bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-22-2023 07:50 PM)XLance Wrote: (08-22-2023 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 10:45 AM)Poster Wrote: Fascinating comments from the UNC women's soccer coach. "I want Cal and Stanford to die on the vine." He apparently deliberately wants to harm Cal and Stanford recruiting. Lol.
https://www.wralsportsfan.com/dorrance-i.../21011056/
Not that the opinion of a women's soccer coach is going to end up mattering in the least.
That is why it was so hard for PSU to get into the B1G 30+ years ago. The ADs were very influential in the decision-making process, and they all had a very short term viewpoint. The women's soccer coach at UNC has the very short term viewpoint that adding good women's soccer schools would be detrimental to her career. In normal circumstances, the President of UNC would take a more long term viewpoint, one which would benefit the entire Conference. But these are not normal circumstances.
His career **** ***!
Anson Dorrance 7 time NCAA woman's soccer coach of the year.
Won 21 NCAA championships in Women's soccer.
His career record is 921-86-46.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Dorrance
I don't think he is too concerned about something being too detrimental to his career.
Learn before you post.

Please tell me you didn't have that info memorized. It's women's college soccer, I have to draw the line somewhere, and this is it for me. I refuse to look up women's college soccer stats. Have you learned nothing from what happened to Calford? NOBODY cares about women's college soccer.
|
|
| 08-22-2023 10:49 PM |
|
DawgNBama
RL/ Radio lover

Posts: 10,006
Joined: Sep 2002
Reputation: 651
I Root For: 'Vallo, Troy, UGA
Location: US
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-22-2023 10:49 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 07:50 PM)XLance Wrote: (08-22-2023 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 10:45 AM)Poster Wrote: Fascinating comments from the UNC women's soccer coach. "I want Cal and Stanford to die on the vine." He apparently deliberately wants to harm Cal and Stanford recruiting. Lol.
https://www.wralsportsfan.com/dorrance-i.../21011056/
Not that the opinion of a women's soccer coach is going to end up mattering in the least.
That is why it was so hard for PSU to get into the B1G 30+ years ago. The ADs were very influential in the decision-making process, and they all had a very short term viewpoint. The women's soccer coach at UNC has the very short term viewpoint that adding good women's soccer schools would be detrimental to her career. In normal circumstances, the President of UNC would take a more long term viewpoint, one which would benefit the entire Conference. But these are not normal circumstances.
His career **** ***!
Anson Dorrance 7 time NCAA woman's soccer coach of the year.
Won 21 NCAA championships in Women's soccer.
His career record is 921-86-46.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Dorrance
I don't think he is too concerned about something being too detrimental to his career.
Learn before you post.

Please tell me you didn't have that info memorized. It's women's college soccer, I have to draw the line somewhere, and this is it for me. I refuse to look up women's college soccer stats. Have you learned nothing from what happened to Calford? NOBODY cares about women's college soccer.
I have a slight quibble with the state bolded statement, Bryan. At the University of Montevallo, women's soccer actually is a big deal!! So much so, that we (Montevallo) recruit from foreign countries!! Women's soccer definitely outdraws women's basketball at my alma mater, but then again, our basketball teams have been bad for years!!
|
|
| 08-23-2023 06:39 AM |
|
RUScarlets
Heisman

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
Monty's show last night quoted his source saying Stanford is willing to go three years with zero revenue... SMU 5 years. All that pro-rata money would go to the four no-votes, or UNC, Clemson, FSU at the very least. I'm just not sure what they plan to do with 17 schools. Not sure how much Cal would take year one.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 07:07 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 07:07 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: Monty's show last night quoted his source saying Stanford is willing to go three years with zero revenue... SMU 5 years. All that pro-rata money would go to the four no-votes, or UNC, Clemson, FSU at the very least. I'm just not sure what they plan to do with 17 schools. Not sure how much Cal would take year one.
Anton Chigurh (No Country For Old Men), "You should just accept your situation. There would be more dignity in it."
|
|
| 08-23-2023 07:14 AM |
|
RUScarlets
Heisman

