Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Week 14
Author Message
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #81
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 10:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  Texas dominated the third quarter.

If they win, they would be an extreme threat to all the BYUs and Utahs and Miami's lingering between ten and fifteen hoping to make the playoffs.

Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
11-29-2025 01:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #82
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

With the large conferences, there is no "even." You have to evaluate schedule strength. The SEC ranged from 46 to 67 (Tennessee) for the average Massey composite schedule last year among ranked teams. The Big Ten ranged from 55 to 75 (Indiana).
11-29-2025 01:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #83
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:10 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

With the large conferences, there is no "even." You have to evaluate schedule strength. The SEC ranged from 46 to 67 (Tennessee) for the average Massey composite schedule last year among ranked teams. The Big Ten ranged from 55 to 75 (Indiana).

Right, there is that aspect of things as well. To say that the SEC now will be equal scheduling wise to the other P4 conferences is frankly ignorant. Wake me up when the Big Ten requires their teams to schedule a P4 team OOC. It won't happen.
11-29-2025 01:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #84
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.
11-29-2025 01:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
stever20 Online
Legend
*

Posts: 50,363
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
Post: #85
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

not according to Sagarin. Before today it was Ole Miss 34 Indiana 49. And Mississippi St a lot tougher than Purdue.
11-29-2025 01:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #86
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

ESPN shows Indiana's SOS as #38 (much better than last year) but Ole Miss as #33. Of course IU is #2 SOR, behind only Texas A&M. Wisconsin of the Big Ten is rated as having the toughest schedule.

SEC varies a lot:
2 Florida
3 Arkansas
4 South Carolina
5 Oklahoma
7 Kentucky
9 Alabama
10 Texas
12 Auburn
13 LSU
14 Mississippi St.
16 Georgia
21 Missouri
23 Texas A&M
26 Vanderbilt
31 Tennessee
33 Ole Miss
11-29-2025 01:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #87
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:13 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:10 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

With the large conferences, there is no "even." You have to evaluate schedule strength. The SEC ranged from 46 to 67 (Tennessee) for the average Massey composite schedule last year among ranked teams. The Big Ten ranged from 55 to 75 (Indiana).

Right, there is that aspect of things as well. To say that the SEC now will be equal scheduling wise to the other P4 conferences is frankly ignorant. Wake me up when the Big Ten requires their teams to schedule a P4 team OOC. It won't happen.

This is all about gaming the system for playoff money and is a holdover attitude from when the conferences had to agree to split everything. Well when the conferences were all 10 or 12 members the number of strong shcools were somewhat more equal among the various conferences. Since OU/UT and USC/UCLA it simply isn't the case anymore. And now the conference with 18 has a fatter bottom than the conference of 16.

It's clear to me that in the future we are likely to go through a period where each holds its own playoff for the conference championship as some kind of playin qualification and that eventually the SEC and Big Ten will simply host a joint one set up to their agreed upon specifications and that revenue generation will be the aim.

It will either be that or the SEC will do its own and the Big Ten its own and the winner will attract the top of the other and a super league wil be born.

Any way you cut it all of this is driven by the pursuit of a buck and and the ninth conference game was money driven, the 10th P game money driven, and the playoff format that grants the SEC and Big Ten 60% or more of the revenue generated and split with the network(s) will likely be the plan that wins and then a cry will go out from the rest and the rush to be in one of the two will be on in earnest and afterward the playoff will be closed to those two conferences and they will keep all of the revenue share not belonging to the network(s).

In this regard it is all hounds to the hunters as the networks seek a larger purse, a larger audience, and greater advertising revenue. Meanwhile we get to fuss about who is due the breaks and who isn't. Nothing has changed about human nature and people will still believe in the fairness of a mob paid to do the network's bidding and who go by the name of "Selection Committee."

