(03-02-2025 12:05 AM)The Beaver Wrote: (03-01-2025 10:12 PM)Dignan Wrote: (03-01-2025 02:09 PM)Crayton Wrote: March 1st update: I added the G5 schedules (except for the MAC, pending). Nothing really changed. Not all spots in "The 12 Playoff spots" are head-to-head anymore; I shuffled some around to get the season-openers on this list (like Catholics vs. Convicts).
As of right now the chance an M2 champ is shut out of the playoffs relies on 2 undefeated G5 teams (though not from CUSA) boxing out a Big 12 Champ with 2 losses or an ACC Champ with 3. A 1-loss Tulane is also in lock territory. Though I'm sure they'd find a way to shoehorn a 10-3 ACC Champ into the the #12 ranking in that scenario.
I’m just trying to understand the graphic, from the lens of a JMU fan. If I understand this correctly, you’re predicting Louisville to be a playoff team. Also if I understand it correctly, you’re predicting that if JMU goes 12-1, they’ll still not be in the playoffs. This would include presumably running the table on the Sun Belt, beating Liberty and Washington State, and losing to Lousville. If we did all that and still ended up on the outside looking in, that’d be tough.
No, his graphic is hard to understand but, having read all his threads on it last year, he's saying that if Louisville gets to 11-1 they are 73% likely to get an at large bid, and this is the 11th highest probability of any at large bid playoff team outcome.
To be quite frank, if JMU's only accolades are running the table in the Sun Belt and beating Washington State and then Boise does the same then Boise does deserve the nod over you (depending on game margins, etc.) They have the MWC, a much better conference, to run through and then also App State, USF on the road and Notre Dame on the road (higher in playoff probability than UL.) Unless you are saying that JMU would somehow deserve it over the ACC or BXII champions, yeah, you would be forced to compete for an at large bid at that point. Unfortunately ND and UL don't play this year, which would have been a nice tie breaker.
The graphic is tough (which is probably the opposite of what a graphic should be). My problem is trying to cram too much into one place.
If JMU goes 12-1, they are "likely" going to finish #11. But they could finish #6 or #16 with that record. Much depends on how good the Sun Belt is and how many "good" teams the major conferences produce.
Still, JMU has an 80% chance of making the playoff at 12-1. That is better than Louisville's chance of making the playoff at 11-1, 73%. Of course, these are averages. If both teams finish the regular season with only 1 combined loss outside their game, that will enhance the playoff prospects of both.
The "12 playoff spots" is intended to be a synthesis, predicting which teams will make the playoff if they win-out. Obviously, preseason, 100+ teams will likely make the playoff if they win-out. And so I took the 24 most likely playoff teams and paired them off, the intended implication being that if Clemson loses to LSU or Georgia to Tennessee, that team 'might' fall out of the playoff picture.
Then again, still, if Georgia loses 'only' to Tennessee, they are almost assuredly locks for the playoff. And the Golden "AT LARGE RACE" is a helpful tool to see that Georgia must lose 2 games to drop outside the >95% area, to only a 88% chance of making the playoff. Clemson at 11-1 with that loss to LSU falls to 85%.
BUT (and there are too many of these) the Golden Area is only for AT LARGE chances. A Clemson whose only loss is to LSU will appear in Charlotte; a win there and playoff chances are probably 100%; the 85% is their chance of the playoff if they go 11-1 but DON'T win the ACC.
You can use the far-right Blue column to see that winning the ACC at 12-1 or 11-2 should amount to a playoff berth for the Tigers. But 10-3 (with 2 OOC SEC opponents) and they'd start to sweat it, with a 75% chance of falling behind 2 G5 champs, like JMU. Analogously, JMU at 13-0 should be a playoff lock.