(12-12-2024 07:03 AM)Curtisc83 Wrote: (12-12-2024 06:14 AM)TexanMark Wrote: (12-11-2024 11:57 PM)lakesbison Wrote: (12-11-2024 09:11 AM)Curtisc83 Wrote: Does this imply that the MAC will have an opening? If the MAC is open to adding new members, I would suggest that NDSU focus on securing a place in that conference. I believe they shouldn’t be overly selective in their approach. If NDSU were already in the FBS, they would have a significantly better chance of aligning with their desired destination conference.
NDSU is too good for the MAC/CUSA/SUN BELCH.
NDSU is too good for the MWC now it looks like (more likely they don't want another Boise State!)
PAC 12 or AAC probably now the focus.
Wow talk about an inflated sense of worth. Look at a map...you are remote AF in a sparsely populated area. The MWC would be a homerun for NDSU.
That’s an incredibly toxic outlook. NDSU would be a solid addition, just like other recent FCS call-ups, but it’s far from being a ‘gift from God.’ There’s nothing NDSU offers that couldn’t be replicated by another school in a less remote location. It seems like their FCS championship titles have gone to their heads. While I can’t speak for all FBS fans, success at the FCS level doesn’t carry much weight in the FBS world. NDSU should absolutely be proud of its accomplishments, but a little humility would go a long way.
So, I won’t hammer fans for looking at their favorite school in the most positive light possible. We all do that to some degree.
I think it’s more that it goes back to a fundamental misunderstanding for so many people since we have been evaluating conference realignment in earnest: on-the-field performance isn’t the only factor and very often isn’t even close to the most important factor for realignment decisions. That goes from the very top of the sport (see the Big Ten adding Rutgers) to the very bottom with who gets to be an FCS call-up.
NDSU’s continued success at the FCS level is evidence of sustained commitment for football, which is certainly of value. That’s probably the biggest reason why talks with the MWC got as far as they did.
However, commitment to football is really a basic “check the box” requirement. It’s an inherent minimum requirement to move up to FCS in the first place. That is then where off-the-field factors come in, such as TV market, recruiting area, and institutional fit (which could range from
academic fit to geographic fit or other types of fits as defined by the conference).
Where it generally goes off the rails for most fans is overrating the “brand” of their favorite school or even just assigning any brand value to their school at all. Even at the P4 level, the number of actual brands is relatively small. At the G5 level, only Boise State and maybe the service academies have any real football brand, there are a handful of schools that have good basketball/all-sports brands such as Memphis and San Diego State where it can carry over to certain extent, but by and large, being a true brand is a waaaaaaay more exclusive club compared to market size, elite performance or top academics. We’re talking about Ohio State, Michigan, Alabama, Texas, Notre Dame, etc. When we’re talking about brands bringing major value from a small market, we’re talking about Oklahoma and Nebraska.
And that is where I see so many NDSU fans going off the rails. With all apologies, they’re coming in with ZERO brand from a national perspective. FCS Championships are meaningless in that regard - only a tiny sliver of the broad fan audience (which is what matters for TV values) knows that they even exist. Around 3-4 times as many people saw NIU beat Notre Dame than any FCS Championship Game in history even when those games have been moved from cable to ABC.
There is no such thing as an “FCS brand” that translates to FBS. As a result, we have seen every recent FCS call-up come in large population states and/or TV markets. Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (the massive #4 TV market with Philly) are just the latest examples. UC Davis, if it ends up moving up to FBS, would fit both a large population state and large TV market.
To be sure, I get the frustration of fans of places like the Dakota or Montana schools. The one thing that you can’t control is your location, so when FBS leagues are valuing things like TV markets and recruiting locations that are totally outside of a school’s control, it feels like great performance doesn’t matter (and to be honest, it really doesn’t matter at the FCS level in terms of moving up to FBS or at least it isn’t weighed anywhere near as much as the off-the-field factors).