RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 02:58 PM)Owls9878 Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Sitake has an objectively better resume, no?
Not really, Campbell has been a turnaround artist at both Toledo and ISU, doing just as much as, if not more than, Sitake at a pair of schools with limited budgets and tough histories (well, Toledo's always been near the top of the MAC but ISU spend decades in the doghouse with Campbell taking them to their first major bowl ever in 2021 despite them, of course, being theoretically power conference members since1908.)
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 03:17 PM by The Beaver.)
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 02:58 PM)Owls9878 Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Sitake has an objectively better resume, no?
Kalani Sitake is 83–44 at BYU.
Matt Campbell is 72–55 at ISU.
Both started in 2016.
On the other hand, Iowa State was in the Big 12 the whole time while BYU was independent until 2023. It's certainly tougher to win in the Big 12 year in and year out so it's debatable if Sitake would have the same record in the Big 12, especially in the years Oklahoma and Texas were still in the conference.
Kalani was a BYU alum and seems happy. I'm not going to say Campbell is a huge downgrade over Sitake.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 03:20 PM)schmolik Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:58 PM)Owls9878 Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Sitake has an objectively better resume, no?
Kalani Sitake is 83–44 at BYU.
Matt Campbell is 72–55 at ISU.
Both started in 2016.
On the other hand, Iowa State was in the Big 12 the whole time while BYU was independent until 2023. It's certainly tougher to win in the Big 12 year in and year out so it's debatable if Sitake would have the same record in the Big 12, especially in the years Oklahoma and Texas were still in the conference.
Kalani was a BYU alum and seems happy. I'm not going to say Campbell is a huge downgrade over Sitake.
Campbell also has a 35-15 record at Toledo to include.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Wouldn't necessarily say Campbell is a downgrade from Sitake but he's definitely a downgrade from Franklin. I'm sure he'll win some games but I don't see how he lives up to the expectations at Penn State. Imo if Penn State actually wanted to compete for a title they should've just doubled down on Franklin and upped his NIL.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 06:29 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Wouldn't necessarily say Campbell is a downgrade from Sitake but he's definitely a downgrade from Franklin. I'm sure he'll win some games but I don't see how he lives up to the expectations at Penn State. Imo if Penn State actually wanted to compete for a title they should've just doubled down on Franklin and upped his NIL.
Someone at one of the PSU boards posted that Campbell and Franklin both have a total of 19 wins over the past two years but Campbell did it with a single blue chip player while Franklin had 58 of them.
I don't think we should have fired Franklin and made it clear-ish at the time* but don't think Campbell is a clear downgrade.
*I don't normally support firing a coach unless he has like three or four years of unmitigated failure but, given that I sound like a broken record on that, deliberately did not say that it was a bad idea day-of, merely saying that it was "off-brand" or "unPenn State". But, for reference' sake if I say something is unPenn State then I think its bad, the two are synonyms to me
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 06:46 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 06:29 PM)WhoseHouse? Wrote: Wouldn't necessarily say Campbell is a downgrade from Sitake but he's definitely a downgrade from Franklin. I'm sure he'll win some games but I don't see how he lives up to the expectations at Penn State. Imo if Penn State actually wanted to compete for a title they should've just doubled down on Franklin and upped his NIL.
Someone at one of the PSU boards posted that Campbell and Franklin both have a total of 19 wins over the past two years but Campbell did it with a single blue chip player while Franklin had 58 of them.
I don't think we should have fired Franklin and made it clear-ish at the time* but don't think Campbell is a clear downgrade.
*I don't normally support firing a coach unless he has like three or four years of unmitigated failure but, given that I sound like a broken record on that, deliberately did not say that it was a bad idea day-of, merely saying that it was "off-brand" or "unPenn State". But, for reference' sake if I say something is unPenn State then I think its bad, the two are synonyms to me
Tbc clear I like Campbell. He's done a good job at ISU. And when people judge his resume they shouldn't just look at the W/L total but what the program had done prior to his arrival. Its like how Fritz was at Tulane. A 7 win season at many programs isn't something to write home about but at a place like Tulane or Iowa State, historically thats a nice year. In Campbells case they have 12 seasons where they've won more than 7 games and he's responsible for 5 of them.
