Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
Author Message
Bookmark and Share
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,766
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #1181
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-14-2024 08:45 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote:  ... Respectfully (because I do respect you BruceMcF), it seems to me that the real game of pretend here is that North Dakota State isn't a real flagship because they happen to be located in a small state.

My point is that what the associations of the term "flagship" come from Universities that are flagships of states that are five to ten to twenty time the size, or more. When we say "flagship", we think of Wisconsin and Illinois and Texas and Oklahoma, not Rhode Island and Wyoming.

You could say, "but Oklahoma is a flagship of a small state", but Oklahoma is a state with five times the population of North Dakota.

Just qualifying for the term doesn't carry with it the characteristics associated with the term when we are talking about being the flagship of a fleet of cutters rather than the flagship of a fleet of ships of the line.

So what I am referring to is the suggestion that being the "flagship" of North Dakota is somehow an automatic "institutional fit" card into a group of Universities that are all larger, and a number twice the size.

Being R1 is an argument toward overlooking NDSU's small size ... being a "flagship" seems to me to just be a way of distracting from it, since the associations we get from the term "flagship" are of being a University toward the size of the larger MAC schools if not bigger than any MAC school.
(This post was last modified: 07-14-2024 01:34 PM by BruceMcF.)
07-14-2024 01:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Steve1981 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,907
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
Post: #1182
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
OK, looked again and posted again on the redbird site. Their conversations remind me of us, UMass and comparing conference etc. So did post the numbers as it's a friggin revenue stream and vision for their athletic department decision. A non FBS program can not fund an athletic department if they want to grow.

Footnote, 28k views since the MAC voted us in, thank you!
07-18-2024 05:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,766
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #1183
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-18-2024 05:26 PM)Steve1981 Wrote:  OK, looked again and posted again on the redbird site. Their conversations remind me of us, UMass and comparing conference etc. So did post the numbers as it's a friggin revenue stream and vision for their athletic department decision. A non FBS program can not fund an athletic department if they want to grow. ...

Huhn, I peeked over there, and saw a post that retorted the distance to their supposed CUSA rival Missouri State by sarcastically referring to how close Buffalo was ... which seems to me they haven't thought through who all is in CUSA.

I was doing the Google drive times from the MAC perspective, but from the Illinois State perspective, the different is pretty dramatic.

Schools within 4 hours: MAC 2, CUSA 0
MAC: NIU, 1:40, Ball State, 3:30, Western Michigan, 3:45

Schools 4-6 hours, MAC 5, CUSA 2
MAC: Miami, 4:40, Eastern Michigan, 5:20, Toledo, 5:25, Bowling Green, 5:30, Central Michigan, 5:40
CUSA: Missouri State, 5:30, WKU, 5:50

Schools 6-8 hours: MAC 3, CUSA, 1
MAC: Ohio, 6:30, Akron, 7:10, Kent State, 7:20
CUSA: MTSU, 6:55

Schools >8hrs: MAC 2, CUSA 9
MAC: Buffalo, 10:10, UMass, 15:00
CUSA: Kennesaw St, 9:40, Jacksonville State, 9:50, Louisiana Tech, 10:25, Liberty University, 11:10; University of Delaware, 12:20; Sam Houston, 13:40; NMSU, 19:30
UTEP, 19:50; FIU, 20:15

MAC average: 6:20
CUSA average: 12:05
07-19-2024 08:02 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Steve1981 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,907
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
Post: #1184
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-19-2024 08:02 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  Huhn, I peeked over there, and saw a post that retorted the distance to their supposed CUSA rival Missouri State by sarcastically referring to how close Buffalo was ... which seems to me they haven't thought through who all is in CUSA.

MAC average: 6:20
CUSA average: 12:05

Yes, saw that one post and kept my mouth shut. My first thought is Southern Illinois would be the only Illinois school that could be on CUSA radar, if they ever expressed interest.
07-19-2024 08:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TOPSTRAIGHT Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 13,365
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 769
I Root For: WKU
Location: Glasgow,KY.
Post: #1185
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
Just came over here to mention a couple of observations/opinions.

Have not heard one single reference concerning CUSA and any school from Illinois. Think they are happy at twelve. Also don't believe any school in Illinois would have interest in a Southern based league.

