JTApps1
1st String

Posts: 2,312
Joined: Feb 2011
Reputation: 169
I Root For: App State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:11 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:00 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:53 PM)Ed Harley Wrote: La Tech doesn’t appeal to most AState fans. Let them rot in CUSA.
This, my friends, is the manifestation of true hate, as opposed to “Let’s bail them out of terrible situation and share our money with them.”
Which is why Arkstfan is right when he says AState may not particularly care who comes in. Some of our fans absolutely want nothing to do with Tech even if from a travel perspective they make some sense
That type of "dislike" is what makes it fun though. It would increase attendance for multiple schools which makes a difference when TV payouts are great.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:29 PM |
|
chiefsfan
No Seriously, they let me be a mod

Posts: 46,950
Joined: Sep 2007
Reputation: 1324
I Root For: ASU
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:29 PM)JTApps1 Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:11 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:00 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:53 PM)Ed Harley Wrote: La Tech doesn’t appeal to most AState fans. Let them rot in CUSA.
This, my friends, is the manifestation of true hate, as opposed to “Let’s bail them out of terrible situation and share our money with them.”
Which is why Arkstfan is right when he says AState may not particularly care who comes in. Some of our fans absolutely want nothing to do with Tech even if from a travel perspective they make some sense
That type of "dislike" is what makes it fun though. It would increase attendance for multiple schools which makes a difference when TV payouts are great.
I think as a school we know that, but La Tech is a bit of a special case with our fan base. Anyone who we see as having involvement in the near SBC collapse 20 years ago is worthless to many who were supporters back then
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:32 PM |
|
JTApps1
1st String

Posts: 2,312
Joined: Feb 2011
Reputation: 169
I Root For: App State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:32 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:29 PM)JTApps1 Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:11 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:00 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:53 PM)Ed Harley Wrote: La Tech doesn’t appeal to most AState fans. Let them rot in CUSA.
This, my friends, is the manifestation of true hate, as opposed to “Let’s bail them out of terrible situation and share our money with them.”
Which is why Arkstfan is right when he says AState may not particularly care who comes in. Some of our fans absolutely want nothing to do with Tech even if from a travel perspective they make some sense
That type of "dislike" is what makes it fun though. It would increase attendance for multiple schools which makes a difference when TV payouts are great.
I think as a school we know that, but La Tech is a bit of a special case with our fan base. Anyone who we see as having involvement in the near SBC collapse 20 years ago is worthless to many who were supporters back then
That's understandable but most of not all people involved are gone now. I think the eastern schools will back whoever the west wants as long as it's reasonable.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:40 PM |
|
Porcine
All American

Posts: 2,645
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 406
I Root For: Arkansas, SBC
Location: Northern Arkansas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 10:54 AM)rokamortis Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:46 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:17 AM)Johns1124 Wrote: (09-29-2024 07:34 AM)JMURocks Wrote: There's rumors/press reporting that the SEC is pressuring MWC and PAC to not add any FCS teams.
Not sure where you read or heard that. I doubt very seriously MWC, (especially) PAC is going to load up with FCS. That's Judy's specialty
if CUSA loses anyone.
North Dakota press members saying SEC is telling MWC and PAC to stay away from FCS. There's been other rumblings of this also, though nothing confirmed from a tier 1 reporter like Thamel yet. Which is why I consider it a rumor at this point.
Matt Brown has hinted at it.
Maybe it was a message for those two to merge.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:43 PM |
|
rokamortis
All American

Posts: 3,388
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 179
I Root For: Coastal
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:43 PM)Porcine Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:54 AM)rokamortis Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:46 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:17 AM)Johns1124 Wrote: (09-29-2024 07:34 AM)JMURocks Wrote: There's rumors/press reporting that the SEC is pressuring MWC and PAC to not add any FCS teams.
Not sure where you read or heard that. I doubt very seriously MWC, (especially) PAC is going to load up with FCS. That's Judy's specialty
if CUSA loses anyone.
North Dakota press members saying SEC is telling MWC and PAC to stay away from FCS. There's been other rumblings of this also, though nothing confirmed from a tier 1 reporter like Thamel yet. Which is why I consider it a rumor at this point.
Matt Brown has hinted at it.
Maybe it was a message for those two to merge.
If it was, they are ignoring it and coming up with some silly plans to avoid merging.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:53 PM |
|
Purplehazed
Heisman

