(07-09-2024 02:10 PM)Schadenfreude Wrote: I rank the possible options this way. ...
4. Sit tight. We shouldn't go to 14 just to get to 14. The next addition should move the needle. If we don't have an option that moves the needle, why get into what could be a decades-long relationship with another school? At some point, another good option will emerge. Sometimes, no action is the best action.
5. Illinois State. If we are just going to throw a dart at a nearby school, Illinois State is probably better than other options such as Eastern Kentucky or Northern Iowa. I'm not sure they move the needle, but we could do worse, I guess.
As far as the "sit tight" option, IMV the "sit tight" decision point was at 12. The MAC decided to add UMass when it became available, and now I definitely don't want the Golden Flashes to have even more midweek FB games every year. 13 requires more midweek games per school, 14 allows slightly fewer, and if they were to find a Saturday GOTW partner would enable substantially fewer.
The argument for Illinois State rather than the Salukis would be that the largest metro area inside the MAC footprint is Chicago, and Illinois State seems like the most effective school to complement NIU's alumni base in Chicago.
The rough argument for either Illinois State or the Salukis can be seen in the population and number of schools in the states in the MAC footprint, recognizing that most of the NY state population is not in the Great Lakes part of the state in the MAC footprint:
NY 19.7m / 1 school | 19.7m/school sic
IL 12.6m / 1 school | 12.6m/school
MA 7.0m / 1 school | 7.0m/school
IN 6.8m / 1 school | 6.8m/school
MI 10.0m / 3 schools | 3.3m/school
OH 11.8m / 6 schools | 2.0m/school
... to ...
NY 19.7m / 1 school | 19.7m/school sic
MA 7.0m / 1 school | 7.0m/school
IN 6.8m / 1 school | 6.8m/school
IL 12.6m / 2 schools | 6.3m/school
MI 10.0m / 3 schools | 3.3m/school
OH 11.8m / 6 schools | 2.0m/school
... vs ...
NY 19.7m / 1 school | 19.7m/school sic
IL 12.6m / 1 school | 12.6m/school
MA 7.0m / 1 school | 7.0m/school
IN 6.8m / 1 school | 6.8m/school
MI 10.0m / 3 schools | 3.3m/school
OH 11.8m / 6 schools | 2.0m/school
ND 0.8m / 1 school | 0.8m/school