For the MAC-- my 2 cents worth---Illinois State would be a better institutional fit than SIU.

An interesting fact from BruceMcF that almost nobody would realize----only 3H 45m from Ill. St. to WMU. Very busable.
(This post was last modified: 07-19-2024 10:13 AM by TOPSTRAIGHT.)
07-19-2024 09:58 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #1186
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-14-2024 12:58 PM)epasnoopy Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 11:58 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 11:41 AM)epasnoopy Wrote:  The core of the the conference--9 schools in total--are in Ohio and Michigan. Adding UMass AND NDSU still doesn't change the fact that the only schools who really have to travel in this conference would be NDSU, UMass, NIU, and Buffalo. Those 9 schools plus Ball State still have relatively easy travel compared to those other four.

Any idea how the Northern Illinois community would regard Illinois State? On the one hand, they would provide an instant rival two hours away. (The "I-39 Rivalry," perhaps. We could let you borrow our I-75 trophy the next time we have it if you need ideas.) And it isn't like Illinois State is a terrible school or anything.

On the other, Northern Illinois would no longer be the only FBS school in the state outside of the Big Ten. Perhaps it would prefer the status quo?

I honestly don't know that NIU fans care enough about having a fellow in-state MAC rival. I think the two schools play each other so infrequently the last 50-60 years in football and basketball that there really isn't much of a dislike or rivalry. The two schools haven't shared a conference together since the 1960s. It would have to be generated by having them on the same level and conference and playing every year. I think Ill St. probably feels it's rivals are the other in-state schools they've shared conferences with, such as SIU and WIU (until they left MVFC). I also think they more associate themselves as a basketball school and probably more rivals with other basketball schools like Bradley, Northern Iowa, and Indiana St.

I was a bit disappointed with the amount of Ill St fans that came to DeKalb in 2019. SIU had way more fans the last few times they came to DeKalb and that's a much further distance.

That's always been my experience. The ISU fans I've always been around, and that includes a former AD, have been all about their rivalries with Bradley and SIU and Arch Madness and MVC hoops. Any link between NIU and ISU is effectively non-existent -- you'd have to travel back 60+ years in time.

I think another part of it is NIU has always been all-in on FB while ISU has traditionally been a MBB school. We're really bad at MBB and ISU hasn't ever been noteworthy at FB, so there's just never been any connectivity between the two schools/fan bases. Even if ISU joined the MAC, I'm not sure a real rivalry would ever develop...NIU would likely dominate FB while ISU would likely dominate MBB. We'd likely send very few fans there for MBB and they'd likely send few fans up here for FB based on past games.
07-20-2024 09:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pvk75 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,375
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 161
I Root For: MW, Horizon, PAC
Location:
Post: #1187
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-20-2024 09:58 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 12:58 PM)epasnoopy Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 11:58 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 11:41 AM)epasnoopy Wrote:  The core of the the conference--9 schools in total--are in Ohio and Michigan. Adding UMass AND NDSU still doesn't change the fact that the only schools who really have to travel in this conference would be NDSU, UMass, NIU, and Buffalo. Those 9 schools plus Ball State still have relatively easy travel compared to those other four.

Any idea how the Northern Illinois community would regard Illinois State? On the one hand, they would provide an instant rival two hours away. (The "I-39 Rivalry," perhaps. We could let you borrow our I-75 trophy the next time we have it if you need ideas.) And it isn't like Illinois State is a terrible school or anything.

On the other, Northern Illinois would no longer be the only FBS school in the state outside of the Big Ten. Perhaps it would prefer the status quo?

I honestly don't know that NIU fans care enough about having a fellow in-state MAC rival. I think the two schools play each other so infrequently the last 50-60 years in football and basketball that there really isn't much of a dislike or rivalry. The two schools haven't shared a conference together since the 1960s. It would have to be generated by having them on the same level and conference and playing every year. I think Ill St. probably feels it's rivals are the other in-state schools they've shared conferences with, such as SIU and WIU (until they left MVFC). I also think they more associate themselves as a basketball school and probably more rivals with other basketball schools like Bradley, Northern Iowa, and Indiana St.

I was a bit disappointed with the amount of Ill St fans that came to DeKalb in 2019. SIU had way more fans the last few times they came to DeKalb and that's a much further distance.

