bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,950
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
(02-16-2016 12:50 PM)Bull_In_Exile Wrote: (02-16-2016 10:45 AM)Fitbud Wrote: In honor of the late SCOTUS, I thought I should start a thread with some of his most famous quotes. Please feel free to add.
"There are those who contend that it does not benefit African Americans to get them into the University of Texas, where they do not do well, as opposed to having them go to a less-advanced school, a slower-track school where they do well. One of the briefs pointed out that most of the black scientists in this country don't come from schools like the University of Texas. They come from lesser schools where they do not feel that they're being pushed ahead in classes that are too fast for them."
One of the greatest minds *ever* to sit on the court and *THIS* is your takeaway from his time in the Supreme Court.
Was this fact checked? Is it an inconvenient truth or blather.
Quote:"As evidence they pointed to a 1996 Dartmouth study that showed 40 percent of black students graduating with science and engineering degrees came from historically black colleges and universities, where students typically have lower average SAT scores and high school grades."
Quote:The most prominent articulation of mismatch theory comes from Richard Sander’s “A Systemic Analysis of Affirmative Action in American Law,” published in 2004 in the Stanford Law Review. Sander, who co-authored the court brief with legal writer Stuart Taylor, is a law professor at the University of California at Los Angeles. He argues that because minority students who are admitted to a school through race-based admissions tend to have lower academic credentials, they struggle to thrive in a learning environment with higher standards than those for which their prior education prepared them.
Quote:On the raw numbers, the claim is "likely to be true, but not for the reasons Scalia thinks it is," said Benjamin Backes, an affirmative action expert with the American Institutes for Research. Most black scientists likely did not go to schools like the University of Texas at Austin — that is to say, selective research universities.
Quote:"Scalia was certainly oversimplifying, but there is a large literature on this problem," said Richard Sander, a University of California Los Angeles law professor who co-wrote a book titled Mismatch.
So there is basis to it but like good little victims the left did not focus on what he said. Instead they decided to use their superpower.... Having a better idea of what is in someone's heart than the person themselves.
The problem of "mismatch" is not one of innate intelligence. Nobody is saying one race is "smarter" than the other. What's being said is that the condition of African Americans coming out of K12 public schools have not been as properly prepared for the rigors of a science/Engineering degree at an AAU school as White kids who tend to live in better school districts.
I've been a lab instructor for the engineering department at an AAU school and I can attest to the fact many of the kids being rammed into the programs are spinning their wheels and piling up debt.
It's like teaching your kid to swim by tossing them into the middle of the Pacific.
I'm talking second semester engineering students taking three or four remedial programs.
When starting engineering at an AAU school you typically skip college level algebra all together and go right into calculus. Sometimes a kid who had no pre-calc in high school will take algebra and calc together.
That's not too bad but it does pile up a bit.
Now for kids taking remedial math they can not also take the college algebra or calculus.
This not just a matter of adding on a few classes. STEM majors, like I suspect some non stem majors, are built in such a way where many of the classes you take require previous knowledge, or at the very least concurrent knowledge. If you don't have that you will bomb out.
example:
When I started College I was a Chemical Engineering Major. After three semesters I decided it was not for me and I switched over to Electrical. EE required a course in Mechanics and a course in physics which I had not yet taken because they were not required of chemical engineers.
First thing the instructor said "If you've not take physics $xyz then you won't pass this course". I walked out that minute (much to the displeasure of the professor who considered my exit rude).
I was *very* lucky that statics was offered every semester because I took it in the spring after completing the requisite physics course. In taking the class I could see how much easier it was because I had taken the physics class first.
===
There are two ways to fix the racial gaps at AAU schools
1 - Fix the abysmal public schools in the inner cities.
2 - Set up a pipeline for community college to AAU schools so that the kids who need remedial learning are not (1) paying through the nose for it remedial learning (2) taking an admission seat from someone ready to dive in at that level. Partner with community colleges near the school to arrange a curriculum which gets the kids ready in two semesters.
Number two is far more achievable in the short term. It would require that AAU Stem programs plan to hold some seats open from the normal freshman attrition.
At least in Texas, they do have #2.
|
|
| 02-16-2016 07:50 PM |
|
200yrs2late
Resident Parrothead

