Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
Author Message
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,547
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #81
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:01 PM)gdunn Wrote:  If athletes wish to be paid, then scholarships need to be a thing of the past. Can't have it both ways.

That's certainly a possible counterargument. Just because you have a right to unionize doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be better off in practicality. Heck, we saw NBA and NFL players unions essentially get steamrolled by the owners a couple of years ago, and these are basketball and football players that can afford the top legal minds and negotiators out there. The threat of unionization (and thereby, uncertainty for schools) is probably a much more powerful force than actual unionization, so that's the biggest leverage point that the students have. If all parties involved are smart about it, they'll work out it separately. It's sad that it took the threat of unions to force the issue.
03-27-2014 01:13 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
gdunn Offline
Repping E-Gang Colors
*

Posts: 34,756
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3144
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: In The Moment

Survivor Champion
Post: #82
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:01 PM)gdunn Wrote:  If athletes wish to be paid, then scholarships need to be a thing of the past. Can't have it both ways.

That's certainly a possible counterargument. Just because you have a right to unionize doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be better off in practicality. Heck, we saw NBA and NFL players unions essentially get steamrolled by the owners a couple of years ago, and these are basketball and football players that can afford the top legal minds and negotiators out there. The threat of unionization (and thereby, uncertainty for schools) is probably a much more powerful force than actual unionization, so that's the biggest leverage point that the students have. If all parties involved are smart about it, they'll work out it separately. It's sad that it took the threat of unions to force the issue.
I read a Forbes article that was written about a year ago addressing this. As a student athlete you may not be getting paid, but you are being compensated for upwards amounts of $50k-$125k/year.

Here's the article:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfm...25000year/

Unionizing won't guarantee you that you'll get all you get now, plus a stipend. They could revoke the tuition, cut you a check and ask you to pay it out of that (of course it could be taxed so you'd have to manage your money wisely).
03-27-2014 01:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,547
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #83
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:19 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:01 PM)gdunn Wrote:  If athletes wish to be paid, then scholarships need to be a thing of the past. Can't have it both ways.

That's certainly a possible counterargument. Just because you have a right to unionize doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be better off in practicality. Heck, we saw NBA and NFL players unions essentially get steamrolled by the owners a couple of years ago, and these are basketball and football players that can afford the top legal minds and negotiators out there. The threat of unionization (and thereby, uncertainty for schools) is probably a much more powerful force than actual unionization, so that's the biggest leverage point that the students have. If all parties involved are smart about it, they'll work out it separately. It's sad that it took the threat of unions to force the issue.
I read a Forbes article that was written about a year ago addressing this. As a student athlete you may not be getting paid, but you are being compensated for upwards amounts of $50k-$125k/year.

Here's the article:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfm...25000year/

Unionizing won't guarantee you that you'll get all you get now, plus a stipend. They could revoke the tuition, cut you a check and ask you to pay it out of that (of course it could be taxed so you'd have to manage your money wisely).

True in theory, but let's also be realistic about power conference schools like the ones in the Big Ten and SEC. They *want* those top athletes, so unless all 100% of those schools decide to revoke scholarships altogether (which would be a massive antitrust violation and get the schools into more trouble than this union ruling), it's not going to work. All it takes is a single Alabama or Ohio State (or even a podunk school trying to make a name for itself) to offer scholarships on top of other compensation and they'll dominate recruiting even more than they do now, and then everyone else will fall into line in order to compete.

You're assuming that people are going to take a stand on principle here, but the reality is that this is entirely about revenue maximization. Sure, you can refuse to provide scholarships or offer less than other schools, but then the alums will get unhappy and stop donating when your football and basketball teams keep getting crushed. When billions of dollars are slushing around in college sports these days, I wouldn't buy any sabre-rattling or threats from universities at ANY level. They're screaming because they're scared as heck.
03-27-2014 01:29 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
nomad2u2001 Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 18,302
Joined: Nov 2006
Reputation: 450
I Root For: ECU
Location: NC
Post: #84
Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
Let's remember that only D1 private school football and basketball players can be members. That leaves out the vast majority of athletes.
03-27-2014 01:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,547
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #85
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:46 PM)nomad2u2001 Wrote:  Let's remember that only D1 private school football and basketball players can be members. That leaves out the vast majority of athletes.

