Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
Author Message
HawaiiMongoose Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,123
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 812
I Root For: Hawaii
Location: Honolulu
Post: #681
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.
11-29-2024 01:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #682
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. ...

Yeah, when someone argues from the basis of the public information being an infallible guide, we get into "should I believe you, or should I believe my own lying eyes?" territory.
11-29-2024 10:07 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,611
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #683
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:07 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. ...

Yeah, when someone argues from the basis of the public information being an infallible guide, we get into "should I believe you, or should I believe my own lying eyes?" territory.

The new PAC wants to be the top conference in football and basketball. They also want to earn a very good media deal. They left behind some respectable MW programs due to their weakness in football or basketball. Nevada and UNM are decent in basketball but mediocre or dreadful in football. Im not sure what the UAB or USF programs offer in football. Look at their recent records in football. Same can be said for suggestions of ECU or Temple.

Again, just keep throwing out random teams to the PAC. I think UTEP and NSMU would be great additions for the conference! Lets hear more about Uconn Fb only or Creighton and Wichita to the PAC.
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2024 10:28 AM by PicksUp.)
11-29-2024 10:27 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #684
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:54 PM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:07 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate. ...

... Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I think that 1 is quite reasonable. Tx St isn't off the table for the MWC, they're just waiting to see if they get an invite from the Pac, or from the AAC as backfill. I'd say that it's like the dilemma that SDSU had last year with the Big 12 vs Pac 12 decision, but Tx St really can't lose here. They can stay in the SBC, which is a fine conference, or they can get an invite to the MWC, which is moderately better financially for them, or they can get an invite from the AAC or even Pac, either of which would be a huge raise for them.

Reasonable, that is, of an example of an unexpected move which, while it seems highly unlikely (accounting for the unexpected part), can't be totally ruled out.

Of course, once an example is offered that is reasonably likely, then it's not an example of an unexpected move.

Perhaps I should be clearer.

I think that Texas St going SOMEWHERE is very likely, but they have 2 excellent potential landing spots in the Pac and AAC and one that's better than their current SBC situation in the MWC. Like SDSU (allegedly), Texas St was offered a spot in a better conference that was, however, not their top choice, so they hesitated. The comparison is not exact, however, as the MWC is quite likely to add Tx St if they change their minds, while SDSU, if they ever had an offer at all from the Yormarks, quickly lost that offer when Punxsutawney Kliavkoff went into his little den for most of 2023. Which makes sense b/c the Big 12 had potentially far more-desirable options in the 4c, while the MWC's best potential addition is probably Tx St.
11-29-2024 10:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #685
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.

We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock
11-29-2024 10:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #686
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  ... We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock

Yes. Regarding:
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  ... Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. ...

... there is a difference between disagreements of, "I don't think that's likely", "that can't happen unless some fundamental change hits the college landscape" and "that can't ever happen".

It's plausible that Stanford would rather go independent than be in the kind of conference that includes a school like Boise State. If so, then so long as being independent is an option, it can't happen.

But we've already seen fundamental changes hit the college landscape in the form of NIL and widespread "no-fault" transfers, and more fundamental changes are coming.

And all of that is on top of the incomplete information we always face, even in "normal" times ... like which "moves that didn't happen" were in fact never attempted, which were tried and just couldn't be made to work, and which are on the back burner to see which way other moves break -- sometimes with no information at all, and often with nothing but rumours which might or might contain any information.
11-29-2024 10:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
EOU93 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 813
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 38
I Root For: MW
Location:
Post: #687
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote:  Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.

Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.

I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.

Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?

To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.
11-29-2024 12:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UIWElite Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
Post: #688
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.

Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?

To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

Stanford and Cal aren’t leaving the ACC for the MWC or the Pac 12. If you believe that, you are abusing drugs or riding the short bus. Even if they wanted to, they probably couldn’t leave the ACC anyway. Florida St and Clemson are allegedly trying to do the same. It’s illogical to believe the ACC left loopholes so Cal and Stanford could leave a year after joining.

Grand Canyon isn’t adding football. Where would they play? Who in Phoenix is asking for GCU football?

