players take the field, sort of like subs in a basketball game. If they don't do something like this, injuries during the season will not see a player of similar strength and ability taking his place.

Ah, but therein lies the issue! Depth is critical. They can keep starters fresh and rebound from losses of starters. There will be injuries.
12-02-2025 08:43 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Alduflux Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 29
Joined: May 2024
Reputation: 4
I Root For: Indiana
Location:
Post: #124
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 03:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  ... they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.

Could strength-based divisions using promotion/relegation lead to more "big brand" matchups? For instance, the B1G would have an A and a B division with previous year's results dictating which teams are in which division.

Eight division games, one cross-division game. Conference championship would be the A champ vs an undefeated B champ, or the highest ranked team if the B champ isn't undefeated.
12-02-2025 10:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #125
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 10:11 PM)Alduflux Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 03:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  ... they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.

Could strength-based divisions using promotion/relegation lead to more "big brand" matchups? For instance, the B1G would have an A and a B division with previous year's results dictating which teams are in which division.

Eight division games, one cross-division game. Conference championship would be the A champ vs an undefeated B champ, or the highest ranked team if the B champ isn't undefeated.

MLB Commish floated this a few years back, putting high-spending teams in the same division to get more frequent big games. The Networks somewhat do this by repositioning brands between different conferences.

Another model is the NFL. They have last year’s division winners all play each other this year. The SEC could mimic how the NFL does its conference schedules (sans divisional home-and-home) and get much the same effect.
12-02-2025 10:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #126
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-02-2025 10:29 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 10:11 PM)Alduflux Wrote:  
(12-02-2025 03:08 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  ... they all agree on one thing: we need *more* big brand matchups. That’s not an SEC or Big Ten issue, but rather how the coldly rational people with financial interests see the sport.

Could strength-based divisions using promotion/relegation lead to more "big brand" matchups? For instance, the B1G would have an A and a B division with previous year's results dictating which teams are in which division.

Eight division games, one cross-division game. Conference championship would be the A champ vs an undefeated B champ, or the highest ranked team if the B champ isn't undefeated.

MLB Commish floated this a few years back, putting high-spending teams in the same division to get more frequent big games. The Networks somewhat do this by repositioning brands between different conferences.

Another model is the NFL. They have last year’s division winners all play each other this year. The SEC could mimic how the NFL does its conference schedules (sans divisional home-and-home) and get much the same effect.

Say you had a 9 game schedule. You do a 5 year rotation and 1 of the 9 games each year is a place game, ie prior year 1 plays prior year 2, prior year 3 plays prior year 4, prior year 5 plays prior year 6, etc. with minor modifications if those schools are already playing and you need to rotate home/away (the teams playing away in year 1 would need to be home in year 2).
12-02-2025 10:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #127
RE: Playoff change still possible
(11-27-2025 03:31 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 12:49 PM)bullet Wrote:  With 18, it could work:
2-2-2-2-2-8.

1st WC plays #8, 2 plays #7, etc. the weekend after the CCGs.

Top 2 get byes to January 1. 4 WC winners, 6 other P4 CCG participants and top 2 G champs play 6 games two weeks after CCGs. 2 games will compete with the NFL, but 4 will be separate times. It can all be seeded after the CCGs.

Then 8 to NYD as now.

I don't think there will be 2 G6 champs with 18 teams, but I wouldn't be opposed. I agree if it's 24 teams that it would be 2 G6 champs. If it were like 2/2/2/2/1+9 or 2+8, I could see the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P4 hosting the next 8 highest ranked teams with the 8 winners in and then seeding teams by rank rather than just all WCGs in the first round.

Well if they split the difference and go to 20, you could do a 2-2-2-2-2-10. 10 wildcards who play the first weekend with 10 vs. 1, 9 vs 2, etc., 2 G champs who play each other, with the winners playing 6 of the 8 P4 CCG participants, who get home games. The top 2 get a bye to January 1.