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 07:14 AM)JRsec Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:07 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: Monty's show last night quoted his source saying Stanford is willing to go three years with zero revenue... SMU 5 years. All that pro-rata money would go to the four no-votes, or UNC, Clemson, FSU at the very least. I'm just not sure what they plan to do with 17 schools. Not sure how much Cal would take year one.
Anton Chigurh (No Country For Old Men), "You should just accept your situation. There would be more dignity in it."
I mean, you kind of have to take it if you are UNC/FSU. Let's assume it all goes to the top (whomever that fourth school is, and I doubt they can push it all to the top), that's 35 million (roughly) x 8 years, which would put FSU closer to 45-46 million is annual media distributions. Then, the post-season incentives could be winner take all. That can get you in the 50-55 million range.
I think all the money will go to the top and get split three ways, with UNC/NCSU splitting 1/3 of the revenue excess 50/50. You have to wonder though, if this dynamic is really in play, why wouldn't more ACC schools flip from Yes to No? You open up a can of worms if it's all funneled to the top 4.
My guess is, they had a closed door meeting and FSU and potentially another school is going to the B1G/SEC no later than '26 once a settlement is finalized. All the windfall profits will then follow a tiered distribution. You take Stanford/SMU's money, plus 3-400 million or whatever it is from FSU? You start to hit that sweet spot for the remaining schools. I'd use that money to poach UCF and UC though.
(This post was last modified: 08-23-2023 07:37 AM by RUScarlets.)
|
|
| 08-23-2023 07:35 AM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13523
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 07:35 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:14 AM)JRsec Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:07 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: Monty's show last night quoted his source saying Stanford is willing to go three years with zero revenue... SMU 5 years. All that pro-rata money would go to the four no-votes, or UNC, Clemson, FSU at the very least. I'm just not sure what they plan to do with 17 schools. Not sure how much Cal would take year one.
Anton Chigurh (No Country For Old Men), "You should just accept your situation. There would be more dignity in it."
I mean, you kind of have to take it if you are UNC/FSU. Let's assume it all goes to the top (whomever that fourth school is, and I doubt they can push it all to the top), that's 35 million (roughly) x 8 years, which would put FSU closer to 45-46 million is annual media distributions. Then, the post-season incentives could be winner take all. That can get you in the 50-55 million range.
I think all the money will go to the top and get split three ways, with UNC/NCSU splitting 1/3 of the revenue excess 50/50. You have to wonder though, if this dynamic is really in play, why wouldn't more ACC schools flip from Yes to No? You open up a can of worms if it's all funneled to the top 4.
My guess is, they had a closed door meeting and FSU and potentially another school is going to the B1G/SEC no later than '26 once a settlement is finalized. All the windfall profits will then follow a tiered distribution. You take Stanford/SMU's money, plus 3-400 million or whatever it is from FSU? You start to hit that sweet spot for the remaining schools. I'd use that money to poach UCF and UC though.
No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:01 AM |
|
RUScarlets
Heisman

