RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 12:54 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:
(12-04-2025 12:30 PM)Ned Low Wrote:
(12-04-2025 10:57 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote:
(12-04-2025 10:13 AM)johnbragg Wrote: I think you're underrating the inherent strength of the Penn State program -- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium is a program that should be a job coaches are falling over themselves to get. Or maybe you're equivocating -- if Franklin was underperforming at Penn State, then Penn State should have been able to snag pretty much any of the coaches who turned them down.
I think you're underrating the inherent ceiling of the Penn State program-- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium but does not have the ability to recruit the level of regional talent that will surpass that seen at Michigan, Ohio State, Alabama, Texas, USC, etc. It's a great program, but much like Notre Dame, will no longer be dominant as it once was, as the base of population from the Northeast and Rust Belt continues to decline.
Penn State has not won a national title in 39 years, Notre Dame in 37. There are bigger issues in these numbers than the coaching of James Franklin or Marcus Freeman.
Both Notre Dame and Penn State recruit nationally so I'm not sure that demographics will play a roll when it comes to recruiting.
It's important to note that Duke also recruits nationally and we see how far that's gotten them.
I fear that Penn State has made a terrible mistake, even if they won't admit it at this time. They were arguably the 4th biggest brand in the conference (behind OSU, Michigan and Southern Cal) before... but Oregon is still rolling and Indiana is trending upward (to put it mildly); they may soon find themselves in a decade-long death spiral of their own doing.
Clemson recruits nationally, including bunches from Georgia & Florida. If one takes a look at their roster and where the players are from, it can be surprising how few are actually from South Carolina.
Clemson is closer to Atlanta than it is to half of South Carolina...
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 01:19 PM)johnintx Wrote:
(12-04-2025 01:17 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: Honestly Kelly would crush it at Penn State:
Villain? Check
Soft schedule? Check
Recruiting roots? Check
What's not to love Happy Valley!?!?
He would kill it there, for sure. But would anyone in the athletic department be able to get along with him? And is he still willing to recruit hard? Those were his two biggest issues at LSU.
Prime Kelly could have been better than Franklin. This husk of the remnants of Kelly that's getting paid $54m by LSU to sit on his couch and make a half-hearted effort to look for jobs for the next few years? There are literally a thousand guys who would do better at PSU.
It's gonna be quite ironic if they end up hiring a P2 or NFL Coordinator (like Joe Brady!) and he wins the National Title in 3 years. It's not always the best thing in the world to get the guy you thought you wanted.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
I'm a Millennial and wasn't born the last time Penn State won a national championship but I never really saw Penn State as an elite program.
TBH outside of a couple of years like last year and the year they had Kajanna Carter/Kerry Collin Penn State have never really been relevant in the national championship picture so I'm not sure how they have such an over inflated view of themselves. They've been always a distant third in the B1G.
They're probably like a 15- 20 ranked program in my lifetime.
Bama
Georgia
Florida
LSU
UT
OU
OSU
Mich
USC
Oregon
FSU
Clemson
Miami
ND
I would put above them.
They're in that UWash/UTenn/Aub level, the only thing you can say positive about PSU is that they consistently good but they're never great.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 04:06 PM)ccbfan Wrote: I'm a Millennial and wasn't born the last time Penn State won a national championship but I never really saw Penn State as an elite program.
TBH outside of a couple of years like last year and the year they had Kajanna Carter/Kerry Collin Penn State have never really been relevant in the national championship picture so I'm not sure how they have such an over inflated view of themselves. They've been always a distant third in the B1G.
They're probably like a 15- 20 ranked program in my lifetime.
Bama
Georgia
Florida
LSU
UT
OU
OSU
Mich
USC
Oregon
FSU
Clemson
Miami
ND
I would put above them.
They're in that UWash/UTenn/Aub level, the only thing you can say positive about PSU is that they consistently good but they're never great.