Using 2024 it looks like:

CCG weekend
Conference championship games

Army Navy weekend
Friday 19 Missouri 9-3 at 5 Notre Dame 11-1
Saturday noon 17 BYU 10-2 at 6 Ohio St. 10-2
Saturday 3:30 15 South Carolina 9-3 at 7 Tennessee 10-2
Saturday 7 14 Ole Miss 9-3 at 8 Indiana 11-1
Saturday 10:30 13 Miami 10-2 at 11 Alabama 9-3
Tuesday 22 Army 11-1 at 9 Boise 12-1
(Tuesday to give them more time, although you may look at Saturday so you aren't starting at 9:30 CST in Tuscaloosa)

Current playoff weekend
Friday Miami/Alabama at 3 Texas 11-2
Tuesday Army/Boise at 4 Penn St. 11-2
Saturday noon Ole Miss/IU at 10 SMU 11-2
Saturday 10:30 SC/TN at 12 Arizona St. 11-2
Saturday 3:30 BYU/Ohio St. at 16 Clemson 10-3
Saturday 7 Missouri/ND at 18 Iowa St. 10-3

NY games
12/31 Penn St./Army/Boise vs. Missouri/ND/ISU
1/1 noon Texas/Miami/Alabama vs. BYU/Ohio St./Clemson
1/1 3:30 Georgia vs. SC/TN/ASU
1/1 7 Oregon vs. OM/IU/SMU

Semifinals
PSU, etc. vs. Oregon, etc.
Texas, etc. vs. Georgia, etc.
12-05-2025 01:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #128
RE: Playoff change still possible
Giving the CCG participants home games gives two weeks planning time for the facilities while rewarding that they got in those games and played them.
The 10 wildcards will be selected before the CCGs so they will have 2 weeks before the first round of the playoffs at home sites.
The G vs. G game will only have 9 days, but those will be smaller facilities with fewer people traveling in.
12-05-2025 01:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #129
RE: Playoff change still possible
In 2024, the 8 extra teams would be:
SEC Alabama 9-3, Ole Miss 9-3, South Carolina 9-3, Missouri 9-3
ACC Miami 10-2
Big 12 BYU 10-2, Iowa St. 10-3
American Army 11-1

The first 3 out would be 20 Illinois 9-3, 21 Syracuse 9-3, 23 Colorado 9-3
12-05-2025 01:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #130
RE: Playoff change still possible
In 2025, the 10 wildcards would be:
5 Oregon 11-1
6 Ole Miss 11-1
7 Texas A&M 11-1
8 Oklahoma 10-2
10 Notre Dame 10-2
12 Miami 10-2
13 Texas 9-3
14 Vanderbilt 10-2
15 Utah 10-2
16 USC 9-3

And then Ohio St., Indiana, Georgia, Alabama, Texas Tech, BYU, Virginia, Duke and the Tulane/UNT winner and most likely James Madison would also be in.
12-05-2025 01:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #131
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-05-2025 01:20 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 03:31 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 12:49 PM)bullet Wrote:  With 18, it could work:
2-2-2-2-2-8.

1st WC plays #8, 2 plays #7, etc. the weekend after the CCGs.

Top 2 get byes to January 1. 4 WC winners, 6 other P4 CCG participants and top 2 G champs play 6 games two weeks after CCGs. 2 games will compete with the NFL, but 4 will be separate times. It can all be seeded after the CCGs.

Then 8 to NYD as now.

I don't think there will be 2 G6 champs with 18 teams, but I wouldn't be opposed. I agree if it's 24 teams that it would be 2 G6 champs. If it were like 2/2/2/2/1+9 or 2+8, I could see the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P4 hosting the next 8 highest ranked teams with the 8 winners in and then seeding teams by rank rather than just all WCGs in the first round.

Well if they split the difference and go to 20, you could do a 2-2-2-2-2-10. 10 wildcards who play the first weekend with 10 vs. 1, 9 vs 2, etc., 2 G champs who play each other, with the winners playing 6 of the 8 P4 CCG participants, who get home games. The top 2 get a bye to January 1.