That's always been my experience. The ISU fans I've always been around, and that includes a former AD, have been all about their rivalries with Bradley and SIU and Arch Madness and MVC hoops. Any link between NIU and ISU is effectively non-existent -- you'd have to travel back 60+ years in time.

I think another part of it is NIU has always been all-in on FB while ISU has traditionally been a MBB school. We're really bad at MBB and ISU hasn't ever been noteworthy at FB, so there's just never been any connectivity between the two schools/fan bases. Even if ISU joined the MAC, I'm not sure a real rivalry would ever develop...NIU would likely dominate FB while ISU would likely dominate MBB. We'd likely send very few fans there for MBB and they'd likely send few fans up here for FB based on past games.

You are absolutely correct. Illinois State has zero potential either as a MAC member or a rival to NIU.

--- NIU has no room for another "rivalry," what with the manufactured ones with Ball State and Miami-O. The Bronze Stalk vs. Ball State originated with a DeKalb artist because NIU didn't have any. The Mallory Trophy game honors Bill Mallory (1935-2018), who coached at both at one time or the other, if and when it gets scheduled.
--- The $11.5 million IPF that ISU opened last October will do absolutely no good for elevating their football program above FCS. What were/are they thinking?!
--- The new ISU College of Engineering, scheduled to open in fall 2025, will not help elevate ISU's academic status.
--- That 14,568 attendance at the ISU-at-NIU football game in 2019, the highest in 23 Huskie Stadium games through 2023, including 2022 vs. Vanderbilt, was a fluke.
--- The 8-hour 'round trip from ISU to SIU is just as good as under-4-hours 'round trip between ISU and NIU. Everybody loves a longer scenic bus ride.
--- There is no way that NIU-ISU in all sports could possibly be better -- either for attendance or TV/streaming -- than the MVC adding UIC and the media deal with Bally Sports/NBC Chicago, both in 2022. Not even with the MAC-ESPN deal.

And with that "can't do/can't happen" attitude, NIU may be relegated to some day becoming Chicago State-West. By then, all 200 remaining fans will love it.
(This post was last modified: 07-21-2024 09:33 PM by pvk75.)
07-21-2024 04:24 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Steve1981 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,907
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
Post: #1188
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
With No-one really standing out and ready, plus the ACC deadline of Aug 15, think the MAC can take it's time and make a wise choice for 2026-27. Realize that some NIU fans are not fans of Illinois State, but they are as worthy and fit the MAC as good as others. Time will tell if if we are presently surprised or a FCS university gets the nod.

Note this from Tiger1983 on the Realignment board.
07-22-2024 02:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pvk75 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,375
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 161
I Root For: MW, Horizon, PAC
Location:
Post: #1189
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-22-2024 02:33 PM)Steve1981 Wrote:  With No-one really standing out and ready, plus the ACC deadline of Aug 15, think the MAC can take it's time and make a wise choice for 2026-27. Realize that some NIU fans are not fans of Illinois State, but they are as worthy and fit the MAC as good as others. Time will tell if if we are presently surprised or a FCS university gets the nod.

Agree 90%, as ISU remains my choice for now (my attempted and perhaps weak sarcasm vis-a-vis anti-ISU types nothwithstanding). The MAC-ESPN contract as exists expires mid-2027, so if there is a #14 it/whoever needs to be on board for negotiations. Until then I agree ... let it sit unless there is some new, actual, real information.
(This post was last modified: 07-22-2024 08:53 PM by pvk75.)
07-22-2024 08:52 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #1190
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-22-2024 08:52 PM)pvk75 Wrote:  
(07-22-2024 02:33 PM)Steve1981 Wrote:  With No-one really standing out and ready, plus the ACC deadline of Aug 15, think the MAC can take it's time and make a wise choice for 2026-27. Realize that some NIU fans are not fans of Illinois State, but they are as worthy and fit the MAC as good as others. Time will tell if if we are presently surprised or a FCS university gets the nod.

Agree 90%, as ISU remains my choice for now (my attempted and perhaps weak sarcasm vis-a-vis anti-ISU types nothwithstanding). The MAC-ESPN contract as exists expires mid-2027, so if there is a #14 it/whoever needs to be on board for negotiations. Until then I agree ... let it sit unless there is some new, actual, real information.

