Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
Author Message
nodak651 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,313
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 136
I Root For: North Dakota
Location:
Post: #121
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-05-2025 02:52 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 08:22 AM)DavidSt Wrote:  Besides UTA, UTSA and Texas State to join the WAC, the WAC visited Lamar at the time as they were upgrading their facilities. Lamar was a willing school to make the jump then.

That's right, Lamar was also discussed as a potential WAC addition back in 2011. You've got a better memory than I do David.

I think the WAC also took a run at the Dakotas but that didn't go anywhere. IIRC Fullerton convinced UND to join the Big Sky instead. The others elected to stick with the MVFC.

UND never had an MVFC offer - the Big Sky was the only option (wouldn't have needed much convincing).
10-06-2025 01:14 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #122
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-03-2025 02:31 PM)Cyniclone Wrote:  

Someone is driving alumni contributions while the time is ripe.

Good luck to the Hornets.
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2025 02:21 AM by Gitanole.)
10-06-2025 01:43 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Outsider Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,536
Joined: Jul 2021
Reputation: 60
I Root For: ACU & Tulane
Location:
Post: #123
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
So when is Sac. St. building that new stadium again?
10-06-2025 08:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
NDSUguy Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 260
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 29
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
Post: #124
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-05-2025 02:17 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:07 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:06 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 01:42 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 12:54 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  No...

There's going to be 6 Group conferences next year:

AAC: 14 teams
CUSA: 10? 11? teams
MAC: 12 teams
MWC 9 teams
PAC: 8 teams
SBC: 13? 14? teams

Unless you're counting the UAC as the 7th Group conference.

arent we talking anout the ridiculous idea of Sacramento State starting up a new FBS conference?

if not then i'd throw out a couple of names who would jump at an FBS invite tomorrow and another half-doxen who would think about it

I have no idea what Sacramento State is planning to do. Their president is a clown if I ever saw one.

true

as for the question....
Sacramento Srate, Tarleton State, NDSU would happily stroke a check for $5M to join any FBS conference.

Montana, MSU, North Dakota, South Dakota, SD State could be dominoes falling if NDSU goes. or they might flinch.

Eastern Kentucky was a "bridesmaid" 5 or 10 years ago. so maybe them

Regarding NDSU, the $5M check is not a problem. If the opportunity comes along, they will move up.
10-06-2025 09:15 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UIWElite2 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 759
Joined: Aug 2025
Reputation: 71
I Root For: UIW/AFA
Location:
Post: #125
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 08:25 AM)Outsider Wrote:  So when is Sac. St. building that new stadium again?

It’s going to be ready for next season too! Although no construction of any kind was been started.
10-06-2025 10:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #126
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-05-2025 02:17 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:07 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:06 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 01:42 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 12:54 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  No...

There's going to be 6 Group conferences next year:

AAC: 14 teams
CUSA: 10? 11? teams
MAC: 12 teams
MWC 9 teams
PAC: 8 teams
SBC: 13? 14? teams

Unless you're counting the UAC as the 7th Group conference.

arent we talking anout the ridiculous idea of Sacramento State starting up a new FBS conference?

if not then i'd throw out a couple of names who would jump at an FBS invite tomorrow and another half-doxen who would think about it

I have no idea what Sacramento State is planning to do. Their president is a clown if I ever saw one.

true

as for the question....
Sacramento Srate, Tarleton State, NDSU would happily stroke a check for $5M to join any FBS conference.

Montana, MSU, North Dakota, South Dakota, SD State could be dominoes falling if NDSU goes. or they might flinch.