Using 2024 it looks like:

CCG weekend
Conference championship games

Army Navy weekend
Friday 19 Missouri 9-3 at 5 Notre Dame 11-1
Saturday noon 17 BYU 10-2 at 6 Ohio St. 10-2
Saturday 3:30 15 South Carolina 9-3 at 7 Tennessee 10-2
Saturday 7 14 Ole Miss 9-3 at 8 Indiana 11-1
Saturday 10:30 13 Miami 10-2 at 11 Alabama 9-3
Tuesday 22 Army 11-1 at 9 Boise 12-1
(Tuesday to give them more time, although you may look at Saturday so you aren't starting at 9:30 CST in Tuscaloosa)

Current playoff weekend
Friday Miami/Alabama at 3 Texas 11-2
Tuesday Army/Boise at 4 Penn St. 11-2
Saturday noon Ole Miss/IU at 10 SMU 11-2
Saturday 10:30 SC/TN at 12 Arizona St. 11-2
Saturday 3:30 BYU/Ohio St. at 16 Clemson 10-3
Saturday 7 Missouri/ND at 18 Iowa St. 10-3

NY games
12/31 Penn St./Army/Boise vs. Missouri/ND/ISU
1/1 noon Texas/Miami/Alabama vs. BYU/Ohio St./Clemson
1/1 3:30 Georgia vs. SC/TN/ASU
1/1 7 Oregon vs. OM/IU/SMU

Semifinals
PSU, etc. vs. Oregon, etc.
Texas, etc. vs. Georgia, etc.

I'd be careful with that Tuesday game. I considered Tuesday and Wednesday games and ran into Christmas, which the NFL is taking over, and I think you'd potentially struggle to get fans to attend a playoff game around Christmas. With 20, I think you'd need 2 Fri., 4 Sat. or move a Sat. Game to Thur. I'm thinking 5 EST, 8:30 EST on Fri., then 10:30, 2, 5:30, 9 EST on Sat give or take a half hour.

I still think 18 will be max. if the P4 can exppand the CFP, keep CCGs, and add WCGs. This way, they get more money from the CFP, WCGs, potential conference schedule agreement(s), and still maintain money from CCGs, but if they can still do this with 20 teams, 20 teams is certainly possible, but I think it's too tight of a schedule as you'll want standalone games that aren't overlapping.
12-05-2025 02:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #132
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-05-2025 02:08 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 01:20 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 03:31 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 12:49 PM)bullet Wrote:  With 18, it could work:
2-2-2-2-2-8.

1st WC plays #8, 2 plays #7, etc. the weekend after the CCGs.

Top 2 get byes to January 1. 4 WC winners, 6 other P4 CCG participants and top 2 G champs play 6 games two weeks after CCGs. 2 games will compete with the NFL, but 4 will be separate times. It can all be seeded after the CCGs.

Then 8 to NYD as now.

I don't think there will be 2 G6 champs with 18 teams, but I wouldn't be opposed. I agree if it's 24 teams that it would be 2 G6 champs. If it were like 2/2/2/2/1+9 or 2+8, I could see the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P4 hosting the next 8 highest ranked teams with the 8 winners in and then seeding teams by rank rather than just all WCGs in the first round.

Well if they split the difference and go to 20, you could do a 2-2-2-2-2-10. 10 wildcards who play the first weekend with 10 vs. 1, 9 vs 2, etc., 2 G champs who play each other, with the winners playing 6 of the 8 P4 CCG participants, who get home games. The top 2 get a bye to January 1.

Using 2024 it looks like:

CCG weekend
Conference championship games

Army Navy weekend
Friday 19 Missouri 9-3 at 5 Notre Dame 11-1
Saturday noon 17 BYU 10-2 at 6 Ohio St. 10-2
Saturday 3:30 15 South Carolina 9-3 at 7 Tennessee 10-2
Saturday 7 14 Ole Miss 9-3 at 8 Indiana 11-1
Saturday 10:30 13 Miami 10-2 at 11 Alabama 9-3
Tuesday 22 Army 11-1 at 9 Boise 12-1
(Tuesday to give them more time, although you may look at Saturday so you aren't starting at 9:30 CST in Tuscaloosa)

