Scoochpooch1
Heisman

Posts: 5,779
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 255
I Root For: P4
Location:
|
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 03:03 PM)nodak651 Wrote: Quote: (10-06-2025 01:16 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:
Yet more reason to question Sac State’s plan. If a fine program like NDSU that has tons of fan support, tons of Titles, and is swimming in money is struggling to find a Conference, then how is Sac St going to manage this? Programs that move up are very strong financially and/or win at a very high level in FCS, usually both. Sac St has neither money nor success, and no reason to expect that will change any time soon.
SAC has the market and NDSU has success, but very few schools have both.
What is the NCAA's current justification for requiring an invite again? I believe in the past the arguement has been that it ensures competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards. Yet, everyone in the industry knows that schools don't really prioritize on-field success when considering new members. It's all really ONLY about how much their non profit institutions may benefit financially. It is also well known, and I assume there is some amount of evidence, that P5 leaders have also been pressuring G5 leagues to not invite new FCS members.
When Sac's FBS waiver was denied, they were told:
"The committee noted a conference invitation is of paramount importance for entering into the reclassification process because the invitation signals an institution’s readiness to enter the process."
"The Division I membership adopted the current legislation to affirm the importance of the nature and purpose of the subdivision reclassification process, choosing to place that decision-making authority with the council. Due to the significance of the bona fide invitation from an FBS conference requirement and the lack of compelling mitigation explaining why that requirement, one that several other FCS institutions have met in recent years, has not been met, the committee does not support relief."
Were Sam Houston and Kennesaw really that much more qualified than Sac, if at all? Or did they benifit because FBS conferences happened to need new membership at the time, and they weren't being threatened by P5 schools not to add from the FCS?
Given that the only viable conference in Sac's region just added UC Davis (oddly without an FBS offer for some reason), we all know the MWC will not want to add another school in that same city... because they are already in that media market now, right? To both the MWC and the PAC, SAC's competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards is completely irrelivent, because they wouldn't increase their media distribution. It's ENTIRELY about financial enrichement.
Given the NCAA recent court struggles, how is there any doubt that they would fail get an injunction, in California of all places, if they seek one? What will the NCAA's legal argument be? Because the evidence is pretty clear that the FBS membership rules
Virginia's AG made a statement when they threatened to sue on behalf of JMU, when it was looking like JMU could possibly possibly be locked out of a bowl after going undeated during their transition, and it applies in many ways to the situation of Sac, NDSU, and others. "Whether analyzed under a 'quick look' or full rule of reason analysis, the end result is likely to be the same: the rule is anticompetitive, prohibiting more qualified teams from competing in bowl games to the advantage of incumbents in the market without any procompetitive justification to support it." Just swap "bowl games" for "FBS".
I'm not a lawyer, so I tinkered with AI to come up with the legal argument for the point I'm, trying to make. Would they not have a high likelyhood of being successful? Seems like there would be a case for punative damages as well, no?
--------------------------------------------------------------
The NCAA's FBS invitation rule remains an illegal market allocation under Sherman Act §1, as it empowers incumbent FBS conferences—horizontal competitors in the national college football market for talent, broadcasts, and revenues—to collusively exclude well-funded FCS schools, preserving exclusive perks like CFP distributions and media deals worth billions, without procompetitive justifications; anticipated defenses of "competitive balance" or "amateurism" fail post-Alston (141 S. Ct. 2141 (2021)), where the Supreme Court deemed them pretextual, and the June 2025 House v. NCAA settlement ($2.8B backpay, $20.5M annual revenue sharing) proves direct athlete pay doesn't disrupt the industry, blurring FCS-FBS lines yet leaving the rule as naked protectionism akin to TV rights caps struck in Board of Regents (468 U.S. 85 (1984)). This coordinated refusal suppresses output (e.g., Sacramento State's denied 2026 waiver despite $20M+ budget and Kessler's antitrust counsel), misallocates talent, and stifles innovation, warranting per se illegality as territorial division per Palmer v. BRG (498 U.S. 46 (1990))—not mere "voluntary association," as courts now scrutinize NCAA rules as commercial restraints (e.g., D. Nev. five-year eligibility ruling, Sept. 2025).
Geography intensifies the violation for Dakotas/Montana FCS giants (NDSU, SDSU, Montana, Montana State), exploiting remote barriers (travel costs, no seamless Group of 5 fits) to carve the Northern Plains as a "no-entry" zone, suppressing regional rivalries and talent flow absent consumer benefits; counterclaims of "natural hurdles" ignore how the rule weaponizes them for cartel exclusion, inviting injunctions like Pavia (2024, appeal dismissed Oct. 2025) or Braham (preliminary relief July 2025), with House scrutiny (e.g., SD AGs on power favoritism) tilting toward success despite protracted appeals.
Parallels in enjoined transfer rules and media bundling highlight systemic flaws, unmitigated by House's governance tweaks, priming challenges like Sac State's brewing suit.
1) Maybe their ruling was anticompetitive, so they can join as Indy but they cant force anyone to play them. So they will have to pay thru the nose just to schedule games.
2) Not sure how any of this is acting responsible in terms of academia or financially speaking. The school sucks and will lose a ton of cash.
3) I doubt the "market" of Sacramento cares a lock about Sac State. At least UC Davis has the pedigree.
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2025 07:01 PM by Scoochpooch1.)
|
|