Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Author Message
Eggszecutor Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 358
Joined: Jun 2020
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Nebraska
Location:
Post: #61
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
06-18-2025 04:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,866
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #62
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
No other league in America does this type of thing. What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American. The Big 12 and ACC should fight it all the way.

It is good for the Big Ten and probably not very good for the SEC. It harms the ACC and Big 12 because they are permanently and publicly listed as 2nd tier. Its bad for college football. Lesser teams will get in because of the extra guarantees.
06-18-2025 04:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
RUScarlets Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,715
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
Post: #63
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Brett McMurphy indicates CFP “reset”…

https://x.com/brett_mcmurphy/status/1935...94703?s=46

As I said, this will go into December.
06-18-2025 07:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #64
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
No other league in America does this type of thing. What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American. The Big 12 and ACC should fight it all the way.

It is good for the Big Ten and probably not very good for the SEC. It harms the ACC and Big 12 because they are permanently and publicly listed as 2nd tier. Its bad for college football. Lesser teams will get in because of the extra guarantees.
What league are we talking about with more than two conferences? Because I can't think of one.
06-18-2025 07:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OdinFrigg Offline
Gone Fishing
*

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
Post: #65
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Ten total P games for each SEC member could be workable. That could apply to to the 8 current conference games format, or move to 9 in the new future.

1. Protect the in-state rivalry games that UF, UGA, SC, and UK, have with ACC members. However, all of these games, for scheduling interests, don’t necessarily have to be the last end of the regular season games. Having a measure of flexibility in this regard, may help with the collective scheduling goals.

2. Missouri, Texas, Texas A&M, and Oklahoma have B12 options for oocs. OU-oSu as the bedlam game would be appealing to be sustained regularly. TCU, TTU, Baylor, UH, and SMU (ACC) are there for UT and T-A&M scheduling as rotation or single school agreements. Mizzou could renew with Kansas and/or has other B12 options or schedule BIG teams from bordering states.

3. Vanderbilt often plays Wake Forest and sometimes Duke. A long-term agreement with either or both is plausible.

4. LSU, Alabama, Auburn, Mississippi State, Ole Miss, and Tennessee, don’t have specific, regular, long-term ooc scheduling with P level schools, but usually have one on their schedules. I’d like to see each of the schools to have a consistent ooc regular with mutual compatibility. A cupcake-type P for yearly scheduling would be contrary to the purpose.

5. A tenth, open choice, P game for all SEC members is desirable. Otherwise, this is where a scheduling agreement with the BIG may work.

6. The SEC could keep two free options each year. Two G-5 picks, or one G-5 pick and a FCS game would remain allowable.
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 05:15 AM by OdinFrigg.)
06-19-2025 05:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Coato Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 62
Joined: Dec 2023
Reputation: 27
I Root For: UCLA
Location:
Post: #66
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
No other league in America does this type of thing. What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American. The Big 12 and ACC should fight it all the way.

It is good for the Big Ten and probably not very good for the SEC. It harms the ACC and Big 12 because they are permanently and publicly listed as 2nd tier. Its bad for college football. Lesser teams will get in because of the extra guarantees.

No other league in America uses voting by people who don’t watch all the games as a metric either. The thing about the AQs is that it gives all of the conferences a known setup to try and maximize their revenue. It also eliminates all of the BS talk trying to compare a 49-point win over Florida A&M vs a 23-point win over UNLV (or whatever).

Teams 9-16 are roadkill anyway so it’s mostly just exhausting talk that ruins the regular season, that will lead to nothing but revenue in the end.

The good thing about the AQs is that it allows for unbalanced NFL scheduling inside the conferences and other things that add interest and parity. Without AQs it’s a race to the scheduling bottom since top 25 ranking (useless after #5) and win-loss total are completely overrated, leading to a month of negative engagement with the sport where one gets mad at the exclusions, who were never going to win anyway.
06-19-2025 06:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #67
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  ....
What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American.
....