Current playoff weekend
Friday Miami/Alabama at 3 Texas 11-2
Tuesday Army/Boise at 4 Penn St. 11-2
Saturday noon Ole Miss/IU at 10 SMU 11-2
Saturday 10:30 SC/TN at 12 Arizona St. 11-2
Saturday 3:30 BYU/Ohio St. at 16 Clemson 10-3
Saturday 7 Missouri/ND at 18 Iowa St. 10-3

NY games
12/31 Penn St./Army/Boise vs. Missouri/ND/ISU
1/1 noon Texas/Miami/Alabama vs. BYU/Ohio St./Clemson
1/1 3:30 Georgia vs. SC/TN/ASU
1/1 7 Oregon vs. OM/IU/SMU

Semifinals
PSU, etc. vs. Oregon, etc.
Texas, etc. vs. Georgia, etc.

I'd be careful with that Tuesday game. I considered Tuesday and Wednesday games and ran into Christmas, which the NFL is taking over, and I think you'd potentially struggle to get fans to attend a playoff game around Christmas. With 20, I think you'd need 2 Fri., 4 Sat. or move a Sat. Game to Thur. I'm thinking 5 EST, 8:30 EST on Fri., then 10:30, 2, 5:30, 9 EST on Sat give or take a half hour.

I still think 18 will be max. if the P4 can exppand the CFP, keep CCGs, and add WCGs. This way, they get more money from the CFP, WCGs, potential conference schedule agreement(s), and still maintain money from CCGs, but if they can still do this with 20 teams, 20 teams is certainly possible, but I think it's too tight of a schedule as you'll want standalone games that aren't overlapping.

You could do two games on Friday, afternoon and evening. Fans isn't the primary driver, but this year that 2nd Tuesday game would really be too late, the 23rd of December. And you can't really ask a team to play on Tuesday and then Saturday while the other team has 2 weeks. Thursdays and Mondays don't work because of the NFL.

The schedule might include one of those wildcard games on the preceding Wednesday. So W, F, 4 on Saturday, including the G champs game.
12-05-2025 02:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #133
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-05-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 02:08 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 01:20 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 03:31 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-27-2025 12:49 PM)bullet Wrote:  With 18, it could work:
2-2-2-2-2-8.

1st WC plays #8, 2 plays #7, etc. the weekend after the CCGs.

Top 2 get byes to January 1. 4 WC winners, 6 other P4 CCG participants and top 2 G champs play 6 games two weeks after CCGs. 2 games will compete with the NFL, but 4 will be separate times. It can all be seeded after the CCGs.

Then 8 to NYD as now.

I don't think there will be 2 G6 champs with 18 teams, but I wouldn't be opposed. I agree if it's 24 teams that it would be 2 G6 champs. If it were like 2/2/2/2/1+9 or 2+8, I could see the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P4 hosting the next 8 highest ranked teams with the 8 winners in and then seeding teams by rank rather than just all WCGs in the first round.

Well if they split the difference and go to 20, you could do a 2-2-2-2-2-10. 10 wildcards who play the first weekend with 10 vs. 1, 9 vs 2, etc., 2 G champs who play each other, with the winners playing 6 of the 8 P4 CCG participants, who get home games. The top 2 get a bye to January 1.

Using 2024 it looks like:

CCG weekend
Conference championship games

Army Navy weekend
Friday 19 Missouri 9-3 at 5 Notre Dame 11-1
Saturday noon 17 BYU 10-2 at 6 Ohio St. 10-2
Saturday 3:30 15 South Carolina 9-3 at 7 Tennessee 10-2
Saturday 7 14 Ole Miss 9-3 at 8 Indiana 11-1
Saturday 10:30 13 Miami 10-2 at 11 Alabama 9-3
Tuesday 22 Army 11-1 at 9 Boise 12-1
(Tuesday to give them more time, although you may look at Saturday so you aren't starting at 9:30 CST in Tuscaloosa)