In conference realignment, nothing is ‘impossible’, that doesn’t mean a lot of things aren’t close to that. I guess Georgia could decide to de-emphasize college athletics and join the Sun Belt. That is ‘possible’, but it’s not happening.

Yeah, it’s possible for an AAC team to leave for the MWC, but that’s totally unrealistic and would be flat out dumb for Rice to do that. Just because you can think it, doesn’t mean it’s an intelligent thought.
11-29-2024 01:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HawaiiMongoose Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,123
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 812
I Root For: Hawaii
Location: Honolulu
Post: #689
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.

Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?

To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

I agree, the possibility of GCU reconsidering its previous disinclination to add football could be another reason that the MWC is waiting a bit on inviting NDSU.

Is it likely that GCU will change its mind? I don’t think so, as the school has said repeatedly in the past that it’s not interested in fielding a football team. But that was before GCU’s unexpected pivot to joining an FBS conference, an outcome that no one expected until GCU’s dream destination of the WCC was abandoned by both BYU and Gonzaga and the MWC found itself in such desperate need of bolstering its membership that it was willing to overlook GCU’s institutional lack of fit. Joining the MWC opens up the possibility of a direct-to-FBS football launch, something that GCU can actually afford and that would have a lot more national marketing value to the school than fielding an FCS team in the WAC.
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2024 01:57 PM by HawaiiMongoose.)
11-29-2024 01:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UIWElite Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
Post: #690
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 01:47 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote:  Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?

To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

I agree, the possibility of GCU reconsidering its previous disinclination to add football could be another reason that the MWC is waiting a bit on inviting NDSU.

Is it likely that GCU will change its mind? I don’t think so, as the school has said repeatedly in the past that it’s not interested in fielding a football team. But that was before GCU’s unexpected pivot to joining an FBS conference, an outcome that no one expected until GCU’s dream destination of the WCC was abandoned by both BYU and Gonzaga and the MWC found itself in such desperate need of bolstering its membership that it was willing to overlook GCU’s institutional lack of fit. Joining the MWC opens up the possibility of a direct-to-FBS football launch, something that GCU can actually afford and that would have a lot more national marketing value to the school than fielding an FCS team in the WAC.

How does GCU adding football help the MWC right now? Even if they announced tomorrow, they would be unable to field a team in 2025. Probably wouldn’t be able to field one in 2026, so maybe in 2027 they could and you think they would want to go directly to FBS? Why wouldn’t you just rather have NDSU playing as football only from the start? If the MWC is unsure about taking a FCS school, why would they want a start up program instead?
11-29-2024 02:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
EOU93 Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 813
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 38
I Root For: MW
Location:
Post: #691
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 01:37 PM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote:  Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?

To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

Stanford and Cal aren’t leaving the ACC for the MWC or the Pac 12. If you believe that, you are abusing drugs or riding the short bus. Even if they wanted to, they probably couldn’t leave the ACC anyway. Florida St and Clemson are allegedly trying to do the same. It’s illogical to believe the ACC left loopholes so Cal and Stanford could leave a year after joining.

Grand Canyon isn’t adding football. Where would they play? Who in Phoenix is asking for GCU football?

In conference realignment, nothing is ‘impossible’, that doesn’t mean a lot of things aren’t close to that. I guess Georgia could decide to de-emphasize college athletics and join the Sun Belt. That is ‘possible’, but it’s not happening.

Yeah, it’s possible for an AAC team to leave for the MWC, but that’s totally unrealistic and would be flat out dumb for Rice to do that. Just because you can think it, doesn’t mean it’s an intelligent thought.

GCU can play in old Phoenix rising soccer stadium and can even expand it or even the new stadium.
Could play in Univ of Phoenix stadium. There are options.
Who was calling for Georgia St to add football? Or S. Alabama? Or UTSA?
None that I heard of. I lived in San Antonio when UTSA started football. It wasn’t the city clamoring for them to start football.
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2024 02:27 PM by EOU93.)
11-29-2024 02:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
MWC Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 98
Joined: Nov 2024
Reputation: 15
I Root For: Nevada
Location:
Post: #692
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 02:21 PM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:47 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

I agree, the possibility of GCU reconsidering its previous disinclination to add football could be another reason that the MWC is waiting a bit on inviting NDSU.

