(03-16-2026 10:20 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: Despite all the facts above---IMO Basketball is still an important factor.
All else being "even" you would pick the stronger Basketball school.
Problem is... "all else being even" almost never happens.
Exactly.
If we had ONE slot available, and that one slot was between two FCS schools with similar markets, similar football success, similar academic reputations (stuff presidents look at), and similar fan support, but one had a basketball team ranked #125 while the other had a basketball team ranked #312, you'd take the #125 team ALL. DAY. LONG.
It wouldn't even be in doubt.
And if you flip that, it still becomes an easy choice. UConn's football team isn't exactly a big ticket commodity that makes network execs quiver with excitement.
But their men's and women's hoops are elite level. If we could somehow pry them away from the Big East, I'd take UConn as an all sports member ALL. DAY. LONG. Even with their often subpar football.
But those aren't actually opposite extremes. The "football" equivalent of UConn would be Notre Dame. Elite-level football. Mediocre hoops.
Even if Notre Dame was lousy at hoops, they'd still be worth taking as an all-sports member because of their football.
Most schools aren't on these fringes.
They have decent football (#40 through #70 on the high end, but usually #90-#100 for a "solid" team) and decent hoops (Tier 2 for an exceptional candidate, but usually Tier 3 for a "solid" prospect).
As I said in my last post, getting a team that helps our SoS is good, and welcome. But that in and of itself won't make us a multi-bid conference.
There aren't a whole lot of Gonzagas and UConns out there. And while a #75 ranked men's basketball team would help our conference strength quite a bit, it would have almost no impact on the value of a TV deal, and unless that team can string together a Cinderella run, it wouldn't get us more units in the NCAA Tourney.
From that standpoint, there's very little difference between #75 and #200 in hoops.
But still... I'd avoid teams in the 300s like the plague.