I don't see how the MAC can go wrong with Illinios State because if it wants to expand into the Dakotas or even SIU/WKU having ISU already in the MAC will help the effort.

Also while the MAC will always be committed to the Midwest I'm not sure if they will staty committed to the east if UMass/Buffalo leave. I mean the MAC could someday go in with Delaware and Temple or it could not. If the AAC cannot reload with teams from the SBC they might have to look back to the northeast.
07-23-2024 09:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #1191
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-21-2024 04:24 PM)pvk75 Wrote:  
(07-20-2024 09:58 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  That's always been my experience. The ISU fans I've always been around, and that includes a former AD, have been all about their rivalries with Bradley and SIU and Arch Madness and MVC hoops. Any link between NIU and ISU is effectively non-existent -- you'd have to travel back 60+ years in time.

I think another part of it is NIU has always been all-in on FB while ISU has traditionally been a MBB school. We're really bad at MBB and ISU hasn't ever been noteworthy at FB, so there's just never been any connectivity between the two schools/fan bases. Even if ISU joined the MAC, I'm not sure a real rivalry would ever develop...NIU would likely dominate FB while ISU would likely dominate MBB. We'd likely send very few fans there for MBB and they'd likely send few fans up here for FB based on past games.

You are absolutely correct. Illinois State has zero potential either as a MAC member or a rival to NIU.

--- NIU has no room for another "rivalry," what with the manufactured ones with Ball State and Miami-O. The Bronze Stalk vs. Ball State originated with a DeKalb artist because NIU didn't have any. The Mallory Trophy game honors Bill Mallory (1935-2018), who coached at both at one time or the other, if and when it gets scheduled.
--- The $11.5 million IPF that ISU opened last October will do absolutely no good for elevating their football program above FCS. What were/are they thinking?!
--- The new ISU College of Engineering, scheduled to open in fall 2025, will not help elevate ISU's academic status.
--- That 14,568 attendance at the ISU-at-NIU football game in 2019, the highest in 23 Huskie Stadium games through 2023, including 2022 vs. Vanderbilt, was a fluke.
--- The 8-hour 'round trip from ISU to SIU is just as good as under-4-hours 'round trip between ISU and NIU. Everybody loves a longer scenic bus ride.
--- There is no way that NIU-ISU in all sports could possibly be better -- either for attendance or TV/streaming -- than the MVC adding UIC and the media deal with Bally Sports/NBC Chicago, both in 2022. Not even with the MAC-ESPN deal.

And with that "can't do/can't happen" attitude, NIU may be relegated to some day becoming Chicago State-West. By then, all 200 remaining fans will love it.

Pardon me, where did I say Illinois St has "zero potential" as a MAC member or NIU rival? I just gave an opinion that I don't see a real rivalry developing, citing my anecdotes and historical knowledge of the schools.

This is a really immature response. All throughout your reply, you are making up things I didn't say and blowing things I did say way out of proportion. You're then making sarcastic, passive-aggressive responses to things....I did not say.

For the sake of having an honest discussion of what I actually said, let's go through this point-by-point:

#1 - I never said or implied "NIU doesn't have room for another rivalry" or that "NIU's rivalries with Miami or Ball St aren't manufactured". I never mentioned either point. All I said is I don't see a real rivalry developing between NIU and ISU as the schools have completely different cultures. NIU is all-in on FB while ISU traditionally has been a BB school. That point is fair and accurate.

#2 - Sure. I never mentioned ISU's facilities, nor implied they were incapable of moving to FCS. So why is this directed at me? This has nothing to do with anything I said.

#3 - Sure. I never mentioned or implied anything about ISU's academics. Again, why is this directed at me?

#4 - Yes, I attended that game. I also attended SIU and EIU games. Like epasnoopy, I felt SIU brought more fans and EIU brought a little less. I agree that in-state opponents bring more visiting fans. But what you're missing is important context: that 14,568 was on the Saturday night of Labor Day weekend. A 72-degree Saturday night on Labor Day weekend is the perfect circumstances for attendance.