Yes Virginia there is a Santa Claus and he looks a lot like your parents. He doesn't work for ESPN or FOX and he does care about you. The Grinch has controlling stock in the networks. And no, he doesn't love you and doesn't really love football, or its fans. He does however love what is green. And, if we were all smart we would send him coal and switches.
11-29-2025 01:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #88
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:28 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.
Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

not according to Sagarin. Before today it was Ole Miss 34 Indiana 49. And Mississippi St a lot tougher than Purdue.
Unless I'm reading Sagarin's ratings wrong he seems to have Penn State as 12th in the country currently. In which case, allow me to laugh at him.
11-29-2025 01:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #89
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

Most SEC teams enjoyed 3 cupcakes this year (Alabama, Florida, and South Carolina played 2; Ole Miss technically played 4, but Washington St. was P5 when this H&H was scheduled so I'm willing to give them a break like I did for Washington), just like Indiana, Penn St., and Nebraska. Texas A&M played 7 of the bottom 8 SEC teams by conference standings.

Now I won't argue about Indiana's non-conference schedule as all P4 teams should play 10 P4 opponents, but they did have a road win @ Oregon. Conference scheduling does need more balanced in the B1G from a geographic and competitive standpoint I'll also admit as OSU and Indiana did end up with weaker conference schedules. Penn St. completely dropping off didn't help both teams or Oregon.

It probably won't matter to you because there's no fancy CFP committee rank next to their name, but Indiana also beat an 8 win Iowa on the road and destroyed a ranked at the time Illinois team that could 8-4 if they beat Northwestern. OSU has the Texas win (which we got a lot of crap about because Arch wasn't the Heisman QB he was hyped him up to be and therefore wasn't a quality win), won @ 9-3 or 8-4 Washington (hosts Oregon), won @ Illinois (first game giving up double digit points), and we play @ TTUN (should win, but also should've won last year so we'll see).
11-29-2025 01:44 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #90
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

What's a 4 team playoff have to do with a 12 team playoff?
And what about losing at home to a .500 Virginia Tech team? That Ohio St. team snuck into the 4 team playoff and won.
Alabama was sitting at #4 despite losing to Florida State.

It's trying to compare the methods of the CFP committee. It's not a perfect apples to apples comparison as people change on the committee, but they still rank pretty similarly. With the 2014 example, it's fair to agrue the lack of a 13th game is what screwed TCU and Baylor. Also, that loss happened Week 2 and we had time to improve (better to lose early than lose late). ND loss to Northern Illinois was early. The OSU blowouts to Purdue and Iowa were mid to late season. Texas lost to Florida mid-season.
11-29-2025 02:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,309
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #91
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:37 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:28 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

not according to Sagarin. Before today it was Ole Miss 34 Indiana 49. And Mississippi St a lot tougher than Purdue.
Unless I'm reading Sagarin's ratings wrong he seems to have Penn State as 12th in the country currently. In which case, allow me to laugh at him.
Sagarin is riding the popularity of being first, not best. The ability to rank teams (and build websites) has come a long way since the 90s.
11-29-2025 07:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #92
RE: Week 14
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)TrojanCampaign Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:29 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 10:24 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  Texas dominated the third quarter.

If they win, they would be an extreme threat to all the BYUs and Utahs and Miami's lingering between ten and fifteen hoping to make the playoffs.

Texas should be in. But they won't be unless Alabama or Notre Dame loses tomorrow. And even then its not certain. Committee is really hung up on the 3 losses. But two of those are to the #1 and #4 (who will be #3 next week) teams on the road, giving #1 their closest game of the season and only down 14-10 until the 4th vs. #3. And Texas has wins over this week's #3, #8 and #14 with the one loss at unranked Florida.

I mean why not award 5 loss teams that play tough schedules then? Yes, Texas played good teams but they lost. Other teams shouldn't be prevented from playing good teams just because Texas did.

I can see jumping Utah but not BYU

I will let the computers sort out things out before saying Texas should be in, but just on a face-value sense, I think Sark has a point when he says what if they'd played a mediocre G5 team, or a bad A4 team, and beaten them instead of losing at Ohio State? They would likely be in the playoffs.

The CFP has claimed it wants teams to schedule tough OOC games and play tough schedules. Texas did and went 9-3. But if the "no three losses" rule from last year is going to be invoked, then nothing has changed and teams have no incentives to play tough OOC games, especially if you also play in a tough conference.
11-29-2025 07:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #93
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:45 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Well look on the bright side. If Texas doesn't get in the SEC will breakaway, expand with Southern schools and hold their own championship. ESPN knows this. Sankey has toyed with it seriously and all it has needed was an impetus, which the snub of Texas with its schedule versus those of Indiana (though a better team than last year and IMO deserving) and 2 loss Miami and Notre Dame whose losses included some much weaker competition. Notre Dame's only victory was over a 19th ranked USC.

