(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: If you don't want to discuss this, fine, I understand.
I have discussed all this already up thread.
(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: The population of Old Kingdom Egypt is said to have been about 1 Million. Think of a structure like that being built in Austin, Texas by only the people of Austin. Then think about doing it with nothing but blood and sweat. Then think about doing it in 4 years. All other commerce would have to effectively cease.
Much of the planning, supply chain, engineering and architecture was done by professional pyramid builders in employ of the Pharaoh. These individuals where thought to permanently live in the cities and towns directly surrounding the pyramid area.
During the Nile flood season, all the farming areas are under water. This is why the Nile plain is so fertile, because the Nile flood deposits silt onto the farmers fields. No one is planting, so those tens of thousands of farmers head up to the Pyramids to provide the heavy labor. Since there are no farmers in the towns to buy goods, the local shopkeeps follow the farmers and set up their shops in shadow of Pyramids, or even join the Pyramid labor force. All this labor is used in combination with water levels, wooden levers, and brute force to place blocks in position on the pyramid as it is built from the ground up.
Within both groups, there were undoubtedly some slaves and probably a lot of people who trudged up to the pyramid area during building season with less than full enthusiasm.
Within both groups there were many individuals devoted to the administration (food, sanitation, education, training etc) of pyramid building who never heaved a stone...
But modeling of populations of ancient Egypt and what it would actually take to build the pyramids does show that all of this is quite possible with only limited strain on the Egyptian state.
Both of my paragraphs above are almost gospel to modern Egyptologists. If it is to be proven wrong, it would need to be proven wrong via a massive influx of newly discovered information. As in someone randomly discovers the archives of the pyramid builders where it says something like
"Aliens, using slaves, built the pyramids using mind rays. Each pyramid was a grain silo."
(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: Think about feeding and housing everyone.
It has been estimated that Egypt had at any one time four years of grain reserves, and each year of reserve was enough to feed the entire population. Ancient Egypt was very fertile and they had many advanced farming techniques, plus the Med and the Nile provide sustenance. Housing was mud brick huts, made from the mud and papyrus of the the Nile that was literally available at the front of the Pyramids.
(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: My city can't even complete a 3 mile road in 4 years with all the machinery it needs.
Your city and mine. But isn't this more a reality of modern work conditions and laws versus the brute strength of tens of thousands of Egyptians working sun-up to sun down, probably 6 days a week?
We all know that those roads could be done in a week, if the local contractor had the resources, if the local government was willing to take the steps to allow the construction, and if the population was willing to put up with those realities.
It takes so darn long to build a road because they can only build for so many hours a day, in confined conditions, with labor laws, and with taking the dangers of fast moving traffic in consideration, and the level of inconvenience to the public.
I think we need to acknowledge as well that academics assume that almost 100% of any population believed in a deity of some sort up through about the 1600's. As in, there were no un-believers. If you thought that the working on the pyramids got you in with Osiris, then you hustled and worked your ace off. Certainly, that aspect is missing from modern construction.
(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: These ancient wonders go far beyond just the engineering. I want to know how it was done.
But that is just the issue I am addressing - the Pyramids are not beyond engineering and construction techniques available to the Egyptians. Water, can lift mountains through lock technology. Lever technology can swing limestone blocks like they are made of feathers. And using a simple string, you can make a line as straight as any modern laser.
It's all there for the Egyptian to do. They had the technology, they had the manpower, they had the food, housing and infrastructure, and they had to motivation.
(11-12-2015 09:37 AM)EverRespect Wrote: I certainly didn't want to imply that I expect you to have all the answers. Nobody does.
But what one cannot do is dismiss the answers already provided by Egyptoligists, scientists, historians, archaeologists, laymen, and even from the ancient Egyptians themselves who wrote that they built the pyramids.