johnbragg
Five Minute Google Expert

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested.
If not, then not.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 10:47 AM |
|
JBB
Water Engineer

Posts: 37
Joined: Dec 2017
Reputation: -1
I Root For: WYO
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested.
If not, then not.
I agree with you. TV money is driving this. I wouldn’t be surprised if tv money won’t try and buy the conference set-up they want.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 11:49 AM |
|
UIWElite
1st String

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested.
If not, then not.
When living in reality, there’s absolutely no way the MWC tv deal is worth enough to get an AAC team. Their exit fees are too high to make it worthwhile.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 11:52 AM |
|
BruceMcF
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested. If not, then not.
Unless the scenario is a media partner losing their mind, if the MWC can land a TV deal high enough to attract Memphis & Tulane, that means that the New PAC lands an even better TV deal which means Memphis & Tulane are already going somewhere else.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 12:30 PM |
|
johnbragg
Five Minute Google Expert

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 12:30 PM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested. If not, then not.
Unless the scenario is a media partner losing their mind, if the MWC can land a TV deal high enough to attract Memphis & Tulane, that means that the New PAC lands an even better TV deal which means Memphis & Tulane are already going somewhere else.
Yeah sorry, I read that in my head as PAC , not MWC.
Y'know, the league with SDSU
|
|
| 11-28-2024 12:41 PM |
|
HawaiiMongoose
Heisman

Posts: 6,123
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 812
I Root For: Hawaii
Location: Honolulu
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 02:05 PM |
|
joeben69
1st String

Posts: 1,934
Joined: Nov 2017
Reputation: 101
I Root For: sdsu, ucsd, usd
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
Quote:1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
LIKE ^^^
IF Memphis & Tulane stay in AAC
THEN PAC invites UNT & UTSA
ELSE IF UNT AND/OR UTSA stay in AAC
THEN PAC invites TXST...
IF AAC loses UNT AND/OR UTSA
THEN AAC invites TXST (to appease the Academies) AND/OR GSU/FIU
ELSE AAC stays at 12/11...
IF TXST still available THEN MWC takes another run at TXST
ELSE NMSU...Do You Invite Me Now???...LOL
|
|
| 11-28-2024 03:02 PM |
|
UIWElite
1st String

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
2 just isn’t happening. If the AAC goes to 8, they can pick off any number of teams they want from CUSA. They’re not merging and losing autobids so they can play San Jose and New Mexico.
1 isn’t happening either. What does AAC losing teams have to do with the Sun Belt and Texas St? If they were unhappy in the SBC, they would have gone to the MWC already.
None of these scenarios are a bit realistic. That’s why they’re looking at NDSU. And looked at Tarleton, and already added UTEP and Grand Canyon.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 03:45 PM |
|
BruceMcF
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 12:41 PM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 12:30 PM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested. If not, then not.
Unless the scenario is a media partner losing their mind, if the MWC can land a TV deal high enough to attract Memphis & Tulane, that means that the New PAC lands an even better TV deal which means Memphis & Tulane are already going somewhere else.
Yeah sorry, I read that in my head as PAC , not MWC.
Y'know, the league with SDSU
Fair enough. Yes, mostly-former-MWC might land a TV deal high enough to attract Memphis and Tulane. If the pre-contract situation is marginal but on the outside of the margin, getting certainty of payout up and getting exit fees down by allowing those two to join in 2027 might conceivably get them over the line.
For still-MWC, NDSU FB-only would seem like a good move to get to an 8-game conference schedule. The inventory bump from that surely pays for the FB teams traveling to Fargo every second year.
(This post was last modified: 11-28-2024 04:16 PM by BruceMcF.)
|
|
| 11-28-2024 04:06 PM |
|
HawaiiMongoose
Heisman

Posts: 6,123
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 812
I Root For: Hawaii
Location: Honolulu
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 03:45 PM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
2 just isn’t happening. If the AAC goes to 8, they can pick off any number of teams they want from CUSA. They’re not merging and losing autobids so they can play San Jose and New Mexico.
1 isn’t happening either. What does AAC losing teams have to do with the Sun Belt and Texas St? If they were unhappy in the SBC, they would have gone to the MWC already.
None of these scenarios are a bit realistic. That’s why they’re looking at NDSU. And looked at Tarleton, and already added UTEP and Grand Canyon.
Must be nice to have a crystal ball that’s so much clearer than mine.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 05:37 PM |
|
DavidSt
Legend