Well, make up your mind. 03-wink

Each league likes the arrangement it stands to fare better with.

SEC coaches, it turns out, like their chances with committee votes and eye tests. Voters know their assignments by now. They have been trained through years of conditioning. Even if their ADs have other ideas, the coaches are cool with opinion polls.

Whatever arrangement ultimately takes shape, I want the committee work out of it. I want a college version of the NFL system: all qualifiers are automatic. Everyone knows what they have to do. If a team gets it done ugly, that team is in the playoffs and people can say what they want about it.

Fans would love it. The NFL makes bank on it.
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 06:58 AM by Gitanole.)
06-19-2025 06:44 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
tf8693 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
Post: #68
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 09:30 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 06:53 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  Interesting question. Mr Petitti can get 4-4-2-2-1 if he can win the SEC on it, so his first effort would surely be invested there. If the P2 leagues agree on format the other conferences will likely have to live with it.

This is the right answer. Step #1 is getting on the same page with Sankey. After media days it seems the SEC ADs and Coaches (and fans like me) want more than 1 at large.

But the 4-4-2-2-1+1 may put more pressure on the M2 than the 4-4-1-1-1+3 because it mostly nerfs the stakes of their CCGs.

I think the M2 is applying the right pressure though, asking for 3 bids apiece if they are to allow WCGs.

Sounds like even with 16 teams though they’ll keep 2 byes, so in the Round of 14 the M2 at most have 4 combined spots, 5 if they convince Notre Dame to go in with them (for a more generous Top 25 qualification than Top 14).

I can assure you that Notre Dame would have zero interest in that. In fact, Notre Dame is okay with a more difficult path to the CFP provided that they are not systematically excluded from the CFP, which is why you haven't heard a lot of complaints from ND's corner about 4-4-whatever, even though that format works to ND's disadvantage.

In fact, if it were up to the majority of posters on NDNation, we probably would be scrapping the CFP altogether and going back to the pre-Coalition bowl game system, with a maximum of, oh, I dunno, 10, maybe, bowl games. If Pete Bevacqua were to agree to your suggestion, he'd probably be run out of town on a rail.
06-19-2025 09:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
tf8693 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
Post: #69
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 06:44 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  ....
What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American.
....

Well, make up your mind. 03-wink

Each league likes the arrangement it stands to fare better with.

SEC coaches, it turns out, like their chances with committee votes and eye tests. Voters know their assignments by now. They have been trained through years of conditioning. Even if their ADs have other ideas, the coaches are cool with opinion polls.

Whatever arrangement ultimately takes shape, I want the committee work out of it. I want a college version of the NFL system: all qualifiers are automatic. Everyone knows what they have to do. If a team gets it done ugly, that team is in the playoffs and people can say what they want about it.

Fans would love it. The NFL makes bank on it.

I'm pretty much the exact opposite. The NFL is small enough to make that format work. FBS is not.

A more fitting analogy is to the NCAA basketball tournament. That is successful even with a selection committee. It's successful even though a significant portion of the teams in the field would have no business there if qualification were strictly merit based, although occasionally, one of those teams (e.g., St. Peter's in 2022) goes on a deep run, which only adds to the tournament's charm

4-4-2-2-1-1, or 4-4-2-2-1-3, or 4-4-3-3-1-1 is the second worst idea I've ever heard of. The worst idea I've ever heard of is conferences holding play-in games for their AQ bids. If you like that idea, just expand the field to 24 or even 32 teams and be done with it.
06-19-2025 09:44 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,308
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #70
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 09:28 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(06-16-2025 09:30 AM)Crayton Wrote:  I think the M2 is applying the right pressure though, asking for 3 bids apiece if they are to allow WCGs.

Sounds like even with 16 teams though they’ll keep 2 byes, so in the Round of 14 the M2 at most have 4 combined spots, 5 if they convince Notre Dame to go in with them (for a more generous Top 25 qualification than Top 14).