Eastern Kentucky was a "bridesmaid" 5 or 10 years ago. so maybe them

Right - I think the previous poster has the emphasis erroneously flipped around. It’s not a question of whether there are FCS schools willing to write a $5 million check to move up to FBS because the reality is that there are several of those around. Instead, the question is whether an existing G6 conference is willing to take an FCS call-up outside of a pure survival situation (a la C-USA after they had so many defections). We’re finding that they want to avoid it at almost all costs and, to extent that they do have call-ups, they fit a certain profile (e.g. located in large population states or metro areas being much more important than performance at the FCS level).
10-06-2025 11:31 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #127
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 11:31 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:17 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:07 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:06 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 01:42 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  There's going to be 6 Group conferences next year:

AAC: 14 teams
CUSA: 10? 11? teams
MAC: 12 teams
MWC 9 teams
PAC: 8 teams
SBC: 13? 14? teams

Unless you're counting the UAC as the 7th Group conference.

arent we talking anout the ridiculous idea of Sacramento State starting up a new FBS conference?

if not then i'd throw out a couple of names who would jump at an FBS invite tomorrow and another half-doxen who would think about it

I have no idea what Sacramento State is planning to do. Their president is a clown if I ever saw one.

true

as for the question....
Sacramento Srate, Tarleton State, NDSU would happily stroke a check for $5M to join any FBS conference.

Montana, MSU, North Dakota, South Dakota, SD State could be dominoes falling if NDSU goes. or they might flinch.

Eastern Kentucky was a "bridesmaid" 5 or 10 years ago. so maybe them

Right - I think the previous poster has the emphasis erroneously flipped around. It’s not a question of whether there are FCS schools willing to write a $5 million check to move up to FBS because the reality is that there are several of those around. Instead, the question is whether an existing G6 conference is willing to take an FCS call-up outside of a pure survival situation (a la C-USA after they had so many defections). We’re finding that they want to avoid it at almost all costs and, to extent that they do have call-ups, they fit a certain profile (e.g. located in large population states or metro areas being much more important than performance at the FCS level).

That's what I was getting at. There has to be interest on both sides, and not just out of a necessity for survival.

UC-Davis will most likely be the next FCS to FBS call up. They already have full membership in the MWC in just about everything except football.

As for Sacramento State and what happens to them, your guess is as good as mine.
10-06-2025 12:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #128
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 12:08 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-06-2025 11:31 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:17 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:07 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(10-05-2025 02:06 PM)johnbragg Wrote:  arent we talking anout the ridiculous idea of Sacramento State starting up a new FBS conference?

if not then i'd throw out a couple of names who would jump at an FBS invite tomorrow and another half-doxen who would think about it

I have no idea what Sacramento State is planning to do. Their president is a clown if I ever saw one.

true

as for the question....
Sacramento Srate, Tarleton State, NDSU would happily stroke a check for $5M to join any FBS conference.

Montana, MSU, North Dakota, South Dakota, SD State could be dominoes falling if NDSU goes. or they might flinch.

Eastern Kentucky was a "bridesmaid" 5 or 10 years ago. so maybe them

Right - I think the previous poster has the emphasis erroneously flipped around. It’s not a question of whether there are FCS schools willing to write a $5 million check to move up to FBS because the reality is that there are several of those around. Instead, the question is whether an existing G6 conference is willing to take an FCS call-up outside of a pure survival situation (a la C-USA after they had so many defections). We’re finding that they want to avoid it at almost all costs and, to extent that they do have call-ups, they fit a certain profile (e.g. located in large population states or metro areas being much more important than performance at the FCS level).

That's what I was getting at. There has to be interest on both sides, and not just out of a necessity for survival.

UC-Davis will most likely be the next FCS to FBS call up. They already have full membership in the MWC in just about everything except football.

As for Sacramento State and what happens to them, your guess is as good as mine.

UC-Davis "looks" like an FBS school with a $630m endowment (plus another $1.5b in their UC Regents-held fund), and they have a $7.1b budget. Sac St has an $86m endowment, which I believe would be dead last in FBS.

Hmmm, just found this article from Sept 1 in the Sacramento Observer:

https://sacobserver.com/2025/09/economis...athletics/

Noll explained that the collapse of the FCS model is likely inevitable. Currently, top FCS teams can sometimes upset weaker FBS teams, but the new environment — with open transfers and salaries at FBS schools — will strip FCS of competitiveness.

“There’s no way on God’s earth you’re going to be able to compete against FBS schools in FCS in the future,” Noll said. “That means FCS is no longer viable.”

Orr contends that the FBS leap would bring “millions upon millions” to the school in potential new revenue if media rights and ticket sales rise. “The Pac-12 media rights deals are somewhere around $10 million a year per school … and certainly things like donations and ticket sales all go significantly up if you’re playing an FBS schedule,” he said.