That's the application under this particular ruling (as private universities are subject to federal labor laws). However, it's expected that this will be used as precedent for athletes at public universities to attempt to unionize under applicable state laws (which are what public universities are subject to on this issue). So, it definitely matters quite a bit that there was this ruling at a federal level - it's only the proverbial tip of the iceberg.
03-27-2014 01:51 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
LSU04_08 Offline
Deo Vindice
*

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
Post: #86
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:19 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:01 PM)gdunn Wrote:  If athletes wish to be paid, then scholarships need to be a thing of the past. Can't have it both ways.

That's certainly a possible counterargument. Just because you have a right to unionize doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be better off in practicality. Heck, we saw NBA and NFL players unions essentially get steamrolled by the owners a couple of years ago, and these are basketball and football players that can afford the top legal minds and negotiators out there. The threat of unionization (and thereby, uncertainty for schools) is probably a much more powerful force than actual unionization, so that's the biggest leverage point that the students have. If all parties involved are smart about it, they'll work out it separately. It's sad that it took the threat of unions to force the issue.
I read a Forbes article that was written about a year ago addressing this. As a student athlete you may not be getting paid, but you are being compensated for upwards amounts of $50k-$125k/year.

Here's the article:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfm...25000year/

Unionizing won't guarantee you that you'll get all you get now, plus a stipend. They could revoke the tuition, cut you a check and ask you to pay it out of that (of course it could be taxed so you'd have to manage your money wisely).

It would be absolutely hilarious if these morons got unionized and started getting paid, and having their scholarships revoked since they can pay their own way now... That would pretty much eliminate itself.
03-27-2014 01:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
gdunn Offline
Repping E-Gang Colors
*

Posts: 34,756
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3144
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: In The Moment

Survivor Champion
Post: #87
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 01:29 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:19 PM)gdunn Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:13 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 01:01 PM)gdunn Wrote:  If athletes wish to be paid, then scholarships need to be a thing of the past. Can't have it both ways.

That's certainly a possible counterargument. Just because you have a right to unionize doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be better off in practicality. Heck, we saw NBA and NFL players unions essentially get steamrolled by the owners a couple of years ago, and these are basketball and football players that can afford the top legal minds and negotiators out there. The threat of unionization (and thereby, uncertainty for schools) is probably a much more powerful force than actual unionization, so that's the biggest leverage point that the students have. If all parties involved are smart about it, they'll work out it separately. It's sad that it took the threat of unions to force the issue.
I read a Forbes article that was written about a year ago addressing this. As a student athlete you may not be getting paid, but you are being compensated for upwards amounts of $50k-$125k/year.

Here's the article:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffreydorfm...25000year/

Unionizing won't guarantee you that you'll get all you get now, plus a stipend. They could revoke the tuition, cut you a check and ask you to pay it out of that (of course it could be taxed so you'd have to manage your money wisely).

True in theory, but let's also be realistic about power conference schools like the ones in the Big Ten and SEC. They *want* those top athletes, so unless all 100% of those schools decide to revoke scholarships altogether (which would be a massive antitrust violation and get the schools into more trouble than this union ruling), it's not going to work. All it takes is a single Alabama or Ohio State (or even a podunk school trying to make a name for itself) to offer scholarships on top of other compensation and they'll dominate recruiting even more than they do now, and then everyone else will fall into line in order to compete.

You're assuming that people are going to take a stand on principle here, but the reality is that this is entirely about revenue maximization. Sure, you can refuse to provide scholarships or offer less than other schools, but then the alums will get unhappy and stop donating when your football and basketball teams keep getting crushed. When billions of dollars are slushing around in college sports these days, I wouldn't buy any sabre-rattling or threats from universities at ANY level. They're screaming because they're scared as heck.
Frank, let's be honest.. College athletics are in the business of making money, don't believe me, read "Death to the BCS".. Nobody is going to put a team on a field or court unless they think they'll make money.. So Alabama has given you a free ride? Oh and you'll get $5k to spend as well? How long does that money last before they want $10k or $20k or hell even $45k/year.. What does that do to the athletic department? They're not going to lose money.. So they'll jack up ticket prices and the fans will get tired and quit going to games. That big nice 100k stadium will start looking empty on TV.. Which will affect not only Alabama's TV deal but the SEC's TV deal. Now a TV deal that was worth hundreds of millions is now down to tens of millions.. So what do you do to stop the bleeding?

I feel like it'll get overturned or there'll be an option. Someone will explore how much it costs for a free ride plus a stipend and offer either a check to come play or a full ride.

