(10-23-2026 02:00 PM)SlyFox Wrote: TOPSTRAIGHT - Call me a contrarian if you must, but I am dumbfounded by your rankings of prospects.
When adding a new school to a conference, there are a number of things a conference looks at.
The below is what I've read are the 6 pillars of what the American Conference looks for:
- Media Valuation
- Football Strength
- Financial Investment
- Basketball Metrics
- Academic Profile
- Geographic Fit
I would argue that these 6 points are valid for all FBS conferences, the only difference would be how each are weighed.
When I plug in these metrics into Chat GPT, and asked it consider the discussed FCS schools for CUSA, it gave me some very interesting results, HOWEVER, very much inline with our discussions.
Tier 1: High Viability (Premium Expansion Targets)
- Tarleton State: "Elite" for full membership, "High" for football only
- UTRGV: "Elite" for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
- EKU: "High" for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
Tier 2: Regional Boarder Liners (Strong Football, Geographic Hurdles)
- South Dakota St: "Moderate" for full membership, "Elite" for football only
- Illinois St: "Moderate" for full membership, "High" for football only
- SFA: "Moderate to High" for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
Tier 3: Extreme Geographic Outliers (Impractical Full Fits)
- Montana St: "Low" for full membership, "High" for football only
- Montana: "Low" for full membership, "High" for football only
- South Dakota: "Low" for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
- North Dakota: "Low" for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
- Northern Arizona: "Low for full membership, "Moderate" for football only
- Cal Poly: "Unviable" for full membership, "Low" for football only
Tier 4: East Coast Cultural Mismatches
- UT Chattanooga: "Moderate" for full membership, "Low" for football only
- W&M: "Low" for full membership, "Unviable" for football only
(NOTE: I didn't want to post the full results here, because it is long with explanations regarding each, but I will create new post just to provide the results called "
AI rankings of FCS schools")