The other times NIU hosted a Saturday night Labor Day weekend game?
2011 Army (17,003)
2015 UNLV (15,455)
2019 Illinois St (14,568)

When you compare apples-to-apples, in the three instances NIU hosted a Saturday night Labor Day weekend game, the Illinois St game ranked 3rd of the 3 in attendance. That indicates Illinois St itself didn't drive attendance -- it was the date (Labor Day Weekend), day (Saturday), time (night), and weather (72 degrees) that drove it. I do agree there's a slight uptick with an in-state opponent, but not much.

#5 - Um, what? I didn't mention anything about ISU's proximity to SIU or NIU. All I said was ISU fans, including the former AD I'm friends, are passionate about their long histories with Bradley and (to a lesser extent) SIU. Those are schools with very similar athletic cultures as them as they're all BB-passionate schools. That's a fair and accurate point that's played out in those games' historical MBB attendance.

#6 - I didn't mention anything about UIC or a tv deal. Again, making up something I said. What does ISU playing UIC have to do with ISU's attendance playing NIU? If you want to go into attendance, ISU/Bradley and ISU/SIU draw quite a bit better for MBB than what ISU/NIU would draw. A quick look at what ISU/Bradley and ISU/SIU have drawn over many years will confirm that. On the other hand, we (NIU) draw hundreds for MBB and are historically bad, so it doesn't compare as a MBB draw to ISU/Bradley or ISU/SIU.

#7 - How does anything I said indicate NIU will turn into "Chicago State-West"? Simply because I don't believe NIU/ISU would be a big draw or much of a rivalry? A totally valid opinion? You've made a mountain out of a molehill of what I said yet again.


Of your 7 points:
- 5 were things I never said or mentioned.
- 1 was something you twisted what I said massively out-of-proportion.
- Leaving only 1 point where something you claimed I said was actually something I did say.


We're all MAC fans here. If we're going to have an honest discussion, it's important to actually be honest about what the other person is saying. Creating strawmen and making up what the other person said just makes you look small. If you're going to be passive-aggressive and sarcastic, it better be to things the other person *actually* said. Every point I made in my original post is totally valid.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 01:34 AM by IWokeUpLikeThis.)
07-24-2024 12:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pvk75 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,375
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 161
I Root For: MW, Horizon, PAC
Location:
Post: #1192
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
You went through a lot of trouble to disparage me personally for a perceived personal attack that does not exist.

I never said you or any other specific person said those things.

In fact, I said those things ... me ... myself. No one else. That should be obvious since they appear in no one else's post. You attached those items to yourself.

Some dismiss ISU and its potential in favor of other possibilities they like better. They also question whether NIU is capable of establishing what some would call a real rivalry, which IMO it does not have.

I added facts I know -- certainly not all there is -- to support the above (though did not disparage other possibilities) to make the points that a) ISU is moving forward and b) there is potential there for NIU as well.

Sarcasm is difficult to achieve; had I simply stated facts, no problem. But I won't lose any sleep over my choice. It is unfortunate that I chose to attach it to a string of comments, of which yours was the last. I could have simply posted it without attachment. But I apologize for nothing else. (BTW, that reference to Chicago State has nothing to do with you; CSU's problems are well-documented, and a "merger" of sorts had been discussed way, way back on these forums. Do some homework if you like.)

"Creating strawmen in your head and then being passive-aggressive and sarcastic to things the other person didn't say isn't productive. Playing games like that just makes you look small."

That's worse than anything anyone could imagine from what I posted. But I won't spend more time than this being butt-hurt by a real personal attack rather than a perceived one.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 01:40 AM by pvk75.)
07-24-2024 01:31 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Online
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #1193
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-24-2024 01:31 AM)pvk75 Wrote:  You went through a lot of trouble to disparage me personally for a perceived personal attack that does not exist.

I never said you or any other specific person said those things.

In fact, I said those things ... me ... myself. No one else. That should be clear since no one else did. You attached those items to yourself.

Some dismiss ISU and its potential in favor of other possibilities they like better. They also question whether NIU is capable of establishing what some would call a real rivalry, which IMO it does not have.

I added facts I know -- certainly not all there is -- to support the above (though did not disparage other possibilities) to make the points that a) ISU is moving forward and b) there is potential there for NIU as well.

