(09-30-2024 01:00 PM)Troy_Fan_15 Wrote: Divisions are important to us because it promotes the regional rivalries we like to emphasize. Dropping them and having App St. play South Alabama or Coastal play Troy more at the expense of Coastal and Marshall or App St. and JMU isn't ideal.
(09-30-2024 01:46 PM)bigbelly Wrote: I don't see why divisions are so important either. If a conference has 12 or 14 members, instead of splitting those up why don't you just plan it out so that every school plays their four closest regional rivals every year and then rotates the others? It's not all that complicated.
When C-USA goes to twelve next year (presumably) I hope we don't split into two divisions.
Divisions make sense when the divisions make sense. They made sense for the previous version of CUSA and they make sense for the current SB. They don't make sense for the current CUSA.
By the time you've played your four regional rivals, you might as well have a divisional race. Pods have their place too in theory, but again, not for the current CUSA.
The reason divisions and pods don't make sense for the current CUSA is that you don't have a clear dividing line (for divisions) and you don't have groups of 2-4 rivals (for pods).
So for us, maybe protect the couple of rivalries you do have and rotate through. Whatever.
For the SB, I'm sure there are outlying cases (they don't all
really care that much about playing
all of their divisional opponents, no matter what they say) but on the whole, it matters more. It's better. Better for all teams involved.