The Beaver
Heisman

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
|
RE: 2025 CFP Race (bye bye Boise)
(08-29-2025 05:50 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (08-29-2025 04:51 PM)The Beaver Wrote: (08-29-2025 03:04 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote: (03-02-2025 12:05 AM)The Beaver Wrote: (03-01-2025 10:12 PM)Dignan Wrote: I’m just trying to understand the graphic, from the lens of a JMU fan. If I understand this correctly, you’re predicting Louisville to be a playoff team. Also if I understand it correctly, you’re predicting that if JMU goes 12-1, they’ll still not be in the playoffs. This would include presumably running the table on the Sun Belt, beating Liberty and Washington State, and losing to Lousville. If we did all that and still ended up on the outside looking in, that’d be tough.
No, his graphic is hard to understand but, having read all his threads on it last year, he's saying that if Louisville gets to 11-1 they are 73% likely to get an at large bid, and this is the 11th highest probability of any at large bid playoff team outcome.
To be quite frank, if JMU's only accolades are running the table in the Sun Belt and beating Washington State and then Boise does the same then Boise does deserve the nod over you (depending on game margins, etc.) They have the MWC, a much better conference, to run through and then also App State, USF on the road and Notre Dame on the road (higher in playoff probability than UL.) Unless you are saying that JMU would somehow deserve it over the ACC or BXII champions, yeah, you would be forced to compete for an at large bid at that point. Unfortunately ND and UL don't play this year, which would have been a nice tie breaker.
Last year's final FPI ratings for JMU's 2025 SBC opponents and Boise's 2025 MWC opponents...
JMU: 58, 62, 73, 77, 78, 97, 100, 109
Boise: 40, 81, 103, 105, 106, 107, 110, 122
Sagarin, SP+, and Massey all tell similar stories. It's hard to call Boise's conference schedule better, let alone "much better". Only two of the conference teams they play this year finished in the top 100.
I see you chose to omit WSU and OSU (ranked 65th and 96th respectively and playing MWC schedules,) in order to hide what their schedule strength actually was. Thankfully, I caught it.
I didn't omit anything. Read my post again. We're talking about 2025 strength of schedule, because that's what factors into the 2025 CFP bid. Boise State doesn't play WSU or OSU, so why would I include them?
Also, WSU and OSU aren't playing MWC schedules this year. WSU has two MWC opponents and OSU has just one MWC opponent.
Sorry about that, I did misread, that said I also don't expect last year's ratings to have as much bearing on this year's teams. UNLV and Boise's current results this past week should be a great example of that. We'll see where the leagues end up this year.
|
|