Is it likely that GCU will change its mind? I don’t think so, as the school has said repeatedly in the past that it’s not interested in fielding a football team. But that was before GCU’s unexpected pivot to joining an FBS conference, an outcome that no one expected until GCU’s dream destination of the WCC was abandoned by both BYU and Gonzaga and the MWC found itself in such desperate need of bolstering its membership that it was willing to overlook GCU’s institutional lack of fit. Joining the MWC opens up the possibility of a direct-to-FBS football launch, something that GCU can actually afford and that would have a lot more national marketing value to the school than fielding an FCS team in the WAC.

How does GCU adding football help the MWC right now? Even if they announced tomorrow, they would be unable to field a team in 2025. Probably wouldn’t be able to field one in 2026, so maybe in 2027 they could and you think they would want to go directly to FBS? Why wouldn’t you just rather have NDSU playing as football only from the start? If the MWC is unsure about taking a FCS school, why would they want a start up program instead?

The MW does not have to do anything. They have one more year before the defectors leave. They already have 8 full members. They have GCU to help out with non football sports. The original MWC only had 8 full members for 6 years. It won't hurt to wait it ous for a few years to see what develops.
11-29-2024 03:22 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
joeben69 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,934
Joined: Nov 2017
Reputation: 101
I Root For: sdsu, ucsd, usd
Location:
Post: #693
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:27 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 10:07 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. ...

Yeah, when someone argues from the basis of the public information being an infallible guide, we get into "should I believe you, or should I believe my own lying eyes?" territory.

The new PAC wants to be the top conference in football and basketball. They also want to earn a very good media deal. They left behind some respectable MW programs due to their weakness in football or basketball. Nevada and UNM are decent in basketball but mediocre or dreadful in football. Im not sure what the UAB or USF programs offer in football. Look at their recent records in football. Same can be said for suggestions of ECU or Temple.

Again, just keep throwing out random teams to the PAC. I think UTEP and NSMU would be great additions for the conference! Lets hear more about Uconn Fb only or Creighton and Wichita to the PAC.

UNR & UNM was part of the MWC 6 bids to the NCAAT 2024..

Boise St.
Colorado St.
Nevada-Reno
New Mexico
San Diego St.
Utah St.

Record Six Mountain West Teams Headed to the 2024 NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament
https://themw.com/news/2024/03/17/record...ournament/

Western Kentucky sole CUSA bid to the NCAAT 2024...
CUSA Tourney Champ...
2024 Conference USA men's basketball tournament
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_Confe...nt#Bracket

CUSA NCAAT Auto Bid
2024 NCAA Division I men's basketball tournament
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_NCAA_...tournament

NCAA MBB
MWC > CUSA
UNR & UNM > UTEP & NMSU

PAC would rather poach from MWC than CUSA...
(This post was last modified: 11-29-2024 06:42 PM by joeben69.)
11-29-2024 04:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UIWElite Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
Post: #694
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 02:26 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:37 PM)UIWElite Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 12:05 PM)EOU93 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 07-coffee3

Exactly.

We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.

2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.

Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I can see something is being worked behind the scenes for the MW and it could be an unexpected opportunity as you mentioned, hence why NDSU or Tarleton have not been offered an invitation.
I’ve speculated that while very unlikely, Stanford and Cal are reevaluating their membership in the ACC…especially regarding the Olympic sports and the travel toll it is taking on their athletes. I speculated they would probably join the MW over the PAC being in a conference with only 1 Cal State school…before GCU joined the MW. Will it happen? Not likely but we been surprised time and time again.
Another scenario that may be behind the scenes is GCU looking to add football as they will be in a FBS conference. That would give the MW 9 schools in football therefore no need to add another football school. Having a football school in Arizona would probably be more valuable than adding a FCS school in the central time zone.

Stanford and Cal aren’t leaving the ACC for the MWC or the Pac 12. If you believe that, you are abusing drugs or riding the short bus. Even if they wanted to, they probably couldn’t leave the ACC anyway. Florida St and Clemson are allegedly trying to do the same. It’s illogical to believe the ACC left loopholes so Cal and Stanford could leave a year after joining.

Grand Canyon isn’t adding football. Where would they play? Who in Phoenix is asking for GCU football?

