(07-21-2024 04:24 PM)pvk75 Wrote: (07-20-2024 09:58 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: That's always been my experience. The ISU fans I've always been around, and that includes a former AD, have been all about their rivalries with Bradley and SIU and Arch Madness and MVC hoops. Any link between NIU and ISU is effectively non-existent -- you'd have to travel back 60+ years in time.
I think another part of it is NIU has always been all-in on FB while ISU has traditionally been a MBB school. We're really bad at MBB and ISU hasn't ever been noteworthy at FB, so there's just never been any connectivity between the two schools/fan bases. Even if ISU joined the MAC, I'm not sure a real rivalry would ever develop...NIU would likely dominate FB while ISU would likely dominate MBB. We'd likely send very few fans there for MBB and they'd likely send few fans up here for FB based on past games.
You are absolutely correct. Illinois State has zero potential either as a MAC member or a rival to NIU.
--- NIU has no room for another "rivalry," what with the manufactured ones with Ball State and Miami-O. The Bronze Stalk vs. Ball State originated with a DeKalb artist because NIU didn't have any. The Mallory Trophy game honors Bill Mallory (1935-2018), who coached at both at one time or the other, if and when it gets scheduled.
--- The $11.5 million IPF that ISU opened last October will do absolutely no good for elevating their football program above FCS. What were/are they thinking?!
--- The new ISU College of Engineering, scheduled to open in fall 2025, will not help elevate ISU's academic status.
--- That 14,568 attendance at the ISU-at-NIU football game in 2019, the highest in 23 Huskie Stadium games through 2023, including 2022 vs. Vanderbilt, was a fluke.
--- The 8-hour 'round trip from ISU to SIU is just as good as under-4-hours 'round trip between ISU and NIU. Everybody loves a longer scenic bus ride.
--- There is no way that NIU-ISU in all sports could possibly be better -- either for attendance or TV/streaming -- than the MVC adding UIC and the media deal with Bally Sports/NBC Chicago, both in 2022. Not even with the MAC-ESPN deal.
And with that "can't do/can't happen" attitude, NIU may be relegated to some day becoming Chicago State-West. By then, all 200 remaining fans will love it.
Pardon me, where did I say Illinois St has "zero potential" as a MAC member or NIU rival? I just gave an opinion that I don't see a real rivalry developing, citing my anecdotes and historical knowledge of the schools.
This is a really immature response. All throughout your reply, you are making up things I didn't say and blowing things I did say way out of proportion. You're then making sarcastic, passive-aggressive responses to things....I did not say.
For the sake of having an
honest discussion of what I actually said, let's go through this point-by-point:
#1 - I never said or implied "NIU doesn't have room for another rivalry" or that "NIU's rivalries with Miami or Ball St aren't manufactured". I never mentioned either point. All I said is I don't see a real rivalry developing between NIU and ISU as the schools have completely different cultures. NIU is all-in on FB while ISU traditionally has been a BB school. That point is fair and accurate.
#2 - Sure. I never mentioned ISU's facilities, nor implied they were incapable of moving to FCS. So why is this directed at me? This has nothing to do with anything I said.
#3 - Sure. I never mentioned or implied anything about ISU's academics. Again, why is this directed at me?
#4 - Yes, I attended that game. I also attended SIU and EIU games. Like epasnoopy, I felt SIU brought more fans and EIU brought a little less. I agree that in-state opponents bring more visiting fans. But what you're missing is important context: that 14,568 was on the Saturday night of Labor Day weekend. A 72-degree Saturday night on Labor Day weekend is the perfect circumstances for attendance.
The other times NIU hosted a Saturday night Labor Day weekend game?
2011 Army (17,003)
2015 UNLV (15,455)
2019 Illinois St (14,568)
When you compare apples-to-apples, in the three instances NIU hosted a Saturday night Labor Day weekend game, the Illinois St game ranked 3rd of the 3 in attendance. That indicates Illinois St itself didn't drive attendance -- it was the date (Labor Day Weekend), day (Saturday), time (night), and weather (72 degrees) that drove it. I do agree there's a slight uptick with an in-state opponent, but not much.
#5 - Um, what? I didn't mention anything about ISU's proximity to SIU or NIU. All I said was ISU fans, including the former AD I'm friends, are passionate about their long histories with Bradley and (to a lesser extent) SIU. Those are schools with very similar athletic cultures as them as they're all BB-passionate schools. That's a fair and accurate point that's played out in those games' historical MBB attendance.
#6 - I didn't mention anything about UIC or a tv deal. Again, making up something I said. What does ISU playing UIC have to do with ISU's attendance playing NIU? If you want to go into attendance, ISU/Bradley and ISU/SIU draw quite a bit better for MBB than what ISU/NIU would draw. A quick look at what ISU/Bradley and ISU/SIU have drawn over many years will confirm that. On the other hand, we (NIU) draw hundreds for MBB and are historically bad, so it doesn't compare as a MBB draw to ISU/Bradley or ISU/SIU.
#7 - How does anything I said indicate NIU will turn into "Chicago State-West"? Simply because I don't believe NIU/ISU would be a big draw or much of a rivalry? A totally valid opinion? You've made a mountain out of a molehill of what I said yet again.
Of your 7 points:
- 5 were things I never said or mentioned.
- 1 was something you twisted what I said massively out-of-proportion.
- Leaving only 1 point where something you claimed I said was actually something I did say.
We're all MAC fans here. If we're going to have an
honest discussion, it's important to actually
be honest about what the other person is saying. Creating strawmen and making up what the other person said just makes you look small. If you're going to be passive-aggressive and sarcastic, it better be to things the other person *actually* said. Every point I made in my original post is totally valid.