(03-09-2026 12:57 PM)MaverickManiac Wrote: (03-09-2026 11:05 AM)teamvsn Wrote: My perspective is based on my decades of watching the NAIA. They handle this all very well. They act as if fairness matters. When you say "nothing will change" you are basically saying it's corrupt. It has nothing to do with "regionality" per se, it's that regionality works for those who make the decisions so there's no reason to change. But it doesn't work for others. Actually, I recognize that regionality is exactly why we had a shot at the Regionals. Eight guaranteed spots in the West. I am really happy with how our season went, with a new coach, new players, new offense, new defense, etc. And yet we managed to finish 2nd in the regular season and the conference tourney at 18-12, when we were predicted to finish 8th. It is because of regionality that an 18-12 team had a shot. No, my complaint is that the computation they use cares more about SOS than wins. Literally, 25% win/loss, 75% record of opponents and opponent's opponents.
I've heard it said that in D2, you must "schedule your way into the tournament". That would be fair if wins & losses counted AT LEAST as much as SOS. But SOS is somewhat out of anyone's control. At scheduling time, you can make a guess as to how good your potential opponents will be, and TRY to get them on the schedule, but they may not agree, effectively blocking you from the tournament before the season even starts. Or, a team the LOOKS like they should be top tier agrees to schedule you, but does not in fact live up to their potential. How does this make any sense at all?
D2 people know that no one is paying attention, and that most people don't care. That's why nothing changes. I care. I have an NAIA platform. There are, no doubt, schools still looking at migrating from NAIA to D2. I will make sure everyone knows what BS the D2 post season is.
18 wins is great for some schools. It's who those 18 wins came against that matter. Why reward schools with bids for playing middle to bottom of the pack opponents?
SOS is a tricky road to travel, that's why it is not the exclusive method for seeding. According to the NCAA they use the following
It starts with the won-lost record in Division II which needs to be .500 or better while having competed against at least 22 DII men's basketball programs. If the program qualifies, next the committee looks at the following.
In-region winning percentage
DII winning percentage
Strength of schedule against DII programs
Head-to-head wins and losses against DII programs
Results against common DII opponents
RPI
KPI
Record vs. ranked teams
What you say makes sense on paper.
Here's the RPI for the West Region:
1. Cal State East Bay
2. St. Martin’s
3. Point Loma Nazarene
4. Cal State Dominguez Hills
5. Alaska–Anchorage
6. Northwest Nazarene
7. Hawaii Pacific
8. Cal Poly Humboldt
Here's the seeding for the West Regional:
#1 CSU East Bay (30-0)
#2 Saint Martin's (25-5)
#3 Point Loma (25-5)
#4 Alaska Anchorage (21-10)
#5 CSU Dominguez Hills (22-8)
#6 Northwest Nazarene (18-10)
#7 Hawaii Pacific (18-11)
#8 Cal Poly Humboldt (17-14)
It's the same, except for swapping #4 Anchorage and #5 Dominguez Hills. Which of course resulted in no difference in the regional first round. A token change. They barely engaged any of the other criteria.
18 wins isn't great. But there are three other teams that got at large bids with 18 or less. If they HAD engaged their criteria, it would have been obvious that Westmont beat Hawaii Pacific twice and had a better record against common opponents. To HPU's credit, they did beat St Martin's while Westmont beat Anchorage. Westmont lost to Saint Martin's and HPU lost to Anchorage. But those are minor advantages from very early in the season, compared to Westmont proving they are the better team on the court over the conference season, in the tournament, and head to head beating them twice. There is simply no justification for taking a 3rd place team over a 2nd place team that beat the 3rd place team twice.
Basically, HPU probably got in because they didn't earn a bye in the conference tournament, thus playing an extra game and raising their SOS.