DrDocMartin
Bench Warmer

Posts: 128
Joined: Dec 2023
Reputation: 12
I Root For: Liberty
Location: Northern Virginia
|
RE: FCS "Prospects" Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc..
(12-12-2024 08:03 PM)TOPSTRAIGHT Wrote: (12-12-2024 12:22 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (12-12-2024 12:05 PM)bullet Wrote: (12-12-2024 10:52 AM)solohawks Wrote: (12-12-2024 10:40 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Yes - we should all reasonably know that this isn’t a viable option for NDSU. Putting aside Notre Dame that is its own special animal, Liberty was able to do it for awhile because it’s a school that’s flush with cash and, as noted by other Liberty-based posters here, even their situation as an independent wasn’t going to be sustainable (and that was never their choice in the first place). UConn puts up with it because they have the Big East revenue and branding coming in for basketball. UMass and New Mexico State were never independents by choice. Navy and now Army have joined the AAC and those are examples of real brands as service academies.
Now, if any FCS school wanted to become an FBS independent and spend the money necessary, then they should be allowed to do so if an existing conference won’t extend and invitation. The exclusionary rule is bogus and Liberty was right to threaten litigation if it didn’t get a waiver. However, that’s different from the market reality that it wouldn’t make any sense financially at all, especially with a remote location in the Dakotas.
I think a lot of FCS schools secretly like the FBS invite needed to upgrade rule.
"We would consider moving up, but gosh darn it the NCAA says we have to have an invite, and we don't have one"
The schools moving up have mostly been big schools since the turn of the century.
Below is the attendance (2021 or more recent) of all the schools that have moved up. Note that only 3 are smaller than NDSU.
2001 South Florida 49,766
2002 Connecticut 27,175
2002 Troy State 6,000 (on campus only)
2006 Florida Atlantic 36,703
2006 Florida International 55,687
2009 Western Kentucky 16,762
2012 Texas-San Antonio 34,393
2012 Massachusetts 30,285
2012 South Alabama 13,463
2012 Texas State 38,171
2013 Georgia State 50,521
2014 Appalachian State 21,253
2014 Old Dominion 23,494
2014 Georgia Southern 26,106
2015 Charlotte 29,551
2017 Coastal Carolina 10,484
2018 Liberty 15,800 (on campus only)
2023 James Madison 22,224
2023 Jacksonville St. 9,540
2023 Sam Houston St. 21,480
2024 Kennesaw St. 45,152
2025 Missouri State 23,418
2025 Delaware 24,221
Others--NDSU-10,200; Tarleton, EKU-both about 11,700 (Knight-Newhouse Data)
The demographics are even more stark: if we make Missouri an honorary Southern state by virtue of membership in the SEC, then 20 out of 23 schools that moved up from FCS since the turn of the century are in Southern states, all of which are in the top half of states for population with the exception of Kentucky (who just missed it as ranked #26 but will probably move into the top half past Louisiana by the next census). 14 out of the 23 came from just the mega-growth states of Texas, Florida, North Carolina, Georgia or Virginia.
Meanwhile, all 3 of the Northern move-ups were flagship schools. Massachusetts is a massive population state. Connecticut arguably has the largest college sports fan base in the NYC market (albeit from basketball) and is directly in the NYC-to-Boston population corridor. Delaware is located directly in the #4 largest TV market of Philadelphia.
The upshot: all 23 of the FCS call-ups this century are in existing large population states and/or markets. It’s pretty stark.
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$
Thought all these comments and random stats would be good to add as sort of a database for this thread.
I've tried to keep this thread mostly Stats Based. SEVERAL current CUSA members in the above discussion and stats above.
One of the "Northern move-ups," Delaware, is actually south of the Mason-Dixon line and puts sugar in their tea.... Love the numbers.
|
|