The Hornets have not received an invitation to join the Pac-12.

Noll also flagged another flaw in the House settlement. “The first premise … is that NCAA schools acting together can set caps on salaries, and that’s not true — that’s an antitrust violation,” he said.

Orr emphasized the broader value of athletics for Sac State. Beyond the revenue potential and the competition itself, he said, sports strengthen student retention, alumni connections, community partnerships and donor relationships. “Athletics and successful athletes, particularly in football and basketball, can be a gateway to a lot of connections,” he said. “(College President) Dr. (Luke) Wood embraces that as part of an overall university strategy.”


It seems more like wishcasting than an actual plan for Sac St, almost a silicon valley attitude of fake it till you make it.
10-06-2025 12:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,890
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #129
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
Of course, Noll ignores that you can't play Division II or III football if you want to be in the Big Dance.

Virtually all the serious programs have left FCS already. You are left with the Dakotas, Montanas and maybe Idaho is serious in FCS. Some of the rest of the Big Sky and MVC are competitive.

There have been 47 FCS championships, 42 since schools were forced down. Those first 5 were won by FAMU, Idaho St., EKU (2) and Boise St. But since then of the 42:
Youngstown St. 1993, 1994, 1997
Eastern Washington 2010
Villanova 2009
Richmond 2008
Furman 1988

The other 35 have been won by the Dakotas, Montanas or schools already in FBS. Of the 42 runnerups, you have
Youngstown St. 1992, 2016
Eastern Washington 2018
Furman 1985, 2001
Illinois St. 2014
Towson 2013
N. Iowa 2005
Colgate 2003
McNeese 1997, 2002
SF Austin 1989
W. Carolina 1983

The other 29 have been the Dakotas, Montanas or current FBS schools.
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2025 12:53 PM by bullet.)
10-06-2025 12:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #130
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 12:51 PM)bullet Wrote:  Of course, Noll ignores that you can't play Division II or III football if you want to be in the Big Dance.

Virtually all the serious programs have left FCS already. You are left with the Dakotas, Montanas and maybe Idaho is serious in FCS. Some of the rest of the Big Sky and MVC are competitive.

There have been 47 FCS championships, 42 since schools were forced down. Those first 5 were won by FAMU, Idaho St., EKU (2) and Boise St. But since then of the 42:
Youngstown St. 1993, 1994, 1997
Eastern Washington 2010
Villanova 2009
Richmond 2008
Furman 1988

The other 35 have been won by the Dakotas, Montanas or schools already in FBS. Of the 42 runnerups, you have
Youngstown St. 1992, 2016
Eastern Washington 2018
Furman 1985, 2001
Illinois St. 2014
Towson 2013
N. Iowa 2005
Colgate 2003
McNeese 1997, 2002
SF Austin 1989
W. Carolina 1983

The other 29 have been the Dakotas, Montanas or current FBS schools.

Yet more reason to question Sac State’s plan. If a fine program like NDSU that has tons of fan support, tons of Titles, and is swimming in money is struggling to find a Conference, then how is Sac St going to manage this? Programs that move up are very strong financially and/or win at a very high level in FCS, usually both. Sac St has neither money nor success, and no reason to expect that will change any time soon.
10-06-2025 01:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,890
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #131
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
SEC and Big Ten have nothing on the Big Sky and MVC for dominance as a P2!
10-06-2025 01:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
indydoug Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 443
Joined: Feb 2012
Reputation: 25
I Root For: Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #132
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-04-2025 11:18 AM)UIWElite2 Wrote:  I want everyone to know that “bryanw1995” has given me 4 negative reps and the only one to do so. He is an immature bully. Get a life man.

Not a fair system that he can continuously bully me and I can’t do anything about it.

f you're really worrying or upset about that .....umm, ok.
10-06-2025 02:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Sicatoka Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,030
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 569
I Root For: North Dakota
Location: see above
Post: #133
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 09:15 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  Regarding NDSU, the $5M check is not a problem. If the opportunity comes along, they will move up.

