bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 07:43 AM)darkdragon99 Wrote: People dont wanna leave their already secure jobs for a job where the standards are way too high and unrealistic. Just go after a assistant whos looking for a head job. Too bad if you dont want that. Time to accept reality. What about the OC for the Buffalo Bills Joe Brady who has PSU ties ? Hes a young and sounds like a good candidate. The Bills are probably underachieving but I dont know if thats his fault, I dont watch their games.
2 choices:
1. Huge overpay for a sexton client, maybe get your governor involved
2. Settle fora g5 coach or top assistant
|
|
| 12-04-2025 09:57 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: As much as coaches are often mercenaries looking for as much money as possible, they are also human beings.
James Franklin has a lot of respect in the coaching profession, especially among the lions like Nick Saban that are pretty directly advising some of the highest profile coaching candidates out there.
The perception is that Franklin was totally screwed by Penn State in a way beyond the norm
even in the context of the overall looney bin of college football. He was essentially fired after only 2 bad games just months after being in the Final Four of the CFP and the Big Ten Championship Game. As much as we like to joke about how the best job in the world is being a fired coach sitting on the beach collectively a massive buyout, these guys sincerely *don’t* want to get fired. So, to see what they perceive as a top coach get fired after essentially a couple of bad games less than a year after achieving success that 99% of coaches will never reach, anyone with a stable P4 job doesn’t really want to touch PSU (and will just use the PSU coaching opening as leverage for an extension at their existing schools or other jobs). Now, PSU will find a coach, but they’ll likely be paying more money for a likely lower profile candidate than what they ever anticipated when they chose to fire Franklin.
Add in that Franklin is a Jimmy Sexton client where an agent that effectively controls the top end of the coaching market can pick apart every tiny detail of PSU’s contracting practices (e.g. say goodbye to the duty to mitigate damages in those coaching buyout clauses for any worthwhile coaching candidate) and let’s just say has both a financial interest in keeping that PSU job open for other clients and a personal interest because he believes that his client was treated unfairly by PSU… and now we see PSU having to dip into much lower tiers of the coaching ranks than they ever thought possible.
I called it immediately after Franklin was fired. Huge and recent success, seemed to be rising above his struggles in past seasons, loses a couple 1 score games then bam fired. Frank Solich at Nebraska all over again. Even LSU, for all the grief I give them about Kelly, at least he hadn’t had any success at LSU at all plus he was trending in the wrong direction, and even still they had to pay $13m a year for a guy who has never won squat. I don’t think there’s any Jimmy Sexton meddling required to explain the hesitancy of top coaches to leave their current digs (as long as current digs are willing to pay up) for a place with stratospheric expectations but perhaps not quite the same level of financial commitment.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:08 AM |
|
johnbragg
Five Minute Google Expert

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:10 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: As much as coaches are often mercenaries looking for as much money as possible, they are also human beings.
James Franklin has a lot of respect in the coaching profession, especially among the lions like Nick Saban that are pretty directly advising some of the highest profile coaching candidates out there.
The perception is that Franklin was totally screwed by Penn State in a way beyond the norm
even in the context of the overall looney bin of college football. He was essentially fired after only 2 bad games just months after being in the Final Four of the CFP and the Big Ten Championship Game. As much as we like to joke about how the best job in the world is being a fired coach sitting on the beach collectively a massive buyout, these guys sincerely *don’t* want to get fired. So, to see what they perceive as a top coach get fired after essentially a couple of bad games less than a year after achieving success that 99% of coaches will never reach, anyone with a stable P4 job doesn’t really want to touch PSU (and will just use the PSU coaching opening as leverage for an extension at their existing schools or other jobs). Now, PSU will find a coach, but they’ll likely be paying more money for a likely lower profile candidate than what they ever anticipated when they chose to fire Franklin.
Add in that Franklin is a Jimmy Sexton client where an agent that effectively controls the top end of the coaching market can pick apart every tiny detail of PSU’s contracting practices (e.g. say goodbye to the duty to mitigate damages in those coaching buyout clauses for any worthwhile coaching candidate) and let’s just say has both a financial interest in keeping that PSU job open for other clients and a personal interest because he believes that his client was treated unfairly by PSU… and now we see PSU having to dip into much lower tiers of the coaching ranks than they ever thought possible.
