monarx
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,468
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 419
I Root For: ODU
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
|
|
| 02-19-2025 12:30 PM |
|
HarborPointe
North American Champion

Posts: 7,734
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 855
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: Parts Unknown
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
More or less.
|
|
| 02-19-2025 12:45 PM |
|
Johnnychimpo
1st String

Posts: 1,701
Joined: Sep 2021
Reputation: 44
I Root For: TXST, G5, TTU sometimes
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly.
It’s not a 1/6 chance. It’s a 1/6 chance that your CONFERENCE places A TEAM in the CFP playoff. Whereas in the current 12 team format there is a 1 in 6 chance that a P4 TEAM, not conference, gets in the CFP and that’s as is. Giving the SEC and B1G 4 auto bids each in the next format is ludicrous. Basically a preseason 50:50 chance (in a hypothetical world that all P2s were relatively equal) that any team that is in either of those conferences gets in.
So my issue is not the 1:6 chance. It’s that 1 G5 conference has basically the same probability of sending a single team as the P4 has of sending ANY team to the playoff. 11 spots in current format for 67 P4 teams = 15% chance. 1/6 G5 conferences = 16.6% chance
|
|
| 02-19-2025 02:01 PM |
|
OsageJ
Sun Belt Nationalist

Posts: 11,039
Joined: May 2002
Reputation: 683
I Root For: stAte
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
Texas State has been trying to move now for 81 pages. Y'all need to stop and just stay with your poor relations!
|
|
| 02-19-2025 03:40 PM |
|
AlwaysSunny
1st String

Posts: 1,392
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 43
I Root For: NCAA
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
You seem to believe that the G6 actually has a choice.
|
|
| 02-19-2025 04:01 PM |
|
Saint3333
Hall of Famer

Posts: 12,679
Joined: Feb 2011
Reputation: 1022
I Root For: App State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 04:01 PM)AlwaysSunny Wrote: (02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
You seem to believe that the G6 actually has a choice.
You can throw the ACC and BIG12 is there as well now.
|
|
| 02-19-2025 04:24 PM |
|
Bobcat87
San Marvelous Cat

Posts: 11,709
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 430
I Root For: TXST, A&M, UNT
Location: Texas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 03:40 PM)OsageJ Wrote: Texas State has been trying to move now for 81 pages. Y'all need to stop and just stay with your poor relations!
eehhh, not really so much US trying to move, as US coming up in realignment conversations.
Thanks to their “Legal Situation,” the PAC is moving at a Glacial pace, so we might see 81 more pages of this before it’s all resolved.
We did decline a MW invite, so there’s that.
Personally, I wish someone would make a damn decision, positive, negative, I don’t care, just make one and let’s move on.
|
|
| 02-19-2025 05:39 PM |
|
chrisattsu
Mom's Favorite

Posts: 2,076
Joined: Jun 2009
Reputation: 81
I Root For: Tarleton / TXST
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 05:39 PM)Bobcat87 Wrote: (02-19-2025 03:40 PM)OsageJ Wrote: Texas State has been trying to move now for 81 pages. Y'all need to stop and just stay with your poor relations!
eehhh, not really so much US trying to move, as US coming up in realignment conversations.
Thanks to their “Legal Situation,” the PAC is moving at a Glacial pace, so we might see 81 more pages of this before it’s all resolved.
We did decline a MW invite, so there’s that.
Personally, I wish someone would make a damn decision, positive, negative, I don’t care, just make one and let’s move on.
Right there with you
|
|
| 02-19-2025 10:09 PM |
|
GreenBison
Heisman

Posts: 8,954
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 735
I Root For: Marshall | SBC
Location: West By God!
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
That’s the plan eventuallly.
|
|
| 02-20-2025 12:08 PM |
|
space orange
2nd String

Posts: 330
Joined: Jun 2021
Reputation: 33
I Root For: UCF
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
I get it since it does add a new conference competing for that same 1 spot. But it's mostly reshuffling chairs that were already there, just added 2 P4 castoffs.. If anything it's CUSA that technically diluted the chances of each G5/6 team by adding 5 FCS call-ups and 2 FBS independents that weren't eligible for that G5 slot before.
Realistically though, how does this change things? The new MWC seems considerably weaker and likely won't be a factor most years. The old MWC that was a factor is now cosplaying as the PAC. So now instead of the G5/6 spot bring between the AAC, MWC, and SB most years it'll be AAC, PAC, and SB.
|
|
| 02-20-2025 01:04 PM |
|
AlwaysSunny
1st String