Fiscally, 100% agree. Some Bison booster would cover.

Politically, with dead flat enrollment the last three years (11952-11952-11952*), recent program cuts and faculty/staff reductions, spending it on athletics would rile up some faculty.


*how do you hit the same number thrice?
10-06-2025 02:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #134
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 02:46 PM)The Sicatoka Wrote:  
(10-06-2025 09:15 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  Regarding NDSU, the $5M check is not a problem. If the opportunity comes along, they will move up.

Fiscally, 100% agree. Some Bison booster would cover.

Politically, with dead flat enrollment the last three years (11952-11952-11952*), recent program cuts and faculty/staff reductions, spending it on athletics would rile up some faculty.


*how do you hit the same number thrice?

90% of the time through a data collection error, or fraud.
10-06-2025 02:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
nodak651 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,313
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 136
I Root For: North Dakota
Location:
Post: #135
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
Quote:
(10-06-2025 01:16 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
Yet more reason to question Sac State’s plan. If a fine program like NDSU that has tons of fan support, tons of Titles, and is swimming in money is struggling to find a Conference, then how is Sac St going to manage this? Programs that move up are very strong financially and/or win at a very high level in FCS, usually both. Sac St has neither money nor success, and no reason to expect that will change any time soon.

SAC has the market and NDSU has success, but very few schools have both.

What is the NCAA's current justification for requiring an invite again? I believe in the past the arguement has been that it ensures competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards. Yet, everyone in the industry knows that schools don't really prioritize on-field success when considering new members. It's all really ONLY about how much their non profit institutions may benefit financially. It is also well known, and I assume there is some amount of evidence, that P5 leaders have also been pressuring G5 leagues to not invite new FCS members.

When Sac's FBS waiver was denied, they were told:

"The committee noted a conference invitation is of paramount importance for entering into the reclassification process because the invitation signals an institution’s readiness to enter the process."

"The Division I membership adopted the current legislation to affirm the importance of the nature and purpose of the subdivision reclassification process, choosing to place that decision-making authority with the council. Due to the significance of the bona fide invitation from an FBS conference requirement and the lack of compelling mitigation explaining why that requirement, one that several other FCS institutions have met in recent years, has not been met, the committee does not support relief."

Were Sam Houston and Kennesaw really that much more qualified than Sac, if at all? Or did they benifit because FBS conferences happened to need new membership at the time, and they weren't being threatened by P5 schools not to add from the FCS?

Given that the only viable conference in Sac's region just added UC Davis (oddly without an FBS offer for some reason), we all know the MWC will not want to add another school in that same city... because they are already in that media market now, right? To both the MWC and the PAC, SAC's competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards is completely irrelivent, because they wouldn't increase their media distribution. It's ENTIRELY about financial enrichement.

Given the NCAA recent court struggles, how is there any doubt that they would fail get an injunction, in California of all places, if they seek one? What will the NCAA's legal argument be? Because the evidence is pretty clear that the FBS membership rules

Virginia's AG made a statement when they threatened to sue on behalf of JMU, when it was looking like JMU could possibly possibly be locked out of a bowl after going undeated during their transition, and it applies in many ways to the situation of Sac, NDSU, and others. "Whether analyzed under a 'quick look' or full rule of reason analysis, the end result is likely to be the same: the rule is anticompetitive, prohibiting more qualified teams from competing in bowl games to the advantage of incumbents in the market without any procompetitive justification to support it." Just swap "bowl games" for "FBS".

