bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:44 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: (11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote: (11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote: Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.
Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?
Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.
If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.
The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?
I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.
One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.
The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.
Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.
As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.
9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.
The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
Most SEC teams enjoyed 3 cupcakes this year (Alabama, Florida, and South Carolina played 2; Ole Miss technically played 4, but Washington St. was P5 when this H&H was scheduled so I'm willing to give them a break like I did for Washington), just like Indiana, Penn St., and Nebraska. Texas A&M played 7 of the bottom 8 SEC teams by conference standings.
Now I won't argue about Indiana's non-conference schedule as all P4 teams should play 10 P4 opponents, but they did have a road win @ Oregon. Conference scheduling does need more balanced in the B1G from a geographic and competitive standpoint I'll also admit as OSU and Indiana did end up with weaker conference schedules. Penn St. completely dropping off didn't help both teams or Oregon.
It probably won't matter to you because there's no fancy CFP committee rank next to their name, but Indiana also beat an 8 win Iowa on the road and destroyed a ranked at the time Illinois team that could 8-4 if they beat Northwestern. OSU has the Texas win (which we got a lot of crap about because Arch wasn't the Heisman QB he was hyped him up to be and therefore wasn't a quality win), won @ 9-3 or 8-4 Washington (hosts Oregon), won @ Illinois (first game giving up double digit points), and we play @ TTUN (should win, but also should've won last year so we'll see).
And the Big Ten had Purdue, Michigan St., Maryland and Rutgers who were almost never competitive. Mississippi St., one of the bottom teams in the SEC, beat Arizona St., who had a shot at the Big 12 title game until yesterday.
|
|