Posts: 8,817
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 211
I Root For: James Madison Dukes
Location: Virginia
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:43 PM)Porcine Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:54 AM)rokamortis Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:46 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:17 AM)Johns1124 Wrote: (09-29-2024 07:34 AM)JMURocks Wrote: There's rumors/press reporting that the SEC is pressuring MWC and PAC to not add any FCS teams.
Not sure where you read or heard that. I doubt very seriously MWC, (especially) PAC is going to load up with FCS. That's Judy's specialty
if CUSA loses anyone.
North Dakota press members saying SEC is telling MWC and PAC to stay away from FCS. There's been other rumblings of this also, though nothing confirmed from a tier 1 reporter like Thamel yet. Which is why I consider it a rumor at this point.
Matt Brown has hinted at it.
Maybe it was a message for those two to merge.
The SEC & Big have FCS programs, Vandy, Northwestern
|
|
| 09-29-2024 02:58 PM |
|
Porcine
All American

Posts: 2,645
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 406
I Root For: Arkansas, SBC
Location: Northern Arkansas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:40 PM)JTApps1 Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:32 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:29 PM)JTApps1 Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:11 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:00 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: This, my friends, is the manifestation of true hate, as opposed to “Let’s bail them out of terrible situation and share our money with them.”
Which is why Arkstfan is right when he says AState may not particularly care who comes in. Some of our fans absolutely want nothing to do with Tech even if from a travel perspective they make some sense
That type of "dislike" is what makes it fun though. It would increase attendance for multiple schools which makes a difference when TV payouts are great.
I think as a school we know that, but La Tech is a bit of a special case with our fan base. Anyone who we see as having involvement in the near SBC collapse 20 years ago is worthless to many who were supporters back then
That's understandable but most of not all people involved are gone now. I think the eastern schools will back whoever the west wants as long as it's reasonable.
I'm not an expert on LT, but it seems they have always been who they are for multiple generations of administrations.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 03:00 PM |
|
Old Dominion
Heisman

Posts: 8,658
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 163
I Root For: Old Dominion
Location: Almost six feet deep
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
I know this s not relevant to todays discussion, but I have a soft spot for La Tech due to their national championship women's basketball program under Leon Barmore. LT and ODU have a very long history together.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 03:03 PM |
|
Porcine
All American

Posts: 2,645
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 406
I Root For: Arkansas, SBC
Location: Northern Arkansas
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 01:54 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:04 PM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:01 PM)rokamortis Wrote: (09-29-2024 12:58 PM)herdfan2013 Wrote: Anybody opposed to adding both LT and WKU to the West and one of Ohio/Delaware/Jacksonville St to the East. Going to 9 conference games?
Unless we are getting a raise not sure we need to go that big unless it is to help with G5 consolidation.
It’d be a pretty damn cool conference if that were to happen but wont happen unless more money would be made
As always, we need to stop and ask, “What problem are we trying to solve, here?”
Looks like making a problem so their can be one to solve.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 03:05 PM |
|
AppManDG
Heisman

Posts: 6,357
Joined: Aug 2010
Reputation: 321
I Root For: App State
Location: Gastonia, NC
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:06 PM)hburg Wrote: (09-29-2024 01:42 PM)AppManDG Wrote: Bowling Green to
Huntington - 290 mi
Atlanta - 310 mi
Boone - 385 mi
Statesboro- 530 mi
Harrisburg - 575 mi
Conway - 660 mi
Norfolk - 745 mi
Jonesboro - 345 mi
Troy - 400 mi
Hattiesburg- 485 mi
Mobile - 510 mi
Monroe - 535 mi
Lafayette - 710 mi
Ruston to
Monroe - 35 mi
Lafayette - 180 mi
Hattiesburg - 240 mi
Jonesboro - 300 mi
Mobile - 335 mi
Troy - 431 mi
Norfolk - 1095 mi
Harrisburg - 1000 mi
Conway - 900 mi
Huntington - 850 mi
Boone - 820 mi
Statesboro- 740 mi
Atlanta - 530 mi
Harrisburg is in Pennsylvania
Sent from my SM-G988U using Tapatalk
Spell Check got me again!! Fixed it. Thanks!
(This post was last modified: 09-29-2024 03:19 PM by AppManDG.)
|
|
| 09-29-2024 03:15 PM |
|
RamblinRedWolf
All American