I'm not a lawyer, so I tinkered with AI to come up with the legal argument for the point I'm, trying to make. Would they not have a high likelyhood of being successful? Seems like there would be a case for punative damages as well, no?
--------------------------------------------------------------
The NCAA's FBS invitation rule remains an illegal market allocation under Sherman Act §1, as it empowers incumbent FBS conferences—horizontal competitors in the national college football market for talent, broadcasts, and revenues—to collusively exclude well-funded FCS schools, preserving exclusive perks like CFP distributions and media deals worth billions, without procompetitive justifications; anticipated defenses of "competitive balance" or "amateurism" fail post-Alston (141 S. Ct. 2141 (2021)), where the Supreme Court deemed them pretextual, and the June 2025 House v. NCAA settlement ($2.8B backpay, $20.5M annual revenue sharing) proves direct athlete pay doesn't disrupt the industry, blurring FCS-FBS lines yet leaving the rule as naked protectionism akin to TV rights caps struck in Board of Regents (468 U.S. 85 (1984)). This coordinated refusal suppresses output (e.g., Sacramento State's denied 2026 waiver despite $20M+ budget and Kessler's antitrust counsel), misallocates talent, and stifles innovation, warranting per se illegality as territorial division per Palmer v. BRG (498 U.S. 46 (1990))—not mere "voluntary association," as courts now scrutinize NCAA rules as commercial restraints (e.g., D. Nev. five-year eligibility ruling, Sept. 2025).

Geography intensifies the violation for Dakotas/Montana FCS giants (NDSU, SDSU, Montana, Montana State), exploiting remote barriers (travel costs, no seamless Group of 5 fits) to carve the Northern Plains as a "no-entry" zone, suppressing regional rivalries and talent flow absent consumer benefits; counterclaims of "natural hurdles" ignore how the rule weaponizes them for cartel exclusion, inviting injunctions like Pavia (2024, appeal dismissed Oct. 2025) or Braham (preliminary relief July 2025), with House scrutiny (e.g., SD AGs on power favoritism) tilting toward success despite protracted appeals.
Parallels in enjoined transfer rules and media bundling highlight systemic flaws, unmitigated by House's governance tweaks, priming challenges like Sac State's brewing suit.
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2025 03:06 PM by nodak651.)
10-06-2025 03:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Sicatoka Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,030
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 569
I Root For: North Dakota
Location: see above
Post: #136
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
Never lose sight of these insights: https://csnbbs.com/thread-1009419.html
(This post was last modified: 10-06-2025 03:21 PM by The Sicatoka.)
10-06-2025 03:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #137
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 03:03 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  
Quote:
(10-06-2025 01:16 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
Yet more reason to question Sac State’s plan. If a fine program like NDSU that has tons of fan support, tons of Titles, and is swimming in money is struggling to find a Conference, then how is Sac St going to manage this? Programs that move up are very strong financially and/or win at a very high level in FCS, usually both. Sac St has neither money nor success, and no reason to expect that will change any time soon.

SAC has the market and NDSU has success, but very few schools have both.

What is the NCAA's current justification for requiring an invite again? I believe in the past the arguement has been that it ensures competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards. Yet, everyone in the industry knows that schools don't really prioritize on-field success when considering new members. It's all really ONLY about how much their non profit institutions may benefit financially. It is also well known, and I assume there is some amount of evidence, that P5 leaders have also been pressuring G5 leagues to not invite new FCS members.

When Sac's FBS waiver was denied, they were told:

"The committee noted a conference invitation is of paramount importance for entering into the reclassification process because the invitation signals an institution’s readiness to enter the process."

"The Division I membership adopted the current legislation to affirm the importance of the nature and purpose of the subdivision reclassification process, choosing to place that decision-making authority with the council. Due to the significance of the bona fide invitation from an FBS conference requirement and the lack of compelling mitigation explaining why that requirement, one that several other FCS institutions have met in recent years, has not been met, the committee does not support relief."

Were Sam Houston and Kennesaw really that much more qualified than Sac, if at all? Or did they benifit because FBS conferences happened to need new membership at the time, and they weren't being threatened by P5 schools not to add from the FCS?

Given that the only viable conference in Sac's region just added UC Davis (oddly without an FBS offer for some reason), we all know the MWC will not want to add another school in that same city... because they are already in that media market now, right? To both the MWC and the PAC, SAC's competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards is completely irrelivent, because they wouldn't increase their media distribution. It's ENTIRELY about financial enrichement.