I'm sorry, in what way was Franklin the most screwed over fired coach in the history of time?
HE was fired after 3 losses, 2 of them narrow losses, less than a year after winning a NEw Years' Day bowl to go to the national semifinals.
Quote:LSU would have fired him 5 times before even reaching the playoff in his 11th season. LSU has fired 2 coaches who won national titles in the last decade and another guy who won 70% of his games with the Governor making a complete joke of himself in the process and they weren't "punished" for it,
Weren't they? LAne Kiffin is arguably punishment. Let's circle back in a few years after Lane Kiffin flames out in Baton Rouge.
Quote:so that seems like a bunch of crap to me. It's a running joke for a reason that Franklin never wins a big game, because he doesn't. I believe this is AD arrogance and incompetence more than being "punished" for firing a guy who had kinda earned being fired at a premier program multiple times over. Kraft way over inflated the type of coach he could land, believed big fish that weren't actually serious options were, went all in on the BYU guy who was a bad fit in general and then was always going to be insanely likely to do exactly what he did, and now it's a disaster. A good AD accurately evaluates the type of hire they can make and then makes it.
WEll, if they hadn't fired Franklin halfway through the season, coming off a playoff run, they probably get one of the coaches they made a run at in the last few weeks.
I think you're underrating the inherent strength of the Penn State program -- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium is a program that should be a job coaches are falling over themselves to get. Or maybe you're equivocating -- if Franklin was underperforming at Penn State, then Penn State should have been able to snag pretty much any of the coaches who turned them down.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:13 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:25 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:10 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: As much as coaches are often mercenaries looking for as much money as possible, they are also human beings.
James Franklin has a lot of respect in the coaching profession, especially among the lions like Nick Saban that are pretty directly advising some of the highest profile coaching candidates out there.
The perception is that Franklin was totally screwed by Penn State in a way beyond the norm
even in the context of the overall looney bin of college football. He was essentially fired after only 2 bad games just months after being in the Final Four of the CFP and the Big Ten Championship Game. As much as we like to joke about how the best job in the world is being a fired coach sitting on the beach collectively a massive buyout, these guys sincerely *don’t* want to get fired. So, to see what they perceive as a top coach get fired after essentially a couple of bad games less than a year after achieving success that 99% of coaches will never reach, anyone with a stable P4 job doesn’t really want to touch PSU (and will just use the PSU coaching opening as leverage for an extension at their existing schools or other jobs). Now, PSU will find a coach, but they’ll likely be paying more money for a likely lower profile candidate than what they ever anticipated when they chose to fire Franklin.
Add in that Franklin is a Jimmy Sexton client where an agent that effectively controls the top end of the coaching market can pick apart every tiny detail of PSU’s contracting practices (e.g. say goodbye to the duty to mitigate damages in those coaching buyout clauses for any worthwhile coaching candidate) and let’s just say has both a financial interest in keeping that PSU job open for other clients and a personal interest because he believes that his client was treated unfairly by PSU… and now we see PSU having to dip into much lower tiers of the coaching ranks than they ever thought possible.
I'm sorry, in what way was Franklin the most screwed over fired coach in the history of time? LSU would have fired him 5 times before even reaching the playoff in his 11th season. LSU has fired 2 coaches who won national titles in the last decade and another guy who won 70% of his games with the Governor making a complete joke of himself in the process and they weren't "punished" for it, so that seems like a bunch of crap to me. It's a running joke for a reason that Franklin never wins a big game, because he doesn't. I believe this is AD arrogance and incompetence more than being "punished" for firing a guy who had kinda earned being fired at a premier program multiple times over. Kraft way over inflated the type of coach he could land, believed big fish that weren't actually serious options were, went all in on the BYU guy who was a bad fit in general and then was always going to be insanely likely to do exactly what he did, and now it's a disaster. A good AD accurately evaluates the type of hire they can make and then makes it.
Lest we forget that Franklin came in when Penn State still didn’t even have a full scholarship roster due to sanctions from the Sandusky scandal? This wasn’t like LSU bringing in Brian Kelly or now Lane Kiffin where every single financial and competitive advantage was in place, but rather PSU was a total gut rehab project following the worst single college sports scandal in history. In a sense, Franklin was the one that actually got PSU back to a place where their fans could have crazy expectations again.