Posts: 1,392
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 43
I Root For: NCAA
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
There's no way to tell if that'll be long lasting for either conference. There have been way too many shifts in which conferences run what. The ACC would've had this argument in basketball not so long ago, not so much now. That media money is going to matter more and more for every conference. Also, being the stronger conference via Massey isn't a metric that's going to get your team into the playoffs. No more than it kept Liberty from getting the spot for that game against Oregon.
|
|
| 02-20-2025 04:41 PM |
|
Bobcat87
San Marvelous Cat

Posts: 11,709
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 430
I Root For: TXST, A&M, UNT
Location: Texas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
* Bump
|
|
| 02-22-2025 10:08 PM |
|
MUther
Heisman

Posts: 9,911
Joined: Jun 2002
Reputation: 729
I Root For: Marshall
Location:

|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-20-2025 04:41 PM)AlwaysSunny Wrote: Also, being the stronger conference via Massey isn't a metric that's going to get your team into the playoffs. No more than it kept Liberty from getting the spot for that game against Oregon.
Which is funny as the very argument used by Alabama as to why they should have been in this year.
|
|
| 02-22-2025 10:29 PM |
|
Bobcat2013
Heisman

Posts: 5,770
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 326
I Root For: Texas State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
Someone on our board posted a tweet from our president implying that something big is about to happen for us... he tweeted two songs "Something Big" and "Any Day Now"
|
|
| 02-23-2025 06:24 PM |
|
Bobcat87
San Marvelous Cat

Posts: 11,709
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 430
I Root For: TXST, A&M, UNT
Location: Texas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-23-2025 06:24 PM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: Someone on our board posted a tweet from our president implying that something big is about to happen for us... he tweeted two songs "Something Big" and "Any Day Now"
Taco Tuesday coming back to The Dining Halls?
. . … ‘bout time.
|
|
| 02-23-2025 06:56 PM |
|
HarborPointe
North American Champion

Posts: 7,734
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 855
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: Parts Unknown
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-23-2025 06:24 PM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: Someone on our board posted a tweet from our president implying that something big is about to happen for us... he tweeted two songs "Something Big" and "Any Day Now"
TxSt’s clearly headed to the Big Ten or Big Twelve.
Or maybe the president just likes Tom Petty.
|
|
| 02-24-2025 03:08 AM |
|
Bobcat87
San Marvelous Cat

Posts: 11,709
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 430
I Root For: TXST, A&M, UNT
Location: Texas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-24-2025 03:08 AM)HarborPointe Wrote: (02-23-2025 06:24 PM)Bobcat2013 Wrote: Someone on our board posted a tweet from our president implying that something big is about to happen for us... he tweeted two songs "Something Big" and "Any Day Now"
TxSt’s clearly headed to the Big Ten or Big Twelve.
Or maybe the president just likes Tom Petty.

|
|
| 02-24-2025 09:34 AM |
|
chiefsfan
No Seriously, they let me be a mod

Posts: 46,947
Joined: Sep 2007
Reputation: 1324
I Root For: ASU
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
I can confirm that Damp does like Tom Petty
|
|
| 02-24-2025 09:44 AM |
|
Bobcat87
San Marvelous Cat

Posts: 11,709
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 430
I Root For: TXST, A&M, UNT
Location: Texas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-24-2025 09:44 AM)chiefsfan Wrote: I can confirm that Damp does like Tom Petty
Well, come on . . . . Who don’t?
|
|
| 02-24-2025 10:39 AM |
|
ericsaid
Heisman

Posts: 9,827
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 258
I Root For: App. State/ECU
Location: High Point, NC
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(02-19-2025 12:30 PM)monarx Wrote: The G5 agreed to the current situation with the understanding they would have a 1 in 5 chance of their champion being in the CFP. Making it 1 in 6 changes the deal significantly. I say the PAC needs to go to the negotiating table or get left out. They were part of the P5, their beef is with them, not us. Just because they get the boot from the P5 doesn't mean they should automatically be in the G5. We shouldn't just let them in and lessen our odds of ever making the playoff. Whats to keep the ACC from being dropped down next? Then the B12? Do we eventually get 8 spots each for the SEC and Big 10 and a play in spot for the top champ of a group of 8?
Your math is off. The G% has a 100% chance of making the CFP. The problem is that each school has a 1 in 64 (or however many schools there are) chance of making it, from the G5. Whereas if you're SEC or Big 10 you have a 2 in 9 chance, and ACC and Big 12 has probably a 1 in 16 chance most years.
|
|
| 02-24-2025 12:00 PM |
|