Are you going to tell me that beating Tree tomorrow is going to make up the schedule that Texas has played?

Miami at least beat Notre Dame head-to-head as did A&M.

If schedule strength is going to matter at all then it should matter in Notre Dame's case. They lost to two ranked teams and beat #19 USC which is average at best.

The committee should have to reconcile its picks with the strength of conference as well. The ACC simply has not been strong with FSU and Clemson in the tank who did Miami really have to beat?

I have many of the same issues concerning those who might want to leave out Oklahoma. The Sooners had a deuce difficult schedule.

One reason Sankey has been intransigent on the CFP is because this year's committee selections may leave it hanging in the balance.

The SEC has a national audience anyway. If it held its own playoff and included either by membership or invitation Big 12 and ACC schools with strong resume's you tell me how many in the nation would watch? And do you think that ABC / ESPN might like to have those rights exclusively? I think so.
Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

I'm not sure about the SOS, but don't know anyone who is saying Ole Miss should be ahead of Indiana. They are top-3 with just about every metric.

One thing I will say about Texas - the most important game for them by far today is Michigan - Ohio State. The CFP sent a clear signal last week in moving Michigan ahead of Texas, namely that if Michigan beats Ohio State, they will finish ranked ahead of Texas, and Texas cannot make the playoffs if they are ranked behind Michigan in the final poll.

And FWIW, I couldn't argue with that.
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2025 07:53 AM by quo vadis.)
11-29-2025 07:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #94
RE: Week 14
Texas is first in with a Bama/ND loss. I think they are in with a UO or TTech loss as well, but that will be very close.

They have to give a bye to TTech with +2 wins as well.
11-29-2025 07:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #95
RE: Week 14
Props to Arizona on beating Arizona State decisively last night.

They have quietly had a very good year. The game was fun to watch as well. A true rivalry game. Last night was when multiple TVs come in handy, LOL.
11-29-2025 08:18 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #96
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 07:53 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Texas is first in with a Bama/ND loss. I think they are in with a UO or TTech loss as well, but that will be very close.

They have to give a bye to TTech with +2 wins as well.

Fat chance Tech drops behind a 9-3 Texas team with a loss to BYU. I’ll take that action from anyone that wants it lol

Ofc I also don’t think BYU is beating Tech but that’s another story.
11-29-2025 09:09 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #97
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 09:09 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 07:53 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Texas is first in with a Bama/ND loss. I think they are in with a UO or TTech loss as well, but that will be very close.

They have to give a bye to TTech with +2 wins as well.

Fat chance Tech drops behind a 9-3 Texas team with a loss to BYU. I’ll take that action from anyone that wants it lol

Ofc I also don’t think BYU is beating Tech but that’s another story.

Right… because you can’t penalize a team for playing an extra game, so it’s really the WVU game. UO would be flirting with disaster if they lose by two scores.
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2025 09:21 AM by RUScarlets.)
11-29-2025 09:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #98
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 07:52 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:15 AM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 01:06 AM)stever20 Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 12:59 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  
(11-28-2025 11:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sark before the game was basically threatening ESPN that the games like Texas-Ohio St. would go away. ESPN has to be unhappy with the committee discouraging tough schedules.

Interesting Sark was completely ignoring the 3-9 Florida loss that is holding them back and had to use outgaining OSU as a reason to be in the CFP when half their yards came in the last 4 minutes of the game when we went to prevent defense up 14-0, and when someone brought up the Florida loss to Sark, his argument turned to arguing that ND lost to Northern Illinois so they should get in, but seemed to forget that was their only loss in the season until the NCG. OSU fans know a bad conference loss keeps you out of the CFP, happened twice to us in the 4 team CFP, shouldn't be any different here just because you're an SEC team, but the SEC will be kicking and screaming to try to get their 6th or even 7th team into a 12 team CFP and whine when they only get 4 or 5 teams in (especially if BYU bid steals just like SMU, not Indiana, did last year). Hey, maybe our Texas win will finally be a quality win again, but I kinda doubt it. I will admit Alabama, along with BYU, are underrated right now while ND is overrated IMO.