And, like I’ve said, it’s about perception among *coaches* as opposed to fans. Sure - a lot of fans probably don’t think Franklin was treated unfairly. That isn’t who we’re talking about. I’m talking about the coaches at the top level that have choices in jobs beyond simply the money (many of whom share Jimmy Sexton as a client with Franklin). The way Franklin was fired less than a year after what would be a banner season for 99% of head coaches could certainly have an impact on how other coaches perceive the PSU job and/or the school’s administration.
Okay, and Eddy O was fired less than 2 years after reaching the tip top of the mountain not just making the first ever 12 team playoff and beating SMU at home and Boise State before losing to Notre Dame. Even in his massive achievement season he lost to Ohio State in the regular season, Oregon in the championship game, beat 2 non-premier programs in the first season of the 12 team playoff (every year prior gagging to OSU and Oregon leaves them sitting at home) and was bounced the second he faced a program on Penn State's tier. Even in that season it showed everything that Franklin is, good enough to beat programs at a lower tier than PSU but almost never beating one at PSU's tier. That was as good as it gets for Franklin, after 11 seasons you can't expect some new gear to be unlocked, and that ceiling showed he was never going to beat those types of programs.
The only thing that stopped them from pivoting to the top G5 coaches like all the other premier openings sans LSU had to do was their AD being a moron. They could have hired the JMU coach no questions asked, but by all reporting Kraft screwed around with him keeping him on the line as a pure backup plan hoping the BYU guy would somehow say yes. They went chasing whales when no whales sans Kiffin were ever moving. That has nothing to do with pissing off the coaching community, that has everything to do with an idiot of an AD.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:14 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:54 AM)schmolik Wrote: (12-04-2025 07:43 AM)darkdragon99 Wrote: People dont wanna leave their already secure jobs for a job where the standards are way too high and unrealistic.
Then how did LSU get Kiffin where standards are even higher and they have Governors who meddle?
They paid him more than any coach in the history of CFB, and Kiffin was the one guy who would be unaffected by the constant drama swirling around the joint. Florida’s AD was cool on Kiffin and backed out of the bidding war, with good reason, otherwise LSU probably goes even higher.
That’s PSU’s dilemma. It’s ok to fire Franklin, but the cost to find someone clearly superior, or even comparable, is enormous. LSU was willing to pay that cost, perhaps with the help of a $20m a year slush fund from the Governor. Whatever it takes!
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2025 10:17 AM by bryanw1995.)
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:15 AM |
|
UTEPDallas
Heisman

Posts: 6,572
Joined: Oct 2004
Reputation: 429
I Root For: UTEP/Penn State
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: As much as coaches are often mercenaries looking for as much money as possible, they are also human beings.
James Franklin has a lot of respect in the coaching profession, especially among the lions like Nick Saban that are pretty directly advising some of the highest profile coaching candidates out there.
The perception is that Franklin was totally screwed by Penn State in a way beyond the norm
even in the context of the overall looney bin of college football. He was essentially fired after only 2 bad games just months after being in the Final Four of the CFP and the Big Ten Championship Game. As much as we like to joke about how the best job in the world is being a fired coach sitting on the beach collectively a massive buyout, these guys sincerely *don’t* want to get fired. So, to see what they perceive as a top coach get fired after essentially a couple of bad games less than a year after achieving success that 99% of coaches will never reach, anyone with a stable P4 job doesn’t really want to touch PSU (and will just use the PSU coaching opening as leverage for an extension at their existing schools or other jobs). Now, PSU will find a coach, but they’ll likely be paying more money for a likely lower profile candidate than what they ever anticipated when they chose to fire Franklin.
Add in that Franklin is a Jimmy Sexton client where an agent that effectively controls the top end of the coaching market can pick apart every tiny detail of PSU’s contracting practices (e.g. say goodbye to the duty to mitigate damages in those coaching buyout clauses for any worthwhile coaching candidate) and let’s just say has both a financial interest in keeping that PSU job open for other clients and a personal interest because he believes that his client was treated unfairly by PSU… and now we see PSU having to dip into much lower tiers of the coaching ranks than they ever thought possible.
