Garcia will most likely make it.

Simpkins is a long shot, but even if he does, Cal would probably redshirt him this season anyway.

CyberTiger Wrote:Garcia will most likely make it.

Simpkins is a long shot, but even if he does, Cal would probably redshirt him this season anyway.

Care to elaborate?

Elaborate how? That is pretty clear isn't it?

CyberTiger Wrote:Elaborate how? That is pretty clear isn't it?

I think the point may be that we understand if that is just your wishful thinking.

And, many have been speculating much the same thing for some time now, while we all await impatiently for definitive news.

But---if you KNOW more, then we would like for you to tell us what you KNOW that would prompt a new thread.

I wouldn't argue with Cyber Tiger. Those who have in the past have lost.

i think people mean they wish to see a post phrased such as .......

"i have spoken to someone at the NCAA clearninghouse or the basketball Staff and this individual has seen hard evidence that Simpkins will not meet eligiblity requirements for 2008, but Simpkins has stated with certitude to the Staff that he will be happy to be a full time member in 2009"

or something like that....

CyberTiger Wrote:Elaborate how? That is pretty clear isn't it?

without a link, or proof...it's useless info.

Go Tigers!!!
Drew

CyberTiger Wrote:Elaborate how? That is pretty clear isn't it?

No. You're saying Simpkins will likely not be cleared and will redshirt. Is that your opinion? What is it based on? Do you have a source? Is it a premonition? Tea leaves?

The part that confuses me the most is why Cal would redshirt Simpkins even if he was cleared to play. We need some depth on the frontlie and MAtt sounds like a pretty good talent.

Plus rumors of Simpkins redshirting for next year can't help in the recruiting of Robinson

After reading Matt's comments the other day, I think he may be
resigned to a red shirt year already.

From what I've heard, this assessment is spot on regarding Garcia making it and Simpkins not. As for the redshirting of Simpkins, I haven't heard that one but will take Cyber's word on it as he has been on target with most things he reports to us.

thedanetrain Wrote:Is that just your opinion or are you in the know?

He's just repeating what EVERYONE has been saying for the last 3 months. Simpkins said it himself in an interview. No news here as usual; just sit back and enjoy the girls making out.

I met Angel Garcia last night while at Half Shell - He was there with one of the Memphis Managers and Geeorge Kline (Elvis's old running buddy). First may I say, He is extremely tall (he towered me and I stand about 6'1) but skinny. When shaking his hand I couldn't help but notice his abnormally long hands. Anyways, I asked when he thought we would hear back from the clearinghouse and he responded by saying that the whole situation has been a circus but assured me he would be dressed out on the court for the first game. Also noted that he loved Memphis thus far mainly due to the warmer weather compared to Chicago. Much like the waiting game in recruiting news it seems like it is only a matter of time but all sources appear confident that Garcia will be cleared.

Stammers Wrote:

thedanetrain Wrote:Is that just your opinion or are you in the know?

He's just repeating what EVERYONE has been saying for the last 3 months. Simpkins said it himself in an interview. No news here as usual; just sit back and enjoy the girls making out.

Actually, you're wrong as usual...this was passed along to me last night from one of my guys.

I didn't realize the paper stated Simpkins would probably be redshirted even if he passed the clearinghouse. Do you get a different version of the CA in Canada?

And if Pierre doesn't get to 280, Cal may not give him a jersey...it seems that's a legit threat and weight target.

Sitting at 300 right now...however, I would think if he's adding muscle and he has his quickness, 280+ could work. My guess is, as long as he's showing the determination and he can handle the off and def schemes, he should get PT...especially if Simpkins doesn't make it.

NJ1 Wrote:I understand that's common... a "weight-loss plateau" I've heard it called. After awhile he might be able to start losing fast again.

Go skinny P!

Yes, anyone who has tried to lose weight (myself included) has experienced the dreaded and discouraging plateau. Pierre will need to work through it. Eventually, the weight will drop if he keeps watching what he eats and exercises vigorously. He can do it!

CyberTiger Wrote:Garcia will most likely make it.

Simpkins is a long shot, but even if he does, Cal would probably redshirt him this season anyway.

Are you able to share when the official word is expected?

Tiger1983 Wrote:

CyberTiger Wrote:Garcia will most likely make it.

Simpkins is a long shot, but even if he does, Cal would probably redshirt him this season anyway.

Are you able to share when the official word is expected?

Up to the NCAA...I don't know the answer to that one.

CyberTiger Wrote:

Tiger1983 Wrote:

CyberTiger Wrote:Garcia will most likely make it.

Simpkins is a long shot, but even if he does, Cal would probably redshirt him this season anyway.

Are you able to share when the official word is expected?

Up to the NCAA...I don't know the answer to that one.

Its ok, no one ever does......Freakin' NCAA