Posts: 27,078
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:19 AM)chargeradio Wrote: I don't see the Pac12 taking enough schools in the short-term to make anyone else leave the American. If the Pac-12 were to take four to five schools from the western half of the American (i.e. Memphis and Tulane and at least two of UTSA, North Texas, Tulsa, Rice) then maybe one of the remaining schools thinks about moving. The more likely scenario is that the American wold just invite Texas State and possibly Sam Houston in an attempt to appease Army and Navy, who want a conference football game in Texas annually.
AAC could invite both now to shave off PAC from getting into their territory. It would solidified the AAC more to make sure nobody else leaves.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 07:40 PM |
|
DavidSt
Legend

Posts: 27,078
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
I don't think we know that until there's a TV deal.
If the TV contract comes in high, then Memphis and Tulane are likely interested.
If not, then not.
Maybe the media do not want to play ball with the PAC 2 for being toxic. I bet they wanted the MWC and PAC do a reverse merger so that the media money would be better. MWC's men's basketball would have been valuable if they all stuck together.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 07:43 PM |
|
UIWElite
1st String

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 05:37 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 03:45 PM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
2 just isn’t happening. If the AAC goes to 8, they can pick off any number of teams they want from CUSA. They’re not merging and losing autobids so they can play San Jose and New Mexico.
1 isn’t happening either. What does AAC losing teams have to do with the Sun Belt and Texas St? If they were unhappy in the SBC, they would have gone to the MWC already.
None of these scenarios are a bit realistic. That’s why they’re looking at NDSU. And looked at Tarleton, and already added UTEP and Grand Canyon.
Must be nice to have a crystal ball that’s so much clearer than mine.
It’s common sense guy. The AAC can pick from any CUSA or SBC team they want. They’re not merging with the MWC. Why would they do that? The AAC has high exit fees, it’s unreasonable to believe any AAC school would leave to join the MWC.
It’s also common sense that the MWC reached out to every FBS team that is reasonable. Maybe they haven’t reached out to Arkansas St or other MAC schools, but there’s not much out there. That’s why they’re going for FCS schools. They already or likely struck out on Texas St, NIU, and Toledo.
I will ask again, who are they going to get?
|
|
| 11-28-2024 08:02 PM |
|
Eichorst
Special Teams

Posts: 774
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 100
I Root For: Wisconsin
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
And also the AAC has a basketball team that just took down UConn, and a football team that's 1 game away from the CFB playoff. The MWC after the Pac-7 plays will have very little going for it.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 08:30 PM |
|
HawaiiMongoose
Heisman

Posts: 6,123
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 812
I Root For: Hawaii
Location: Honolulu
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 08:02 PM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 05:37 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 03:45 PM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
2 just isn’t happening. If the AAC goes to 8, they can pick off any number of teams they want from CUSA. They’re not merging and losing autobids so they can play San Jose and New Mexico.
1 isn’t happening either. What does AAC losing teams have to do with the Sun Belt and Texas St? If they were unhappy in the SBC, they would have gone to the MWC already.
None of these scenarios are a bit realistic. That’s why they’re looking at NDSU. And looked at Tarleton, and already added UTEP and Grand Canyon.
Must be nice to have a crystal ball that’s so much clearer than mine.
It’s common sense guy. The AAC can pick from any CUSA or SBC team they want. They’re not merging with the MWC. Why would they do that? The AAC has high exit fees, it’s unreasonable to believe any AAC school would leave to join the MWC.
It’s also common sense that the MWC reached out to every FBS team that is reasonable. Maybe they haven’t reached out to Arkansas St or other MAC schools, but there’s not much out there. That’s why they’re going for FCS schools. They already or likely struck out on Texas St, NIU, and Toledo.
I will ask again, who are they going to get?
Since you’ve already made up your mind and nothing I say will change it, let’s just wait and see.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 08:55 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 07:06 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:06 AM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Again--I'm Not saying the MW will or should stay at Eight.
Just pointing out that currently I think they might be "somewhat" more willing to consider eight for the short term vs what they Were thinking three-four months ago.
I’m pretty sure the MWC will add a ninth football member for 2026, but not until sfter it sees what the Pac does. There’s no pressure on the MWC to be the first to make a move, and depending on how many and which schools the Pac lands, there could be an unexpected opportunity for the MWC to pick up a more desirable addition than NDSU.
Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
I think that 1 is quite reasonable. Tx St isn't off the table for the MWC, they're just waiting to see if they get an invite from the Pac, or from the AAC as backfill. I'd say that it's like the dilemma that SDSU had last year with the Big 12 vs Pac 12 decision, but Tx St really can't lose here. They can stay in the SBC, which is a fine conference, or they can get an invite to the MWC, which is moderately better financially for them, or they can get an invite from the AAC or even Pac, either of which would be a huge raise for them.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 10:07 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 05:37 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 03:45 PM)UIWElite Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:20 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (11-28-2024 10:05 AM)UIWElite Wrote: Like who? No AAC team is leaving to join the MWC. They already tried the MAC. Already tried Texas State. Which schools are more desirable and getable than NDSU?
To be fair, he did say an unexpected opportunity, so by definition we don't at this point in time know what the opportunity is. 
Exactly.
We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate.
2. The Pac is able to offer an attractive enough media deal payout to convince not only Memphis and Tulane but also UTSA, UAB, and USF to join, increasing football membership to 12 and fulfilling its original vision. That leaves the AAC at just 9/8. In a surprise move, the AAC proposes a full merger to the MWC that would unite all three service academies in the same conference and give media partners inventory in five time zones. The MWC accepts, and Texas State also accepts a full membership invitation to backfill for UTSA and even out the number of football programs at 18.
Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
2 just isn’t happening. If the AAC goes to 8, they can pick off any number of teams they want from CUSA. They’re not merging and losing autobids so they can play San Jose and New Mexico.
1 isn’t happening either. What does AAC losing teams have to do with the Sun Belt and Texas St? If they were unhappy in the SBC, they would have gone to the MWC already.
None of these scenarios are a bit realistic. That’s why they’re looking at NDSU. And looked at Tarleton, and already added UTEP and Grand Canyon.
Must be nice to have a crystal ball that’s so much clearer than mine.
He has Elite in his name, so you know he's good.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 10:08 PM |
|
PicksUp
All American