Current playoff weekend
Friday Miami/Alabama at 3 Texas 11-2
Tuesday Army/Boise at 4 Penn St. 11-2
Saturday noon Ole Miss/IU at 10 SMU 11-2
Saturday 10:30 SC/TN at 12 Arizona St. 11-2
Saturday 3:30 BYU/Ohio St. at 16 Clemson 10-3
Saturday 7 Missouri/ND at 18 Iowa St. 10-3

NY games
12/31 Penn St./Army/Boise vs. Missouri/ND/ISU
1/1 noon Texas/Miami/Alabama vs. BYU/Ohio St./Clemson
1/1 3:30 Georgia vs. SC/TN/ASU
1/1 7 Oregon vs. OM/IU/SMU

Semifinals
PSU, etc. vs. Oregon, etc.
Texas, etc. vs. Georgia, etc.

I'd be careful with that Tuesday game. I considered Tuesday and Wednesday games and ran into Christmas, which the NFL is taking over, and I think you'd potentially struggle to get fans to attend a playoff game around Christmas. With 20, I think you'd need 2 Fri., 4 Sat. or move a Sat. Game to Thur. I'm thinking 5 EST, 8:30 EST on Fri., then 10:30, 2, 5:30, 9 EST on Sat give or take a half hour.

I still think 18 will be max. if the P4 can exppand the CFP, keep CCGs, and add WCGs. This way, they get more money from the CFP, WCGs, potential conference schedule agreement(s), and still maintain money from CCGs, but if they can still do this with 20 teams, 20 teams is certainly possible, but I think it's too tight of a schedule as you'll want standalone games that aren't overlapping.

You could do two games on Friday, afternoon and evening. Fans isn't the primary driver, but this year that 2nd Tuesday game would really be too late, the 23rd of December. And you can't really ask a team to play on Tuesday and then Saturday while the other team has 2 weeks. Thursdays and Mondays don't work because of the NFL.

The schedule might include one of those wildcard games on the preceding Wednesday. So W, F, 4 on Saturday, including the G champs game.

Yeah, you're best bet for 20 teams would be 2 games Friday, 4 games Saturday both weeks unless you can get a game on Thursday, but that Selection Sunday to Thursday prep time would be rough though. I'm not sure which would do better TV wise, Thursday evening against an NFL game streaming or Saturday after dark. It's worth noting that when ESPN has 4 bowl games on the Saturday between Christmas and New Years, their 4 start times are 11:00, 2:15, 5:45, and 9:15, and this is a pattern they've been using since at least 2021 so maybe that's how the 4 Sat. games could look like with maybe the latter 3 games pushed back 15 minutes.
12-05-2025 03:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #134
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-05-2025 03:55 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 02:26 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 02:08 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-05-2025 01:20 PM)bullet Wrote:  [quote='GoBuckeyes1047' pid='20440482' dateline='1764275495']

I don't think there will be 2 G6 champs with 18 teams, but I wouldn't be opposed. I agree if it's 24 teams that it would be 2 G6 champs. If it were like 2/2/2/2/1+9 or 2+8, I could see the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P4 hosting the next 8 highest ranked teams with the 8 winners in and then seeding teams by rank rather than just all WCGs in the first round.

Well if they split the difference and go to 20, you could do a 2-2-2-2-2-10. 10 wildcards who play the first weekend with 10 vs. 1, 9 vs 2, etc., 2 G champs who play each other, with the winners playing 6 of the 8 P4 CCG participants, who get home games. The top 2 get a bye to January 1.

Using 2024 it looks like:

CCG weekend
Conference championship games

Army Navy weekend
Friday 19 Missouri 9-3 at 5 Notre Dame 11-1
Saturday noon 17 BYU 10-2 at 6 Ohio St. 10-2
Saturday 3:30 15 South Carolina 9-3 at 7 Tennessee 10-2
Saturday 7 14 Ole Miss 9-3 at 8 Indiana 11-1
Saturday 10:30 13 Miami 10-2 at 11 Alabama 9-3
Tuesday 22 Army 11-1 at 9 Boise 12-1
(Tuesday to give them more time, although you may look at Saturday so you aren't starting at 9:30 CST in Tuscaloosa)