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
I don't know, it's a lot of money in the interim, and then FSU can buy out closer to 2030. That's logical, mathematically. Not everyone is good at math though.
I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only? I'd agree, the math doesn't work without SMU, and it certainly doesn't work with Cal, even if they are coming in at a subsidized rate for incumbent ACC schools. Cal just seems to be an ego driven add, and Stanford should be able to land affiliate deals for its Olympic sports.
(This post was last modified: 08-23-2023 08:08 AM by RUScarlets.)
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:06 AM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
I don't know, it's a lot of money in the interim, and then FSU can buy out closer to 2030. That's logical, mathematically. Not everyone is good at math though.
I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only? I'd agree, the math doesn't work without SMU, and it certainly doesn't work with Cal, even if they are coming in at a subsidized rate for incumbent ACC schools. Cal just seems to be an ego driven add, and Stanford should be able to land affiliate deals for its Olympic sports.
The thing is that neither Stanford nor the ACC want the football-only situation. Always remember that Stanford is NOT using the Ivy model for their athletic teams. They are legitimately trying to be the #1 producer of Olympians in the world (and have succeeded on that front as they’d be in the top 10 of the medal count in each Summer Olympics if Stanford was its own country). They need *elite* competition for their Olympic sports just as much as they do for football, which is why the ACC is so attractive. On the flip side, the Olympic sports program at Stanford is really what the ACC is getting more value out of from Stanford than the football team.
I’m seeing this play out right in front of me. We have a family friend whose son is one of the top 10 high school swimmers in Illinois. He is the dream athletic recruit: super elite athletically, perfect GPA in all honors/AP classes, perfect ACT score… just a ridiculous combination of academic and athletic achievement that is in the top 1000th of the 1% of the US. He has multiple offers from Big Ten, ACC and Ivy League schools for next year.
You know which school had the highest pure *athletic* bar (NOT academic bar) out of any school he spoke to? STANFORD. Unless you have already qualified for the Olympic Trials as a senior in high school, Stanford won’t even talk to you. I don’t think people are quite comprehending why Stanford isn’t just satisfied with even going to the Ivy League, much less the WCC or MWC. They’re not looking to just pare down non-revenue sport travel costs. Stanford is in the business of producing Olympians and the only way to keep doing that is having the elite competition that is only found on the P5 (and now P4).
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:40 AM |
|
BruceMcF
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: ... I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only?
SMU and Stanford certainly aren't prospective travel partners for ACC visiting teams.
Quote: ... Cal just seems to be an ego driven add ...
The only point for Cal in the whole discussion is that they are ideal travel partners, but while Stanford might have carried its own weight in the ESPN $30m offer, I am skeptical that they would carry their own weight at the ACC distribution, and they surely don't bring enough added value to pay for Cal to come along.
If Stanford/Cal are a pure ego driven add, it'd be cheaper to have them go FB independent, give them five and four game OOC FB scheduling deals, and bring in them in Olympic sports only at Notre Dame's share.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:44 AM |
|
GarnetAndBlue
1st String

Posts: 1,958
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 472
I Root For: Retired
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
I don't know, it's a lot of money in the interim, and then FSU can buy out closer to 2030. That's logical, mathematically. Not everyone is good at math though.
I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only? I'd agree, the math doesn't work without SMU, and it certainly doesn't work with Cal, even if they are coming in at a subsidized rate for incumbent ACC schools. Cal just seems to be an ego driven add, and Stanford should be able to land affiliate deals for its Olympic sports.
The thing is that neither Stanford nor the ACC want the football-only situation. Always remember that Stanford is NOT using the Ivy model for their athletic teams. They are legitimately trying to be the #1 producer of Olympians in the world (and have succeeded on that front as they’d be in the top 10 of the medal count in each Summer Olympics if Stanford was its own country). They need *elite* competition for their Olympic sports just as much as they do for football, which is why the ACC is so attractive. On the flip side, the Olympic sports program at Stanford is really what the ACC is getting more value out of from Stanford than the football team.
I’m seeing this play out right in front of me. We have a family friend whose son is one of the top 10 high school swimmers in Illinois. He is the dream athletic recruit: super elite athletically, perfect GPA in all honors/AP classes, perfect ACT score… just a ridiculous combination of academic and athletic achievement that is in the top 1000th of the 1% of the US. He has multiple offers from Big Ten, ACC and Ivy League schools for next year.
You know which school had the highest pure *athletic* bar (NOT academic bar) out of any school he spoke to? STANFORD. Unless you have already qualified for the Olympic Trials as a senior in high school, Stanford won’t even talk to you. I don’t think people are quite comprehending why Stanford isn’t just satisfied with even going to the Ivy League, much less the WCC or MWC. They’re not looking to just pare down non-revenue sport travel costs. Stanford is in the business of producing Olympians and the only way to keep doing that is having the elite competition that is only found on the P5 (and now P4).
Makes sense. But if it's that critical, why doesn't Stanford just buy their way in? Maybe they thought not being a paid ACC member for a few years would cut it. Maybe they can help negotiate FSU's exit and be the backfill =)
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:47 AM |
|
e-parade
All American