So with that said I thought he would've been a great hire for Nebraska where the lack of success over the last decade has tempered the expectations around the program and he might actually have the time to build his roster. But at Penn State you guys are running off coaches that have almost climbed the mountain top. Will yall be content with good? If 4-5 years from now hes won 75% of his games, made the playoffs once or twice but never made it to the final game or even won a B10 championship are you guys gonna stick with him and continue to let him build? You'd know better than me but the outsider perspective makes me question whether yall will have the patience.
Personally I agree that you guys should've given Franklin at least one more mediocre season. Firing a guy one year removed from final four playoff run to me just seems pretty unfair. I think yall folded early and he could've still won you guys a title.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 03:20 PM)schmolik Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:58 PM)Owls9878 Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Sitake has an objectively better resume, no?
Kalani Sitake is 83–44 at BYU.
Matt Campbell is 72–55 at ISU.
Both started in 2016.
On the other hand, Iowa State was in the Big 12 the whole time while BYU was independent until 2023. It's certainly tougher to win in the Big 12 year in and year out so it's debatable if Sitake would have the same record in the Big 12, especially in the years Oklahoma and Texas were still in the conference.
Kalani was a BYU alum and seems happy. I'm not going to say Campbell is a huge downgrade over Sitake.
Another point to consider is this: Sitake has a winning percentage of .654 at a school with an all-time winning percentage of .586 (difference .068). Campbell has a winning percentage of .567 at a school with an all-time winning percentage of .456 (difference .111).
There's little doubt that it has historically been more difficult to win at Iowa State than at BYU, and that should be taken into consideration when evaluating the two. I'm definitely not prepared to say that Campbell is a huge downgrade from Sitake.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:29 PM)The Beaver Wrote: I think it will be Campbell. ISU just gave him a raise up to 5 million but PSU could more than double that without difficulty.
He's a good coach, most notable for taking a terrible Toledo team (who won one game his first year) and making them regular MAC title contenders. Then he did the same at ISU.
Not terrible but not great either. Very different from Franklin and Smith, would likely lose the whole team to the portal and have a "wait for 2027" type 2026.
I think it's odd that Campbell has been passed up so much over the past few years, though it's also possible that he was passing up other opportunities b/c they weren't as big as PSU. Iowa State was the ultimate doormat in the Big 8 and, later the Big 12. Campbell was Coach of the Year in either the MAC or Big 12 4 of the 6 years between 2015-2020 (once MAC, 3 times Big 12). He's a Pat Fitzgerald-type guy who won a lot of games at a program with limited resources, or, dare I say, a James Franklin-type guy from Franklin's days of winning a lot of games at Vanderbilt before PSU hired him. Perhaps even better than Fitzgerald, as NW at least had some history of success before Fitzgerald got there, while Iowa St was so inept that Campbell is the only coach in their 128 year history with either 10 wins (he had 11 last year) OR a Major Bowl win (he won the Fiesta in 2020).
Considering the tiny buyout you guys ended up paying for Franklin and the obvious benefits of a reset for both parties, I think that this could end up being the marathon search that actually got you guys your Guy. You'll never lack for talent, and if Campbell makes those few small decisions slightly better than Franklin did at just the right time, he could very well be the guy to get you guys back to the top of the Mountain.
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 08:15 PM by bryanw1995.)
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Oh yeah, that "terrible Toledo team" was me mis-reading his resume. His lone win that year was also his lone game coached, winning a bowl after their previous coach took a P5 gig. Still, he did well there regardless.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Matt Brown is calling the Crumbl guy Big Cookie now!
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 03:20 PM)schmolik Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:58 PM)Owls9878 Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:54 PM)The Beaver Wrote:
(12-05-2025 02:47 PM)Owls9878 Wrote: Talk about lowering your expectations. Woof.
Better than Sitake at least. We're real lucky that Crumbl guy stepped up to block our would-be own goal. Keep sending us those overpriced cookies, noone outside of the AD's office is mad.
Sitake has an objectively better resume, no?
Kalani Sitake is 83–44 at BYU.
Matt Campbell is 72–55 at ISU.
Both started in 2016.
On the other hand, Iowa State was in the Big 12 the whole time while BYU was independent until 2023. It's certainly tougher to win in the Big 12 year in and year out so it's debatable if Sitake would have the same record in the Big 12, especially in the years Oklahoma and Texas were still in the conference.
Kalani was a BYU alum and seems happy. I'm not going to say Campbell is a huge downgrade over Sitake.
I think that Sitake would have been good, too, but Campbell has done more with less. There's a reason he's won all those COTY awards.