Sarcasm is difficult to achieve; had I simply stated facts, no problem. But I won't lose any sleep over my choice. It is unfortunate that I chose to attach it to a string of comments, of which yours was the last. I could have simply posted it without attachment. But I apologize for nothing else. (BTW, that reference to Chicago State has nothing to do with you; CSU's problems are well-documented, and a "merger" of sorts had been discussed way, way back on these forums. Do some homework if you like.)

"Creating strawmen in your head and then being passive-aggressive and sarcastic to things the other person didn't say isn't productive. Playing games like that just makes you look small."

That's worse than anything anyone could imagine from what I posted. But I won't spend more time than this being butt-hurt by a real personal attack rather than a perceived one.

Your very first line to me was this:
Quote:You are absolutely correct. Illinois State has zero potential either as a MAC member or a rival to NIU.
-- You are directly implying that I think Illinois State has zero potential (something I didn't say or mention). How am I supposed to perceive this? Perhaps this was not intentional on your end, but certainly you can see how someone read it this way.

Read through my original post. Then read through your reply. You start with addressing me directly, and then your whole reply is sarcastic and passive-aggressive when it was totally unnecessary. How else is someone supposed to receive that?

You say "it's unfortunate that I chose to attach my reply to a string of comments" but you're ignoring that you addressed me directly at the beginning with a sarcastic "you are absolutely correct". Who else am I supposed to think your reply is for?

I'll accept that it's a misunderstanding. But I'm not sure how you expect me to take your post - given your first two sentences - different than how I did.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 03:33 AM by IWokeUpLikeThis.)
07-24-2024 02:16 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pvk75 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,375
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 161
I Root For: MW, Horizon, PAC
Location:
Post: #1194
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
This is getting ridiculous and this will be my last post on it.

I'll concede it could be read that way if someone cut the string of posts off the top. Maybe I should have said "you'all" or "those who think" or something like that. (I don't speak "Southern" and I'm not really sure how to spell "you'all.")

From that, you derive that all my points are aimed at you. How? Nobody including you said anything I listed. In fact, you said you didn't say those things. Those were my points, not somebody else's. In fact, none of those things were mentioned by anyone else.

Does that provide an excuse for a personal attack like "Creating strawmen in your head and then being passive-aggressive and sarcastic to things the other person didn't say isn't productive. Playing games like that just makes you look small."

That's a pretty hefty response for a "you." And if I think I need a psychoanalyst, I'll pay one.

From now on I am going to do several things:
--- Be very cautious at using sarcasm.
--- Post independent of others.
--- If addressed to an individual, cite their username so there is no misunderstanding.

You can have the last word if you like.

FYI. From Malice in Blunderland, Thomas Lyle Martin (1973): "I know you believe you understand what you think I said. But I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant."
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 04:10 AM by pvk75.)
07-24-2024 04:07 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,766
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #1195
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
Quote: ... Maybe I should have said "you'all" or "those who think" or something like that. (I don't speak "Southern" and I'm not really sure how to spell "you'all.")

I am not a native Southern speaker, but having gone to graduate school in Knoxville, where I now live, it's "y'all". The all-inclusive plural you (said more often than written) is all'a'y'all.

If you prefer the east coast, you can also do the Jersey "youse guys".

It does read differently if it is assumed that it is addressing everything above it, and not just the last statement in the nested block.

If the two schools the MAC are in discussion with are NDSU and Illinois State, all'a'y'all know where my preference lies.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 06:36 AM by BruceMcF.)
07-24-2024 06:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FMRocket Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,543
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 121
I Root For: UT Blue & Gold
Location: Perrysburg, Ohio
Post: #1196
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-24-2024 06:23 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
Quote: ... Maybe I should have said "you'all" or "those who think" or something like that. (I don't speak "Southern" and I'm not really sure how to spell "you'all.")

I am not a native Southern speaker, but having gone to graduate school in Knoxville, where I now live, it's "y'all". The all-inclusive plural you (said more often than written) is all'a'y'all.

If you prefer the east coast, you can also do the Jersey "youse guys".

It does read differently if it is assumed that it is addressing everything above it, and not just the last statement in the nested block.

If the two schools the MAC are in discussion with are NDSU and Illinois State, all'a'y'all know where my preference lies.