Given the NCAA recent court struggles, how is there any doubt that they would fail get an injunction, in California of all places, if they seek one? What will the NCAA's legal argument be? Because the evidence is pretty clear that the FBS membership rules

Virginia's AG made a statement when they threatened to sue on behalf of JMU, when it was looking like JMU could possibly possibly be locked out of a bowl after going undeated during their transition, and it applies in many ways to the situation of Sac, NDSU, and others. "Whether analyzed under a 'quick look' or full rule of reason analysis, the end result is likely to be the same: the rule is anticompetitive, prohibiting more qualified teams from competing in bowl games to the advantage of incumbents in the market without any procompetitive justification to support it." Just swap "bowl games" for "FBS".

I'm not a lawyer, so I tinkered with AI to come up with the legal argument for the point I'm, trying to make. Would they not have a high likelyhood of being successful? Seems like there would be a case for punative damages as well, no?
--------------------------------------------------------------
The NCAA's FBS invitation rule remains an illegal market allocation under Sherman Act §1, as it empowers incumbent FBS conferences—horizontal competitors in the national college football market for talent, broadcasts, and revenues—to collusively exclude well-funded FCS schools, preserving exclusive perks like CFP distributions and media deals worth billions, without procompetitive justifications; anticipated defenses of "competitive balance" or "amateurism" fail post-Alston (141 S. Ct. 2141 (2021)), where the Supreme Court deemed them pretextual, and the June 2025 House v. NCAA settlement ($2.8B backpay, $20.5M annual revenue sharing) proves direct athlete pay doesn't disrupt the industry, blurring FCS-FBS lines yet leaving the rule as naked protectionism akin to TV rights caps struck in Board of Regents (468 U.S. 85 (1984)). This coordinated refusal suppresses output (e.g., Sacramento State's denied 2026 waiver despite $20M+ budget and Kessler's antitrust counsel), misallocates talent, and stifles innovation, warranting per se illegality as territorial division per Palmer v. BRG (498 U.S. 46 (1990))—not mere "voluntary association," as courts now scrutinize NCAA rules as commercial restraints (e.g., D. Nev. five-year eligibility ruling, Sept. 2025).

Geography intensifies the violation for Dakotas/Montana FCS giants (NDSU, SDSU, Montana, Montana State), exploiting remote barriers (travel costs, no seamless Group of 5 fits) to carve the Northern Plains as a "no-entry" zone, suppressing regional rivalries and talent flow absent consumer benefits; counterclaims of "natural hurdles" ignore how the rule weaponizes them for cartel exclusion, inviting injunctions like Pavia (2024, appeal dismissed Oct. 2025) or Braham (preliminary relief July 2025), with House scrutiny (e.g., SD AGs on power favoritism) tilting toward success despite protracted appeals.
Parallels in enjoined transfer rules and media bundling highlight systemic flaws, unmitigated by House's governance tweaks, priming challenges like Sac State's brewing suit.

It would be shocking if Sac St sued the NCAA to get into FBS. Not that they wouldn't have a realistic chance of winning, but rather b/c the Cal St Board of Trustees already has several school in FBS and, at least in my opinion, is unlikely to support Luke Wood's quixotic quest to force Sac St into FBS against the wishes of the current FBS member institutions. I certainly haven't seen anything coming out of SDSU, Fresno St, or SJSU, 3 schools that could offer Sac St all kinds of support, and I have also noted above that Sac St would be the poorest school in FBS if they were to move up. This isn't like NDSU at all, you guys are an FBS school waiting for more drama to open up a spot for you. This isn't Liberty, they had the finances from day 1 to join FBS as an independent even if there wasn't any potential issue from anti-religion comments made by other FBS schools. This is a very poor school that is averaging 13k attendance this season in a mediocre market that has little football enthusiasm, trying to shoehorn their way into FBS using smoke, mirrors, duct tape and rubber bands. The rule about having a Conference invite was made specifically for schools like Sac St.

As an aside...what do you think Alabama, Miami, and Ohio St are going to do if Sac St DOES sue and successfully forces their way into FBS? Would this be conclusive evidence to the P4 that it's time to break off into a new Super-D1, perhaps even leave the NCAA entirely? It sure would be nice to have greater control over who gets to move up, instead of just allowing anybody with a lawyer and $5m to do it. And before you get all worked up, *I* am not in favor of a breakaway right now, and perhaps not ever, but that position is weakened every time a Luke Wood of the world tries taking a very poor college and pretending that it's Florida.
10-06-2025 04:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #138
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 03:21 PM)The Sicatoka Wrote:  Never lose sight of these insights: https://csnbbs.com/thread-1009419.html

(04-21-2025 01:40 PM)JRsec Wrote:  2. If it doesn't add to the bottom line or fails to meet a major need it is bogus.