“Be careful what you wish for.” It’s what I often told the few PSU fans I know here in Dallas when they ranted about Franklin not being good enough. Maybe I see CFB from a G5 point of view or maybe I remember how Franklin resurrected a program that experts thought it would never recover from the Sankusky scandal. I get the frustration from some fans and I’m guilty of those frustrations as well (the losing record vs Ohio State and the SEC are two of them) but this was not the year to fire him.
I still believe somebody up there wanted Franklin gone for a long time and the bad loses to UCLA and Northwestern were the perfect excuse to seal the deal. From a PR point of view it looks bad how it was handled and we still didn’t have a coach two months later.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:17 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 09:46 AM)Hokie Mark Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:10 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: I'm sorry, in what way was Franklin the most screwed over fired coach in the history of time? LSU would have fired him 5 times before even reaching the playoff in his 11th season. LSU has fired 2 coaches who won national titles in the last decade and another guy who won 70% of his games with the Governor making a complete joke of himself in the process and they weren't "punished" for it, so that seems like a bunch of crap to me. It's a running joke for a reason that Franklin never wins a big game, because he doesn't. I believe this is AD arrogance and incompetence more than being "punished" for firing a guy who had kinda earned being fired at a premier program multiple times over. Kraft way over inflated the type of coach he could land, believed big fish that weren't actually serious options were, went all in on the BYU guy who was a bad fit in general and then was always going to be insanely likely to do exactly what he did, and now it's a disaster. A good AD accurately evaluates the type of hire they can make and then makes it.
Hey, getting fired by LSU should be a badge of honor! They regularly fire national champions!
As for Franklin "never" winning the big games: he was 14-22 versus Top 25 teams since 2016, not including 2020 (Pandemic) or 2025 (incomplete).
Unless you define "big game" as one Franklin lost?
That ain't a brag, and what is his record against the other premier programs, not whatever fringe Iowa or whoever they probably got 12 of those 14 wins against who were in the back 1/2 of the top 25. Also not including a season they played 9 games and went 4-5 is interesting.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:18 AM |
|
b0ndsj0ns
Legend

Posts: 30,775
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 1639
I Root For: ECU
Location:
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 10:13 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:10 AM)b0ndsj0ns Wrote: (12-04-2025 09:00 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: As much as coaches are often mercenaries looking for as much money as possible, they are also human beings.
James Franklin has a lot of respect in the coaching profession, especially among the lions like Nick Saban that are pretty directly advising some of the highest profile coaching candidates out there.
The perception is that Franklin was totally screwed by Penn State in a way beyond the norm
even in the context of the overall looney bin of college football. He was essentially fired after only 2 bad games just months after being in the Final Four of the CFP and the Big Ten Championship Game. As much as we like to joke about how the best job in the world is being a fired coach sitting on the beach collectively a massive buyout, these guys sincerely *don’t* want to get fired. So, to see what they perceive as a top coach get fired after essentially a couple of bad games less than a year after achieving success that 99% of coaches will never reach, anyone with a stable P4 job doesn’t really want to touch PSU (and will just use the PSU coaching opening as leverage for an extension at their existing schools or other jobs). Now, PSU will find a coach, but they’ll likely be paying more money for a likely lower profile candidate than what they ever anticipated when they chose to fire Franklin.
Add in that Franklin is a Jimmy Sexton client where an agent that effectively controls the top end of the coaching market can pick apart every tiny detail of PSU’s contracting practices (e.g. say goodbye to the duty to mitigate damages in those coaching buyout clauses for any worthwhile coaching candidate) and let’s just say has both a financial interest in keeping that PSU job open for other clients and a personal interest because he believes that his client was treated unfairly by PSU… and now we see PSU having to dip into much lower tiers of the coaching ranks than they ever thought possible.
I'm sorry, in what way was Franklin the most screwed over fired coach in the history of time?
HE was fired after 3 losses, 2 of them narrow losses, less than a year after winning a NEw Years' Day bowl to go to the national semifinals.
Quote:LSU would have fired him 5 times before even reaching the playoff in his 11th season. LSU has fired 2 coaches who won national titles in the last decade and another guy who won 70% of his games with the Governor making a complete joke of himself in the process and they weren't "punished" for it,
Weren't they? LAne Kiffin is arguably punishment. Let's circle back in a few years after Lane Kiffin flames out in Baton Rouge.