Posts: 3,140
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 111
I Root For: Arkansas State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 03:03 PM)Old Dominion Wrote: I know this s not relevant to todays discussion, but I have a soft spot for La Tech due to their national championship women's basketball program under Leon Barmore. LT and ODU have a very long history together.
Quite opposite I think the reason you just pointed out is another reason that a decision between WKU and La Tech is more doing than it seems.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 03:17 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 06:59 AM)Cnelson203 Wrote: (09-28-2024 11:37 PM)chiefsfan Wrote: As for who comes in:
I think ultimately comes down to whether or not the Eastern schools are going to let the West Division choose their replacement, or if they'll try to have input. Multiple East Division schools would prefer WKU, but they may not stand in the way if the West thinks Ruston in October is the ideal footballing vacation.
I absolutely believe that the West Division teams should decide which team gets added. That's the only fair way to do it. (If, and I'm not convinced TSU will exit, but what do I know?)
There is nothing wrong with recommendations from the East Presidents, but let's let those most impacted make the call.
Within reason. I mean West presidents get drunk and want UTEP or NMSU might want to nip that in the bud.
(This post was last modified: 09-29-2024 04:46 PM by arkstfan.)
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:12 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 08:14 AM)Troy_Fan_15 Wrote: So Western Kentucky is closer than Tech to only Troy in the West. From Troy to Ruston it’s about a 7 hour drive give or take. Troy to Bowling Green is about 5 hours and 30 minutes give or take. I thought though we would avoid a 3rd team in the same state (unless a huge geographic merger took place).
I’m wouldn’t be mad if Tech was added but I would think WKU makes more sense in the moment.
But y'all have the only president who was here when MTSU and WKU left, that makes Troy's stance interesting to know.
For AState the three are interchangeable in travel.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:18 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 08:25 AM)hburg Wrote: It doesn't make sense adding a 3rd team from Louisiana. Why I think Liberty would never have a chance at the SBC now with JMU and ODU.
The SBC really needs to focus on building the basketball brand while strengthening the football reach.
Does LT, WKU, or MTSU do any of those?
Sent from my SM-G988U using Tapatalk
The question is:
If we have to replace TXST does ESPN care if it is La.Tech, MTSU, WKU or dark horses like Missouri State or SHSU?
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:20 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 09:27 AM)Big Buds Wrote: (09-29-2024 09:20 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:58 AM)InjunJohn86 Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:50 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:29 AM)InjunJohn86 Wrote: With the disaster that is unfolding at Tech right now, I imagine their Daddy Warbucks is already making the push to hire a new football coach. Hell, they are paying Cumbie $975K a year. Right hire (they have some cash to do it) and the portal, Tech football could bounce back pretty quick.
Tech would add an immediate "hate" game with ULM, ULL, USM and Ark State.
Coaching hires as a quick fix is WAY overrated.
Look at Napier in Florida on the hotseat now.
Napier might be a G5 head coach. Jumping from the SBC to the SEC is a massive step, especially a school like Florida, that expects to contend for a NC. That being said, what I mean about right HC is one that can navigate the portal, bring in the right guys, and mesh them quickly. When you have teams that are bringing in 70+ new players, it is more about meshing that developing. The blue bloods get to develop. Smaller schools get to develop and then get poached. LOL
LT feels like a dice roll at best vs a more proven commodity.
If we are going to ignore the competition side of things, what do they bring to the table in terms of media value? It feels like WKU wins on that count also. Does LT have a large fan base or add a lot of viewership potential?
Delaware likely trumps both schools in that respect, though I know the geography side may rule them out.
This is the SBC, when have we ever cared about market size? I compare LaTech to Southern Miss. Rich football history with elite baseball. WKU does not have the football pedigree of LaTech…those are facts.
Marketz perspective we've added Georgia State, TXST on paper is in the 35th largest market, ODU in #43, USA in #57, Marshall at #79.
We tend to be regional state universities that grew from being teacher colleges and agriculture schools into colleges that offer broader services drawing primarily from their region and typically in smaller communities and generally have local TV news covering us because their corporate overlords won't pay for the sports anchor to go trekking off to cover the nearest P5 school.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:30 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 09:52 AM)chiefsfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 09:20 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:58 AM)InjunJohn86 Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:50 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:29 AM)InjunJohn86 Wrote: With the disaster that is unfolding at Tech right now, I imagine their Daddy Warbucks is already making the push to hire a new football coach. Hell, they are paying Cumbie $975K a year. Right hire (they have some cash to do it) and the portal, Tech football could bounce back pretty quick.
Tech would add an immediate "hate" game with ULM, ULL, USM and Ark State.
Coaching hires as a quick fix is WAY overrated.
Look at Napier in Florida on the hotseat now.
Napier might be a G5 head coach. Jumping from the SBC to the SEC is a massive step, especially a school like Florida, that expects to contend for a NC. That being said, what I mean about right HC is one that can navigate the portal, bring in the right guys, and mesh them quickly. When you have teams that are bringing in 70+ new players, it is more about meshing that developing. The blue bloods get to develop. Smaller schools get to develop and then get poached. LOL
LT feels like a dice roll at best vs a more proven commodity.
If we are going to ignore the competition side of things, what do they bring to the table in terms of media value? It feels like WKU wins on that count also. Does LT have a large fan base or add a lot of viewership potential?
Delaware likely trumps both schools in that respect, though I know the geography side may rule them out.
Tech's biggest addition is hate, and hate is strong enough to fuel attendance in the SBC West. Tech/ULM would be a sell out most years. Ditto Tech/UL
That and they are better at baseball, which the one sport where Texas State would be a decent sized loss for the league.
Other than a one-off bowl meeting, Arkansas State and Louisiana Tech haven't played in football for 25 years. You have to be 35-45 years old to even care about La.Tech if you are an AState fan.
As I've said before, I think Arkansas State would be quite agnostic about the whole thing. I "think" Dr. Shields would prefer WKU but isn't so in to the idea that he'd align against UL, ULM, USA who I think would all be for Tech.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:38 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 10:46 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:17 AM)Johns1124 Wrote: (09-29-2024 07:34 AM)JMURocks Wrote: There's rumors/press reporting that the SEC is pressuring MWC and PAC to not add any FCS teams.
Not sure where you read or heard that. I doubt very seriously MWC, (especially) PAC is going to load up with FCS. That's Judy's specialty
if CUSA loses anyone.
North Dakota press members saying SEC is telling MWC and PAC to stay away from FCS. There's been other rumblings of this also, though nothing confirmed from a tier 1 reporter like Thamel yet. Which is why I consider it a rumor at this point.
I've heard it, my question is what carrot are they offering to stop it?
If Pac-7 and MWC merged this whole thing is over and no one is adding new FCS schools but that certainly doesn't seem to be on the table.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:42 PM |
|
RamblinRedWolf
All American