3. If it doesn't fit the organizing principles of the Conference involved it's bogus.
(SEC: Stay relatively Southeastern and focus on rivals)
(Big Ten: AAU preferred, large land grant state schools preferred)

There is no way that Sac St adds to anybody's bottom line or meets a major need. They also don't fit the organizing principles of either the MWC or the Pac12/2.
10-06-2025 04:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #139
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 04:52 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-06-2025 03:03 PM)nodak651 Wrote:  
Quote:
(10-06-2025 01:16 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
Yet more reason to question Sac State’s plan. If a fine program like NDSU that has tons of fan support, tons of Titles, and is swimming in money is struggling to find a Conference, then how is Sac St going to manage this? Programs that move up are very strong financially and/or win at a very high level in FCS, usually both. Sac St has neither money nor success, and no reason to expect that will change any time soon.

SAC has the market and NDSU has success, but very few schools have both.

What is the NCAA's current justification for requiring an invite again? I believe in the past the arguement has been that it ensures competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards. Yet, everyone in the industry knows that schools don't really prioritize on-field success when considering new members. It's all really ONLY about how much their non profit institutions may benefit financially. It is also well known, and I assume there is some amount of evidence, that P5 leaders have also been pressuring G5 leagues to not invite new FCS members.

When Sac's FBS waiver was denied, they were told:

"The committee noted a conference invitation is of paramount importance for entering into the reclassification process because the invitation signals an institution’s readiness to enter the process."

"The Division I membership adopted the current legislation to affirm the importance of the nature and purpose of the subdivision reclassification process, choosing to place that decision-making authority with the council. Due to the significance of the bona fide invitation from an FBS conference requirement and the lack of compelling mitigation explaining why that requirement, one that several other FCS institutions have met in recent years, has not been met, the committee does not support relief."

Were Sam Houston and Kennesaw really that much more qualified than Sac, if at all? Or did they benifit because FBS conferences happened to need new membership at the time, and they weren't being threatened by P5 schools not to add from the FCS?

Given that the only viable conference in Sac's region just added UC Davis (oddly without an FBS offer for some reason), we all know the MWC will not want to add another school in that same city... because they are already in that media market now, right? To both the MWC and the PAC, SAC's competitive viability, financial stability, and alignment with FBS standards is completely irrelivent, because they wouldn't increase their media distribution. It's ENTIRELY about financial enrichement.

Given the NCAA recent court struggles, how is there any doubt that they would fail get an injunction, in California of all places, if they seek one? What will the NCAA's legal argument be? Because the evidence is pretty clear that the FBS membership rules

Virginia's AG made a statement when they threatened to sue on behalf of JMU, when it was looking like JMU could possibly possibly be locked out of a bowl after going undeated during their transition, and it applies in many ways to the situation of Sac, NDSU, and others. "Whether analyzed under a 'quick look' or full rule of reason analysis, the end result is likely to be the same: the rule is anticompetitive, prohibiting more qualified teams from competing in bowl games to the advantage of incumbents in the market without any procompetitive justification to support it." Just swap "bowl games" for "FBS".