I can assure you that Notre Dame would have zero interest in that. In fact, Notre Dame is okay with a more difficult path to the CFP provided that they are not systematically excluded from the CFP, which is why you haven't heard a lot of complaints from ND's corner about 4-4-whatever, even though that format works to ND's disadvantage.

In fact, if it were up to the majority of posters on NDNation, we probably would be scrapping the CFP altogether and going back to the pre-Coalition bowl game system, with a maximum of, oh, I dunno, 10, maybe, bowl games. If Pete Bevacqua were to agree to your suggestion, he'd probably be run out of town on a rail.

Notre Dame already signed an MOU that they’d get a spot if they are Top X. Whether the other spots are assigned via at larges or AQs makes 0 difference to them. That is why they are quiet.

I’m not sure what you are saying. Notre Dame would take a more difficult path in exchange for…? Either way you may know more about ND politics than me.

My suggestion, in part, is to box out the P2 from the ND spot when the Irish are mediocre. Rather than being in/out based on finishing in the Top 14, the Irish would be afforded an opportunity to play-into the playoff if they are Top 25 and would be guaranteed a spot PLUS a play-in for a potential bye if they are top 2 among Alliance (ACC+XII+ND) teams.

2024 example
4 Notre Dame vs 8 SMU (both in, ND might steal bye from 5 Georgia)
12 Miami vs 22 Syracuse (winner in)
15 Arizona St vs 18 BYU (winner in)
16 Iowa St vs 17 Clemson (winner in)

Top 3 from each M2 qualify plus next 2 ranked teams (including Irish if Top 25).
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 10:03 AM by Crayton.)
06-19-2025 09:54 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,866
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #71
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 06:20 AM)Coato Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
No other league in America does this type of thing. What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American. The Big 12 and ACC should fight it all the way.

It is good for the Big Ten and probably not very good for the SEC. It harms the ACC and Big 12 because they are permanently and publicly listed as 2nd tier. Its bad for college football. Lesser teams will get in because of the extra guarantees.

No other league in America uses voting by people who don’t watch all the games as a metric either. The thing about the AQs is that it gives all of the conferences a known setup to try and maximize their revenue. It also eliminates all of the BS talk trying to compare a 49-point win over Florida A&M vs a 23-point win over UNLV (or whatever).

Teams 9-16 are roadkill anyway so it’s mostly just exhausting talk that ruins the regular season, that will lead to nothing but revenue in the end.

The good thing about the AQs is that it allows for unbalanced NFL scheduling inside the conferences and other things that add interest and parity. Without AQs it’s a race to the scheduling bottom since top 25 ranking (useless after #5) and win-loss total are completely overrated, leading to a month of negative engagement with the sport where one gets mad at the exclusions, who were never going to win anyway.

You will have a weaker field than with a 5/11. At least last year, Alabama, South Carolina and Ole Miss were not "roadkill." But if you dig deeper, maybe you do get that.
06-19-2025 11:06 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,866
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #72
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 07:09 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.
No other league in America does this type of thing. What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American. The Big 12 and ACC should fight it all the way.

It is good for the Big Ten and probably not very good for the SEC. It harms the ACC and Big 12 because they are permanently and publicly listed as 2nd tier. Its bad for college football. Lesser teams will get in because of the extra guarantees.
What league are we talking about with more than two conferences? Because I can't think of one.

Every other sport, pro, college and high school in America.
06-19-2025 11:08 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,866
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #73
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 06:44 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  ....
What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American.
....

Well, make up your mind. 03-wink

Each league likes the arrangement it stands to fare better with.

SEC coaches, it turns out, like their chances with committee votes and eye tests. Voters know their assignments by now. They have been trained through years of conditioning. Even if their ADs have other ideas, the coaches are cool with opinion polls.