We ended the regular season ranked 3rd twice in the top 2 era (three times if you count that Collins/Carter team in the BC/BA era) and ranked 5th twice in the top 4 era. I suppose that evens out with teams like Tennessee and Auburn who were worse more often but also won a national championship or with UW who had a lot of playoff appearances even if they never got a championship out of it. Its all on where you draw the line? Is it championships, playoff games, AP rankings, bowl eligibility, etc? And what year is your cur-off? Or perhaps you look at money being put into the program or recruitment rankings, etc?
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 12:07 AM by The Beaver.)
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
I think it will be Campbell. ISU just gave him a raise up to 5 million but PSU could more than double that without difficulty.
He's a good coach, most notable for taking a terrible Toledo team (who won one game his first year) and making them regular MAC title contenders. Then he did the same at ISU.
Not terrible but not great either. Very different from Franklin and Smith, would likely lose the whole team to the portal and have a "wait for 2027" type 2026.
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 12:07 AM by The Beaver.)
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 12:16 PM)schmolik Wrote:
(12-04-2025 11:46 AM)OdinFrigg Wrote: Harvey Bradford (Brad) Scott appears to be available.
Who?
Oh, my sweet summer child, are you not familiar with the FSU ->Sakerlina -> Clemson coach, inexplicable (because of his abject mediocrity, not lack of egregious consumption) Heinz ketchup spokespig, and 1995 CarQuest Bowl Winner, the portly Prince of Palmetto State pigskin, Ser Fat Bradstard, The First of His Name?!?
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Saw some emotional Iowa State fan commenting on how family man Campbell has to explain to his wife and kids what went on there at PSU years ago with Sandusky so how could he take the job. I mean if you wanna go there I could say well how do the students and faculty who go to and work at Brown explain to their families that the school is named after a guy who's family were slave owners. We could play this game all day if you want.
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2025 11:15 PM by darkdragon99.)
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 11:12 PM)darkdragon99 Wrote: Saw some emotional Iowa State fan commenting on how family man Campbell has to explain to his wife and kids what went on there at PSU years ago with Sandusky so how could he take the job. I mean if you wanna go there I could say well how do the students and faculty who go to and work at Brown explain to their families that the school is named after a guy who's family were slave owners. We could play this game all day if you want.
The culture has changed at Brown. It hasn't at Penn State. They really just doubled down.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 11:12 PM)darkdragon99 Wrote: Saw some emotional Iowa State fan commenting on how family man Campbell has to explain to his wife and kids what went on there at PSU years ago with Sandusky so how could he take the job. I mean if you wanna go there I could say well how do the students and faculty who go to and work at Brown explain to their families that the school is named after a guy who's family were slave owners. We could play this game all day if you want.
If PSU grabs Diaz from Duke, I wonder if something similar would occur. There were murmurs about Drinkwitz's wife not liking Penn State and the family thing when he had a hot moment, and some calling her a snob and more impolite things...got a chuckle. Like, how dare an involved mother have opinions about living in an area that cares a little too much about a school over youth wellbeing in the middle of nowhere.
(12-04-2025 11:46 AM)OdinFrigg Wrote: Harvey Bradford (Brad) Scott appears to be available.
Who?
Oh, my sweet summer child, are you not familiar with the FSU ->Sakerlina -> Clemson coach, inexplicable (because of his abject mediocrity, not lack of egregious consumption) Heinz ketchup spokespig, and 1995 CarQuest Bowl Winner, the portly Prince of Palmetto State pigskin, Ser Fat Bradstard, The First of His Name?!?
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
I'll take the job on a 6-year, $9m deal with 100% buyout guaranteed without offset. I'll use the saved money to hire assistant coaches who will actually be in charge while I delegate like a CEO.
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-05-2025 01:31 PM)CitrusUCF Wrote: I'll take the job on a 6-year, $9m deal with 100% buyout guaranteed without offset. I'll use the saved money to hire assistant coaches who will actually be in charge while I delegate like a CEO.
That was pretty much what JoePa was doing in his last decade or so. His coordinators called the plays...he just stomped around like a grouch. Your way would be familiar to those up in Happy Valley!
(This post was last modified: 12-05-2025 02:09 PM by The Cutter of Bish.)