In conference realignment, nothing is ‘impossible’, that doesn’t mean a lot of things aren’t close to that. I guess Georgia could decide to de-emphasize college athletics and join the Sun Belt. That is ‘possible’, but it’s not happening.

Yeah, it’s possible for an AAC team to leave for the MWC, but that’s totally unrealistic and would be flat out dumb for Rice to do that. Just because you can think it, doesn’t mean it’s an intelligent thought.

GCU can play in old Phoenix rising soccer stadium and can even expand it or even the new stadium.
Could play in Univ of Phoenix stadium. There are options.
Who was calling for Georgia St to add football? Or S. Alabama? Or UTSA?
None that I heard of. I lived in San Antonio when UTSA started football. It wasn’t the city clamoring for them to start football.

They’re going to play at UoP stadium with 80k seats, with the name of their competitors? That’s seems like a dumb idea, don’t you think?

South Alabama doesn’t have any competition within their city. Mobile isn’t a large city like the others. UTSA has been relatively successful and doesn’t have a NFL team in their city. Georgia St is probably what GCU could hope for. Does anyone in Atlanta care about GSU? Football or not. I would have to believe Phoenix feels the same way about GCU.
11-29-2024 04:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Aztecgolfer Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,908
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 353
I Root For: San Diego State
Location: San Diego
Post: #695
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:37 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:54 PM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:07 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?

Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:

1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate. ...

... Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.

I think that 1 is quite reasonable. Tx St isn't off the table for the MWC, they're just waiting to see if they get an invite from the Pac, or from the AAC as backfill. I'd say that it's like the dilemma that SDSU had last year with the Big 12 vs Pac 12 decision, but Tx St really can't lose here. They can stay in the SBC, which is a fine conference, or they can get an invite to the MWC, which is moderately better financially for them, or they can get an invite from the AAC or even Pac, either of which would be a huge raise for them.

Reasonable, that is, of an example of an unexpected move which, while it seems highly unlikely (accounting for the unexpected part), can't be totally ruled out.

Of course, once an example is offered that is reasonably likely, then it's not an example of an unexpected move.

Perhaps I should be clearer.

I think that Texas St going SOMEWHERE is very likely, but they have 2 excellent potential landing spots in the Pac and AAC and one that's better than their current SBC situation in the MWC. Like SDSU (allegedly), Texas St was offered a spot in a better conference that was, however, not their top choice, so they hesitated. The comparison is not exact, however, as the MWC is quite likely to add Tx St if they change their minds, while SDSU, if they ever had an offer at all from the Yormarks, quickly lost that offer when Punxsutawney Kliavkoff went into his little den for most of 2023. Which makes sense b/c the Big 12 had potentially far more-desirable options in the 4c, while the MWC's best potential addition is probably Tx St.

Right now I'd say the MWC is the least stable conference among those being mentioned here, so joining them is a big risk. Were the AAC to lose Memphis and Tulane, they would likely look at the MWC for options to replace. They could also do that with TexSt though their proximity to UTSA would make that add less than ideal. But, the AAC, even with the loss of Memphis and Tulane would still be a more attractive conference than the MWC.
11-29-2024 06:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Aztecgolfer Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,908
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 353
I Root For: San Diego State
Location: San Diego
Post: #696
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.

We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock


Stanford hopes for the B1G and have the money to stick in the ACC for awhile, though many of their student athletes are being harmed by the extensive travel. Cal doesn't have the money that Stanford has and has incredible debt that they haven't even begun making principal payments on. They want the B1G as well but I really don't see the B1G wanting, much less adding, both.
11-29-2024 06:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #697
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 06:09 PM)Aztecgolfer Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.

We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock


Stanford hopes for the B1G and have the money to stick in the ACC for awhile, though many of their student athletes are being harmed by the extensive travel. Cal doesn't have the money that Stanford has and has incredible debt that they haven't even begun making principal payments on. They want the B1G as well but I really don't see the B1G wanting, much less adding, both.

I can see them both as travel partners.

Bring in Stanford/Cal and ASU and you have for yourself a west coast division
11-29-2024 06:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Aztecgolfer Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,908
Joined: Jan 2021
Reputation: 353
I Root For: San Diego State
Location: San Diego
Post: #698
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 06:19 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 06:09 PM)Aztecgolfer Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.