Let's not forget, that while college atheletes get full scholarships, some get additional scholarships, grants, and financial aid. I understand they're not allowed to work, but sometimes the additional scholarships, grants, and financial aid will allow them to get a refund check once a semester if all other debts are paid.
03-27-2014 02:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HeartOfDixie Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 24,572
Joined: Oct 2013
Reputation: 945
I Root For: Alabama
Location: Huntsville AL
Post: #88
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
Regardless of which side of the fence you fall I'm glad this is coming to a head. It's an issue that needs to be debated.

Personally, I think a scholarship at a per week stipend is fair, maybe $100. The kids need the schools as bad as the schools need the kids and they are supposed to be students. I'm hoping the end result is a move away from the extreme monetization of the game.

Besides, the "student athlete" is hardly the most put upon kid on campus. Some folks actually work jobs around class. Those are the kids who ought to get some relief not some "student athletes" who get free tuition, room, and board.
03-27-2014 02:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
LSU04_08 Offline
Deo Vindice
*

Posts: 17,736
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 234
I Root For: The Deplorables
Location: Bon Temps, La
Post: #89
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 02:31 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  Regardless of which side of the fence you fall I'm glad this is coming to a head. It's an issue that needs to be debated.

Personally, I think a scholarship at a per week stipend is fair, maybe $100. The kids need the schools as bad as the schools need the kids and they are supposed to be students. I'm hoping the end result is a move away from the extreme monetization of the game.

Besides, the "student athlete" is hardly the most put upon kid on campus. Some folks actually work jobs around class. Those are the kids who ought to get some relief not some "student athletes" who get free tuition, room, and board.

+100
03-27-2014 02:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,547
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3292
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #90
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 02:31 PM)HeartOfDixie Wrote:  Regardless of which side of the fence you fall I'm glad this is coming to a head. It's an issue that needs to be debated.

Personally, I think a scholarship at a per week stipend is fair, maybe $100. The kids need the schools as bad as the schools need the kids and they are supposed to be students. I'm hoping the end result is a move away from the extreme monetization of the game.

Besides, the "student athlete" is hardly the most put upon kid on campus. Some folks actually work jobs around class. Those are the kids who ought to get some relief not some "student athletes" who get free tuition, room, and board.

The thing is that the NCAA doesn't allow such jobs for athletes. The NCAA has literally taken the position that athletes cannot make outside income whatsoever *anywhere* while they're on scholarship. That's what I mean about the black-and-white view that the NCAA has had up to this point - when you have such a hardline position, it's easier to punch holes into it. If the NCAA allowed athletes to work even in just the cafeteria or McDonald's, then they'd have a much stronger case, but they completely overstepped their bounds and are now paying the price.
03-27-2014 03:32 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Owl 69/70/75 Offline
Just an old rugby coach
*

Posts: 82,008
Joined: Sep 2005
Reputation: 3446
I Root For: RiceBathChelsea
Location: Montgomery, TX

DonatorsNew Orleans Bowl
Post: #91
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
The basic problem here is very simple. If student-athletes are getting a real education, then the value of that education vastly exceeds reasonable compensation for their time and effort. But when they are majoring in staying eligible and picking up no more useful skills than parks and wildlife, then they are underpaid. The ironic thing is that Northwestern is one of those places where the athletes are at least in theory acquiring that real education.
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2014 03:52 PM by Owl 69/70/75.)
03-27-2014 03:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dcCid Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,538
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 37
I Root For: ACC, Big East
Location: Ft Lauderdale, FL
Post: #92
RE: Northwestern University football players can unionize, federal agency says
(03-27-2014 12:00 PM)LSU04_08 Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 09:30 AM)Fitbud Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 09:08 AM)LSU04_08 Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 08:55 AM)dcCid Wrote:  
(03-27-2014 08:39 AM)LSU04_08 Wrote:  Matt Mauck took LSU to the National Championship victory in 2003. He was a good QB, but hung around his Sr year to finish with a degree in dentistry. When he realized that he wasn't going to go far in the NFL, he had his degree and now makes great money outside of football.

He is the exception to many. Back in the 80's David Robinson played for Navy. In a Navy Duke game in the NCAA tournament the announcers said it was probably the first tournament game in history when all the players could actually spell their major:)

That said there are different types of inelegance, so how do others receive some piece of paper.

It's too bad a degree and graduation isn't a requirement to play in the NFL, like it is to play in college.

Graduation and a degree is a requirement to play football in college?

That's a new one on me.

You know what I mean, dickleg...

To play in the NFL you primarily need just the skill. Why would you need a degree?
03-27-2014 05:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.