I'm not a lawyer, so I tinkered with AI to come up with the legal argument for the point I'm, trying to make. Would they not have a high likelyhood of being successful? Seems like there would be a case for punative damages as well, no?
--------------------------------------------------------------
The NCAA's FBS invitation rule remains an illegal market allocation under Sherman Act §1, as it empowers incumbent FBS conferences—horizontal competitors in the national college football market for talent, broadcasts, and revenues—to collusively exclude well-funded FCS schools, preserving exclusive perks like CFP distributions and media deals worth billions, without procompetitive justifications; anticipated defenses of "competitive balance" or "amateurism" fail post-Alston (141 S. Ct. 2141 (2021)), where the Supreme Court deemed them pretextual, and the June 2025 House v. NCAA settlement ($2.8B backpay, $20.5M annual revenue sharing) proves direct athlete pay doesn't disrupt the industry, blurring FCS-FBS lines yet leaving the rule as naked protectionism akin to TV rights caps struck in Board of Regents (468 U.S. 85 (1984)). This coordinated refusal suppresses output (e.g., Sacramento State's denied 2026 waiver despite $20M+ budget and Kessler's antitrust counsel), misallocates talent, and stifles innovation, warranting per se illegality as territorial division per Palmer v. BRG (498 U.S. 46 (1990))—not mere "voluntary association," as courts now scrutinize NCAA rules as commercial restraints (e.g., D. Nev. five-year eligibility ruling, Sept. 2025).

Geography intensifies the violation for Dakotas/Montana FCS giants (NDSU, SDSU, Montana, Montana State), exploiting remote barriers (travel costs, no seamless Group of 5 fits) to carve the Northern Plains as a "no-entry" zone, suppressing regional rivalries and talent flow absent consumer benefits; counterclaims of "natural hurdles" ignore how the rule weaponizes them for cartel exclusion, inviting injunctions like Pavia (2024, appeal dismissed Oct. 2025) or Braham (preliminary relief July 2025), with House scrutiny (e.g., SD AGs on power favoritism) tilting toward success despite protracted appeals.
Parallels in enjoined transfer rules and media bundling highlight systemic flaws, unmitigated by House's governance tweaks, priming challenges like Sac State's brewing suit.

It would be shocking if Sac St sued the NCAA to get into FBS. Not that they wouldn't have a realistic chance of winning, but rather b/c the Cal St Board of Trustees already has several school in FBS and, at least in my opinion, is unlikely to support Luke Wood's quixotic quest to force Sac St into FBS against the wishes of the current FBS member institutions. I certainly haven't seen anything coming out of SDSU, Fresno St, or SJSU, 3 schools that could offer Sac St all kinds of support, and I have also noted above that Sac St would be the poorest school in FBS if they were to move up. This isn't like NDSU at all, you guys are an FBS school waiting for more drama to open up a spot for you. This isn't Liberty, they had the finances from day 1 to join FBS as an independent even if there wasn't any potential issue from anti-religion comments made by other FBS schools. This is a very poor school that is averaging 13k attendance this season in a mediocre market that has little football enthusiasm, trying to shoehorn their way into FBS using smoke, mirrors, duct tape and rubber bands. The rule about having a Conference invite was made specifically for schools like Sac St.

As an aside...what do you think Alabama, Miami, and Ohio St are going to do if Sac St DOES sue and successfully forces their way into FBS? Would this be conclusive evidence to the P4 that it's time to break off into a new Super-D1, perhaps even leave the NCAA entirely? It sure would be nice to have greater control over who gets to move up, instead of just allowing anybody with a lawyer and $5m to do it. And before you get all worked up, *I* am not in favor of a breakaway right now, and perhaps not ever, but that position is weakened every time a Luke Wood of the world tries taking a very poor college and pretending that it's Florida.

I agree with your sentiments, Bryan.
10-06-2025 05:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
billybobby777 Offline
The REAL BillyBobby
*

Posts: 14,627
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 755
I Root For: ECU, Army
Location: Houston dont sleepon
Post: #140
RE: Sacramento State president: See ya in FBS next year!
(10-06-2025 04:59 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-06-2025 03:21 PM)The Sicatoka Wrote:  Never lose sight of these insights: https://csnbbs.com/thread-1009419.html

(04-21-2025 01:40 PM)JRsec Wrote:  2. If it doesn't add to the bottom line or fails to meet a major need it is bogus.

3. If it doesn't fit the organizing principles of the Conference involved it's bogus.
(SEC: Stay relatively Southeastern and focus on rivals)
(Big Ten: AAU preferred, large land grant state schools preferred)

There is no way that Sac St adds to anybody's bottom line or meets a major need. They also don't fit the organizing principles of either the MWC or the Pac12/2.

No they don’t. I don’t believe they fit CUSA’s principles either.
10-06-2025 05:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.