Around Pittsburgh, “Yinz” is the equivalent to y’all - used to address two or more people as a second person plural pronoun …04-cheers
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 01:22 PM by FMRocket.)
07-24-2024 01:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Steve1981 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,907
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
Post: #1197
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-24-2024 01:18 PM)FMRocket Wrote:  
(07-24-2024 06:23 AM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
Quote: ... Maybe I should have said "you'all" or "those who think" or something like that. (I don't speak "Southern" and I'm not really sure how to spell "you'all.")

I am not a native Southern speaker, but having gone to graduate school in Knoxville, where I now live, it's "y'all". The all-inclusive plural you (said more often than written) is all'a'y'all.

If you prefer the east coast, you can also do the Jersey "youse guys".

It does read differently if it is assumed that it is addressing everything above it, and not just the last statement in the nested block.

If the two schools the MAC are in discussion with are NDSU and Illinois State, all'a'y'all know where my preference lies.

Around Pittsburgh, “Yinz” is the equivalent to y’all - used to address two or more people as a second person plural pronoun …04-cheers

It's 2 yutes!


07-24-2024 03:30 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
nodak651 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,313
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 136
I Root For: North Dakota
Location:
Post: #1198
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-14-2024 01:26 PM)BruceMcF Wrote:  
(07-14-2024 08:45 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote:  ... Respectfully (because I do respect you BruceMcF), it seems to me that the real game of pretend here is that North Dakota State isn't a real flagship because they happen to be located in a small state.

My point is that what the associations of the term "flagship" come from Universities that are flagships of states that are five to ten to twenty time the size, or more. When we say "flagship", we think of Wisconsin and Illinois and Texas and Oklahoma, not Rhode Island and Wyoming.

You could say, "but Oklahoma is a flagship of a small state", but Oklahoma is a state with five times the population of North Dakota.

Just qualifying for the term doesn't carry with it the characteristics associated with the term when we are talking about being the flagship of a fleet of cutters rather than the flagship of a fleet of ships of the line.

So what I am referring to is the suggestion that being the "flagship" of North Dakota is somehow an automatic "institutional fit" card into a group of Universities that are all larger, and a number twice the size.

Being R1 is an argument toward overlooking NDSU's small size ... being a "flagship" seems to me to just be a way of distracting from it, since the associations we get from the term "flagship" are of being a University toward the size of the larger MAC schools if not bigger than any MAC school.

I suppose it could be argued that NDSU is A flagship of ND, but they aren't THE flagship. Either way, despite the smaller size of the state and school, Institutional expenses, Institutional Endowment, Athletics Endowment, and Total Institutional expenses all align with the middle to top of the MAC.

Athletics Dedicated Endowments: $43,388,686
Institutional Endowments: $377,961,500
Institutional Expenses: $582,707,279
Institution's Education and General Expenses: $520,614,266
Right there when it comes to FB attendance, athletics generated revenue, and fanbase size, as well.

Other than attendance being a bit less, I don't see how they aren't an institutional fit in the MAC? That said, that doesn't mean I think they are a good fit for athletics membership. IMO, they don't make any sense due to geography and travel costs for Olympic sports.
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2024 04:42 PM by nodak651.)
07-24-2024 04:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
pvk75 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,375
Joined: Jan 2018
Reputation: 161
I Root For: MW, Horizon, PAC
Location:
Post: #1199
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
I have nothing against NDSU. They have fine football and mbball programs, solid attendance, etc. I agree with the statistical profile that indicates NDSU does "fit" the MAC.

However, statistics do not explain the orientation of NDSU. As far as I can tell, their chief rivals for all/most sports are the other three Dakota schools, the Montanas, Idaho, a growing St. Thomas (Minneapolis/St. Paul), and maybe a few other West and Southwest schools.

Also, when one moved to the MVFC and Summit League, all four Dakotas eventually moved. The Summit HQ moved from Moline, Il., to Souix Falls, where both bball tournaments are played. NDSU leaving all sports would require major adjustments to all that (consider political ramifications).