Whatever arrangement ultimately takes shape, I want the committee work out of it. I want a college version of the NFL system: all qualifiers are automatic. Everyone knows what they have to do. If a team gets it done ugly, that team is in the playoffs and people can say what they want about it.

Fans would love it. The NFL makes bank on it.

The NFL has a draft. It has a limited number of teams. It shares its revenues so everyone is somewhat close financially. It has a coordinated schedule that is relatively similar. College football has none of that.
06-19-2025 11:11 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,939
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #74
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.

She doesn't even have a real conference at this point. Wake me up when 2026 rolls around and they're playing actual football games as a cohesive unit. Or, to look at the 23-24 payouts, assuming nothing falls apart for the Pac between now and then:

63m B1G
52m SEC
45m ACC
43m Big 12

Avg of the M2 is $44m, and that's for the 23-24 season. By 2026 they'll both be at $50m+. Oh, wait, $60m+ when you factor in CFP money. Sure, the P2 might be closer to $90m by then, but $60m is a whole lot closer to $90m than it is to, what, $7-8m? So, projected for 2026:

SEC ~ $90m
B1G ~ $90m
ACC ~ $60m
Big 12 ~ $60m
Memphis ~ $11m
Pac 8 ~ $7-8m

The nuPac can't even keep up with legacy AAC schools, perhaps Gould should set her sights a bit lower...

Gould's claims to be comparable to the M2 are weaker than Aresco's old claims that the AAC was part of the "P6".
(This post was last modified: 06-19-2025 11:14 AM by bryanw1995.)
06-19-2025 11:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #75
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-16-2025 12:23 PM)stechs02 Wrote:  EDIT: I feel strongly that ESPN should have no influence over the selection of the 16 teams. Beyond that, I’m just not a fan of ESPN in general. That said, please don’t take my passion as a criticism of you or your reasoning—I respect your perspective.

No worries. Personally, I actually think the AQ model makes sense. It's just the 4-4-2-2-1 is not very beneficial from the ACC perspective.
06-19-2025 01:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #76
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.
06-19-2025 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,299
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #77
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-18-2025 04:45 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 03:01 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 02:21 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 01:48 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(06-17-2025 12:44 PM)Eggszecutor Wrote:  If the SEC is dead-set on 5+11, then the next step is to see how Strength-of-Schedule is factored in. To me the most likely outcome is 5+11 with the Big Ten moving back to 8 conference games.

There's, in my opinion, a real difference between the SEC, where eastern and western schools have no real interest in playing eachother, and the Big Ten where they absolutely do. This means no divisions for the Big Ten and, given its massive size, also means we need 9 games in order to more quickly see all other teams. There's no way back to 8.

Agreed. I definitely think that’s a significant cultural difference at play here. The Big Ten schools actually do want to play each other more and that’s more important than gaming what’s perceived to be best for a particular playoff format. A lot of people outside of the Big Ten don’t seem to get that.

And Big 10 people absolutely do not understand the SEC where right now there are no East and West divisions. For instance Auburn until 1992 ended its season with what Pat Dye called the Amen Corner as we played Florida and Georgia, and Alabama to close the season every year. And Tennessee was forever the third Saturday of the football season. Vanderbilt's best rivalry outside of UT was Ole Miss. There are plenty of schools from the former West that have rivals of old in the East and vice versa. Arkansas, Oklahoma, Texas A&M, Texas and Missouri do not have a burning desire for games annually against Georgia, South Carolina, or Auburn for that matter. They do love playing one another and LSU which was once the Aggies second most hated rival behind the Horns.

Face it. Each of our conference grew in different but similar ways. You added Penn State to the East and Nebraska to the West. The SEC added South Carolina (went for Clemson first) to the East and Arkansas to the West. All four of those additions were bridge additions which were an attempt to maintain conference standards by expanding with solid schools, but schools clearly aimed at expanding our markets further into new regions. Penn State and South Carolina have not paid dividends yet in that regard, but Nebraska remains a key bridging piece to market connection to the West and Penn State & South Carolina remains the same to the Mid-Atlantic states for the SEC and Big 10.