Posts: 3,140
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 111
I Root For: Arkansas State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 04:20 PM)arkstfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:25 AM)hburg Wrote: It doesn't make sense adding a 3rd team from Louisiana. Why I think Liberty would never have a chance at the SBC now with JMU and ODU.
The SBC really needs to focus on building the basketball brand while strengthening the football reach.
Does LT, WKU, or MTSU do any of those?
Sent from my SM-G988U using Tapatalk
The question is:
If we have to replace TXST does ESPN care if it is La.Tech, MTSU, WKU or dark horses like Missouri State or SHSU?
Come on Arkstfan! Gotta give us some more insight than that!
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:44 PM |
|
arkstfan
Sorry folks

Posts: 26,138
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 1040
I Root For: Fresh Starts
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 04:44 PM)RamblinRedWolf Wrote: (09-29-2024 04:20 PM)arkstfan Wrote: (09-29-2024 08:25 AM)hburg Wrote: It doesn't make sense adding a 3rd team from Louisiana. Why I think Liberty would never have a chance at the SBC now with JMU and ODU.
The SBC really needs to focus on building the basketball brand while strengthening the football reach.
Does LT, WKU, or MTSU do any of those?
Sent from my SM-G988U using Tapatalk
The question is:
If we have to replace TXST does ESPN care if it is La.Tech, MTSU, WKU or dark horses like Missouri State or SHSU?
Come on Arkstfan! Gotta give us some more insight than that!
I'm skeptical there is any material financial difference.
When MAC was talking to WKU, the MAC stance was nah we don't want to hassle with 14, MTSU has to join or we do nothing. When UMass called it was all man we can cope with 13.
The key thing to my mind is we aren't having a discussion about any of these schools if President Selfie had scoffed at expansion overtures. There is nothing about them has anyone itching to make them #15 or #16. The interest is all contingent on needing to fill a vacancy and I suspect that gives us a hint about television rights values.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:56 PM |
|
hotrod2001
1st String

Posts: 1,467
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 172
I Root For: App State
Location:
|
RE: Mid-Major Realignment About to Happen Again?
(09-29-2024 02:58 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: (09-29-2024 02:43 PM)Porcine Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:54 AM)rokamortis Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:46 AM)JMURocks Wrote: (09-29-2024 10:17 AM)Johns1124 Wrote: Not sure where you read or heard that. I doubt very seriously MWC, (especially) PAC is going to load up with FCS. That's Judy's specialty
if CUSA loses anyone.
North Dakota press members saying SEC is telling MWC and PAC to stay away from FCS. There's been other rumblings of this also, though nothing confirmed from a tier 1 reporter like Thamel yet. Which is why I consider it a rumor at this point.
Matt Brown has hinted at it.
Maybe it was a message for those two to merge.
The SEC & Big have FCS programs, Vandy, Northwestern
You'd think they wouldn't have an issue with NDSU moving up since they can obviously compete. They can ask Iowa and Minnesota about that one.
|
|
| 09-29-2024 04:57 PM |
|