As long as we have a large number of at-large teams resulting in teams politicking and beauty pageanting their way into CFP spots, it's going to cause teams to schedule soft in the non-conference and continue to hurt the sport as a whole. The SEC going to 9 conference games and requiring 1 P4 opponent in the non-conference is also probably going to hurt the SEC even though it'll probably put them on even ground scheduling wise compared to the rest of the P4 (B1G should require this too even though most already do this). That is why it would be the good of the sport, we need to figure out a multi-AQ format that the P4 can agree to or compromise on, but I can understand the SEC wanting to maximize their CFP bids and pushing back against them right now or with any format that nukes their valuable CCG. I know I've pushed 3/3/3/3/1+5 and 4/4/3/3/1+3, but 4/4/2/2/1+X almost made it until the SEC coaches pushed back. Seeing the SEC standings and rankings from a WCG perspective, I wonder if the SEC would agree to 4/4/2/2/1+5. I know the M2 wouldn't like that. Maybe 4/4/2.5/2.5/1+4 if 4/4/3/3/1+3 isn't acceptable, which knowing the SEC goes to 9 games next season, I think it's reasonable.

9+1 is going to put the SEC even schduling ground to the rest of the P4? Are you high? When you have Indiana with their total ASS schduling- and proud of it. That's not even at all whatsoever.

The problem is this committee is so behlolden to the W-L record, something that just wasn't the case the first decade of the CFP. Ever since we've gone to 12, the CFP Committee has changed the way they ranked teams.

Indiana played a tougher schedule than Ole Miss this year. And won all of the games to boot.

I'm not sure about the SOS, but don't know anyone who is saying Ole Miss should be ahead of Indiana. They are top-3 with just about every metric.

One thing I will say about Texas - the most important game for them by far today is Michigan - Ohio State. The CFP sent a clear signal last week in moving Michigan ahead of Texas, namely that if Michigan beats Ohio State, they will finish ranked ahead of Texas, and Texas cannot make the playoffs if they are ranked behind Michigan in the final poll.

And FWIW, I couldn't argue with that.

I went over my Harbin Rankings this morning updating the games from earlier this week. Looking at L2 points, even if Ole Miss had beat Georgia and gone undefeated, they would've still had less L2 points than Indiana. L2 points is essentially a SoR where you get points from the opponents you beat winning games.

Also worth noting as of this moment. Georgia is barely above Indiana and Ohio St. at 11-1 (0.4 points above Indiana and 2.7 points above OSU), but with Saturday games still to go, OSU will be the clear #1 with a win today while Indiana and Georgia will probably be back and forth today. OSU with 11 wins to Indiana's 12 games are nearly equal right now.

Texas is #12 right now, but USC, Miami, Tulane, and Virginia (maybe ND) could jump Texas with a win, and obviously, right now, you need to be in the top 10 with the 4th and 5th champs outside the top 12. Also worth noting BYU and Oklahoma are tied for 5th currently (Bama 4th). A&M is 7th, but probably stays in the top 8 as Oregon would jump them with a win, though Michigan likely would jump too with a win. Texas Tech may just be out of reach, but we'll see.
11-29-2025 09:26 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
WhoseHouse? Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,210
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 729
I Root For: UH
Location:
Post: #99
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 09:20 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 09:09 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  
(11-29-2025 07:53 AM)RUScarlets Wrote:  Texas is first in with a Bama/ND loss. I think they are in with a UO or TTech loss as well, but that will be very close.

They have to give a bye to TTech with +2 wins as well.

Fat chance Tech drops behind a 9-3 Texas team with a loss to BYU. I’ll take that action from anyone that wants it lol

Ofc I also don’t think BYU is beating Tech but that’s another story.

Right… because you can’t penalize a team for playing an extra game, so it’s really the WVU game. UO would be flirting with disaster if they lose by two scores.

You can drop them but not behind a 9-3 team. Precedent was set last year by SMU. And this Tech team has significantly better profile than that team.
11-29-2025 09:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #100
RE: Week 14
(11-29-2025 09:29 AM)WhoseHouse? Wrote:  You can drop them but not behind a 9-3 team. Precedent was set last year by SMU. And this Tech team has significantly better profile than that team.

They clinched a Big 12 CCG slot, so they could still play their way in. So, ultimately it won’t matter. UT would still need a Bama or ND loss.
11-29-2025 09:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.