Posts: 4,362
Joined: Apr 2015
Reputation: 803
I Root For: UMass
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-22-2023 10:49 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 07:50 PM)XLance Wrote: (08-22-2023 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 10:45 AM)Poster Wrote: Fascinating comments from the UNC women's soccer coach. "I want Cal and Stanford to die on the vine." He apparently deliberately wants to harm Cal and Stanford recruiting. Lol.
https://www.wralsportsfan.com/dorrance-i.../21011056/
Not that the opinion of a women's soccer coach is going to end up mattering in the least.
That is why it was so hard for PSU to get into the B1G 30+ years ago. The ADs were very influential in the decision-making process, and they all had a very short term viewpoint. The women's soccer coach at UNC has the very short term viewpoint that adding good women's soccer schools would be detrimental to her career. In normal circumstances, the President of UNC would take a more long term viewpoint, one which would benefit the entire Conference. But these are not normal circumstances.
His career **** ***!
Anson Dorrance 7 time NCAA woman's soccer coach of the year.
Won 21 NCAA championships in Women's soccer.
His career record is 921-86-46.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Dorrance
I don't think he is too concerned about something being too detrimental to his career.
Learn before you post.

Please tell me you didn't have that info memorized. It's women's college soccer, I have to draw the line somewhere, and this is it for me. I refuse to look up women's college soccer stats. Have you learned nothing from what happened to Calford? NOBODY cares about women's college soccer.
I dunno, a record like that is something to be proud of regardless of the sport. I'm sure any school that had a coach who won that many championships and had that dominant a record would want to publicize it.
And while it didn't work out this year, the women's national team does get ratings. Not as much as others for sure, but it's nothing to scoff at. I feel like there's a decent chance a lot of those women came from places like UNC.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:53 AM |
|
Sactowndog
All American

Posts: 3,203
Joined: Dec 2010
Reputation: 120
I Root For: Fresno State Butler
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
I don't know, it's a lot of money in the interim, and then FSU can buy out closer to 2030. That's logical, mathematically. Not everyone is good at math though.
I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only? I'd agree, the math doesn't work without SMU, and it certainly doesn't work with Cal, even if they are coming in at a subsidized rate for incumbent ACC schools. Cal just seems to be an ego driven add, and Stanford should be able to land affiliate deals for its Olympic sports.
The thing is that neither Stanford nor the ACC want the football-only situation. Always remember that Stanford is NOT using the Ivy model for their athletic teams. They are legitimately trying to be the #1 producer of Olympians in the world (and have succeeded on that front as they’d be in the top 10 of the medal count in each Summer Olympics if Stanford was its own country). They need *elite* competition for their Olympic sports just as much as they do for football, which is why the ACC is so attractive. On the flip side, the Olympic sports program at Stanford is really what the ACC is getting more value out of from Stanford than the football team.
I’m seeing this play out right in front of me. We have a family friend whose son is one of the top 10 high school swimmers in Illinois. He is the dream athletic recruit: super elite athletically, perfect GPA in all honors/AP classes, perfect ACT score… just a ridiculous combination of academic and athletic achievement that is in the top 1000th of the 1% of the US. He has multiple offers from Big Ten, ACC and Ivy League schools for next year.
You know which school had the highest pure *athletic* bar (NOT academic bar) out of any school he spoke to? STANFORD. Unless you have already qualified for the Olympic Trials as a senior in high school, Stanford won’t even talk to you. I don’t think people are quite comprehending why Stanford isn’t just satisfied with even going to the Ivy League, much less the WCC or MWC. They’re not looking to just pare down non-revenue sport travel costs. Stanford is in the business of producing Olympians and the only way to keep doing that is having the elite competition that is only found on the P5 (and now P4).
Yes swimming is one of Stanfords main sports but swimming doesn’t super matter which conference you are in. Too your point Stanford has plenty of competition in their own pool.
As for the other sports where they medal a lot is the ACC adding men’s and women’s water polo? How about men’s gymnastics or beach volleyball?
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:54 AM |
|
GarnetAndBlue
1st String