Earlier in this thread, I postulated that whoever is #14 must fill one of two "gaps" (a #15 and #16 -- if ever -- can fill the other):

--- The West Gap: roughly, a triangle between NIU, WMU and Ball State. IMHO, Illinois State is in the best position at present with the best potential to do that. Yes, they need a full-time AD first.
--- The East Gap: roughly, a geographic area between UMass and a north-south "line" of Buffalo, Kent State, Akron and Ohio. Several potentials have been mentioned (UAlbany, Stony Brook/needs new president, Youngstown State, etc.). I have since dropped any preference because the potentials and variables are too numerous to opine reasonably.

The "gaps" are important because the MAC and MAC schools have made it clear (see UMass) that it wants all-sports adds. At the same time, some travel cost control is paramount with limited resources (MAC schools do not have big TV/streaming money to fly cross-country like the "power" conferences; in fact, other threads' posts have opined that even they may "localize" some "minor" sports regionally.)

IMHO, the MAC's almost-legendary stability -- and need for geographic cohesion -- may evolve to greater importance with all the changes coming down from "on high."

NDSU would be a great football add. But while football drives the bus, schools need to be able to afford to put other sports in the other seats.

All this with two things:
--- We don't pick anybody. MAC presidents will decide any invites, and invitees will say yay or nay.
--- The new/renewal of the MAC-ESPN media rights deal is inching closer but it isn't moving ... it's still mid-2027.
(This post was last modified: 07-25-2024 08:34 AM by pvk75.)
07-25-2024 12:10 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Steve1981 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,907
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 333
I Root For: UMass
Location: North Quabbin Region
Post: #1200
RE: MAC Expansion and Keeping an Eye on Media Contracts, Partners Discussions.
(07-25-2024 12:10 AM)pvk75 Wrote:  I have nothing against NDSU. They have fine football and mbball programs, solid attendance, etc. I agree with the statistical profile that indicates NDSU does "fit" the MAC.

However, statistics do not explain the orientation of NDSU. As far as I can tell, their chief rivals for all/most sports are the other three Dakota schools, the Montanas, Idaho, a growing St. Thomas (Minneapolis/St. Paul), and maybe a few other West and Southwest schools.

Also, when one moved to the MVFC and Summit League, all four Dakotas eventually moved. The Summit HQ moved from Moline, Il., to Souix Falls, where both bball tournaments are played. NDSU leaving all sports would require major adjustments to all that (consider political ramifications).

Earlier in this thread, I postulated that whoever is #14 must fill one of two "gaps" (a #15 and #16 -- if ever -- can fill the other):

--- The West Gap: roughly, a triangle between NIU, WMU and Ball State. IMHO, Illinois State is in the best position at present with the best potential to do that. Yes, they need a full-time AD first.
--- The East Gap: roughly, a geographic area between UMass and a north-south "line" of Buffalo, Kent State, Akron and Ohio. Several potentials have been mentioned (UAlbany, Stony Brook/needs new president, Youngstown State, etc.). I have since dropped any preference because the potentials and variables are too numerous to opine reasonably.

The "gaps" are important because the MAC and MAC schools have made it clear (see UMass) that it wants all-sports adds. At the same time, some travel cost control is paramount with limited resources (MAC schools do not have big TV/streaming money to fly cross-country like the "power" conferences; in fact, other threads' posts have opined that even they may "localize" some "minor" sports regionally.)

IMHO, the MAC's almost-legendary stability -- and need for geographic cohesion -- may evolve to greater importance with all the changes coming down from "on high."

NDSU would be a great football add. But while football drives the bus, schools need to be able to afford to put other sports in the other seats.

All this with two things:
--- We don't pick anybody. MAC presidents will decide any invites, and invitees will say yay or nay.
--- The new/renewal of the MAC-ESPN media rights deal is inching closer but it isn't moving ... it's still mid-2027.
Personally look at NDSU and Delaware and both are R1, great institutions. NDSU is better in football and in basketball. Delaware is still good in football, not as good in basketball and larger sports portfolio. Both are in non continuous states to the MAC footprint, though Delaware is a lot closer. Delaware is a flight risk to the AAC with Temple, Navy and the Carolina teams are not that far.

I know Delaware is not on the table, but think the reasons are similar enough that thought of comparing the two. NDSU is better sportswise and R1. It will be interest to see all this play out in the next 6 months.
(This post was last modified: 07-25-2024 06:57 PM by Steve1981.)
07-25-2024 08:59 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.