This scheduling mess is rightly perceived on both sides. The Big 10 has a much larger and less competitive bottom than the SEC. Playing 9 conference games is more difficult than 8 and leaves less room for games which create an outside comparison. I get the arguments on both sides. The solution is simple. Just require the two conference to schedule 10 P games per member school. The ACC and Big 12 and Notre Dame will remain P games for scheduling purposes. Then the SEC has room for those 4 season ending games against the ACC schools and still have a scheduling agreement with the Big 10. The rest of the argument over 9 conference games is buried under the new requirement and the 2 non-P games still give us all 7 home tickets to sell.

I see this as a bit of a power struggle right now. Both the Big Ten and SEC want to position themselves to get the most out of the CFP.

The SEC stands to gain the most bids in a more open, non-AQ style set up with their current 8-game schedule. Moving to 9-games and/or having more AQ's prevents them from maximzing the number of schools they might get in.

On the flip side, the Big Ten is perceived to have easier conference schedules than the SEC. Maybe they are thinking that they need to guarantee 4 AQ's every year to protect themselves? Maybe the move is to go back to 8 conference games if they adopt a 5+11. With fewer conference losses, they might have more teams in the top 15 like the SEC is used to having with their 8 game conference schedules.

I feel like it's more likely that they just want the play-in games at the end of the year, though, and the AQ's enable the play-in games to be viable. The play-in games will create more losses for the Big Ten and AQ's protect the Big Ten to make sure they get 4 schools in a year, but it will likely come at the cost of getting more than 4 teams in because of those extra losses in the play-in games. If their 4-seed in the play-in game losses to the 5-seed, that 4-seed is probably not getting an at large bid, where as without the play-in game, and 8-conference games, both the 4th and 5th place Big Ten team may have a better chance to get into the field.

Regarding the ACC and Big XII, they likely get more in with the guaranteed AQ's every year, but then they have a perception issue that they are inferior to the SEC/Big Ten if they agree to something like a 4-4-2-2-1. Heck the PAC-12 commissioner this week stated that her conference was on par with the Big XII and ACC. That's not something either of those two conferences want to be likened to.

If a team can lose a play-in game and still get into the CFP, then it isn't a play-in game at all. The only way WCGs can be relevant is if they are win or go home (or at least go to a bowl instead of the CFP). They can't just be a way to game the system to get another conference team in the playoff at some other conference's expense.

We should just think of the WCG's as a part of they playoffs in which the conference staging them gets to keep all the revenue in addition to another team in the CFP where each conference's share of the revenue depends on how deep into the tournament they go.
06-19-2025 01:40 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
OdinFrigg Offline
Gone Fishing
*

Posts: 3,200
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 923
I Root For: Canine & Avian
Location: 4,250 mi sw of Oslo
Post: #78
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
Just wait, at large picks will eventually turn into wild card games.
06-19-2025 01:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Crayton Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,308
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
Post: #79
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 01:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  I think many people vastly underestimate the B1G's desire for the AQ model. The number of bids is just one factor; the most important thing is money.

The AQ model would introduce play-in games and more SEC-B1G challenge games, generating additional revenue. I don't know whether it’s a coincidence, but Joel Klatt of Fox and Josh Pate of CBS strongly support the AQ model.

For the SEC, both the AQ model (more money) and the 5-11 model (greater representation if SOS becomes more critical) are probably acceptable options. But for the B1G, the choice is between more money (AQ model) or less money (5-11 model).

Thus, it would be naive to assume the B1G will easily give up on the AQ model, even if the SEC and other conferences agree on nine conference games or ten P4 games. To me, the 9 conference game argument seems like an excuse to avoid endorsing the 5-11 model and that's probably why this CFP issue remains unresolved.