Posts: 1,958
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 472
I Root For: Retired
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-22-2023 10:49 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 07:50 PM)XLance Wrote: (08-22-2023 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 10:45 AM)Poster Wrote: Fascinating comments from the UNC women's soccer coach. "I want Cal and Stanford to die on the vine." He apparently deliberately wants to harm Cal and Stanford recruiting. Lol.
https://www.wralsportsfan.com/dorrance-i.../21011056/
Not that the opinion of a women's soccer coach is going to end up mattering in the least.
That is why it was so hard for PSU to get into the B1G 30+ years ago. The ADs were very influential in the decision-making process, and they all had a very short term viewpoint. The women's soccer coach at UNC has the very short term viewpoint that adding good women's soccer schools would be detrimental to her career. In normal circumstances, the President of UNC would take a more long term viewpoint, one which would benefit the entire Conference. But these are not normal circumstances.
His career **** ***!
Anson Dorrance 7 time NCAA woman's soccer coach of the year.
Won 21 NCAA championships in Women's soccer.
His career record is 921-86-46.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Dorrance
I don't think he is too concerned about something being too detrimental to his career.
Learn before you post.

Please tell me you didn't have that info memorized. It's women's college soccer, I have to draw the line somewhere, and this is it for me. I refuse to look up women's college soccer stats. Have you learned nothing from what happened to Calford? NOBODY cares about women's college soccer.
What's wrong with college women's soccer? You should have watched the FSU-TAMU game the other day. It was a great one...Noles won 2-1.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 08:59 AM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:54 AM)Sactowndog Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
I don't know, it's a lot of money in the interim, and then FSU can buy out closer to 2030. That's logical, mathematically. Not everyone is good at math though.
I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only? I'd agree, the math doesn't work without SMU, and it certainly doesn't work with Cal, even if they are coming in at a subsidized rate for incumbent ACC schools. Cal just seems to be an ego driven add, and Stanford should be able to land affiliate deals for its Olympic sports.
The thing is that neither Stanford nor the ACC want the football-only situation. Always remember that Stanford is NOT using the Ivy model for their athletic teams. They are legitimately trying to be the #1 producer of Olympians in the world (and have succeeded on that front as they’d be in the top 10 of the medal count in each Summer Olympics if Stanford was its own country). They need *elite* competition for their Olympic sports just as much as they do for football, which is why the ACC is so attractive. On the flip side, the Olympic sports program at Stanford is really what the ACC is getting more value out of from Stanford than the football team.
I’m seeing this play out right in front of me. We have a family friend whose son is one of the top 10 high school swimmers in Illinois. He is the dream athletic recruit: super elite athletically, perfect GPA in all honors/AP classes, perfect ACT score… just a ridiculous combination of academic and athletic achievement that is in the top 1000th of the 1% of the US. He has multiple offers from Big Ten, ACC and Ivy League schools for next year.
You know which school had the highest pure *athletic* bar (NOT academic bar) out of any school he spoke to? STANFORD. Unless you have already qualified for the Olympic Trials as a senior in high school, Stanford won’t even talk to you. I don’t think people are quite comprehending why Stanford isn’t just satisfied with even going to the Ivy League, much less the WCC or MWC. They’re not looking to just pare down non-revenue sport travel costs. Stanford is in the business of producing Olympians and the only way to keep doing that is having the elite competition that is only found on the P5 (and now P4).
Yes swimming is one of Stanfords main sports but swimming doesn’t super matter which conference you are in. Too your point Stanford has plenty of competition in their own pool.
As for the other sports where they medal a lot is the ACC adding men’s and women’s water polo? How about men’s gymnastics or beach volleyball?
Come on - swimming or track is like anything else: if you’re not continuously competing against the other top competition, you’re not going to get to peak level. It’s not merely about being really good, but pushing to that extra tenth of a second that’s the difference between being in the Olympic team or not.
You’re correct that swimming isn’t a revenue sport. My point is that Stanford isn’t just parking their Olympic sports in a random place like the WCC or MWC outside of literally *no* other choice. They *want* to send their Olympic sports cross-country to the ACC: the elite competition matters more than the travel time or costs to them, so a football-only membership is a negative (not a positive).
|
|
| 08-23-2023 09:01 AM |
|
CardFan1
Red Thunderbird