Current playoff weekend
Friday Miami/Alabama at 3 Texas 11-2
Tuesday Army/Boise at 4 Penn St. 11-2
Saturday noon Ole Miss/IU at 10 SMU 11-2
Saturday 10:30 SC/TN at 12 Arizona St. 11-2
Saturday 3:30 BYU/Ohio St. at 16 Clemson 10-3
Saturday 7 Missouri/ND at 18 Iowa St. 10-3

NY games
12/31 Penn St./Army/Boise vs. Missouri/ND/ISU
1/1 noon Texas/Miami/Alabama vs. BYU/Ohio St./Clemson
1/1 3:30 Georgia vs. SC/TN/ASU
1/1 7 Oregon vs. OM/IU/SMU

Semifinals
PSU, etc. vs. Oregon, etc.
Texas, etc. vs. Georgia, etc.

I'd be careful with that Tuesday game. I considered Tuesday and Wednesday games and ran into Christmas, which the NFL is taking over, and I think you'd potentially struggle to get fans to attend a playoff game around Christmas. With 20, I think you'd need 2 Fri., 4 Sat. or move a Sat. Game to Thur. I'm thinking 5 EST, 8:30 EST on Fri., then 10:30, 2, 5:30, 9 EST on Sat give or take a half hour.

I still think 18 will be max. if the P4 can exppand the CFP, keep CCGs, and add WCGs. This way, they get more money from the CFP, WCGs, potential conference schedule agreement(s), and still maintain money from CCGs, but if they can still do this with 20 teams, 20 teams is certainly possible, but I think it's too tight of a schedule as you'll want standalone games that aren't overlapping.

You could do two games on Friday, afternoon and evening. Fans isn't the primary driver, but this year that 2nd Tuesday game would really be too late, the 23rd of December. And you can't really ask a team to play on Tuesday and then Saturday while the other team has 2 weeks. Thursdays and Mondays don't work because of the NFL.

The schedule might include one of those wildcard games on the preceding Wednesday. So W, F, 4 on Saturday, including the G champs game.

Yeah, you're best bet for 20 teams would be 2 games Friday, 4 games Saturday both weeks unless you can get a game on Thursday, but that Selection Sunday to Thursday prep time would be rough though. I'm not sure which would do better TV wise, Thursday evening against an NFL game streaming or Saturday after dark. It's worth noting that when ESPN has 4 bowl games on the Saturday between Christmas and New Years, their 4 start times are 11:00, 2:15, 5:45, and 9:15, and this is a pattern they've been using since at least 2021 so maybe that's how the 4 Sat. games could look like with maybe the latter 3 games pushed back 15 minutes.

In this scenario, the wildcard teams are selected the week before the CCGs. So they will have 1 full week+ or 2 full weeks if they play on Saturday.
12-05-2025 05:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #135
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-05-2025 01:22 PM)bullet Wrote:  Giving the CCG participants home games gives two weeks planning time for the facilities while rewarding that they got in those games and played them.
The 10 wildcards will be selected before the CCGs so they will have 2 weeks before the first round of the playoffs at home sites.
The G vs. G game will only have 9 days, but those will be smaller facilities with fewer people traveling in.

A couple suggestions from these posts:

1) Ditch the G6 Championship. The G6 have long been guaranteed a single spot yet they have expressed no appetite for another game of wear and tear on their athletes to winnow the field. UNT-TU is already the G6 Championship; no need for another game.

2) 7-5 Duke having a shot at the playoff today is crazy; giving them a home game is even crazier; giving them a home game AFTER THEY LOSE to Virginia is Banana-Slug crazy. You have identified 9 spots for CCG teams; give 5 to the AQ Champs and the next 4 (or fewer) to the best CCG losers or potential additional champs. The 2 weeks teams have to prepare to host is fine, adding a third week of prep is unnecessary.

3) 5 games on Army-Navy weekend (6 if the service academies stay there) is probably not value-add. Having Oregon play USC again might make sense if the Trojans had won before, but putting them on the same field now negates the value of their first game. We can drop 1 or 2 of these games and the top teams who avoid these games now have the 3 weeks to prepare to host a game on the current playoff weekend.