We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock


Stanford hopes for the B1G and have the money to stick in the ACC for awhile, though many of their student athletes are being harmed by the extensive travel. Cal doesn't have the money that Stanford has and has incredible debt that they haven't even begun making principal payments on. They want the B1G as well but I really don't see the B1G wanting, much less adding, both.

I can see them both as travel partners.

Bring in Stanford/Cal and ASU and you have for yourself a west coast division

The B1G had the chance to add them before, and didn't and they still paid UW and Oregon a half share each.
11-29-2024 06:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
andybible1995 Offline
Banned

Posts: 14,847
Joined: Apr 2022
I Root For: TN, MTSU, MD, Army
Location:
Post: #699
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 06:19 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 06:09 PM)Aztecgolfer Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 10:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!

I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!

Offended? Not really. I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. But if that’s how someone feels I see no point in uselessly dragging out the debate to try to change their mind.

I will take a minute though to address the notion of UAB becoming a Pac expansion candidate if the Pac finds itself in a position to poach five AAC schools and has already taken Memphis, Tulane, UTSA, and USF. UNT is more commonly assumed to be the next most desirable Pac addition, but I think that’s in part due to recency bias. It’s easy to overlook UAB because the Blazers haven’t done much in football since Trent Dilfer took over as head coach in 2023. But prior to that UAB had earned bowl invitations for six consecutive seasons. Also the men’s basketball team has won 20 or more games in eight of the past ten seasons, and in the last three seasons has been to the NCAA tournament twice and NIT once. Plus UAB has a nearly new stadium and is well placed geographically to serve as a bridge to and travel partner for USF.

But hey, if you’re genuinely sure the Pac would never consider adding UAB under any plausible set of circumstances, go right ahead and dismiss the possibility with a little sarcastic wit. It’s not as if you’re at much risk of eventually being proven wrong.

We all have our biases. I can clearly see when Frank says "Stanford will never join the truck stoppers or rejoin the Pac 12" that there are a whole lot of scenarios where exactly that happens, but I get my blinders on when people say "A&M and Florida to the B1G, book it!". Admittedly, I have a far better understanding of A&M than Swaim or other rumor-mongers, but it is foolish for any of us to say "never" these days. I might have a different opinion tomorrow ofc, depending upon how the game goes and whether I or my Aggie brethren detect one iota of any officiating mistake that doesn't 100% favor the home team. 04-rock


Stanford hopes for the B1G and have the money to stick in the ACC for awhile, though many of their student athletes are being harmed by the extensive travel. Cal doesn't have the money that Stanford has and has incredible debt that they haven't even begun making principal payments on. They want the B1G as well but I really don't see the B1G wanting, much less adding, both.

I can see them both as travel partners.

Bring in Stanford/Cal and ASU and you have for yourself a west coast division

I believe that the BIG will expand past 20 teams by adding Arizona, Arizona State, California, Colorado, Stanford and Utah to bridge the West Coast with the rest of the conference.
11-29-2024 06:45 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DavidSt Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,078
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
Post: #700
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-29-2024 10:27 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 10:07 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(11-29-2024 01:42 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:  ... I do find it amusing that despite all the insanity we’ve witnessed in conference realignment over the past couple of years, there are still some folks confidently making absolute pronouncements about what is or is not possible. ...

Yeah, when someone argues from the basis of the public information being an infallible guide, we get into "should I believe you, or should I believe my own lying eyes?" territory.

The new PAC wants to be the top conference in football and basketball. They also want to earn a very good media deal. They left behind some respectable MW programs due to their weakness in football or basketball. Nevada and UNM are decent in basketball but mediocre or dreadful in football. Im not sure what the UAB or USF programs offer in football. Look at their recent records in football. Same can be said for suggestions of ECU or Temple.

Again, just keep throwing out random teams to the PAC. I think UTEP and NSMU would be great additions for the conference! Lets hear more about Uconn Fb only or Creighton and Wichita to the PAC.

UNR 5 games came close to winning which would put them at 8-4 with a game left. UNR's balls were not bouncing in the right direction.
11-29-2024 06:49 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.