Posts: 15,319
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 680
I Root For: Louisville ACC
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:01 AM)JRsec Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:35 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:14 AM)JRsec Wrote: (08-23-2023 07:07 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: Monty's show last night quoted his source saying Stanford is willing to go three years with zero revenue... SMU 5 years. All that pro-rata money would go to the four no-votes, or UNC, Clemson, FSU at the very least. I'm just not sure what they plan to do with 17 schools. Not sure how much Cal would take year one.
Anton Chigurh (No Country For Old Men), "You should just accept your situation. There would be more dignity in it."
I mean, you kind of have to take it if you are UNC/FSU. Let's assume it all goes to the top (whomever that fourth school is, and I doubt they can push it all to the top), that's 35 million (roughly) x 8 years, which would put FSU closer to 45-46 million is annual media distributions. Then, the post-season incentives could be winner take all. That can get you in the 50-55 million range.
I think all the money will go to the top and get split three ways, with UNC/NCSU splitting 1/3 of the revenue excess 50/50. You have to wonder though, if this dynamic is really in play, why wouldn't more ACC schools flip from Yes to No? You open up a can of worms if it's all funneled to the top 4.
My guess is, they had a closed door meeting and FSU and potentially another school is going to the B1G/SEC no later than '26 once a settlement is finalized. All the windfall profits will then follow a tiered distribution. You take Stanford/SMU's money, plus 3-400 million or whatever it is from FSU? You start to hit that sweet spot for the remaining schools. I'd use that money to poach UCF and UC though.
No! It's simply not logical. They don't add much value at all since they are worth about 40 million each for Cal and Stanford which is what the ACC schools are worth to ESPN and even that is propped up by Clemson & FSU and North Carolina to a lesser degree. SMU is a boat anchor on value. There is no money and even if they all 3 played 5 years for free they only add for 5 of the 12 remaining years on the GOR.
The only solution for the top brands of the ACC is to leave. 7 are easy to place in the super 2. 5 or 6 are easy to place in Big 12. The hem-hawing you see is over who gets to leave second and collect the exit fees of the ones leaving first. UNC opposes additions. Why? Let Clemson and FSU leave early and they get 20 million in exit fees as would N.C. State, Virginia, and Virginia Tech in addition to all of the other remaining ACC schools (N.D. gets a a fractional share of the exit fees). Then if the remainder decide to dissolve the conference they are 20 million richer and have stuck it too FSU and Clemson. This is the whole impetus behind not adding Stanford and Cal. If they are added getting the required % of votes to dissolve the conference later is impacted. It has nothing to do with Cal and Stanford. It has everything to do with UNC getting a fat check and then leaving.
So in a nutshell ,FSU, Clemson pay the brunt of the exit fees! UNC/NCSU get paid then use their cut to reduce their share of exit fees , then that windfall is passed on to the next group that leaves and used to exit at a reduced rate using the windfall vs actual up front out lay. Genius eventually WF and BC are rich
(This post was last modified: 08-23-2023 10:34 AM by CardFan1.)
|
|
| 08-23-2023 09:02 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,080
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2771
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-22-2023 10:49 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 07:50 PM)XLance Wrote: (08-22-2023 04:15 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (08-22-2023 10:45 AM)Poster Wrote: Fascinating comments from the UNC women's soccer coach. "I want Cal and Stanford to die on the vine." He apparently deliberately wants to harm Cal and Stanford recruiting. Lol.
https://www.wralsportsfan.com/dorrance-i.../21011056/
Not that the opinion of a women's soccer coach is going to end up mattering in the least.
That is why it was so hard for PSU to get into the B1G 30+ years ago. The ADs were very influential in the decision-making process, and they all had a very short term viewpoint. The women's soccer coach at UNC has the very short term viewpoint that adding good women's soccer schools would be detrimental to her career. In normal circumstances, the President of UNC would take a more long term viewpoint, one which would benefit the entire Conference. But these are not normal circumstances.
His career **** ***!
Anson Dorrance 7 time NCAA woman's soccer coach of the year.
Won 21 NCAA championships in Women's soccer.
His career record is 921-86-46.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anson_Dorrance
I don't think he is too concerned about something being too detrimental to his career.
Learn before you post.