Posts: 3,611
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!
I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!
(This post was last modified: 11-28-2024 10:41 PM by PicksUp.)
|
|
| 11-28-2024 10:41 PM |
|
BruceMcF
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:07 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-28-2024 02:05 PM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote: ... We all know the twists and turns of conference realignment can sometimes be surprising. And there’s absolutely no telling at this point how the Pac drama is going to play out or what the fallout may be. Why should the MWC act to constrain its options before it has to?
Here are two examples of scenarios that IMHO are unlikely but still possible, that would lead me as MWC commissioner to caution against moving on NDSU just yet:
1. The Pac fails to lure Memphis and Tulane aboard because its media deal revenue projections aren’t high enough to overcome their concerns about negative travel impacts on their non-football sports. However as a fallback the Pac is able to convince UNT and UTSA to make the jump because they’re only receiving partial AAC distributions and travel west is less daunting from central Texas. The AAC chooses not to backfill because a 12/11 membership structure is more than adequate and it doesn’t want to add less attractive mouths to feed. That gives the MWC an opportunity to take a second run at Texas State. Does it decide to follow UTSA west? Maybe, if the MWC media deal revenue projections are adequate. ...
... Again, these are unlikely scenarios. But neither are entirely off the table yet, and both would be good outcomes for the MWC that would be even less likely to occur if the MWC hurries to add NDSU now.
I think that 1 is quite reasonable. Tx St isn't off the table for the MWC, they're just waiting to see if they get an invite from the Pac, or from the AAC as backfill. I'd say that it's like the dilemma that SDSU had last year with the Big 12 vs Pac 12 decision, but Tx St really can't lose here. They can stay in the SBC, which is a fine conference, or they can get an invite to the MWC, which is moderately better financially for them, or they can get an invite from the AAC or even Pac, either of which would be a huge raise for them.
Reasonable, that is, of an example of an unexpected move which, while it seems highly unlikely (accounting for the unexpected part), can't be totally ruled out.
Of course, once an example is offered that is reasonably likely, then it's not an example of an unexpected move.
|
|
| 11-28-2024 10:54 PM |
|
UIWElite
1st String

Posts: 1,094
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 105
I Root For: UIW
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(11-28-2024 10:41 PM)PicksUp Wrote: Some of you guys have a great imagination but get offended when we dont agree with you. Keep throwing out random scenarios, one of them might hit one of these days. Lets see how many Big West programs the MW and PAC want. That one was my favorite!
I dont think anyone had offered UAB as a PAC candidate yet. Kudos!
Rice is secret candidate for the MWC. They just need to pay the huge AAC exit fee, take less money, and then be willing to travel across 3 other time zones for baseball. Reporters are just throwing off everyone by leaking out these FCS and football only schools!
Just wait until the AAC and MWC merge, despite the AAC having 2 conferences to pick and choose replacements from!
|
|
| 11-28-2024 11:13 PM |
|