(07-14-2024 11:58 AM)Schadenfreude Wrote: (07-14-2024 11:41 AM)epasnoopy Wrote: The core of the the conference--9 schools in total--are in Ohio and Michigan. Adding UMass AND NDSU still doesn't change the fact that the only schools who really have to travel in this conference would be NDSU, UMass, NIU, and Buffalo. Those 9 schools plus Ball State still have relatively easy travel compared to those other four.
Any idea how the Northern Illinois community would regard Illinois State? On the one hand, they would provide an instant rival two hours away. (The "I-39 Rivalry," perhaps. We could let you borrow our I-75 trophy the next time we have it if you need ideas.) And it isn't like Illinois State is a terrible school or anything.
On the other, Northern Illinois would no longer be the only FBS school in the state outside of the Big Ten. Perhaps it would prefer the status quo?
IDK because I know of no survey, but consider that Chicago is first and foremost pro sports + Notre Dame. Everyone else gets a bit piece of the market. IMHO being one of three FBS in the state is no more than a bragging point when total wins of the three are considered. More important to me is market, attendance and travel costs.
Here are some things I do know:
--- TV market: Illinois State fans were thrilled (look through their fan forum) when UIC joined and the MVC made a TV deal with Bally/NBC Sports Chicago, both in 2022. Chicago is the #2 or #3 TV market, depending on which rating you use. No reason that might not flourish with an NIU-Illinois State rivalry ... and in many more sports than just football.
--- Draw: The ISU game at NIU drew an official 14,568 in 2019. Even the Vanderbilt homer drew less (14,110) in 2022. So the ISU game drew the best attendance of 22 games in DeKalb over four years (excluding 2020/Covid).
--- Distance 1: NIU and Illinois State are about 120 miles apart (under two hours), all interstate. Distance between Ball State and Illinois state is about 220 miles (about 2 3/4 hours), all interstate. For Friday, Sat and maybe Sunday games, meets matches, not too bad. Weekdays/nights, not good for fans, but travel is reasonable for the teams.
--- Distance 2: Calculating from the rough center (Columbus) of the MAC is not a reasonable point of discussion. Obviously, the MAC presidents decided it can be done with UMass, but to
add another long-distance trip for most everybody else to NDSU?! Only four football teams would visit Fargo each season, but the cost for all the other sports would be horrendous. Think about all the air travel not only for UMass but Buffalo, Kent State, Akron and Ohio, e.g. The "power" schools could handle it, but for the "little people" these costs are more significant in budgets.
Way, way, way, way, way out there speculation with no basis in fact or rumor: Are the "discussions" with NDSU and Illinois State reported by BeatWestern possibly a nudge to the MAC for Illinois State when it finally gets an AD? Like saying, "yeah but we have an alternative if not you?" That ESPN contract doesn't expire until mid-2027. Plenty of time.