Quote:so that seems like a bunch of crap to me. It's a running joke for a reason that Franklin never wins a big game, because he doesn't. I believe this is AD arrogance and incompetence more than being "punished" for firing a guy who had kinda earned being fired at a premier program multiple times over. Kraft way over inflated the type of coach he could land, believed big fish that weren't actually serious options were, went all in on the BYU guy who was a bad fit in general and then was always going to be insanely likely to do exactly what he did, and now it's a disaster. A good AD accurately evaluates the type of hire they can make and then makes it.
WEll, if they hadn't fired Franklin halfway through the season, coming off a playoff run, they probably get one of the coaches they made a run at in the last few weeks.
I think you're underrating the inherent strength of the Penn State program -- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium is a program that should be a job coaches are falling over themselves to get. Or maybe you're equivocating -- if Franklin was underperforming at Penn State, then Penn State should have been able to snag pretty much any of the coaches who turned them down.
I'm not saying they should have snagged the coaches that turned them down, I'm saying their AD was a moron as to how he ran that search. Florida didn't land a coach on that tier that PSU thought they should have landed, hell only 1 sitting P4 coach moved. Coaches on the tier PSU thought they were going to land almost never leave. I don't blame him for putting out feelers for whales during the weeks they had, but he never got realistic at any point like Florida/Auburn/every other open P4 job did.
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2025 10:25 AM by b0ndsj0ns.)
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:21 AM |
|
darkdragon99
1st String

Posts: 1,622
Joined: Sep 2011
Reputation: 36
I Root For: geography
Location:
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
All SEC jobs are technically "good but its clear there is a hierarchy. Ole Miss, MSU, Missouri, ARK, Kentucky, Vandy, and SC are the "lesser jobs and the others are all a step above. So he did take a step up for a huge payday. You can argue about the hierarchy. and say LSU belongs with schools above but I dont think they do and they belong more with the others based on money and fan support and history.
(This post was last modified: 12-04-2025 10:32 AM by darkdragon99.)
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:31 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,072
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Trivia time!
Who orchestrated the defense that lead Notre Dame to the championship game last season? Hint: he is a former Penn State player and current NFL defensive coordinator.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:45 AM |
|
DFW HOYA
Heisman

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 10:13 AM)johnbragg Wrote: I think you're underrating the inherent strength of the Penn State program -- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium is a program that should be a job coaches are falling over themselves to get. Or maybe you're equivocating -- if Franklin was underperforming at Penn State, then Penn State should have been able to snag pretty much any of the coaches who turned them down.
I think you're underrating the inherent ceiling of the Penn State program-- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium but does not have the ability to recruit the level of regional talent that will surpass that seen at Michigan, Ohio State, Alabama, Texas, USC, etc. It's a great program, but much like Notre Dame, will no longer be dominant as it once was, as the base of population from the Northeast and Rust Belt continues to decline.
Penn State has not won a national title in 39 years, Notre Dame in 37. There are bigger issues in these numbers than the coaching of James Franklin or Marcus Freeman.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 10:57 AM |
|
GoldenWarrior11
Heisman

Posts: 6,613
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 788
I Root For: Marquette, BE
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Perception may very well be that Franklin was fired only after two bad losses (despite getting the CFP Semifinals last year). However, Franklin was 4-21 against top-10 teams while at Penn State. He was also 1-18 against top-10 teams that were in the Big Ten. The Penn State AD referenced this in the announcement that Franklin was dismissed. The Sexton/Franklin camp has done a masterful job at presenting his termination as unfair, brash and unbecoming of a respected top college football program (despite nearly half of the SEC doing the exact same thing this cycle). Penn State - for its in-state recruiting, program history, fan support, etc. - should be much more competitive with Ohio State/Michigan in the Big Ten; it just hasn't been.
