(07-30-2024 08:11 AM)inutech Wrote: I don't know if a picked over MWC would be a better situation for us or not. Doesn't seem like it would be, but I guess the details would matter.
This is the gist of it all.
If the MWC only lost a small handful of teams (as many as four... maybe Boise, SDSU, UNLV, and Colorado State?) it'd be a huge hit, but there'd still be a solid core remaining. The league would still have a strong presence in California, which would be big for TV and recruiting.
Even if they lost a step or two, they'd still be a premier G5 league.
They could replace those lost teams with two FBS schools (UTEP/NMSU), a former FBS school (Idaho), and maybe a single FCS call up from the Big Sky (probably another California school).
But if they were to lose just a couple more teams beyond that (bye, Fresno and Air Force), suddenly, the league would be in a DRASTICALLY weakened position.
At this point, while on paper, it'd be easy enough to plug in those holes (with the same schools as above, plus the Montanas/Dakotas/SHSU/LT), this is when those same schools would begin to question whether the MWC would be worth the move.
UTEP and NMSU would probably GLADLY jump to a west coast/Rockies league, but ONLY if it significantly improved their revenue, reach, and prestige. At what point does the MWC lose enough teams that it falls BELOW CUSA on those metrics?
Likewise, as unlikely as I feel it would be, if today's MWC contacted La Tech and Sammy, yeah, they'd be gone. The opportunity to play in a high-revenue G5 alongside teams like Boise State, SDSU, UNLV, and Air Force would be hard to pass up. But would they jump so quickly if all those teams were gone, and they were instead rubbing shoulders with UC Davis and Idaho?
Every team that moves out of the MWC would impact the teams willing to move into the MWC. (It's the same with every conference.)
The PAC (and even to a certain extent the ACC) have proven that the "name" of a conference means very little. It's the schools within that conference which determine perception of the league.
Point of Fact:
If the ACC lost Clemson and FSU, and replaced them with Jax State and Liberty, people outside those fan bases wouldn't say, "Wow! It's amazing how far Liberty and Jax State have come!"
They'd say, "Man. Can you believe how far the ACC has fallen?"