Please tell me you didn't have that info memorized. It's women's college soccer, I have to draw the line somewhere, and this is it for me. I refuse to look up women's college soccer stats. Have you learned nothing from what happened to Calford? NOBODY cares about women's college soccer.
Where do you think overhead Big Ten and SEC money is going? It's distributed across the entire athletic department lol
|
|
| 08-23-2023 09:07 AM |
|
dgrace4cards
All American

Posts: 4,988
Joined: Apr 2005
Reputation: 284
I Root For: UL
Location: Louisville
|
|
| 08-23-2023 09:28 AM |
|
RUScarlets
Heisman

Posts: 9,717
Joined: May 2012
Reputation: 313
I Root For: Rutgers
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 08:44 AM)BruceMcF Wrote: (08-23-2023 08:06 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: ... I do wonder, what if it's just Stanford/SMU coming in? Can Stanford come in as football only?
SMU and Stanford certainly aren't prospective travel partners for ACC visiting teams.
Quote: ... Cal just seems to be an ego driven add ...
The only point for Cal in the whole discussion is that they are ideal travel partners, but while Stanford might have carried its own weight in the ESPN $30m offer, I am skeptical that they would carry their own weight at the ACC distribution, and they surely don't bring enough added value to pay for Cal to come along.
If Stanford/Cal are a pure ego driven add, it'd be cheaper to have them go FB independent, give them five and four game OOC FB scheduling deals, and bring in them in Olympic sports only at Notre Dame's share.
You don't need a travel partner with football only. I'd agree they have to take both for all sports. Perhaps Stanford reneges on the three year zero revenue distribution if they are only considered for football. Independence makes just as much sense, I'd agree. If they can't find a suitable Olympic home at all, then I guess it is take it or leave it for Furd to the ACC.
|
|
| 08-23-2023 09:47 AM |
|
mj4life
1st String

Posts: 1,287
Joined: Sep 2012
Reputation: 48
I Root For: unc
Location:
|
|
| 08-23-2023 10:18 AM |
|
BruceMcF
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
|
RE: From Bearinsider….
(08-23-2023 09:47 AM)RUScarlets Wrote: ... You don't need a travel partner with football only. ...
You don't invite Stanford/Cal if it's FB only, you invite Stanford/SMU.
And, of course, it's possible that Stanford doesn't accept the FB-only invite, where they might accept the (long term cheaper, even at a 'full' 20% distribution from year one) Olympic-sports-only with a FB scheduling deal, which SMU would have no interest in, but which Cal might take (though five/five games add up to 15, so maybe four/four games).
(This post was last modified: 08-23-2023 10:21 AM by BruceMcF.)
|
|
| 08-23-2023 10:20 AM |
|