Posts: 15,754
Joined: Jan 2010
Reputation: 846
I Root For: East Carolina
Location: SE of disorder
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
"What is a 'moderate' interpretation of the text? Halfway between what it really means and what you'd like it to mean?"
--Remarks before Woodrow Wilson Center, March 14, 2005
|
|
| 02-16-2016 08:38 PM |
|
Kaplony
Palmetto State Deplorable
Posts: 25,311
Joined: Apr 2013
I Root For: Newberry
Location: SC
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
Quote:The Court must be living in another world. Day by day, case by case, it is busy designing a Constitution for a country I do not recognize.
--Dissent in Wabaunsee County, KS v. Umbehr (1996)
Quote:War is war, and it has never been the case that when you capture a combatant, you have to give him a jury trial in your civil courts. It's a crazy idea to me. … If he was captured by my army on the battlefield that is where he belongs. I had a son on that battlefield and they were shooting at my son. And I am not about to give this man -- captured in war -- a full jury trial, that is just crazy.
--Remarks at University of Freiberg, Switzerland, March 8, 2006
Quote:I guess the one that created the most waves of disagreement was Bush v. Gore, OK? That comes up all the time. And my usual response is: Get over it.
--2012 CNN interview
Quote:Our manner of interpreting the Constitution is to begin with the text, and to give that text the meaning that it bore when it was adopted by the people ... This is such a minority position in modern academia and in modern legal circles that on occasion I'm asked when I've given a talk like this a question from the back of the room -- 'Justice Scalia, when did you first become an originalist?' -- as though it is some kind of weird affliction that seizes some people -- 'When did you first start eating human flesh?'
--Remarks before Woodrow Wilson Center, March 14, 2005
|
|
| 02-16-2016 10:09 PM |
|
QuestionSocratic
Banned
Posts: 8,222
Joined: Jul 2013
I Root For: Buffalo
Location:
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
Although it is extremely difficult to get a truly objective analysis of any Supreme, there are some sources. The Cornell University Law School maintains a database of "historic" decisions. In this sense, the school is not subjectively analyzing whether they agree or disagree, but only noting importance. They also include dissents in their list.
I've counted the historic opinions of all the justices to reach the bench between Scalia and Ginsberg. The list only runs to 2002 year. Here's what Cornell found:
Justice-Year joined court- historic opinions
Scalia-1986-53
Kennedy-1988-40
Souter-1990-27
Thomas-1991-21
Ginsberg-1993-14
Breyer-1994-18
So my guess is that Scalia had plenty of good quotes.
For contrast, Thurgood Marshall in a 24 year career, wrote one historic opinion. No typo, one as in 1, as in uno.
|
|
| 02-17-2016 03:14 PM |
|
HeartOfDixie
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,572
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 945
I Root For: Alabama
Location: Huntsville AL
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
I remember my favorite, but I can't recall which case or where he was; it was along the lines of "the operation was successful but the patient died. That operation is to medicine what this case is to this Court."
|
|
| 02-17-2016 03:19 PM |
|
Hambone10
Hooter

Posts: 41,255
Joined: Nov 2005
Reputation: 1310
I Root For: My Kids
Location: Right Down th Middle
 
|
RE: Justice Scalia quotes
(02-16-2016 10:45 AM)Fitbud Wrote: In honor of the late SCOTUS, I thought I should start a thread with some of his most famous quotes. Please feel free to add.
"There are those who contend that it does not benefit African Americans to get them into the University of Texas, where they do not do well, as opposed to having them go to a less-advanced school, a slower-track school where they do well. One of the briefs pointed out that most of the black scientists in this country don't come from schools like the University of Texas. They come from lesser schools where they do not feel that they're being pushed ahead in classes that are too fast for them."
Not pointing a finger at you, because I don't know if you know or not, or if you did it intentionally or not, but threads/comments/actions like this are generally an incredible insult.
First, This specific quote has often been attributed to Scalia in the first person, which it most assuredly is not. He is raising a point brought by 'some people', so that the point can be addressed in an intellectual way. Whether he is playing devil's advocate or merely making sure that an opinion is on the record (not his opinion, but the opinion he stated) so that it can't be brought up in a later argument as something the court didn't consider... nobody could ever prove... but it is highly unlikely that if he held such an opinion that he would present it there in public.
Second, if you understand the way the court works... briefs have already been filed and read... and the justices rarely want the parties to recant what is in their briefs. Instead what they want them to do is defend their position against attacks from all sides... even ones they don't necessarily agree with.
Scalia is very well known for playing devil's advocate... The debate is something he enjoys... People who are smart and thoughtful like he was often enjoy playing counter-point... and if you speak to the other justices, they will certainly tell you that about him.
|
|
| 02-17-2016 05:21 PM |
|