There is no doubt that Sexton is leveraging the PSU opening for pay increases to his other clients (not to mention hurting a former employer that fired one of his current clients). That's another reality in the present market. I think PSU should strongly look at Daboll, if they haven't already. Golden would be another good get.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:03 AM |
|
Keswick_Crusaders_Forever51
1st String

Posts: 1,677
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation: 195
I Root For: Liberty, UF, NCSU, USF
Location: Sanford, NC
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
I'll take $500K guaranteed & coach them. Won't hurt their pocketbooks, I'll get to meet great coaches, & they can fire me after one year, no matter the record. Win-win for everyone.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:03 AM |
|
GoldenWarrior11
Heisman

Posts: 6,613
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 788
I Root For: Marquette, BE
Location: Chicago
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 10:57 AM)DFW HOYA Wrote: (12-04-2025 10:13 AM)johnbragg Wrote: I think you're underrating the inherent strength of the Penn State program -- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium is a program that should be a job coaches are falling over themselves to get. Or maybe you're equivocating -- if Franklin was underperforming at Penn State, then Penn State should have been able to snag pretty much any of the coaches who turned them down.
I think you're underrating the inherent ceiling of the Penn State program-- a program that fills a 100,000 stadium but does not have the ability to recruit the level of regional talent that will surpass that seen at Michigan, Ohio State, Alabama, Texas, USC, etc. It's a great program, but much like Notre Dame, will no longer be dominant as it once was, as the base of population from the Northeast and Rust Belt continues to decline.
Penn State has not won a national title in 39 years, Notre Dame in 37. There are bigger issues in these numbers than the coaching of James Franklin or Marcus Freeman.
Notre Dame has at least made two National Championship games in the past decade. When was the last National Championship that Penn State made?
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:05 AM |
|
schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,633
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:23 AM |
|
schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,633
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Translation: Matt Campbell is getting a pay raise at Iowa State!
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:33 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 11:03 AM)GoldenWarrior11 Wrote: Perception may very well be that Franklin was fired only after two bad losses (despite getting the CFP Semifinals last year). However, Franklin was 4-21 against top-10 teams while at Penn State. He was also 1-18 against top-10 teams that were in the Big Ten. The Penn State AD referenced this in the announcement that Franklin was dismissed. The Sexton/Franklin camp has done a masterful job at presenting his termination as unfair, brash and unbecoming of a respected top college football program (despite nearly half of the SEC doing the exact same thing this cycle). Penn State - for its in-state recruiting, program history, fan support, etc. - should be much more competitive with Ohio State/Michigan in the Big Ten; it just hasn't been.
There is no doubt that Sexton is leveraging the PSU opening for pay increases to his other clients (not to mention hurting a former employer that fired one of his current clients). That's another reality in the present market. I think PSU should strongly look at Daboll, if they haven't already. Golden would be another good get.
Neither of whom is as good as Franklin was. Better to promote an assistant on a small contract then move on in a couple years if he doesn't pan out at this point, or hire a top end P2 or NFL Coordinator.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:34 AM |
|
DFW HOYA
Heisman

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 11:05 AM)GoldenWarrior11 Wrote: Notre Dame has at least made two National Championship games in the past decade. When was the last National Championship that Penn State made?
Penn State's last title (AP) was in 1986. Its 2024 semifinal was its only CFP appearance.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:35 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
(12-04-2025 11:33 AM)schmolik Wrote: Translation: Matt Campbell is getting a pay raise at Iowa State!
I don't think that Iowa St can afford to fight off PSU. They don't have the deep-pocketed donor base, and they have well-publicized money problems these days.
Some numbers on Campbell:
7 of the 19 total EVER Iowa State bowl appearances
Only Major Bowl appearance (and win) in Iowa St history
He inherited a team that hadn't hat a winning record in a decade and has only had 2 losing records in his own decade
He's always on the radar for job searches, especially in B1G country, and he only makes $5m a year.
I know that the Big 12 is extremely competitive, but the BYU job is clearly better than the Iowa St job due to the greater resources available to BYU. Combine BYU's financial backing with Sitake's loyalty, and there was always a glimmer of hope that he'd stick around. Campbell, however...even if he goes to PSU and gets canned in 3-4 years, he could easily find another job comparable to Iowa St.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:40 AM |
|
OdinFrigg
Gone Fishing

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
|
RE: Does Anyone Want to Be Penn State's Head Football Coach?
Harvey Bradford (Brad) Scott appears to be available.
|
|
| 12-04-2025 11:46 AM |
|