Personally, I believe the B1G’s best offer to the SEC would be a 4-4-2-2-1-3 model with modified ranking criteria emphasizing SOS for at-large selections. Under this model, the SEC can still aim for six bids (with four guaranteed bids). However, the SEC doesn't appears eager to push the AQ model probably because of public backlash. Then Petitti may have to give something to the M2 to gain their support and present the AQ model as a "P4 consensus".

That’s a tall task.

I think you are 100% right about the Big Ten and 4 AQs. They want the security of a 4-bid floor and (most of all) they have the TV partners to handle additional games on CCG weekend. Getting the SEC to 9 conference games is just another path to more money with a scheduling agreement.

Per the MOU which the M2 signed, the P2 can ram through a 4-4-x-x model for 2026 but if they want those extra WCGs legislated they are going to need to offer the M2 something more.

The M2 set the price at 4-4-3-3-1+1. The P2 must either accept that or go to some model that somehow has WCGs but no/fewer guaranteed bids. Like the 5+4+3, which perhaps can be expanded to a 5+5+4.
06-19-2025 02:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
GoBuckeyes1047 Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,075
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 302
I Root For: Ohio State
Location:
Post: #80
RE: What’s Tony Petitti’s next move? (regarding CFP format)
(06-19-2025 09:44 AM)tf8693 Wrote:  
(06-19-2025 06:44 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(06-18-2025 04:57 PM)bullet Wrote:  ....
What the Big Ten wants is anti-competitive and anti-American.
....

Well, make up your mind. 03-wink

Each league likes the arrangement it stands to fare better with.

SEC coaches, it turns out, like their chances with committee votes and eye tests. Voters know their assignments by now. They have been trained through years of conditioning. Even if their ADs have other ideas, the coaches are cool with opinion polls.

Whatever arrangement ultimately takes shape, I want the committee work out of it. I want a college version of the NFL system: all qualifiers are automatic. Everyone knows what they have to do. If a team gets it done ugly, that team is in the playoffs and people can say what they want about it.

Fans would love it. The NFL makes bank on it.

I'm pretty much the exact opposite. The NFL is small enough to make that format work. FBS is not.

A more fitting analogy is to the NCAA basketball tournament. That is successful even with a selection committee. It's successful even though a significant portion of the teams in the field would have no business there if qualification were strictly merit based, although occasionally, one of those teams (e.g., St. Peter's in 2022) goes on a deep run, which only adds to the tournament's charm

4-4-2-2-1-1, or 4-4-2-2-1-3, or 4-4-3-3-1-1 is the second worst idea I've ever heard of. The worst idea I've ever heard of is conferences holding play-in games for their AQ bids. If you like that idea, just expand the field to 24 or even 32 teams and be done with it.

Hold up a second, I'm not ready to completely dismiss an idea of an NFL-like playoff model in CFB. Let's say we get everyone to 9 conf. games + 1 P4 non-conf or just 10 total P4 games. Conferences still control how many conf. games they play (though they should try to balance conference schedules better), and teams are still able to schedule in non-conference. I wouldn't be opposed of using overall record as a primary factor for playoff qualification and seeding. I would still allow the top 5-6 champs automatic qualification and maybe multiple bids guaranteed for the P4.

Hypothetically for last year, Oregon was undefeated and the only undefeated team so clearly the 1 seed. Then you have all the 11-1 teams. Head to head, Common opponents, Strength-of-Schedule, Strength-of-Record, conference standings, etc. as tiebreakers. Then do the same for 10-2, then 9-3 until you get to the desired number of teams. The biggest hurdle is CCGs and potential WCGs so I would want all CFP contending teams to play a 13th game whether a CCG or WCG. For the G6, because they have a weaker schedule, but I don't want to completely dismiss them, maybe treat a 12-0 G6 teams like an 11-1 P4 team.

This is just a brainstorm, I'm not full advocating for this, not yet at least. Just something I want to look into and chew on.
06-19-2025 02:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.