4) And maybe the same with 6 games the following week, going against the NFL no less. 3 byes fits the current dynamic, gives the M2 something to vie for, rather than letting the P2 take the byes.

I think that leaves you with:

Army-Navy Weekend:
13 (9-3) Texas @ 12 (10-2) Miami
14 (10-2) Vanderbilt @ 10 (10-2) Notre Dame
15 (10-2) Utah @ 8 (10-2) Oklahoma

Current Playoff Weekend:
UVA/JMU @ Big Ten CG loser
TU/UNT @ 5 (11-1) Oregon*
WCG A @ 6 (11-1) Ole Miss
WCG B @ 7 (11-1) Texas A&M
WCG C @ 2nd best CG loser

*The Oregon game could be moved up a week to best capitalize on the NFL-free weekend. They’d still have 2 weeks to prep their facilities.

9-3 USC is the only team that loses access, but you beef up the value of all the CCGs by not having them be pointless seeding exercises. You also trim back the fat without abandoning valuable TV windows.
12-05-2025 08:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #136
RE: Playoff change still possible
So IF Alabama misses the CFP, what would the SEC do to try to push the needle to get the CFP expanded sooner after their top seed in the regular season misses the CFP, despite getting 4 other teams in?
12-06-2025 09:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #137
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-06-2025 09:36 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So IF Alabama misses the CFP, what would the SEC do to try to push the needle to get the CFP expanded sooner after their top seed in the regular season misses the CFP, despite getting 4 other teams in?

Nothing. 1. It hasn't happened yet. 2. Four in for 12 is plenty don't you think. 3. The SEC and Big 10 are at odds on purpose to stall for leverage until realignment is over and they know for sure what they want and agree upon what each will get.
12-06-2025 10:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,083
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #138
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-06-2025 10:15 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-06-2025 09:36 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So IF Alabama misses the CFP, what would the SEC do to try to push the needle to get the CFP expanded sooner after their top seed in the regular season misses the CFP, despite getting 4 other teams in?

Nothing. 1. It hasn't happened yet. 2. Four in for 12 is plenty don't you think. 3. The SEC and Big 10 are at odds on purpose to stall for leverage until realignment is over and they know for sure what they want and agree upon what each will get.

Tell that to Sankey lobbying for 7 teams in a 12 team playoff

A follow up question is what does the ACC do now that Duke won and could get no teams in.
12-07-2025 12:02 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #139
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-07-2025 12:02 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-06-2025 10:15 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-06-2025 09:36 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So IF Alabama misses the CFP, what would the SEC do to try to push the needle to get the CFP expanded sooner after their top seed in the regular season misses the CFP, despite getting 4 other teams in?

Nothing. 1. It hasn't happened yet. 2. Four in for 12 is plenty don't you think. 3. The SEC and Big 10 are at odds on purpose to stall for leverage until realignment is over and they know for sure what they want and agree upon what each will get.

Tell that to Sankey lobbying for 7 teams in a 12 team playoff

A follow up question is what does the ACC do now that Duke won and could get no teams in.

ACC will reevaluate tiebreaker. May not necessarily change them though.
12-07-2025 12:03 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,991
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #140
RE: Playoff change still possible
(12-07-2025 12:02 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(12-06-2025 10:15 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(12-06-2025 09:36 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So IF Alabama misses the CFP, what would the SEC do to try to push the needle to get the CFP expanded sooner after their top seed in the regular season misses the CFP, despite getting 4 other teams in?

Nothing. 1. It hasn't happened yet. 2. Four in for 12 is plenty don't you think. 3. The SEC and Big 10 are at odds on purpose to stall for leverage until realignment is over and they know for sure what they want and agree upon what each will get.

Tell that to Sankey lobbying for 7 teams in a 12 team playoff

A follow up question is what does the ACC do now that Duke won and could get no teams in.

They get one and a partial. Miami will get in and likely Notre Dame as well.
12-07-2025 12:04 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.